Trophy Talk

Rotten Tomatoes’ Ridiculously Early Oscar Predictions: Best Actor

Will Smith, Timothée Chalamet, and Dev Patel lead old vets, Oscar darlings, and fresh faces vying for the trophy in an unpredictable year.

by | August 16, 2021 | Comments

Timothee Chalamet in Dune

(Photo by Warner Bros.)

Our Ridiculously Early Prediction Series feels particularly ridiculous this time around because it has only been a few months since the last awards season wrapped. Wasn’t it just yesterday that Nomadland was crowned Best Picture at the 93rd Academy Awards? Not quite, but the 2022 season is now in full swing, and we are back to kick off our series with the Best Actor contest.

Most of the films on our list of potential Best Actor performances have yet to screen for critics or at a festival, but most will debut soon, and early buzz is out for some that borrow from existing source material. The Best Actor race is poised to feature several prior winners and former nominees competing against an ever-growing slate of newcomers and marquee names yet to receive their first Oscar nominations. If history — or basic math — tells us anything, it’s that many of these names won’t make it to Oscar night, but we’re pretty confident most of them will be right up there in the awards chatter. So read on as we break down our ridiculously early picks for 2022’s Best Actors.

Disagree with our picks? Have at us in the comments.

Will Smith

King Richard (2021)

Nowadays, Will Smith makes more headlines for his meme-worthy Instagram feed and guest appearances on his wife’s Red Table Talk series, but King Richard should remind everyone that he is, in fact, one of the best actors of our generation and one of the last bona fide “movie stars.” Starring as Richard Williams, the father of future tennis superstars Venus and Serena Williams, Smith is on track for his third acting nomination.

We don’t know much as of yet, and though the new trailer offers a glimpse of what to expect from the sports biopic, it’s still unclear if it will push past its “Sandra Bullock in The Blind Side” appeal to snag our Fresh Prince an Oscar win. No matter what happens on nomination morning, the film should enjoy similar commercial success to the football biopic that won Bullock the Best Actress statue in 2012 – or it would have in a typical year at the box office. Centering on earlier days of the Williams sisters’ tennis careers as they catapulted to the national stage, King Richard, like The Blind Side, will live or die by what Smith does on screen. Casting him as a dedicated and determined father should also bode well for him, as his last Best Actor nomination for The Pursuit of Happyness shared a similar crowd-pleasing, tear-jerking appeal. Funnily enough, for all that Smith has done in Hollywood, he has yet to win a golden statue, and both times he was nominated, he lost to another Black actor. Forest Whitaker topped him in 2007 for The Last King of Scotland, and our next pick for Best Actor took home the prize in 2002 when Smith was nominated for Ali.

(Photo by The Tragedy of Macbeth. Courtesy of Apple and A24.)

Denzel Washington

We thought Denzel Washington had his third Oscar wrapped up when he was nominated for 2016’s Fences. (Clearly so did he, as his disappointed reaction when Casey Affleck took home the prize went viral.) That said, it isn’t too difficult to envision several nominations emerge from his next film, a new adaptation of Shakespeare’s Macbeth in which he plays the ill-fated king. Besides the drama we expect from Washington and his on-screen wife Frances McDormand, director Joel Coen has to contend with his own bit of drama behind the scenes as this will be the first film of his career without his writing and directing partner, brother Ethan Coen, who announced he wanted to take a break from filmmaking to focus on theater. This black-and-white feature, which will open the New York Film Festival in September, is one of the most hotly anticipated films of the fall circuit, and early pundit whispers have been echoing the project with a different “M-word” actors get superstitious about – masterwork. With two Best Actor Oscars at home and nine total nominations, Washington is a threat whenever he is on screen, but with the addition of a director and co-star who both have four Oscars each, it’s hard to imagine Denzel’s name won’t be called come nominations morning. Right now, several months ahead of the ceremony, he is also the blind-speculation frontrunner.

Oscar Isaac

Speaking of the Coens, we might as well remind everyone that we are still upset that our next Best Actor contender, Oscar Isaac, was not nominated for his brilliant work in 2013’s Inside Llewyn Davis. This time around, we’re hoping he can finally snag his first nomination for Taxi Driver scribe Paul Schrader’s The Card Counter. Isaac plays an ex-con card counter named William Tell who looks to be plotting to avenge himself of a wrong committed by Oscar-nominated actor Willem Dafoe. We know from Oscar-nominated revenge thrillers like Unforgiven, Cape Fear, and Promising Young Woman that Academy voters love a dark revenge tale.

