Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Interview Earns Mixed Reviews

Plus, Unbroken Is Well-Meaning But Conventional, The Gambler is a so-so bet; Into the Woods hits most of the right notes, and Big Eyes is a sharp black comedy.

by | December 24, 2014 | Comments

Merry Christmas! This week at the movies, we’ve got unlikely CIA operatives (The Interview, starring Seth Rogen and James Franco), a resilient war hero (Unbroken, starring Jack O’Connell and Domhnall Gleeson), an indebted English professor (The Gambler, starring Mark Wahlberg and John Goodman), fractured fairy tale characters (Into the Woods, starring Meryl Streep and Anna Kendrick), and a subjugated artist (Big Eyes, starring Amy Adams and Christoph Waltz). What do the critics have to say?

The Interview


Look, we know you’ve probably heard all about how The Interview sparked an international incident. Now that it’s popping up online and in a few theaters, it’s fair to ask: is it any good? Well, critics say The Interview is pretty funny in spots, but its tone is more sophomoric than politically astute. Dave Skylark (James Franco), the host of a trashy talk show, and his producer Aaron Rapoport (Seth Rogen) land the biggest interview of their careers: North Korean dictator Kim Jong-un (Randall Park). But before they journey to Pyongyang, the CIA recruits them to assassinate the Dear Leader. The pundits say The Interview works better as a bromance than as a political farce, and while the cast (especially Park) gives its all, the movie ultimately falls short as a satire of international relations and the media.



The life of Louis “Louie” Zamperini seems tailor-made for a big-budget biopic. Unfortunately, not every great story makes for a great movie, and critics say that’s sadly the case for director Angelina Jolie‘s Unbroken, a well-meaning, occasionally stirring epic that suffers from conventional storytelling and a lack of tension. Zamperini (Jack O’Connell) was a track star who served in World War II, where he survived a plane crash by clinging to a raft for more than a month before being captured by Japanese troops and held in a prisoner of war camp for more than two years. He’s undoubtedly heroic, but Unbroken frequently feels too similar to other inspirational war films.

The Gambler


Plenty of contemporary films borrow from the gritty imagery and moral ambiguity of mid-1970s thrillers, so a remake of The Gambler sounds like a solid bet. However, critics say that this slick, well-acted film never fully lures the audience into its protagonist’s plight. Mark Wahlberg stars as Jim Bennett, a self-destructive English professor whose gambling habit could cost him his fortune — and that of his family. Bennett turns to a loan shark for help, but he continues to sink into a hole, with potentially dire consequences. The pundits say The Gambler is slick and reasonably tense, but it lacks the existential moodiness of the classic crime flicks that inspired it.

Into the Woods


The time seems right for a big-screen adaptation of Stephen Sondheim’s Into the Woods, a meta-musical that deconstructed fairy tales long before Frozen or Once Upon a Time. Critics say Rob Marshall mostly does right by the play, maintaining its dark spirit and bringing an imaginative touch to the sets and costumes (though it’s still a little on the long side). A mashup of Cinderella, Jack And The Beanstalk, Little Red Riding Hood, and Rapunzel, Into the Woods finds all your favorite childhood characters converging and intersecting in a story about a baker and his wife who try to lift a curse that’s been placed on them by a malevolent witch. The pundits say Into the Woods is sometimes uneven, but it’s well-staged and features fine performances from a star-studded cast. (Watch our video interviews with stars Emily Blunt, James Corden, Anna Kendrick, Christine Baranski, and Tracey Ullman.)

Big Eyes


Once in a while, director Tim Burton departs his beguilingly wacky fantasyland for the real world; Ed Wood, a biopic of the notoriously incompetent filmmaker, is one of his most beloved films. With Big Eyes, Burton takes on another strange-but-true story, and while critics say it’s thoughtful, visually striking, and well-acted, its overall tone is sometimes hard to define. Amy Adams stars as Margaret Keane, a painter whose images of children with oversized eyes were big sellers in the 1960s. There was just one problem: While Margaret painted, her husband Walter (Christoph Waltz) took the credit and reaped the rewards, keeping his wife a virtual prisoner. The pundits say Big Eyes shows that Burton’s taste for black comedy is still strong, even if he never fully gets to the heart of his characters here.

What’s Hot on TV:

The pundits say The Missing (Certified Fresh at 96 percent) turns a routine premise into a standout thriller, thanks to heartfelt, affecting performances.

