Critics Consensus

1917 and Just Mercy Are Certified Fresh

Plus, Underwater is well-crafted but derivative, and Like A Boss is a missed opportunity.

by | January 9, 2020 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a perilous mission (1917, featuring the voices of George MacKay and Dean-Charles Chapman), a battle for justice (Just Mercy, starring Michael B. Jordan and Jamie Foxx), undersea danger (Underwater, starring Kristen Stewart and Vincent Cassel), and a corporate rivalry (Like a Boss, starring Tiffany Haddish and Rose Byrne). What are the critics saying?


1917 (2020) 89%

Fresh off a couple of surprise Golden Globe wins for Best Director and Best Motion Picture – Drama, 1917 expands into wide release this week to afford broader audiences the opportunity to see writer-director Sam Mendes’ ambitious spectacle on the big screen. Ingeniously crafted from several long takes to spin its narrative as a single, unbroken shot, the story follows a pair of British soldiers in World War I (played by George MacKay and Dean-Charles Chapman) who are tasked with delivering an urgent message to a battalion behind enemy lines in order to prevent a massive ambush. It’s the most anticipated film opening this month by a wide margin, according to our fans on social media, and it’s already won heaps of awards (particularly for its stunning cinematography, courtesy of the legendary Roger Deakins) en route to what will likely be a strong showing at the Oscars in February. It’s also Certified Fresh, with critics calling it an immersive and visceral journey that is, of course, technically impressive, but also grounded in a moving tribute to the sacrifices made by the soldiers engaged in the war.


Just Mercy (2020) 83%

Another film expanding into more theaters this week after a limited release back in December is Destin Daniel Cretton’s Just Mercy, which has already earned star Jamie Foxx a SAG Award nomination. Based on a true story, the film chronicles the efforts of a Harvard-educated attorney named Bryan Stevenson (played by Michael B. Jordan) to exonerate Walter McMillian (Foxx), who was convicted and sentenced to death for the murder of a teenager in 1987. It was a landmark case for Stevenson, who had set out to represent those he believed were wrongly accused of the crimes they were sent to prison for, and it spanned several years as he battled the systemic racism that allowed McMillian’s conviction in the first place. Just Mercy also impressed the critics enough to earn the Certified Fresh distinction, with reviews praising its timely, timeless themes and its outstanding performances. Though it skirts the edges of feeling overly earnest, it manages to overcome its less than subtle messaging with enough nuance and compelling drama to make it well worth a watch.


Underwater (2020) 47%

Former Twilight star Kristen Stewart has, by all accounts, done an excellent job carving out a unique path in Hollywood, starring in a number of acclaimed indie films and earning rave reviews for her performances. But she still makes time for genre fare every once in a while; last year, it was the Charlie’s Angels reboot, and this week, it’s a deep-sea thriller called, appropriately, Underwater. Stewart stars alongside Vincent Cassell, T.J. Miller, Jessica Henwick, Mamoudou Athie, and John Gallagher Jr., who together comprise a research crew stationed at a facility seven miles below the surface of the ocean. When an unseen force rips their vessel to shreds, the surviving members must figure out a way to get to safety… and avoid whatever it was that did the damage. Critics are fairly split on Underwater, with some crying foul at its all-too-familiar setup and reliance on horror cliches, while others call it a competently crafted thriller that, yes, wears its inspirations on its sleeve, but also mimics them quite effectively. In other words, your mileage may vary here, but if you’re looking for something scary at the theaters this weekend, this is probably at least better than last week’s The Grudge.


Like a Boss (2020) 20%

Tiffany Haddish has been a comedy queen since her breakout role in 2017’s Girls Trip, and Rose Byrne has proven her own chops in several projects, most notably in 2011’s Bridesmaids. Throw in a scenery-chewing Salma Hayek, and you’d be forgiven for assuming the result would be a surefire hit. The reviews for Like a Boss, however, would indicate otherwise. Haddish and Byrne play Mia and Mel, a pair of odd-couple BFFs who run a modest cosmetics company together but are deep in debt. When they decide to sell 51% of their company to Hayek’s makeup mogul Claire Luna and their business begins to tank, Mel and Mia find themselves at odds with each other, even as they must work together to take Claire down and save their brand. Like a Boss isn’t without its share of laughs, with its heavy dose of physical humor and raunchy jokes, but critics say the film doesn’t explore Mel and Mia’s relationship deeply enough to make their redemptive turnaround feel earned. Plus, thanks to a repetitive series of clashes and reconciliations and a story whose turns are stale and predictable, it feels longer than its 83-minute runtime. Haddish and Byrne have solid chemistry, and they and Hayek appear to be having fun, but that’s one of the few bright spots Like a Boss offers, so if you aren’t a particularly big fan of any of the stars, you may find yourself counting the ways in which it could have been a better movie.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Woman Who Loves Giraffes (2020) , a documentary about naturalist Anne Innis Dagg’s groundbreaking studies on wild giraffes in the 1950s, is at 100%.
  • VHYes (2020) , a coming-of-age film shot in the style of a VHS camcorder, with faux 1980s TV content peppered throughout, is at 100%.
  • Les Misérables (2020) , a drama about a trio of cops assigned to an impoverished Paris neighborhood who encounter unexpected trouble during an arrest, is at 84%.
  • Inherit the Viper (2020) , a crime thriller about a pair of opioid-dealing siblings who encounter resistance when they try to leave the business, is at 57%.
  • The Sonata (2020) , a horror film about a violinist who discovers a possibly cursed piece of music that her late father composed, is at 57%.
  • The Informer (2020) , starring Joel Kinnaman and Rosamund Pike in a thriller about a former soldier in jail who becomes wrapped up in a messy FBI operation, is at 54%.
  • Three Christs (2020) , starring Peter Dinklage and Richard Gere in a based-on-true-events drama about three men at a mental hospital who all believe they are Jesus Christ, is at 54%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

