Anne Hathaway and Andrew 'Hot Priest' Scott Are Just Two of Modern Love’s Irresistible Charms

Hathaway and Scott talk to Rotten Tomatoes about their episodes in the Amazon Prime Video series that also stars Tina Fey, John Slattery, Julia Garner, and Dev Patel.

by | October 18, 2019 | Comments

Like most anthology series, the eight episodes that make up Amazon’s Modern Love – based on the popular New York Times column of the same name – are hit and miss. Some, like — surprisingly — the one that stars Tina Fey and John Slattery as longtime marrieds who are try to get their groove back by playing tennis, are just meh.

But then there’s “Take Me as I Am, Whoever I Am,” a moving installment in which Anne Hathaway’s Lexi is a whirlwind of energy and charm as she and Jeff (The Deuce scene-stealer Gary Carr) meet-cute at the supermarket. Her excitement about the prospects of this new romance can’t be contained – hence, the song-and-dance number that ensues in the store’s parking lot.

Modern Love, Anne Hathaway (Christopher Saunders/Amazon Studios)
(Photo by Christopher Saunders/Amazon Studios)

But when Jeff arrives at her apartment to pick her up for their date, the much more subdued Lexi seems like a completely different person. We learn she has bipolar disorder, and her brief relationship with Jeff may be a crushing disappointment as a romance, but it sparks Lexi to seek medical help and open up to a friend about the all-consuming challenges she’s kept hidden.

“It felt beautifully honest and surrealist at the same time,” Hathaway told Rotten Tomatoes about the story. “Something we’ve experienced in doing press for (the series) is that almost everybody that’s come in has said, ‘I know and love someone who has bipolar disorder,’ or, ‘I know and love someone who has a mental health condition that makes them feel different and alienated.’

“And we’re no different,” she said of the stories in the series. “I was just really happy to make an episode for the people in my life who are going through that, to be able to say, ‘I love you, I see you, you’re gorgeous, you’re absolutely worth loving.’”

Modern Love, Cristin Milioti and Laurentiu Possa (Christopher Saunders/Amazon Studios)
(Photo by Christopher Saunders/Amazon Studios)

Another gem in the line-up, “When the Doorman Is Your Main Man,” is about the friendship that develops between Cristin Milioti’s Maggie and Laurentiu Possa’s Guzmin, the titular doorman who seems a little too concerned about Maggie’s love life.

Like the best of the “Modern Love” columns and TV episodes, this story highlights how it’s the connections people forge with each other, romantic and otherwise, that prevent them from being swallowed up and isolated in a fast-paced world or a big city like New York. Guzmin and Maggie have something more important than a fling: a friendship that continues through Maggie’s pregnancy, her life as a single mother, and other major life changes.

“I think they’re … like two kindred spirits,” Milioti said about the episode, which also spotlights the not-at-all uncommon bonds that form between longtime residents and the doormen (and women) who become a part of their daily lives.

Modern Love, Olivia Cooke, Kyle Goodman, and Andrew Scott (Christopher Saunders/Amazon Studios)
(Photo by Christopher Saunders/Amazon Studios)

Another of the series’ best episodes stars an alum of another Amazon series: Andrew Scott (yes, Fleabag’s Hot Priest) in “Hers Was a World of One” (based on “Modern Love: Three Mothers, One Bond“). Scott’s Tobin and Brandon Kyle Goodman’s Andy are a gay couple who enter an open adoption with homeless-by-choice free spirit Karla (Olivia Cooke).

Karla upends their well-ordered life well before the baby arrives, and Tobin, in particular, becomes more open-minded and tolerant as he very reluctantly at first experiences with Karla’s bohemian lifestyle.

“We’re very interested in identity politics, and we’re very interested in what we are, where we come from, where we’re going, and I think what’s very important to remember is we can co-exist with people and love people and like them and have them in our lives that have completely different political aspirations and points of view,” Scott said. “And our job is not to annihilate people who disagree with us, but to try to co-exist with everyone … and that’s really what this story says.”

“And that families can look different,” Goodman added. “It doesn’t have to be a mom and dad … there can be three parents together. It’s about love, and the child having their love, whoever the parents are.”

Modern Love, Julia Garner (Christopher Saunders/Amazon Studios)
(Photo by Christopher Saunders/Amazon Studios)

Other stars of Modern Love episodes include Catherine Keener, Dev Patel, Andy Garcia, Julia Garner, Shea Whigham, Jane Alexander, Judd Hirsch, Peter Hermann,
Sofia Boutella, and John Gallagher Jr. with guest spots by a certain red-headed British pop star and a Chopped star. Whether or not you enjoy their New York–set stories depends largely on how much you like the cast, and whether or not you’re a fan of the personal essay-ness of the NYT column.

Not every story is as compelling, or just plain entertaining on a rom-com level, but Hathaway and Carr’s performances do create one of the most satisfying episodes of TV of the year.

