2019 Is the Best Year For Horror in Four Decades, According to the Tomatometer

Certified Fresh flicks like Us, Ready Or Not, and Midsommar helped make 2019 the only overall Fresh year for horror movies since 1980.

by | December 10, 2019 | Comments

(Photo by © A24)

2019 has been such a strong year for wide-release horror films that the upcoming Black Christmas remake could receive a 0% Tomatometer score and the average for the 23 horror films released in 2019 would still be a Fresh 60%. This may not seem all that important, but this is big news for horror fans. Why? Because in the modern era of horror (which we’ll define as from 1980 forward), there hasn’t been a year with a Fresh overall Tomatometer score.

This Fresh average shouldn’t come as a surprise to those paying attention to the genre this year – Certified Fresh hits like Us, Crawl, Ready or Not, and Midsommar have won over critics and audiences alike. Even remakes/adaptations are over-performing critically as Child’s Play (63%) and Pet Sematary (57%) are Fresh and very close to it, respectively, when historically horror remakes average a Rotten 44% Tomatometer average.

In honor of this Fresh year of theatrically released horror, we pulled the Tomatometer data on the 644 horror movies that received wide releases (defined here as 600+ theaters) in the United States since 1980. We wanted to know how the preceding 40 years of horror films matched up against 2019, and if any year had a higher Tomatometer average.

Quick Note: We chose 1980-2019 because there is greater consistency in Tomatometer data than in earlier years. The 1970s were the bomb though.


The Descent
(Photo by Lions Gate / Everett Collection )
The overall Tomatometer average for the 644 horror movies that received wide theatrical releases since 1980 is a Rotten 43.8%, and 438 of those movies (or 68%) have scores below 60%. The Rotten far outweigh the Fresh, and for every Green Room, The Descent, The Thing, and Scream 2 , there are movies like Jaws: The Revenge, House of the Dead, I, Frankenstein, Godsend, The Roommate, and Dream House bringing down their average.

Another interesting fact (for data nerds and horror movie lovers who are also data nerds) is that since 1990, only five years have had more Fresh horror films than Rotten: 1982 (7 > 4), 1983 (8 > 7), 1987 (10 > 7), 2013 (7 > 6), and 2019 (12 > 10). This data makes 2019’s Fresh score even more impressive.

On a side note, the years 1997-1999 have a seriously high number of Rotten horror movies that we at RT actually love. Between Anaconda, Halloween H20: 20 Years Later, The Faculty, Idle Hands, Blade, Deep Rising, The Relic, The Mummy, Lake Placid, and the king of all Rotten horror movies, Event Horizon (you can read more about Event Horizon as well as Blade in our book Rotten Movies We Love), the years are stacked with Rotten movies that are pretty awesome.

THE BEST DECADE FOR HORROR IS THE 1980s. No Surprise there. 

New Line Cinema
(Photo by New Line Cinema)

Despite having no single year with a Fresh Tomatometer score, the 1980s have the highest overall average with a groovy 52.5%. Buoyed by A Nightmare on Elm Street, Near Dark, The Fly, The Thing, and Fright Night, the 1980s slaughtered the 1990s (43.6%), 2000s (32.2%), and the 2010s (47.1%).

Six of the top 10 years in our data set come from the 1980s, and 1987 came close to being Fresh, but the 0%-rated Jaws: The Revenge and the 9% House 2 kept it at a Rotten 57%. A big reason for the 1980s being the highest-rated decade is that it has only one year in the bottom 10 Rottenest years on the list (1989, with a Tomatometer average of 34.4%).


The Wicker Man
(Photo by © Warner Bros. )

The worst year in our entire data set is 2006, which currently has a Rotten 31.1% average. The distinction is dubious, but at least 2006 kept it interesting with movies like Pan’s Labyrinth, The Descent, Slither, Hostel, Snakes on a Plane, The Hill Have Eyes, and The Wicker Man remake, an amazingly bonkers movie that features Nicolas Cage running all over the place while wearing a bear suit. Also, the first Black Christmas remake was released in 2006, and with a 14% Tomatometer score, the less said, the better.

The 2000s as a whole weren’t much better, as the decade averaged a 32% Tomatometer score. Four of the five lowest Tomatometer years in the data set are from the 2000s, and only 33 of the 189 theatrically released movies in that decade have a Fresh Tomatometer score. The numbers may look bad, but on a positive note, the 2000s are responsible for bona fide classics like Shaun of the Dead, 28 Days Later, The Mist, and Zombieland. Plus, movies like Jennifer’s Body, 28 Weeks Later, 30 Days of Night, Constantine, Frailty, Eight Legged Freaks, and The Happening (it’s awesome, get over yourself), are starting to gain their due popularity.

Random Tomatometer Fact: Imogen Poots, the star of the upcoming Black Christmas remake, made her horror debut in 2007, appearing in the Fresh 28 Weeks Later (the opening scene is awesome). Since then, she’s crushed it the underrated Fright Night remake and in Green Room, which is one of the best-reviewed horror films of recent memory.



What makes 2019 the only Fresh year in our data set might surprise you. While movies like Us, Doctor Sleep, The Lighthouse, and Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark helped greatly, it’s the remakes, prequels, sequels, and adaptations that greatly contributed to the overall Freshness. 2019 has been a lot of fun because of movies like Annabelle Comes Home, a sequel to a prequel (Annabelle: Creation) of a prequel (Annabelle), which has a Fresh 64% Tomatometer score. Normally, a horror movie so far removed from the original is almost always Rotten. Toss in the Certified Fresh Crawl (82%), a movie about rampaging alligators, and 3 From Hell, Rob Zombie’s 50%-rated sequel to The Devil’s Rejects, and you have movies that are over-performing critically when compared the likes of Lake Placid (46%), Primeval (18%), 31 (47%), and Lords of Salem (46%) from past years.

