Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Positive Role Models, So-So Soul Men

Plus, Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa tops the original.

by | November 6, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Big Brothers (Role Models, starring Paul Rudd and Seann William Scott), wild animals (Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa, with voice work by Ben Stiller and Chris Rock), and R&B vets (Soul Men, starring Bernie Mac and Samuel L. Jackson). What do the critics have to say?

Films that are at once raucously stupid and genuinely funny are a rarity. However, critics say Role Models fits the bill with aplomb. The film stars Paul Rudd and Seann William Scott as a pair of energy drink pitchmen with a proclivity for bad behavior and law-breaking; assigned to community service, they act as Big Brothers to a pair of troublemakers — and learn something in the process. It may sound like pure formula, but the pundits say this is a worthy entry in the Judd Apatow-inspired subgenre of gross-out comedy with heart, featuring well-paced, spectacularly dumb (in a good way) gags and engaging performances. At 75 percent on the Tomatometer, Role Models may be worth following.

“I’d like to dedicate this next number to McLovin.”

Speaking of rarities, how many sequels top the original? Madagascar
made a ton of money but disappointed critics unimpressed with its string of pop culture references and flatulence jokes. The scribes say Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa is better in almost every regard, with sharper animation, funnier jokes, and a better story. Alex the Lion (Ben Stiller), Gloria the Hippo (Jada Pinkett Smith), Marty the Zebra (Chris Rock) and Melman the Giraffe (David Schwimmer) are relocated from captivity in New York to a savannah in Africa. Once there, they rediscover their roots, but pine for the friendly confines of the zoo. It may not be the edgiest animation out there, but pundits say Madagascar is bright and cheerful, with a good deal of energy and some smart laughs. At 68 percent on the Tomatometer, Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa may be worth a trip.

“They call me the Hiphopapotamus, my lyrics are bottomless…..”

The script of Soul Men may be coarse and shopworn, but critics say it’s an ok sendoff for the great comic Bernie Mac, who passed away earlier this year. The film stars Mac and Samuel L. Jackson as a pair of R&B backup singers who reluctantly agree to perform at a tribute concert for a soul legend despite mutual acrimony; their cross-country journey to the show is filled with wacky hostility. The critics say Soul Men isn’t particularly original, borrowing from a number of road-buddy flicks, and the jokes are pretty blue. Still, they also note it’s a worthy final performance for Bernie Mac, an actor who stole many scenes in supporting roles and is in fine form as a lead here (and the late soul great Isaac Hayes also turns in a sharp supporting performance). At 54 percent on the Tomatometer, Soul Men hits some decent notes.

One of these men is in no hurry to take it to the bridge, to the consternation of the other.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Captain Abu Raed, a tale of a janitor in Jordan who inspires a goup of children who believe he’s a pilot, is at 100 percent.

  • A revival of Francois Truffaut‘s classic The Wild Child, based on the true story of a boy who survived alone in the wild, is at 100 percent.

  • Pray the Devil Back to Hell, a documentary about a group of Liberian women’s political activism in the midst of civil war, is at 100 percent.

  • JCVD, starring Jean-Claude Van Damme as a version of himself fighting to escape a hostage situation in a bank, is at 85 percent (check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down the Muscles from Brussels’ best-reviewed films).

  • The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, a Holocaust drama about the son of a Nazi officer who forms a friendship with a boy in a concentration camp, is at 71 percent.

  • The World Unseen, a drama about two South African women who form a tight bond during the Apartheid era, is at 29 percent.

  • Repo! The Genetic Opera, a futuristic musical about a biotech company that harvests human organs, is at 25 percent.

Finally, props to indiefilmfan2, Mary R., and rockclimbr6 for coming the closest to guessing The Haunting Of Molly Hartley‘s three percent Tomatometer.

Best-Reviewed Bernie Mac Movies:

