Critics Consensus

Is Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice Critical Kryptonite?

Plus, My Big Fat Greek Wedding 2 is a stale sequel.

by and | March 24, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a superhero battle royale (Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, starring Ben Affleck and Henry Cavill) and a family reunion (My Big Fat Greek Wedding 2, starring Nia Vardalos and John Corbett). What do the critics have to say?


Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016) 28%

Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice promises both an epic throwdown between two of popular culture’s most beloved characters and a world-building introduction to the DC Comics Extended Universe. Unfortunately, critics say this hotly-anticipated superhero flick is a big misfire — a narratively slack, overly self-serious action fest that fails to do justice to the essence of its titular heroes. Following the events of Man of Steel — in which much of Metropolis was reduced to rubble — Bruce Wayne (Ben Affleck) becomes deeply concerned about Superman’s unchecked power. Meanwhile, Clark Kent (Henry Cavill) has some quibbles with Batman’s vigilante approach to fighting crime in Gotham City. The critics say Batman V Superman benefits from strong performances (particularly Affleck and Gal Gadot as Wonder Woman) and moments of striking visual panache, but overall, it’s less gritty than depressing, and less exciting than bombastic.


My Big Fat Greek Wedding 2 (2016) 28%

Back in 2002, former Second City member Nia Vardalos earned heaps of praise and a Best Original Screenplay Oscar nod for writing and starring in the surprise hit rom-com My Big Fat Greek Wedding. It’s unclear what prompted a sequel 14 years later, but it’s here now, and critics say it’s not likely to win any awards. Vardalos reprises her role as Toula Portokalos, who discovers her parents were never officially married and decides to organize a bigger, fatter, Greeker wedding for them. The pundits say My Big Fat Greek Wedding 2 is predictably sentimental and harmless enough, but its recycled jokes and aimless narrative do little to justify its existence.


What’s Hot on TV

The Catch: Season 1 (2015) 74%

While the jury is out on its weekly worthiness, The Catch largely yields satisfying results with tried-and-true Shondaland production qualities, fun cases of the week, and bendy plot twists.


Heartbeat: Season 1 (2015) 20%

Heartbeat is a Frankensteined drama made up of hospital genre cliches and unlikable characters, though the cases-of-the-week are sporadically interesting.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

TruTV Song of Ice and Fire rotten movies we love Quiz romantic comedy movies Pirates dogs space name the review Comic Book Turner Freeform San Diego Comic-Con Women's History Month E! Stephen King A24 Schedule The Arrangement science fiction crime Esquire MSNBC animated revenge based on movie Teen Nat Geo APB Hulu Logo ghosts Masterpiece tv talk Marvel Studios Awards Tour New York Comic Con reboot Holidays Academy Awards Fox News Hallmark Watching Series 71st Emmy Awards Travel Channel aliens Sneak Peek reviews political drama binge CBS joker canceled thriller Animation christmas movies Netflix Winners HBO Max social media A&E crossover Anna Paquin Film Festival war Certified Fresh LGBTQ disaster Paramount Network Elton John comic movie Marathons TV renewals 2015 Shondaland Food Network zombies Trailer Star Wars green book game of thrones Netflix Christmas movies sequel BET cats MTV Hallmark Christmas movies blockbuster police drama NYCC vampires Awards Nickelodeon Disney Channel screen actors guild TCA 2017 south america Video Games Red Carpet Sundance Set visit Avengers scary movies Amazon Prime Video adaptation richard e. Grant Britbox Walt Disney Pictures SundanceTV composers true crime batman Photos 2020 ABC Family singing competition Trivia Television Academy Classic Film Mary Tyler Moore Holiday casting Rom-Com werewolf spy thriller 2018 Western Cartoon Network Baby Yoda discovery ITV festivals breaking bad Ellie Kemper FXX Toys TV dragons Thanksgiving natural history Warner Bros. Universal spinoff Mary Poppins Returns Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Musical Mudbound sitcom Sundance Now adventure romance cinemax VH1 Pride Month First Look period drama TCA Winter 2020 anthology zero dark thirty Emmys Infographic El Rey Writers Guild of America Binge Guide cancelled TV shows cars doctor who 20th Century Fox Countdown nature spanish language facebook Pet Sematary NBC FX PBS WarnerMedia Spectrum Originals cops Interview FOX teaser Disney Plus politics Action Showtime 2019 mutant Sci-Fi strong female leads docudrama Ovation TV Land Extras Winter TV cartoon spain Bravo Funimation The Witch psycho serial killer golden globes latino Cannes supernatural Comics on TV spider-man WGN BBC America anime free movies Reality Competition blaxploitation RT21 Paramount Comedy cancelled television GoT YouTube Premium cooking Marvel Television Best and Worst quibi jamie lee curtis video Spring TV Arrowverse Premiere Dates Superheroes book medical drama HBO boxoffice Starz Creative Arts Emmys American Society of Cinematographers franchise E3 YouTube Rocketman Lionsgate Amazon transformers The CW canceled TV shows YA Reality diversity Epix sports Sony Pictures Pop Kids & Family theme song game show The Purge cults IFC IFC Films documentary Christmas Vudu stand-up comedy YouTube Red ABC X-Men Character Guide Ghostbusters Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dramedy Mindy Kaling LGBT Fall TV award winner Opinion SDCC Tomatazos GLAAD hispanic miniseries See It Skip It Syfy USA Network series dceu Lucasfilm Music Discovery Channel Biopics versus DC Universe ESPN kids VICE cancelled Tubi Sundance TV mockumentary DirecTV CBS All Access crime drama TNT Rocky Mystery renewed TV shows TCM Lifetime PaleyFest DC Comics President Family witnail CMT Peacock Black History Month directors Fantasy Shudder OneApp CNN Mary poppins RT History finale Oscars Horror National Geographic 007 Summer 2017 Film Captain marvel indie Podcast elevated horror Lifetime Christmas movies USA talk show 45 MCU Marvel halloween Drama DC streaming service FX on Hulu Amazon Studios Election Disney streaming service Pixar comics slashers Spike SXSW travel Calendar justice league Tarantino what to watch hist Valentine's Day Cosplay television 21st Century Fox comiccon 2016 sag awards TIFF children's TV universal monsters First Reviews 24 frames robots BBC harry potter cancelled TV series Rock Adult Swim TBS Crunchyroll Grammys CW Seed AMC Year in Review Chernobyl Superheroe Nominations TLC Apple TV Plus DGA GIFs foreign Comedy Central psychological thriller Brie Larson screenings zombie Box Office Columbia Pictures Emmy Nominations Musicals streaming Pop TV Dark Horse Comics Turner Classic Movies historical drama Apple Trophy Talk Acorn TV crime thriller biography Star Trek technology Disney Crackle toy story unscripted Apple TV+ Polls and Games Super Bowl Disney+ Disney Plus Heroines Black Mirror OWN The Walking Dead Country History Martial Arts ratings Endgame dc independent Amazon Prime Tumblr TCA