American Horror Story: 1984 First Reviews: Nostalgia-Packed Premiere Off to a Solid Start

How many '80s slasher movies can the newest installment of Ryan Murphy's horror series pay tribute to in its first episode? Read critics' first takes on AHS: 1984.

by | September 19, 2019 | Comments

The ninth season of American Horror Story is subtitled 1984 — meaning viewers are in for a mega dose of nostalgia with their scares this year. The campy horror series goes to literal camp this year as the core cast of Ryan Murphy’s players gathered at Camp Redwood for a summer of outdoor fun (and, apparently, death).

The action begins with a flashback to a 1970 summer camp massacre by the now-incarcerated Mr. Jingles (John Carroll Lynch), then introduces the five Los Angeles youngsters who venture to the great outdoors for their new summer job. Brooke (Emma Roberts) is the “last American virgin” who decides to join her relatively new friends after being attacked in her apartment by the real-life killer eventually dubbed the Night Stalker. Montana (Billie Lourd) is a sexually charged aerobics obsessive, Ray (DeRon Horton) is the nice guy of the group, Xavier (Cody Fern) is a serious actor uninterested in soap opera gigs, and Chet (Gus Kenworthy) is an athlete recently kicked out of the Olympics. They head to the summer camp led by uber-Christian camp director Margaret (Leslie Grossman), a survivor of the aforementioned massacre, where they meet camp staffers Rita (Angelica Ross), the nurse, and Trevor (Matthew Morrison), an anatomically gifted activities director.

Cue slasher movie references galore, plus some more scares for the main cast.

See what critics had to say about American Horror Story: 1984 (2019) 87% below.

Blast from the Past

AMERICAN HORROR STORY: 1984 -- Pictured: Emma Roberts as Brooke Thompson. CR: Kurt Iswarienko/FX
(Photo by Kurt Iswarienko/FX)

Only one episode into the season, it already looks to be a fun ride because 1984 is the first season since Freak Show to be set in the past. (Yes, Hotel had some other eras popping up, but it was mostly set in the present day.) This year seems like a real treat for campy horror, though, harkening back to not only the original Friday the 13th movies but also the fun knockoffs like Sleepaway Camp and Summer Camp Nightmare. —Andrea Reiher, Variety

There’s ’80s Nostalgia Galore

AMERICAN HORROR STORY: 1984 -- Pictured: Billie Lourd as Montana Duke. CR: Kurt Iswarienko/FX
(Photo by Kurt Iswarienko/FX)

The ’80s references come so hard and fast the start of the show almost reads like a sketch sending up ’80s nostalgia, from the neon font introducing the cast to “Cruel Summer” playing within the first fifteen minutes. —Molly Horan, AV Club

It seems very possible that Ryan Murphy appropriated the writing budget for this episode and spent it all on thong leotards, shimmer stockings, and sleeveless polyester turtlenecks — because the story makes no sense, but lord, the cast looks fabulous. —Kat Rosenfield, Entertainment Weekly

If last season — Apocalypse, if you have already lost track of where we are in the series’ nine-season run — was the first time I felt like campiness and silliness overrode the core mandate to be freaky and creepy, Wednesday (September 18) night’s American Horror Story: 1984 premiere was the first time it seemed like Murphy and Falchuk were engaging in nostalgia for nostalgia’s sake. The launch was an hour-ish of the writers and frequent director Bradley Buecker saying, “You like Glow? You like Stranger Things? You like the ’80s? Remember those summer camp killer movies? Reference! Reference! Reference!” —Daniel Fienberg, The Hollywood Reporter

And Plenty of Horror References

AMERICAN HORROR STORY: 1984 -- Pictured: Cody Fern as Xavier Plympton. CR: Kurt Iswarienko/FX
(Photo by Kurt Iswarienko/FX)

In classic horror fashion, a gas station attendant learns where they’re going and warns the group that they’re all gonna die. In more classic horror fashion, the gang run down a random hiker. He’s still alive, though he can’t remember his name. Xavier (who was driving) wants them all to agree they didn’t hit him. —David Oliver, USA Today

Friday the 13th is the main reference point here, obviously, but John Carpenter’s Halloween creeps in, in a big way, toward the end when Mr. Jingles escapes from his asylum (which almost feels like a Goonies moment). There’s even a gender-swapped Dr. Loomis-type, along with a fun cameo by The X-Files‘ Mitch Pileggi, who was killer Horace Pinker in 1989’s Shocker. —Matt Fowler, IGN