Tag Cloud

TV Pop TV festival Lucasfilm singing competition Vudu miniseries Calendar TCM Oscars A24 MCU Country TCA 2017 christmas movies DC streaming service Esquire Starz Premiere Dates cancelled television crime thriller Character Guide casting AMC sag awards thriller true crime Video Games CBS All Access Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Arrowverse screen actors guild football comiccon Quiz TCA Awards 4/20 Writers Guild of America Superheroe comics Rom-Com asian-american Black History Month batman BBC America Apple SDCC game of thrones TV Land Star Wars Pride Month chucky theme song 72 Emmy Awards YouTube BBC Tarantino rotten remakes sequel Warner Bros. Apple TV+ spinoff die hard vampires Paramount Best and Worst films Showtime YouTube Premium screenings facebook indiana jones sports renewed TV shows Pet Sematary disaster Sneak Peek Fall TV Mindy Kaling Comic Book romance Awards Trailer See It Skip It TCA San Diego Comic-Con Travel Channel Tumblr Lifetime Box Office video on demand Syfy binge Rocky PaleyFest Paramount Network Cartoon Network Shondaland Amazon Studios Black Mirror Superheroes 2018 Sundance Now adventure 21st Century Fox Netflix Christmas movies Film CW Seed Fox News RT History 2019 007 Endgame Discovery Channel breaking bad zero dark thirty Animation psycho 2017 serial killer Epix social media Amazon Prime Video Academy Awards Sundance Fantasy parents diversity Schedule Pixar Spring TV Turner Classic Movies Emmys canceled Ovation Dark Horse Comics TIFF Avengers GIFs based on movie Christmas Song of Ice and Fire reboot Baby Yoda Mudbound twilight kids teaser Masterpiece ABC Universal Disney+ Disney Plus Tubi Red Carpet travel Walt Disney Pictures Comedy Central USA blaxploitation CNN First Look best Teen TruTV technology Martial Arts discovery cooking HBO Go all-time HBO Max The CW comedies PBS blockbuster movies laika 45 Nat Geo Disney Channel Funimation TV renewals LGBT Thanksgiving Cannes critics Freeform spanish language universal monsters stand-up comedy superhero Chernobyl hollywood cars OneApp Opinion werewolf Netflix WGN Comedy space witnail Reality nfl dogs transformers Disney golden globes First Reviews Interview Horror free movies canceled TV shows dceu NYCC Ellie Kemper Marvel Studios DC Comics slashers Super Bowl PlayStation Mary Tyler Moore mutant BET Awards Sundance TV 20th Century Fox FOX sitcom toronto Pop ABC Family Television Critics Association Action festivals VH1 jamie lee curtis Drama award winner historical drama APB ESPN Classic Film Film Festival cancelled TV series DGA worst The Walking Dead medical drama Watching Series FXX Mystery Cosplay series cinemax adaptation Marvel children's TV dark science fiction E! ITV NBC CMT venice Star Trek spider-man TLC Musical Summer WarnerMedia natural history HBO boxoffice MSNBC RT21 Countdown Crackle The Purge ratings VOD DirecTV X-Men Acorn TV documentary BBC One reviews talk show SXSW Podcast Food Network Disney streaming service period drama composers Mary poppins zombie cops A&E Lionsgate cancelled TV shows Music Anna Paquin BAFTA Musicals Spectrum Originals war History Grammys anthology obituary dc Stephen King concert satire crossover Television Academy versus Crunchyroll police drama 2020 Marathons Extras Amazon Prime Sci-Fi emmy awards Western elevated horror TCA Winter 2020 The Arrangement independent Photos Lifetime Christmas movies news Valentine's Day Comics on TV criterion Shudder Set visit Pirates what to watch Hallmark richard e. Grant hispanic Brie Larson Turner Spike worst movies joker Rocketman movie YouTube Red Trophy Talk nature Polls and Games video 2016 IFC Films Emmy Nominations E3 television Columbia Pictures stop motion directors Logo Marvel Television scorecard Disney Plus Adult Swim OWN book scary movies Britbox child's play franchise Year in Review indie Certified Fresh New York Comic Con Nominations dramedy crime supernatural Peacock foreign Reality Competition VICE USA Network Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Bravo Sony Pictures animated Holidays Hallmark Christmas movies Election rotten movies we love Hear Us Out nbcuniversal strong female leads Heroines docudrama Creative Arts Emmys unscripted mission: impossible fast and furious Captain marvel FX on Hulu National Geographic TBS Winter TV Trivia politics cancelled Amazon robots spy thriller President Toys Biopics Infographic Binge Guide LGBTQ The Witch Nickelodeon revenge 24 frames ghosts GLAAD Family harry potter American Society of Cinematographers Women's History Month hist Mary Poppins Returns south america romantic comedy political drama GoT documentaries Tomatazos quibi name the review CBS SundanceTV psychological thriller streaming a nightmare on elm street doctor who comic MTV El Rey cartoon Kids & Family Apple TV Plus sequels YA spain IFC Awards Tour finale aliens Winners halloween 71st Emmy Awards tv talk Holiday biography Elton John toy story DC Universe Ghostbusters crime drama dragons Hulu 2015 cats mockumentary stoner anime zombies justice league cults TNT BET green book classics game show latino Rock FX