Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Take Or Leave This "Lead,: An Odd "Number," "Benchwarmers"

by | April 6, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we explore the joys of dance ("Take the Lead"), mistaken identity ("Lucky Number Slevin"), our national pastime ("The Benchwarmers"), and the search for love ("Phat Girlz"). What do the critics say?

It’s a scenario Hollywood loves to ("Stand and") deliver: A tough-but-fair new teacher helps a ragtag bunch of teenage troublemakers learn to be better citizens and believe in themselves through a disciplined approach to basketball/martial arts/poetry/feng shui/tiddley winks, etc. Add ballroom dancing to the list. "Take the Lead" stars Antonio Banderas as a professional dancer whose old-school approach melds with the students’ hip-hop sensibilities. (If this sounds familiar, it’s because there was a documentary called "Mad Hot Ballroom" that told the same tale, albeit with elementary school kids, and uh, it was real.) Critics say the movie is fine, if a little shopworn; while the performances and dance numbers are stirring, we’ve kinda seen this one before. It’s currently at 45 percent on the Tomatometer.

From its inscrutable title to its labyrinthine plot, the scribes are pretty split on "Lucky Number Slevin." Is the screenplay smart? Yes, critics say. Too clever for its own good? Perhaps, they concede. Josh Hartnett stars as a regular dude who falls into a web of intrigue after a case of mistaken identity. The film has a stellar cast (Morgan Freeman, Bruce Willis, Lucy Liu, Ben Kingsley) and a plot with more twists and turns than a marathon session of Chutes and Ladders. So, is "Lucky" any good? Depends on which critic you ask. At 55 percent on the Tomatometer, "Slevin" is either pulp heaven or an overplotted purgatory.

Like a utility infielder hitting well below the Mendoza line, "The Benchwarmers" probably deserves to ride the pine, since the scribes weren’t allowed to see it. And likewise, "Phat Girlz," which was also not screened for critics, is probably not all that, uh, phat. So kiddies, it’s time for our new national pastime: Guess the Tomatometer! The winner gets tickets to the World Series and a complete makeover. (Sorry, you only win props.)

Recent Antonio Banderas Movies:
26% — The Legend of Zorro (2005)
89% — Shrek 2 (2004)
44% — Spy Kids 3-D: Game Over (2003)
68% — Once Upon a Time in Mexico (2003)
33% — Imagining Argentina (2003)

Recent Josh Hartnett Movies:
78% — Sin City (2005)
24% — Wicker Park (2004)
31% — Hollywood Homicide (2003)
38% — 40 Days and 40 Nights (2002)
76% — Black Hawk Down (2001)

