Total Recall

Benicio Del Toro's 10 Best Movies

In this week's Total Recall, we look back at the Sicario: Day of the Soldado star's best-reviewed movies.

by | June 27, 2018 | Comments

With this weekend’s Sicario: Day of the SoldadoBenicio Del Toro returns to the role of CIA spook Alejandro Gillick for another round of grim and gritty action south of the border — and adds another entry to a filmography that’s gone in any number of exciting directions since he notched his first big-screen credit as Duke, the Dog-Faced Boy in Big Top Pee-wee 30 years ago. There’s clearly no time like the present to take a fond look back at some of his Oscar-winning thespian’s brightest critical highlights, and you know what that means: it’s time for Total Recall!

1. Sicario (2015) 92%

(Photo by Richard Foreman Jr./Lionsgate)

Some pretty powerful films have been made about the international drug trade — look no further than Traffic, right next door to this entry, for proof — and at this point, if you’re going to throw your cinematic hat in the ring, you’d better be prepared to add a singular statement to the genre. Director Denis Villeneuve managed to pull it off with 2015’s Sicario, starring Emily Blunt as an FBI agent who teams up with a pair of CIA operatives (Josh Brolin and Benicio Del Toro) to bring down a Mexican cartel. In terms of plot outline, it’s boilerplate stuff — but in Villeneuve and screenwriter Taylor Sheridan’s hands, and through the stellar efforts of the well-chosen cast, the end results are elevated considerably. “Far from being just another crime story,” wrote the St. Louis Post-Dispatch’s Calvin Wilson, “Sicario is cinema at its most ambitious.”

2. Traffic (2000) 92%

(Photo by USA Films courtesy Everett Collection)

One of the more darkly ambitious films to make its way through the studio system over the 20 years, Steven Soderbergh’s Traffic looks at the human cost of the drug trade by following seemingly unconnected stories that slowly converge. In Mexico, a police officer (Benicio Del Toro, who won an Oscar for his work) becomes the unwitting employee of a drug lord; in San Diego, a major dealer (Miguel Ferrer) is targeted by a pair of DEA agents (Don Cheadle and Luis Guzman); and in the Midwest, a crusading judge (Michael Douglas) finds his black-and-white views on drugs challenged when his teenage daughter (Erika Christensen) develops a cocaine addiction. In condensing the six-part BBC series Traffik, Soderbergh had to trim some of the original’s heft, but Traffic was still a four-time Academy Award winner (including Best Director) as well as one of the best-reviewed films of the year, thanks to critics like Andrew Sarris of the New York Observer, who proclaimed, “The promise of Sex, Lies, and Videotape has been fulfilled.”

3. Star Wars: The Last Jedi (2017) 91%

(Photo by Jonathan Olley/Walt Disney Studios)

Decades after Randall from Clerks argued that the Star Wars Empire couldn’t have solidified its rule without the work of countless grunts, wage slaves, and dispassionate bureaucrats who were only trying to make a living, the saga got around to echoing that point explicitly — and doing so with an assist from DJ (Benicio Del Toro), the determinedly morally ambiguous hacker who fills in Finn and Rose on the existence of a galactic arms trade fueling both sides of the war between the First Order and the Resistance. Proving he doesn’t see much of a difference between either ideology, DJ ends up stabbing his new friends in the back for a quick buck, paving the way for an epic set piece while adding another layer to a story once told as a simple battle between good and evil. “Nothing in The Last Jedi is allowed to be mundane,” wrote NPR’s Bob Mondello. “Including the places the filmmakers take the story.”

4. Guardians of the Galaxy (2014) 92%

(Photo by Marvel Studios)

Over the course of his career, Benicio del Toro has yoinked the spotlight from numerous above-the-title stars in all sorts of ways, from the flashy to the subtle — and although his tenure as the Collector in the Marvel Cinematic Universe hasn’t allowed him to (ahem) collect much screentime with appearances in Thor: The Dark WorldAvengers: Infinity War, and, most prominently, Guardians of the Galaxy, it’s definitely one of his more memorably outlandish roles. As his name suggests, he’s known for gathering stuff, including a number of priceless and powerful artifacts — including an Infinity Stone, which puts him in the path of the homicidal Thanos on the Mad Titan’s quest to restore order to the universe by wiping out half of all life. His brief (and apparently illusory) appearance in 2018’s Infinity War might have briefly convinced audiences he was done for, but if it seems unlikely we’ll see the Collector again, Del Toro can at least point to his pivotal role in GotG as a high note. “If you’re old enough to remember when sci-fi and comic books were fun,” wrote Joe Williams of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, “Guardians of the Galaxy will be your new favorite movie. If you’re not, it will set a standard for everything you see.”