The Season Feels Lighter…

AMERICAN HORROR STORY: 1984 -- Pictured: Gus Kenworthy as Chet Clancy. CR: Kurt Iswarienko/FX
(Photo by Kurt Iswarienko/FX)

AHS: 1984’s tone is so much brighter, lighter, and stylized than previous seasons of American Horror Story (God, the opening credits this year are amazingly on point) that this almost feels like a stealth season three of Scream Queens, especially with Emma Roberts leading the pack as Brooke Thompson. Make no mistake, this is a good thing, and at least this first episode embraces that show’s gleeful murder-happy impulses. —Daniel Kurland, Bloody Disgusting

…But Still Scary

AMERICAN HORROR STORY: 1984 -- Pictured: Leslie Grossman as Margaret Booth. CR: Kurt Iswarienko/FX
(Photo by Kurt Iswarienko/FX)

The whole thing opens with our serial killer, Mr. Jingles (John Carroll Lynch), murdering an entire cabin of teenagers — one via knife through the eye — and collecting their ears as trophies, so, uh, no, they aren’t messing around with the gore this season. —Maggie Fremont,

Where’s the Twist?

AMERICAN HORROR STORY: 1984 -- Pictured: CR: DeRon Horton as Ray Powell. CR: Kurt Iswarienko/FX
(Photo by Kurt Iswarienko/FX)

One of the big elements that makes American Horror Story interesting is that each season tends to contain some kind of major, game-changing twist. Last year in Apocalypse, for example, the show killed off most of the main cast a couple episodes in and transitioned into a crossover between Coven and Murder House. Back in Roanoke, they revealed midway through that we had been watching a reenactment of real events — a show within a show — before those real ghosts started going after the cast and crew of that meta-show. Since it seems like it would be difficult to make a straight homage to ’80s slasher movies last ten episodes, we can’t help but assume that AHS 1984 will feature some kind of similar change-up, but of course it’s hard to guess right now what it might be. But there has to be something, right? —Jennifer Maas and Phil Owen, The Wrap

The premiere episode of 1984 has played out exactly like a 1980s slasher film would — it’s a perfect homage to the genre — but I’m wondering when it’s going to go all American Horror Story on us. You know, aliens, the antichrist, that Lady Gaga blood orgy. I’m here for the ’80s horror of it all, but I can’t help but feel like something else is coming. As long as it isn’t the clowns. Please, no more clowns. —Maggie Fremont,

Final Verdict?

Thus far, 1984 is pastiche. Like Scream without the analysis, it is obsessed with what made slashers slashers with little more to say at any given moment than, “‘Member that?” Of course, being a TV show that has to air for several weeks and take up about 10 hours of airtime in total, it can’t be as flagrant with its characters’ wellbeing, which means there’s a lot of dead-end suspense when the show manages to be suspenseful at all. It’s fun enough, though, and the VHS-inspired intro is killer —Rich Juzwiak, Jezebel

The big question as the pilot closes with the crazed killer having escaped from the asylum, running loose in the rain near a bunch of buzzed camp counselors who really, really want to get into each other’s short shorts isn’t what comes next. Anyone who has seen even a snippet of a classic horror film from the ’80s knows what comes next. It’s how what comes next fills another ten or so episodes when it usually only covers the second half of a 90-minute movie. —Molly Horan, AV Club

In many ways, the premiere’s approach feels like classic AHS—even a return to basics after the bonkers if entertaining spectacle that was AHS Apocalypse. The slasher theme moves the show away from any whiff of topicality, instead fixing its lens on a simpler time, when killers stabbed and their victims ran screaming through the woods. —Laura Bradley, Vanity Fair