Despite his incredible filmography of groundbreaking cinema, Schrader has only been nominated once in his nearly five-decade career. His last effort, 2018’s First Reformed, snagged him his first nomination for writing, but in the same year, lead actor Ethan Hawke was snubbed for what we argued was a much-deserved nomination. Unlike First Reformed or even Isaac’s on-the-Oscar-bubble performance in Ex Machina, The Card Counter appears to be a more commercial effort that will appeal to wider audiences and the younger members of the Academy. Plus, the Star Wars actor also has another little sci-fi feature this year that will keep him top of mind throughout the season, and another potential Best Actor nominee plays his son…

Timothée Chalamet

Dune (2021)

Adaptations of Frank Herbert’s seminal novel Dune is a fraught enterprise – just ask director David Lynch, whose 1981 adaptation was a commercial and critical failure. This latest version, set to hit theaters in October after months of delay, could be our best shot to pay homage to the iconic sci-fi series. At the center of all that attention is Oscar-nominated actor Timothée Chalamet, who has been a staple of award-worthy cinema since he rose to prominence playing Elio in Call Me By Your Name. Chalamet also has the enviable honor of appearing in not one or two but three awards contenders this season, and word has it he is a threat to be nominated for all of them.

Many have remarked on Chalamet’s comedic chops in Wes Anderson’s The French Dispatch, and he will go up against the likes of Meryl Streep and Leonardo DiCaprio for Adam MacKay’s Don’t Look Up. We are thinking his performance as the prodigal prince returning home in Dune will be the one to capture the voters’ attention, but it never hurts to be featured in multiple contenders. Denis Villeneuve has racked up Oscar nominations for just about every one of his efforts in recent years, and though he has a less than stellar track record for grabbing Oscar nominations outside of below-the-line categories, the A-list talent of Dune could be what allows the Blade Runner 2049 director to overcome a hurdle he has yet to clear – directing an Oscar-nominated performance. In Lady Bird, Little Women, and The King, Chalamet has proven his ability to command an audience with a performance that belies his years. Considering the rich source material here and what we spied in the trailer, he will have plenty for an awards highlight reel.

Andrew Garfield

Andrew Garfield is another name on our list with two potential bites at the Oscar apple, with lead Performances in tick, tick… Boom! and The Eyes of Tammy Faye. Both have the potential to make a deep run come awards season, and it just might be down to which film is more beloved by the voting body. While tick, tick… Boom! could appeal to the Gothams and Indie Spirit crowd, playing televangelist Jim Bakker, who had a penchant for activities one would hardly classify as “living within the faith,” is the kind of role actors dream of playing. The Bakkers’ PTL ministries were, for a time, some of the most popular television programs in the United States, the donations from which exceeded millions of dollars. Their epic rise to the top of Christian television entertainment was only rivaled by their equally epic fall from grace. tick, tick… Boom! will showcase Garfield’s talent as a singer and performer, but we also expect to see that in The Eyes of Tammy Faye, in which he will deliver the gospel performances that catapulted the Bakkers into superstardom. Adding a delicious true-crime tale of rags to riches and a downfall by dirty deeds, we think his work alongside Oscar-nominated actress Jessica Chastain will be the performance that voters single out.

Simon Rex in Red Rocket

(Photo by A24)

Simon Rex

Red Rocket (2021)

This one is going to surprise some, and we have to admit it is a non-traditional choice. However, we are confidently placing our bet on Simon Rex as the narcissistic aging porn star in Red Rocket to make it to Oscar nightRex is likely more memorable from his days on MTV, his modeling work for Calvin Klein, or his comedic turns in the Scary Movie franchise, but he shows true acting prowess and comedic timing in this entertaining character study that premiered at the Cannes Film Festival in July. Playing adult film star Mikey Saber, who is down on his luck and back home in Texas after washing out in Los Angeles, Rex is already prompting conversations among critics about end-of-year honors; Guy Lodge for Film of the Week called it the “role of a lifetime for the former VJ.”