5. The Usual Suspects (1995) 88%

(Photo by Gramercy courtesy Everett Collection)

The greatest trick the Devil ever pulled was convincing the world he didn’t exist, but the greatest one Kevin Spacey might have pulled was scoring the role of Roger “Verbal” Kint, the palsied small-time hood whose post-heist interrogation frames the twisty goings-on of Bryan Singer’s neo-noir ‘90s classic The Usual Suspects. It turned into an Academy Award-winning breakout vehicle for the actor, but he certainly didn’t do it alone: Suspects is a quintessentially ’90s ensemble piece, spinning a number of narrative plates with the aid of an outstanding cast that included Pete Postlethwaite, Gabriel Byrne, Kevin Pollak, and — as the virtually incomprehensible crook Fred Fenster — Benicio Del Toro, who stole every scene he was in even though no one ever had any idea what he was saying. A master class in character actor chemistry, Suspects provided audiences with 106 minutes of water-cooler entertainment in the bargain — and earned some of the best reviews of the year. “For many true movie fiends, noir is the key American movie type, and the most fun when it’s done right,” observed Newsweek’s Jack Kroll. “The Usual Suspects is done right.”

6. Fearless (1993) 85%

(Photo by Warner Bros. courtesy Everett Collection)

Cheating death sounds like an incredible gift — but what do you do after you’ve accepted you’re about to die and walked away from the experience? As Peter Weir’s Fearless powerfully argues, that second lease on life can sometimes be harder to come to grips with than we might imagine — especially if you’re like protagonist Max Klein (Jeff Bridges), who survives a plane crash that ends up killing almost everyone on board and embarks on a quest that includes reaching out to a fellow passenger (Rosie Perez) who’s coping with survivor’s guilt without assistance from her boyfriend (Benicio Del Toro). The type of thought-provoking adult drama that seems all but extinct in the modern studio system, Fearless didn’t make much of a dent at the box office after its 1993 release, but many critics rightly applauded it as a refreshing change of pace. Calling it “the rare commercial movie that raises more questions than it answers,” Newsweek’s David Ansen wrote, “You leave it in an altered state yourself — moved, not quite satisfied, but certain you’ve seen something out of the ordinary.”

7. 21 Grams (2003) 80%

(Photo by Focus Features courtesy Everett Collection)

The second installment in writer-director Alejandro González Iñárritu’s “Trilogy of Death,” 21 Grams wrings some outstanding performances (not to mention plenty of tears) out of an outstanding cast in service of a gripping — albeit harrowing — tale. Using a handful of seemingly disparate plot threads, Iñárritu plunged viewers into the darkness pooling out of a tragedy unintentionally wrought by an ex-con (Benicio Del Toro) whose irrevocable mistake has a profound impact on a dying math professor (Sean Penn) and a woman with a complicated past (Naomi Watts) — all of whom are drawn irrevocably together by the final act. Watts and Del Toro both earned Oscar nominations for their work, and neither could be accused of holding anything back; as Moira MacDonald wrote for the Seattle Times, “Watching it is a wrenching experience; the usual layers of distance between actors and audience are stripped away, and we not only watch their anguish, but become part of it.”

8. Swimming With Sharks (1994) 78%

(Photo by Lionsgate)

One of two critically acclaimed releases that saw Benicio Del Toro sharing screentime with Kevin Spacey in 1995, Swimming with Sharks revolves around Spacey’s Buddy Ackerman, a bottomlessly selfish studio executive haranguing the naive film-school graduate (Frank Whaley) who unwittingly agrees to enter a waking nightmare when he signs on to become Ackerman’s new assistant. Del Toro, playing Whalley’s predecessor, isn’t seen for long — Sharks is dominated by Spacey’s volcanic performance — but he was already well on his way to “that guy” status, and this is another early example of why. Little-seen during its initial release, writer-director George Huang’s black comedy was a hit with critics like MaryAnn Johanson of Flick Filosopher, who deemed it “As fine a ‘revenge on the boss from hell’ movie as the wickedly vindictive 9 to 5 (and as outrageous a satire on Hollywood as The Player).”

