Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Third Time's Not the Charm for "Shrek"

by | May 17, 2007 | Comments

America is going green this week: "Shrek the Third" (featuring the voices of Mike Meyers, Eddie Murphy, and Antonio Banderas) is our single new wide release. Critics loved the first two, how do they feel about this one?

Shrek’s third outing finds our green antihero in an unusual predicament: the king has died, and Shrek is next in line to ascend to the throne. Typically, he wants nothing of it and must set off to find a replacement. Hijinks, fart jokes, and ironic postmodern deconstruction ensue. But critics say "Third" has gone too far with the "Shrek" formula: it relies too heavily on pop culture references and fairy tale spoofs, marginalizing the heart and charm that made the first two classics. Also, the sheer amount of new and returning characters has given the best characters – Shrek, Donkey, and Fiona – the least screen time in any "Shrek" yet. "Shrek the Third" is at 42 percent, a far cry from "Shrek"’s and "Shrek 2"’s 89 and 88 percent Tomatometers, respectively.

"I…am not right-handed."

And opening in limited release: "Once," a crowd-pleasing drama about two street musicians (check out our interview with director John Carney), is at 100 percent; "Severance," a British import of shock horror and droll comedy, is at 74 percent; "Brooklyn Rules," a drama set in the titular borough circa 1985, is at 56 percent; "Flanders," the new art pic from festival fave Bruno Dumont, is at 50 percent; "The Wendell Baker Story," a light-hearted drama featuring possibly more Wilson Brothers than we’re equipped to handle, is at 40 percent; "Fay Grim," the new action/thriller/comedy from quirky auteur Hal Hartley, is at 40 percent; "Even Money," a cautionary tale about the ills of gambling, is at 20 percent; and "The Last Sin Eater," the second release of Fox Faith’s Christian parable, is at 20 percent.

In "Flanders" field.

And medals, commendations, and accolades to unbreakable_samurai and SplendidIsolation who both came closest to guessing "Delta Farce"’s three percent Tomatometer last week. We, too, were surprised by its extraordinarily high rating.

Recent Mike Meyers Movies
88% – Shrek 2 (2004)
14% – View From the Top (2003)
12% – Dr. Seuss’ The Cat in the Hat (2003)
55% – Austin Powers in Goldmember (2002)
89% – Shrek (2001)

Tag Cloud

batman Stephen King Avengers History Comic Book A&E renewed TV shows 4/20 The Witch dragons sag awards Premiere Dates Writers Guild of America hispanic Awards Starz Apple TV Plus child's play CW Seed Teen X-Men Logo Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Action south america Mary Poppins Returns Marvel Studios Hallmark Christmas movies toy story Trailer Horror CBS All Access universal monsters Summer blaxploitation Pop TNT films ratings festivals comic Hallmark Tubi MSNBC Sci-Fi Countdown Universal Comedy breaking bad miniseries Television Academy TruTV NYCC spain Cannes documentary chucky award winner romance series Tumblr Freeform dramedy Superheroe Shondaland biography police drama Walt Disney Pictures 2020 vampires Drama Rock sequel SXSW Mudbound IFC Films Superheroes Comics on TV DC streaming service latino Musicals foreign television Emmy Nominations twilight stoner mockumentary DC Comics Holiday Year in Review Arrowverse space A24 Sneak Peek spanish language cops HBO Max canceled TV shows Mary poppins Netflix Christmas movies ABC Trophy Talk National Geographic Pet Sematary spy thriller VH1 Classic Film Black Mirror Character Guide elevated horror romantic comedy name the review Travel Channel medical drama Rocky Vudu revenge independent Warner Bros. Turner Classic Movies Marvel Television zero dark thirty cancelled indiana jones Endgame indie Certified Fresh TV renewals Toys Election Hear Us Out Fox News technology crime thriller Podcast Sundance TV Binge Guide dogs mutant critics Brie Larson Spectrum Originals YouTube 2016 WGN Discovery Channel Star Wars concert based on movie canceled Showtime cancelled television docudrama Comedy Central 2019 WarnerMedia Musical comedies social media natural history Music BAFTA cartoon comiccon 45 Mary Tyler Moore CBS BET Awards spinoff VOD Marathons DirecTV Box Office hist a nightmare on elm street game show Nominations Heroines GoT stand-up comedy Watching Series RT21 Apple TV+ San Diego Comic-Con The Purge comics Animation Acorn TV reviews BBC Set visit cars screenings LGBTQ golden globes Funimation Grammys Star Trek YouTube Premium VICE scary movies Crunchyroll Thanksgiving PlayStation Apple The CW Pirates blockbuster TIFF TV Martial Arts Spike criterion Country 24 frames Sundance talk show cinemax Mystery composers Fall TV Christmas franchise boxoffice anime Columbia Pictures Interview 2017 Emmys Amazon Prime Video Polls and Games Cosplay anthology Masterpiece Women's History Month Awards Tour OneApp transformers satire singing competition PaleyFest zombie 2015 free movies TCA 2017 christmas movies war zombies science fiction movies Ovation Ghostbusters sports BBC One El Rey CMT politics New York Comic Con Lucasfilm Reality E3 Calendar DC Universe Britbox OWN ABC Family parents Nickelodeon richard e. Grant AMC Dark Horse Comics cults Syfy harry potter TCM Shudder The Arrangement political drama Photos Nat Geo what to watch jamie lee curtis cancelled TV shows GLAAD Anna Paquin news Best and Worst thriller Black History Month crime drama binge Amazon Studios The Walking Dead period drama asian-american Food Network Netflix RT History Disney Channel SundanceTV Quiz casting crime Reality Competition aliens Winter TV unscripted Disney Disney Plus HBO Go adaptation psychological thriller Paramount Network GIFs green book USA Network See It Skip It ghosts Fantasy halloween ESPN cancelled TV series reboot YA E! Schedule BBC America Tarantino psycho tv talk nature werewolf adventure animated SDCC cooking Oscars cats Spring TV justice league Winners IFC Peacock Video Games slashers Disney+ Disney Plus Rocketman MTV documentaries MCU witnail Cartoon Network 21st Century Fox teaser Kids & Family best TCA Winter 2020 strong female leads CNN Paramount Sony Pictures Family Amazon First Reviews Lifetime Crackle spider-man Captain marvel PBS TCA joker facebook children's TV Pride Month FX versus Lionsgate Hulu Mindy Kaling Trivia Biopics First Look directors finale quibi book HBO USA Holidays Lifetime Christmas movies dc TBS Extras rotten movies we love FOX Film mission: impossible discovery Valentine's Day Pixar BET travel Tomatazos Amazon Prime Film Festival video on demand TV Land DGA FX on Hulu LGBT NBC serial killer Elton John FXX all-time sitcom Disney streaming service disaster Baby Yoda Marvel theme song true crime game of thrones Red Carpet Super Bowl video President crossover doctor who ITV 20th Century Fox Creative Arts Emmys dceu Ellie Kemper Infographic 2018 kids 007 dark Chernobyl robots Turner American Society of Cinematographers Western Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TLC 71st Emmy Awards Rom-Com Epix Opinion APB screen actors guild die hard Bravo Adult Swim Pop TV streaming historical drama movie Academy Awards YouTube Red Esquire diversity Song of Ice and Fire supernatural Sundance Now