Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Mighty Thrills, Spartan Plot In "300"; "Gift" Doesn't Keep On Giving

by | March 8, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got 300 mighty Spartans ("300," starring Gerard Butler) and a reluctant do-gooder ("The Ultimate Gift," starring Abigail Breslin). What do the critics have to say?

Fangirls and fanboys, the wait is over. "300," Zack Snyder’s CG adaptation of Frank Miller‘s cult graphic novel sensation is here. And while critics say it’s a feast for the eyes, many note it’s slightly less a delight for the brain. "300" tells the tale of the ancient Battle of Thermopylae, in which 300 Spartans fought a star-crossed battle against the heavily fortified Persian army. Subtlety is not the order of the day here, nor is slavish attention to historical detail, but the pundits say the movie is visually sumptuous, a spectacle of ultraviolence and visceral thrills. However, others say "300" takes itself seriously to the point of self parody, and lacks compelling characters and cohesive plotting. "300" is currently at 60 percent on the Tomatometer.

Because "Anticipate Defeat!" was less rousing.

"The Ultimate Gift" is a movie about learning the true meaning of wealth, and stepping outside one’s self centered existence. These are good lessons to learn, but critics say the movie, while likeable, is too sappy to fully register. "The Ultimate Gift" tells the story of a trust fund kid who stands to inherit the fortune of his recently deceased grandfather — but only after he completes a series of tasks, which include living on the streets, doing manual labor, and being nice to people. Critics say "The Ultimate Gift" is sweet, heartfelt, and well-meaning — but also schmaltzy and dramatically inert. At 35 percent on the Tomatometer, this may not be the "Ultimate" viewing experience.

"’Silverado’ was 20 years ago. You can change clothes now."

Also opening this week in limited release: the South Korean import "The Host," a monster movie/satire/family drama, is at 94 percent; "Maxed Out," a doc that takes on the credit card industry, is at 85 percent; "Beyond the Gates," a drama about a teacher caught up in the Rwandan genocide starring John Hurt and Hugh Dancy, is at 71 percent; "The Namesake," a drama about a family caught between two cultural worlds starring Kal Penn and Jacinda Barrett, is at 70 percent; and "Exterminating Angels," a French drama about voyeurism and taboos, is at 52 pecent.

"KBBL’s going to give me something stupid!"

Recent Historical Epics:
65% — Apocalypto (2006)
39% — Kingdom of Heaven (2005)
16% — Alexander (2004)
55% — Troy (2004)
78% — Gladiator (2000)