9. The Funeral (1996) 79%

(Photo by October Films courtesy Everett Collection)

With Abel Ferrara behind the camera, an ensemble cast led by Christopher Walken and Chris Penn, and a storyline revolving around occasionally grisly gang violence, The Funeral should rank among the quintessential indie dramas of the ’90s. It’s mostly escaped the spotlight since its release, but even in the context of Ferrara’s typically hard-hitting work, it’s dark stuff — the story of a pair of gangsters who set out to avenge their brother’s (Vincent Gallo) murder by retaliating against the competing mobster (Benicio Del Toro) they suspect of the crime. Naturally, not all is as it seems; the brothers’ quest takes some unexpected turns, and what might have been a simple shoot-’em-up has more on its mind. While audiences didn’t turn out, critics were suitably impressed; as Desson Thomson wrote for the Washington Post, “You’re engaged on a moral level rarely found in movies about violence.”

10. The Pledge (2001) 78%

(Photo by Warner Bros. courtesy Everett Collection)

Few who watched Sean Penn’s timeless turn as the affably bewildered stoner Jeff Spicoli in Fast Times at Ridgemont High could have guessed he’d grow up to favor dark dramas — or that when he eventually started directing features of his own, they’d include the sort of harrowing descent into the darkest depths of human nature plumbed by 2001’s The Pledge. The story begins with an alcoholic police detective (Jack Nicholson) whose retirement party is interrupted by the news of a young girl’s murder; pledged to solve the case by the victim’s mother, he doggedly persists in hunting down the killer even after it’s officially closed by the confession — and subsequent suicide — of a local man with a learning disability. Del Toro’s relatively brief (and somewhat controversial) appearance as the suspect is just one of several disquieting things about the film, which was destined for the commercial margins even as it drew applause from critics like Sean Burns of the Philadelphia Weekly, who wrote, “Steeped in an almost unbearable sadness, dense with moral ambiguity, it stubbornly withholds comfort at every startling turn.”