PBS anthology Polls and Games Super Bowl Bravo Reality crime thriller Film FOX cats discovery book travel Baby Yoda Drama war disaster Schedule cartoon Summer Kids & Family WarnerMedia TIFF spy thriller cults zombie TV renewals Fox News Tomatazos Trivia south america Chernobyl cops CBS All Access First Look Writers Guild of America Television Academy MCU BET witnail renewed TV shows kids San Diego Comic-Con 20th Century Fox Tubi strong female leads Video Games BBC Acorn TV romantic comedy YouTube Red The Walking Dead binge Britbox Comics on TV Hallmark Christmas movies singing competition Shudder APB Mystery Heroines cinemax Winter TV Logo El Rey Ghostbusters The Witch Tarantino See It Skip It TCM Paramount Network Crackle award winner TV comic comiccon Winners cancelled TV shows Rock Universal 007 ratings President USA Network anime Podcast Rocky Ovation Disney+ Disney Plus TV Land RT History free movies Spectrum Originals ABC Family sequel robots Crunchyroll GIFs Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cars natural history 71st Emmy Awards Black Mirror Film Festival Year in Review boxoffice game show Thanksgiving Lifetime Christmas movies Mudbound LGBTQ Anna Paquin richard e. Grant sports Pride Month blaxploitation Starz breaking bad Christmas biography Disney YouTube Premium FXX SDCC VH1 PaleyFest 2015 SundanceTV finale game of thrones political drama YA Red Carpet animated screen actors guild Columbia Pictures reboot Action Best and Worst Pirates streaming golden globes Spike theme song DC Universe Turner Classic Movies television Syfy justice league Infographic Election Lucasfilm 2016 Warner Bros. Nickelodeon christmas movies indie Vudu nature Awards Tour CBS Walt Disney Pictures RT21 Biopics Spring TV diversity spinoff latino Trailer composers 2017 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina The Purge CNN American Society of Cinematographers HBO series cancelled television revenge teaser halloween Apple zombies Freeform AMC Elton John Avengers Musicals Trophy Talk Sci-Fi ABC Esquire ghosts Sundance Now Captain marvel werewolf Rom-Com stand-up comedy IFC tv talk movie Epix HBO Max psycho USA Pet Sematary docudrama Holiday DC Comics Endgame Netflix Christmas movies Academy Awards Mary Tyler Moore Reality Competition adaptation Mary Poppins Returns A&E Lifetime festivals GoT miniseries NYCC Certified Fresh CW Seed spider-man Apple TV+ 45 Animation Toys Cosplay Brie Larson Pixar canceled TV shows dramedy science fiction ITV crime drama FX Peacock Song of Ice and Fire Discovery Channel Calendar Classic Film directors children's TV Stephen King Comic Book TruTV Photos Cannes based on movie zero dark thirty unscripted romance Sneak Peek OWN true crime rotten movies we love Oscars green book Musical Superheroes casting canceled Mindy Kaling Amazon aliens Marvel Studios thriller 2019 slashers screenings DirecTV NBC space MTV Character Guide foreign TBS movies Creative Arts Emmys serial killer psychological thriller Quiz Women's History Month Turner Premiere Dates harry potter Ellie Kemper Fall TV spain YouTube Adult Swim documentary toy story Netflix Grammys blockbuster name the review OneApp mockumentary Dark Horse Comics mutant Set visit Pop Lionsgate Awards 2018 Sundance TV adventure Comedy Central Amazon Prime Video Mary poppins quibi hispanic spanish language 21st Century Fox Sundance Marvel Television versus doctor who Disney streaming service dceu Paramount Arrowverse Tumblr Emmys Showtime Music Country ESPN Cartoon Network Nat Geo History Holidays TCA 2017 dc DC streaming service Martial Arts Comedy Masterpiece sitcom what to watch facebook BBC America independent historical drama Shondaland social media politics First Reviews talk show LGBT VICE Nominations vampires Interview Amazon Prime Star Trek Box Office Disney Channel MSNBC technology jamie lee curtis Emmy Nominations TLC X-Men WGN TCA crossover A24 video cooking Sony Pictures supernatural National Geographic Countdown hist The CW SXSW Western Superheroe New York Comic Con Apple TV Plus E3 comics TNT Star Wars The Arrangement sag awards Hulu Binge Guide IFC Films elevated horror CMT Rocketman transformers dragons police drama Teen medical drama Food Network Opinion Marathons Extras joker crime Family 24 frames Valentine's Day E! TCA Winter 2020 Marvel cancelled TV series period drama cancelled Disney Plus batman Horror Watching Series Hallmark 2020 DGA Fantasy GLAAD