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Disney streaming service police drama independent Emmy Nominations Food Network Comic Book Martial Arts IFC Films spinoff space television Fall TV Walt Disney Pictures Acorn TV blockbuster comiccon Tarantino streaming revenge FXX Amazon Prime Video TLC south america GoT The Arrangement dogs book cults Netflix YouTube Country politics supernatural Spring TV Tomatazos Musicals TCM romantic comedy The Purge Premiere Dates Film Festival witnail Rom-Com X-Men Holidays YouTube Red all-time Character Guide Sony Pictures Netflix Christmas movies children's TV documentary Adult Swim Watching Series Pixar Red Carpet reboot Epix spider-man cops stand-up comedy Stephen King DGA theme song Marvel Fox News name the review Spike Winter TV talk show comic ITV Turner Classic Movies golden globes tv talk chucky DC Comics transformers Captain marvel Ghostbusters Marvel Studios adaptation dc TruTV A&E psycho Fantasy Television Academy breaking bad spanish language sequel nature E! zombies Super Bowl mission: impossible The CW First Look President Sundance TV CNN facebook dceu sports Pride Month asian-american dark binge American Society of Cinematographers Valentine's Day GLAAD 007 MCU FX Amazon Thanksgiving SXSW Britbox Paramount SDCC Horror dramedy BET Binge Guide National Geographic Rocky movies 45 blaxploitation crime Action Dark Horse Comics hispanic Set visit Vudu Disney Plus Holiday Turner spy thriller ghosts OWN LGBT 2016 CBS All Access Mindy Kaling Hallmark Christmas movies vampires DC streaming service 71st Emmy Awards true crime scary movies ESPN casting science fiction Ovation finale Avengers Hulu Comics on TV travel Crackle historical drama Photos miniseries werewolf Travel Channel ABC Polls and Games Extras 2015 Crunchyroll die hard halloween Kids & Family critics Reality Competition E3 VICE robots TV Land series Film toy story APB jamie lee curtis elevated horror 24 frames social media Video Games New York Comic Con cancelled TV shows adventure TCA indie parents Disney+ Disney Plus CBS Arrowverse Star Wars El Rey Bravo Best and Worst ABC Family 21st Century Fox Lifetime Christmas movies Comedy Logo TV renewals free movies franchise 20th Century Fox Mystery SundanceTV Apple zero dark thirty cancelled TNT Apple TV Plus See It Skip It Pirates IFC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt First Reviews concert BBC America Year in Review Trivia mutant PaleyFest HBO cats DirecTV Nominations sag awards Shondaland Paramount Network child's play renewed TV shows LGBTQ NBC criterion Cartoon Network 2019 screen actors guild dragons Election period drama Musical crime drama Women's History Month boxoffice Black History Month Freeform PBS christmas movies Universal Superheroe Opinion Music cartoon doctor who Family hist USA Network Amazon Prime FOX Emmys Disney Cosplay 2017 Black Mirror MSNBC docudrama universal monsters Elton John Discovery Channel RT History Countdown versus WGN ratings kids Ellie Kemper cancelled TV series comics foreign TBS Anna Paquin medical drama Chilling Adventures of Sabrina VH1 Classic Film Nickelodeon AMC spain Oscars Reality disaster USA Grammys Mary poppins RT21 Warner Bros. Mary Tyler Moore Starz Drama Certified Fresh Christmas 2018 a nightmare on elm street richard e. Grant Trailer TV TIFF YA mockumentary Box Office Pet Sematary war animated Awards festivals Columbia Pictures Tumblr Lionsgate zombie The Walking Dead Nat Geo Mary Poppins Returns History Creative Arts Emmys what to watch teaser Toys BBC batman Pop cinemax award winner Rocketman Mudbound Amazon Studios WarnerMedia latino discovery Baby Yoda game show Infographic TCA 2017 Interview GIFs harry potter Marathons Animation Calendar DC Universe Apple TV+ The Witch Podcast Peacock thriller game of thrones stoner Academy Awards natural history Star Trek Endgame comedies Spectrum Originals Hallmark cancelled television San Diego Comic-Con Tubi Schedule Writers Guild of America Lucasfilm 2020 cars aliens HBO Max quibi Brie Larson green book FX on Hulu Song of Ice and Fire CMT 4/20 Marvel Television screenings movie biography psychological thriller directors Sundance Now YouTube Premium crime thriller technology Funimation political drama video Chernobyl joker Quiz Cannes based on movie CW Seed justice league rotten movies we love best crossover Sci-Fi Trophy Talk Superheroes singing competition canceled MTV Showtime Teen strong female leads unscripted composers Awards Tour Rock Sundance A24 Shudder anime Comedy Central cooking sitcom Winners Masterpiece OneApp Pop TV Sneak Peek serial killer Lifetime Heroines canceled TV shows Western diversity reviews romance Esquire Disney Channel TCA Winter 2020 Summer Biopics anthology Hear Us Out Syfy NYCC slashers