Tag Cloud

dc documentary Comedy films Brie Larson talk show TIFF TCA dogs NBC WGN Horror A&E award winner directors slashers BBC 2020 Pirates binge singing competition what to watch LGBTQ spinoff APB The Purge Year in Review Tomatazos joker blockbuster OWN IFC jamie lee curtis MSNBC NYCC Lionsgate Esquire VOD 45 documentaries finale science fiction Travel Channel President free movies news FXX comedies Anna Paquin Showtime concert Red Carpet sitcom reboot Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Walt Disney Pictures cats SDCC Grammys romance USA robots docudrama BET Awards TCM Columbia Pictures Election Shudder Sony Pictures Apple TV Plus Best and Worst 24 frames The Walking Dead Ovation Trailer Sneak Peek rotten movies we love Martial Arts green book ABC sports TV renewals classics Amazon Studios all-time cancelled Adult Swim video on demand spy thriller sequel historical drama Mystery Baby Yoda Avengers TLC Comics on TV Freeform television Pixar American Society of Cinematographers Musicals Logo Star Wars parents cinemax DGA YA 2017 HBO Go Nominations IFC Films MCU Amazon Prime crime thriller critics book Mindy Kaling TCA 2017 Cannes Writers Guild of America Fall TV travel mockumentary festivals a nightmare on elm street Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dark Watching Series CW Seed cults Podcast Emmy Nominations Oscars AMC breaking bad FOX medical drama aliens based on movie CMT Film Film Festival franchise dragons Acorn TV Summer Winners First Reviews natural history Apple TV+ sequels cancelled TV shows sag awards Rocketman YouTube Premium Box Office kids Photos Character Guide Disney police drama comiccon Marathons The CW Hear Us Out VH1 X-Men independent Disney+ Disney Plus Star Trek Vudu Mudbound disaster Fantasy serial killer ghosts GLAAD Sundance Now Hallmark Christmas movies Awards Tour Music Trivia hispanic supernatural OneApp 72 Emmy Awards cartoon Hulu Endgame HBO CNN Cartoon Network The Witch San Diego Comic-Con Pop TV Elton John dceu Bravo cancelled TV series Valentine's Day DC Universe worst movies Rom-Com Lifetime stop motion RT History PaleyFest Super Bowl PlayStation toronto Christmas 2015 screenings El Rey zombie VICE BET BAFTA cooking SXSW casting Premiere Dates Arrowverse Tumblr Holidays cops Food Network National Geographic halloween Binge Guide Infographic politics Warner Bros. Sundance RT21 Polls and Games facebook cancelled television Hallmark festival remakes Epix Countdown Winter TV Set visit Mary Tyler Moore canceled TV shows Heroines anime Superheroes 2016 spanish language Emmys crossover witnail werewolf harry potter New York Comic Con Country Tarantino 2018 adventure Lifetime Christmas movies Comedy Central E! child's play discovery Discovery Channel Calendar stoner mutant satire See It Skip It social media Western fast and furious FX Turner Classic Movies TV Land Certified Fresh hist doctor who Nickelodeon series Universal Paramount richard e. Grant ratings DC Comics TBS Television Academy Teen Action ABC Family screen actors guild FX on Hulu Television Critics Association Marvel Television scary movies twilight Turner venice Musical quibi batman asian-american Stephen King Marvel nfl game of thrones SundanceTV Amazon Prime Video crime drama Disney streaming service biography Kids & Family tv talk Spring TV elevated horror superhero game show Britbox WarnerMedia zero dark thirty political drama christmas movies Spike CBS All Access TCA Awards versus blaxploitation The Arrangement reviews 21st Century Fox comic TCA Winter 2020 worst crime cars best Fox News movies Reality hollywood YouTube Extras Interview 20th Century Fox south america Shondaland Apple boxoffice Crunchyroll renewed TV shows First Look technology Cosplay Family Netflix Christmas movies latino indie Spectrum Originals dramedy rotten Black History Month miniseries indiana jones laika foreign Biopics Masterpiece 007 anthology stand-up comedy DirecTV Opinion TNT Marvel Studios Netflix video strong female leads psycho PBS GIFs Reality Competition Disney Plus Awards Pop Mary Poppins Returns Black Mirror war BBC America obituary Trophy Talk Tubi Funimation Mary poppins zombies BBC One criterion theme song Rock ESPN MTV spain TV comics TruTV Creative Arts Emmys chucky vampires children's TV true crime streaming die hard Comic Book period drama revenge scorecard Pet Sematary Holiday thriller Superheroe Ghostbusters LGBT Classic Film YouTube Red Peacock Paramount Network justice league 4/20 Women's History Month Chernobyl E3 Dark Horse Comics History Lucasfilm romantic comedy HBO Max transformers canceled DC streaming service teaser Nat Geo Ellie Kemper Animation animated emmy awards adaptation football Crackle name the review Captain marvel Schedule golden globes Syfy toy story space A24 Pride Month mission: impossible CBS diversity Song of Ice and Fire Video Games Toys Drama Starz psychological thriller ITV 71st Emmy Awards movie nature Thanksgiving Academy Awards Disney Channel unscripted nbcuniversal USA Network Rocky Sundance TV Amazon spider-man composers GoT Quiz universal monsters Sci-Fi 2019