The 25% Tomatometer-rated Countdown, a movie about a ‘killer’ phone app, has the lowest score of any wide-release horror movie in 2019. Typically, a 25% score isn’t reason to celebrate – but when compared to the Rottenest horror movie of each year in our data set, it’s the least Rotten (the closest is 1984’s 23%-rated C.H.U.D.). In fact, the 10 Rotten horror movies released in 2019 have a 46.3% average, which is the highest average for the Rotten films of all the years in our data set. 2019 has the best of the worst, and that’s why it’s Fresh.

What is your favorite year for horror? Let us know in the comments.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

cancelled television elevated horror LGBT transformers Lifetime Certified Fresh theme song Women's History Month supernatural DC streaming service halloween Travel Channel book blockbuster Marvel Television Binge Guide period drama Television Critics Association finale Writers Guild of America Comic Book nature dark best PaleyFest a nightmare on elm street TCA 2017 spider-man Premiere Dates Heroines aliens Sundance TV 45 singing competition talk show Shudder The Arrangement diversity zombie christmas movies NYCC Lucasfilm directors twilight Opinion E3 Lifetime Christmas movies TBS reboot A24 comics comedies Superheroe Trophy Talk BBC America Stephen King tv talk thriller Mary Poppins Returns Teen Paramount batman vampires Musicals based on movie Apple TV Plus Creative Arts Emmys The Walking Dead 4/20 true crime DirecTV Amazon Anna Paquin Epix Funimation YA Esquire OWN TCA Awards Academy Awards YouTube blaxploitation TV Land San Diego Comic-Con Pixar CMT crossover Pride Month TCM ghosts GoT Song of Ice and Fire FOX Adult Swim Bravo science fiction Sundance Now Grammys Walt Disney Pictures MCU cults The CW Nickelodeon Masterpiece social media crime thriller adventure Amazon Prime Video 21st Century Fox Sony Pictures stoner CBS All Access Winter TV Television Academy El Rey 2018 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Spring TV Hulu parents versus award winner Comics on TV zombies cats Tubi mission: impossible justice league boxoffice facebook Sci-Fi USA Mudbound DGA FX on Hulu Warner Bros. HBO Go Film toy story serial killer Nat Geo screen actors guild anime Dark Horse Comics Horror IFC Films Acorn TV comiccon SXSW Turner natural history Fall TV screenings spy thriller asian-american Election Rocky streaming all-time Mary poppins adaptation Mary Tyler Moore Starz Tomatazos Reality TNT cartoon Box Office ABC Hear Us Out Arrowverse Chernobyl Black Mirror Showtime Pirates strong female leads canceled HBO 2015 YouTube Premium revenge Year in Review ESPN Universal Captain marvel travel news scary movies ratings LGBTQ Spectrum Originals cars Schedule BBC jamie lee curtis Photos werewolf Turner Classic Movies sag awards Best and Worst MSNBC 20th Century Fox spinoff indie spain Paramount Network FXX CBS festivals witnail emmy awards Disney streaming service rotten movies we love composers Watching Series SDCC criterion documentary IFC cinemax HBO Max Rock Chilling Adventures of Sabrina universal monsters TLC die hard CNN Lionsgate nbcuniversal stand-up comedy Fantasy RT History dramedy Oscars Pet Sematary Animation Cartoon Network Hallmark Christmas movies psycho spanish language franchise YouTube Red BBC One teaser Quiz police drama documentaries political drama Disney Channel independent canceled TV shows binge cancelled TV series Disney discovery Pop TV Freeform E! zero dark thirty Apple video on demand Mindy Kaling casting Valentine's Day Family Hallmark cops doctor who Marvel Classic Film Film Festival Star Wars animated child's play VOD MTV 71st Emmy Awards Drama Set visit dceu BAFTA BET Awards miniseries Superheroes green book Syfy Country Amazon Studios Logo Sneak Peek technology sequel History Shondaland First Reviews Podcast robots WGN children's TV biography mutant Biopics Martial Arts television Winners politics hispanic VH1 DC Comics Christmas Disney+ Disney Plus renewed TV shows reviews 2019 National Geographic romantic comedy Holiday Reality Competition Emmy Nominations Netflix space harry potter Video Games Infographic Music historical drama game of thrones Cannes Food Network TCA dogs DC Universe Cosplay Vudu critics New York Comic Con films Toys Fox News Nominations American Society of Cinematographers Ellie Kemper psychological thriller TCA Winter 2020 series Avengers GIFs PlayStation Marathons satire See It Skip It NBC Countdown Black History Month Star Trek ABC Family Polls and Games richard e. Grant USA Network Awards kids The Witch Red Carpet Elton John Musical First Look disaster war cancelled TV shows Spike unscripted dc Marvel Studios Action TV renewals SundanceTV Trivia movie crime Baby Yoda Brie Larson Ghostbusters concert President foreign FX TIFF Holidays name the review Western 2020 anthology Apple TV+ BET south america hist WarnerMedia Comedy Central cancelled TruTV Sundance medical drama Discovery Channel crime drama sitcom Mystery The Purge golden globes quibi Thanksgiving Britbox Ovation PBS Crunchyroll sports Kids & Family mockumentary Super Bowl Extras TV joker Crackle CW Seed what to watch APB RT21 2016 007 chucky Amazon Prime Emmys dragons latino cooking romance Disney Plus Netflix Christmas movies Pop Character Guide Summer slashers 2017 docudrama ITV Rom-Com video comic Tumblr Trailer Awards Tour X-Men OneApp Peacock Rocketman A&E VICE Endgame Tarantino Comedy GLAAD indiana jones Interview game show 24 frames movies AMC breaking bad Columbia Pictures free movies Calendar