Tag Cloud

Holiday olympics LGBTQ Marvel Television Hulu telelvision cinemax SDCC Creative Arts Emmys RT21 action-comedy talk show lord of the rings Cartoon Network The Purge rotten HBO Go based on movie prank spanish 99% reviews 73rd Emmy Awards franchise streaming movies YA Amazon Prime marvel comics Walt Disney Pictures boxoffice series spanish language Classic Film kong green book A24 Mudbound monster movies Pop TV Thanksgiving a nightmare on elm street Mary Poppins Returns slashers crime renewed TV shows twilight mutant aapi Endgame VOD Character Guide 2017 VICE hidden camera tv talk book adaptation NBA Apple TV+ Photos composers debate worst stand-up comedy Captain marvel Marathons award winner TruTV child's play Mystery MTV spy thriller docuseries Calendar YouTube Red Comedy all-time jurassic park Infographic comic books ID rotten movies we love Song of Ice and Fire Mary poppins cartoon Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt crime thriller Exclusive Video dramedy National Geographic festivals Legendary Star Wars TCA 2017 robots hist Avengers psychological thriller Best and Worst french critic resources indie 72 Emmy Awards TV spider-man Sundance TV space IFC Films docudrama international slasher festival ghosts USA Network ESPN BBC American Society of Cinematographers Red Carpet news Food Network remakes Disney Channel Rocky OneApp IFC Certified Fresh Fox Searchlight Discovery Channel archives WGN justice league Apple TV Plus harry potter Amazon new zealand women The Academy Martial Arts Pop sports MSNBC superhero Animation Country jamie lee curtis Columbia Pictures El Rey critics Pacific Islander Election Women's History Month target Hear Us Out USA golden globe awards FX on Hulu Paramount movies Extras name the review Academy Awards wonder woman Masterpiece crime drama stoner Disney streaming service PlayStation CMT Paramount Plus First Reviews cancelled television casting Awards Opinion Countdown cancelled Image Comics popular Oscars cars 2020 Esquire children's TV dc Ellie Kemper Syfy BBC One Rocketman Shudder TLC Netflix Christmas movies DGA biography Black Mirror Spectrum Originals dexter halloween tv Hallmark Christmas movies 1990s Marvel Studios golden globes Nat Geo sequel Spring TV cancelled TV shows saw The CW godzilla deadpool 21st Century Fox football 71st Emmy Awards SundanceTV die hard obituary ABC Turner Classic Movies TCA Winter 2020 Comic-Con@Home 2021 Watching Series richard e. Grant Nominations social media LGBT screen actors guild Cannes Christmas facebook posters TCA Awards Turner San Diego Comic-Con 24 frames 45 independent Chernobyl Starz boxing documentaries comedies strong female leads fresh dceu RT History Podcast rt archives television binge adaptation Mary Tyler Moore true crime Pride Month Winners marvel cinematic universe ITV Black History Month Crunchyroll Emmy Nominations TV renewals 90s legend romance new star wars movies natural history video on demand Baby Yoda Crackle cancelled TV series medical drama kaiju Television Academy History revenge comic book movies werewolf Anna Paquin black science fiction E! trailers fast and furious Western The Walt Disney Company Freeform political drama New York Comic Con diversity 2021 supernatural Peacock Disney Plus documentary hispanic BET Adult Swim Wes Anderson Travel Channel Teen young adult sequels thriller Schedule Nickelodeon anime basketball Premiere Dates finale 20th Century Fox satire Horror nature elevated horror japanese Reality comic HBO Max latino DC streaming service mcc adenture vampires Elton John FXX 007 Tomatazos Cosplay Mindy Kaling scorecard 4/20 CBS All Access nfl historical drama Netflix rt labs Comedy Central doctor who BBC America Warner Bros. miniseries TV Land classics video Pixar canceled versus 2019 rt labs critics edition Superheroes Year in Review scary movies President japan movie kids dogs gangster GLAAD WarnerMedia war Sony Pictures DC Universe king kong Awards Tour high school Ovation ABC Signature First Look comics spain Britbox what to watch new york Family ViacomCBS GIFs Tumblr TBS christmas movies Binge Guide NYCC Pirates Emmys films Polls and Games theme song discovery Holidays GoT book cooking Shondaland DirecTV biopic game show comic book movie mockumentary PBS Lucasfilm razzies Sneak Peek sag awards Toys SXSW Alien crossover Film Festival Fall TV YouTube Premium superman Video Games TCM Musical NBC Logo Broadway Super Bowl asian-american psycho transformers animated heist movie scene in color Biopics YouTube Interview The Witch BAFTA TNT Epix TIFF Comics on TV TV movies anthology 2015 travel rom-coms Stephen King Ghostbusters Apple spinoff Lifetime Fantasy OWN Rom-Com Disney Writers Guild of America chucky quibi Sundance royal family PaleyFest laika TV One zombies Bravo dragons CBS batman Brie Larson best stop motion cats blaxploitation Sundance Now Trailer indiana jones Lionsgate See It Skip It Acorn TV 2018 foreign E3 DC Comics dark A&E Hallmark emmy awards Funimation serial killer Paramount Network Quiz directors Star Trek blockbusters zombie live action HBO CNN Trivia Valentine's Day venice Comic Book toy story MCU disaster Universal Pet Sematary ratings Music Television Critics Association know your critic technology ABC Family singing competition FOX comiccon pirates of the caribbean Box Office parents Set visit Amazon Prime Video Kids & Family zero dark thirty Showtime halloween Grammys Arrowverse Dark Horse Comics Sci-Fi reboot Vudu politics Film adventure james bond FX period drama romantic comedy 93rd Oscars south america Reality Competition Disney+ Disney Plus Tubi sitcom Rock mission: impossible Tarantino toronto screenings king arthur Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Marvel Winter TV The Arrangement police drama aliens nbcuniversal feel good Superheroe universal monsters Tokyo Olympics joker BET Awards streaming hollywood Spike hispanic heritage month Heroines Drama X-Men game of thrones teaser Fox News Trophy Talk blockbuster suspense AMC VH1 free movies italian breaking bad Musicals 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards The Walking Dead Summer worst movies unscripted witnail TCA australia 2016 canceled TV shows Lifetime Christmas movies APB Amazon Studios cults cops criterion CW Seed Action concert