Tag Cloud

ESPN boxoffice Walt Disney Pictures crossover supernatural TV Land MTV Travel Channel LGBT 2016 Spike comics Cosplay nature Infographic Britbox Rocky Disney Biopics concert Anna Paquin Turner Cannes El Rey Cartoon Network Television Critics Association Tomatazos Nickelodeon WGN 2018 Winners TIFF harry potter TLC APB ghosts Marvel casting disaster USA Network mission: impossible YouTube Red Star Wars The Walking Dead Rom-Com Animation space TBS The CW CMT TNT dc Epix ABC Family FX Sneak Peek sequel 20th Century Fox Creative Arts Emmys cults Lionsgate Extras stand-up comedy A&E spain Columbia Pictures YouTube Ellie Kemper 45 Super Bowl movies Amazon Prime Video festivals blaxploitation Shudder Comedy PaleyFest classics CBS Elton John Tarantino Peacock Christmas Black History Month mutant christmas movies Grammys BBC America Black Mirror Arrowverse quibi BAFTA Amazon Prime Amazon Studios Interview franchise Avengers rotten movies we love Film Festival revenge Calendar Premiere Dates toy story BET sports Martial Arts CW Seed game show IFC Films child's play ITV DC streaming service The Arrangement Western Fantasy universal monsters Amazon finale asian-american zombie police drama movie YouTube Premium canceled Musicals Hulu scary movies superhero biography war thriller Syfy transformers robots Acorn TV HBO Max documentaries Red Carpet comiccon hist Emmy Nominations Apple Mary Tyler Moore Lifetime Christmas movies what to watch true crime TCA Winter 2020 Vudu name the review nbcuniversal Warner Bros. streaming A24 award winner hispanic romance DC Comics AMC Universal SundanceTV screen actors guild Stephen King BBC werewolf TCM Tumblr Sundance Now children's TV justice league Rock 2020 criterion Character Guide stop motion Lifetime Comics on TV elevated horror Starz Esquire Mystery Classic Film TV dragons worst psycho WarnerMedia cops Marvel Television indiana jones political drama VICE TCA Awards Paramount indie Disney Channel Pride Month Apple TV Plus American Society of Cinematographers twilight Valentine's Day Pop TV Drama spinoff Sundance TV Star Trek Hear Us Out Polls and Games Hallmark NYCC documentary doctor who theme song animated best Writers Guild of America History sag awards HBO Go Crackle miniseries science fiction San Diego Comic-Con anthology Superheroes Turner Classic Movies game of thrones E3 TruTV FOX cancelled television MSNBC Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pop comedies binge politics Family Countdown Discovery Channel 21st Century Fox Reality Competition Best and Worst stoner green book First Look video vampires mockumentary Pirates spy thriller RT History comic psychological thriller Funimation romantic comedy strong female leads New York Comic Con sequels dark breaking bad Summer Academy Awards Disney+ Disney Plus crime Brie Larson BET Awards Certified Fresh medical drama GIFs facebook Podcast Country The Witch TV renewals VH1 crime thriller book Awards video on demand Ghostbusters golden globes Sony Pictures 2015 Shondaland Comic Book cancelled Women's History Month See It Skip It renewed TV shows Trailer Set visit kids social media Trivia SDCC Watching Series emmy awards dramedy sitcom FX on Hulu Schedule Food Network CNN adaptation GLAAD Binge Guide jamie lee curtis Lucasfilm singing competition Freeform die hard DirecTV Pet Sematary President Song of Ice and Fire Emmys anime slashers Marvel Studios composers Fox News cartoon Baby Yoda Box Office TCA technology The Purge Ovation rotten First Reviews 72 Emmy Awards spanish language Spectrum Originals Superheroe zombies Captain marvel obituary a nightmare on elm street Chernobyl Oscars OneApp diversity Rocketman foreign canceled TV shows Sundance docudrama IFC SXSW Music Pixar travel USA chucky discovery Showtime NBC Fall TV Comedy Central Bravo cancelled TV shows BBC One richard e. Grant Disney streaming service blockbuster news 71st Emmy Awards Crunchyroll Mary Poppins Returns batman joker Kids & Family Masterpiece FXX Adult Swim talk show cars Film Logo Apple TV+ Year in Review based on movie cats television satire E! witnail Paramount Network X-Men aliens Musical VOD 4/20 screenings cancelled TV series critics OWN cinemax CBS All Access Toys Thanksgiving spider-man historical drama zero dark thirty Photos Endgame Election 007 tv talk Nat Geo Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt MCU National Geographic Disney Plus 24 frames Opinion films PlayStation Trophy Talk Mary poppins reboot teaser Quiz Mudbound Tubi TCA 2017 Television Academy free movies Video Games independent DC Universe crime drama directors Teen Hallmark Christmas movies reviews Mindy Kaling Marathons adventure Netflix Christmas movies ABC YA cooking DGA parents HBO Spring TV period drama Holidays Netflix Heroines Holiday Reality Action dceu 2017 series Awards Tour RT21 Sci-Fi Horror 2019 Winter TV dogs serial killer laika halloween all-time LGBTQ unscripted south america Nominations Dark Horse Comics latino fast and furious hollywood natural history versus PBS GoT ratings