Modern Love is now streaming on Amazon Prime Video.

Adjusted Score: 78.892%
Critics Consensus: Carried by its charming cast, Modern Love sweet and simple sensibilities are easy enough to enjoy, even if its quaint portrait of modern life in New York City doesn't always ring true.
Synopsis: An unlikely friendship. A lost love resurfaced. A marriage at its turning point. A date that might not have been... [More]

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

A24 Mary poppins Biopics CMT Turner Thanksgiving Oscars romantic comedy Turner Classic Movies TCA Paramount Disney streaming service Ellie Kemper LGBT cults period drama spinoff Mystery Film Pet Sematary Summer Classic Film romance science fiction Podcast Food Network Spectrum Originals Lionsgate ghosts Ghostbusters series Red Carpet Infographic Photos canceled 21st Century Fox HBO Max Country Star Trek christmas movies Apple TV Plus Calendar Universal Crunchyroll Acorn TV sequel IFC Films TV Sundance San Diego Comic-Con Martial Arts Super Bowl versus WarnerMedia President Hulu Year in Review Marvel Lifetime social media CBS All Access PBS BBC Masterpiece discovery Video Games Paramount Network 2019 Holiday sitcom ratings stand-up comedy facebook dramedy supernatural The Witch Chilling Adventures of Sabrina game of thrones foreign Arrowverse jamie lee curtis Sony Pictures Disney Plus Lucasfilm Shondaland Election talk show YouTube TLC spanish language Grammys Superheroes robots TCM Character Guide Trailer Schedule Disney Disney Channel Winter TV ITV SXSW dc A&E MSNBC YouTube Red politics vampires Emmy Nominations National Geographic werewolf ESPN Valentine's Day See It Skip It Comedy Central WGN Peacock Mudbound Cannes DC Universe blaxploitation Holidays Walt Disney Pictures Amazon miniseries NBC cancelled TV shows Elton John disaster Comedy New York Comic Con Starz USA Sundance Now Best and Worst quibi aliens blockbuster Warner Bros. binge cinemax Marathons cooking comic TBS Spring TV VH1 kids RT21 breaking bad Esquire 71st Emmy Awards Black Mirror Sneak Peek TNT Opinion sports indie Captain marvel Winners serial killer Women's History Month rotten movies we love animated CW Seed GLAAD dceu screenings SDCC thriller award winner television halloween technology Marvel Studios biography Rocketman Watching Series Pride Month The CW cars Chernobyl spain revenge ABC Family Extras TIFF adventure Netflix Tarantino joker justice league YouTube Premium Star Wars Drama TV Land TV renewals Nominations crime Film Festival Netflix Christmas movies Tomatazos cancelled television USA Network Toys political drama American Society of Cinematographers First Look FXX Brie Larson NYCC GIFs Superheroe Kids & Family YA Sci-Fi Western Rock Awards Tour ABC Lifetime Christmas movies police drama medical drama Nat Geo Syfy RT History richard e. Grant Set visit book Reality Box Office zombie Mary Tyler Moore Binge Guide festivals nature Vudu Fox News 24 frames Amazon Prime Video Rom-Com true crime video game show FOX children's TV Hallmark Christmas movies cancelled cancelled TV series The Walking Dead Song of Ice and Fire Adult Swim Apple HBO IFC dragons cats DC Comics 2017 movies green book crossover BET DirecTV GoT tv talk transformers Musical Mary Poppins Returns SundanceTV Musicals mutant Family docudrama anthology Pixar travel VICE 2015 war psycho streaming Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt doctor who Pirates Amazon Prime boxoffice Creative Arts Emmys Fantasy golden globes Premiere Dates elevated horror teaser Cartoon Network cops Comic Book Showtime Reality Competition AMC based on movie adaptation Television Academy 2016 Countdown CNN latino Marvel Television History comiccon Hallmark cartoon Logo crime thriller Spike psychological thriller Polls and Games Action crime drama Columbia Pictures 2018 Comics on TV BBC America canceled TV shows Rocky Animation spy thriller witnail batman slashers MCU zombies Music 007 what to watch Teen Ovation LGBTQ harry potter DGA spider-man composers finale PaleyFest historical drama First Reviews renewed TV shows casting 20th Century Fox FX Mindy Kaling toy story Quiz Horror Emmys south america Christmas hist independent singing competition Epix Awards natural history Heroines anime APB diversity Trophy Talk Certified Fresh E3 Britbox Writers Guild of America Cosplay X-Men Dark Horse Comics Fall TV CBS zero dark thirty Bravo unscripted Interview Anna Paquin The Purge Trivia DC streaming service Tumblr Shudder strong female leads Apple TV+ 45 TCA 2017 space Stephen King hispanic mockumentary theme song Disney+ Disney Plus E! El Rey Crackle Pop TruTV Freeform Nickelodeon MTV free movies The Arrangement OWN