The critics say that a talented ensemble raises Benched (67 percent) above its trite writing, resulting in a nicely diverting half-hour of comedy.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

History SundanceTV spy thriller Sony Pictures docudrama NBC CBS All Access Interview screen actors guild Set visit disaster stand-up comedy diversity spain Infographic book comic HBO Go Ovation Biopics zombies Disney+ Disney Plus SXSW Premiere Dates MCU Extras Academy Awards Holiday biography Amazon Prime Video comiccon miniseries Mary poppins Trivia cancelled television discovery chucky Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cooking YouTube Red series Nominations travel mission: impossible Shudder PlayStation Hallmark El Rey Stephen King National Geographic joker richard e. Grant TNT Paramount Network First Reviews BBC jamie lee curtis 2019 medical drama Showtime politics YouTube sequel BET Awards 2015 spinoff Sci-Fi versus TCA Film BBC America Box Office PaleyFest President science fiction Columbia Pictures VH1 criterion New York Comic Con Musicals Netflix Television Academy 45 Starz Paramount Cosplay TLC American Society of Cinematographers 24 frames Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt children's TV thriller Netflix Christmas movies Arrowverse period drama crime thriller FX on Hulu Drama finale Classic Film mutant facebook Reality Competition Year in Review Lucasfilm franchise Spike Film Festival Oscars IFC Films YA crime drama reboot Spring TV MSNBC ratings historical drama supernatural FXX Adult Swim Awards Discovery Channel spanish language satire golden globes game of thrones ESPN The CW Fall TV Family Tumblr Awards Tour animated WGN Acorn TV dramedy renewed TV shows USA Network anime A&E halloween transformers Heroines Sundance TV canceled ABC Winners Amazon Prime films Calendar Video Games First Look Marvel BBC One streaming psycho Pet Sematary DC streaming service Watching Series Martial Arts Apple TV Plus BET Mary Tyler Moore zombie Valentine's Day San Diego Comic-Con Music Trailer 2016 Disney streaming service Lionsgate cancelled TV series Vudu Winter TV Opinion Elton John Mudbound Crackle adventure Polls and Games cats a nightmare on elm street IFC USA Ghostbusters Hulu 71st Emmy Awards christmas movies Amazon Walt Disney Pictures TruTV strong female leads sag awards Women's History Month LGBT dceu documentaries Cannes green book Grammys boxoffice doctor who Brie Larson Television Critics Association Anna Paquin Black Mirror what to watch GLAAD die hard critics Spectrum Originals Lifetime Peacock binge political drama harry potter TV Land blockbuster werewolf Mindy Kaling Endgame WarnerMedia game show hispanic Fox News Horror festivals TCA 2017 foreign parents revenge Esquire psychological thriller documentary Chernobyl GoT Britbox MTV Tarantino Pop TV E! The Purge Countdown scary movies Apple TV+ 21st Century Fox movie Epix screenings rotten movies we love VICE Sundance latino elevated horror serial killer slashers Apple hist HBO AMC RT History The Walking Dead teaser comedies asian-american sitcom police drama 2020 BAFTA Election Amazon Studios LGBTQ Pop Rocky indiana jones witnail dogs Baby Yoda Avengers cults Rock Warner Bros. tv talk A24 Kids & Family CBS Shondaland talk show Superheroe ghosts all-time FX dc TCA Winter 2020 anthology Musical vampires aliens Logo YouTube Premium Rocketman Marvel Studios Best and Worst DGA social media romantic comedy Crunchyroll Universal television Nat Geo child's play Western breaking bad Syfy Comic Book blaxploitation natural history cancelled TV shows independent zero dark thirty award winner Teen Disney Plus cops Quiz cartoon TBS Captain marvel TIFF spider-man Rom-Com 007 FOX Bravo Masterpiece composers DirecTV Comedy Central Funimation Star Wars CMT 2017 TV renewals Fantasy south america Animation Lifetime Christmas movies See It Skip It Reality The Witch TV toy story Character Guide Creative Arts Emmys 2018 Travel Channel quibi crossover Super Bowl Schedule Christmas nature CNN Disney Red Carpet Summer technology sports batman DC Universe OWN NYCC Country cars HBO Max true crime Tomatazos ABC Family unscripted indie Hallmark Christmas movies RT21 Action free movies best Thanksgiving Certified Fresh X-Men news Hear Us Out kids Disney Channel Marvel Television SDCC based on movie Sneak Peek The Arrangement 20th Century Fox Emmys stoner cinemax singing competition video on demand Nickelodeon APB adaptation 4/20 casting GIFs twilight Mystery Writers Guild of America Comics on TV Holidays Song of Ice and Fire crime space mockumentary E3 justice league Podcast PBS DC Comics concert name the review TCA Awards directors Trophy Talk Pirates Marathons romance Mary Poppins Returns Sundance Now Superheroes universal monsters dragons Dark Horse Comics VOD dark Comedy Black History Month OneApp movies Ellie Kemper TCM CW Seed cancelled Pride Month Turner reviews Emmy Nominations Toys comics Pixar Star Trek video war Food Network theme song canceled TV shows Cartoon Network Binge Guide Freeform Tubi robots Photos Turner Classic Movies ITV