In truth, director Sean Baker’s uncanny skill with bold casting choices is what gave us Rex in the lead and what makes the film feel so indescribably authentic. At Cannes, Baker expressed his desire to center his next story on male sex workers (his previous efforts Tangerine, Starlet, and The Florida Project centered on female sex workers). That’s when he discovered so-called “suitcase pimps,” typically the unemployed boyfriends or husbands of porn stars who “take care” of the women and usually rake in a cut for their services. Rex, a man with more than few chapters in his Hollywood career, is the perfect choice, as he knows all too well what happens to people when the industry leaves them behind. His delivery on screen is undeniable and award-worthy, but he will have to work the circuit and have a little luck if he wants to rise above the fate that befell Adam Sandler during his Oscar campaign for Uncut Gems. Like Sandler, we predict Rex will find love and possibly a win at the Independent Spirit Awards no matter what happens with the Academy.

Ben Platt

The internet has been having a bit of fun with the idea of Ben Platt playing a high schooler while he himself is just three years shy of 30, and Platt hasn’t been doing himself any favors with his reaction to the naysayers, but we think he is a more than worthy contender for Best Actor. Already taking home a Grammy, Tony, and Emmy for his work on the smash Broadway musical Dear Evan Hansen, it is hard to argue he has more than a fighting chance at a Best Actor Oscar nom. Playing an awkward teenager who finds himself caught up in a lie he can’t undo, Platt has a part built to wow Oscar voters as he did Tony Voters in 2019. After Anthony Hopkins took home the Best Actor prize in 2020 for The Father, we think it is noteworthy to lean on the original theater  production’s pedigree: Like the role of the father in the eponymous play, every actor who has played Evan Hansen on stage has taken home a Best Actor prize. Though many have shaken their heads at some of the more controversial aspects of the film, it is anchored by such a gut-wrenching lead performance and underscored by Oscar-winning composers Benj Pasek and Justin Paul, and we think the Academy will be less concerned and more awed by what Platt will do on screen. This is another tearjerker with commercial appeal, and as many detractors as the film has online, there is an even more dedicated fanbase that has been anxiously waiting for the film to hit theaters.

Dev Patel

Outside of dark horse pick of Simon Rex in Red Rocket, our next outside-the-box pick is Dev Patel for The Green Knight, which is only fitting as it also was produced by the folks who gave us Adam Sandler in Uncut Gems and Robert Pattinson in The Lighthouse. The Green Knight will undoubtedly be a strong contender for below-the-line categories, but we don’t want to dismiss the lead performance by Patel, which might just be a bit too out there for many Oscar voters but remains one of the best performances we have seen this year. Like Rex, Patel has already enjoyed outstanding reviews from critics, with Sara Michelle Fetters of Movie Freak calling him “simply marvelous” and, despite the dense source material and lyrical adaptation, stating he “still makes it all work… while his physically stoic permutations gradually give way, stripping the character of his confidence and leaving him contentedly naked as he readies himself for his ‘gift’ from The Green Knight.” A polarizing film, to be sure, but even those who aren’t a fan of David Lowery’s Arthurian fable agree Patel is incredible in it. Such envelope-pushing performances have also not been a favorite among Academy voters in recent years, but the same could have been said for foreign language films and Best Picture… until Parasite made history.

Also in contention:

Thumbnail images by Warner Bros. and A24

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Rom-Com Comedy Central Awards Tour crime documentary 24 frames dragons franchise WarnerMedia revenge dark Rocky IFC Films cats Lifetime The Arrangement 2016 scary movies venice french documentaries foreign japanese Binge Guide hidden camera spanish language X-Men superhero Disney streaming service slasher YouTube sports mockumentary Calendar Image Comics New York Comic Con richard e. Grant Disney Channel WGN cancelled television spinoff adenture Tokyo Olympics Countdown scene in color Turner Classic Movies streaming movies Sundance Fox Searchlight quibi marvel cinematic universe Horror nbcuniversal cartoon doctor who Bravo deadpool Photos Drama Pop TV 2018 slashers Esquire king arthur spanish Amazon Prime godzilla boxoffice TV renewals crime thriller 1990s First Look MSNBC CBS Heroines Shudder romance singing competition mob Cosplay Academy Awards rt labs critics edition Summer canceled TV shows heist movie parents President kids rotten movies we love toy story VH1 Neflix natural history target joker Rocketman nature science fiction hispanic mission: impossible spain Schedule YouTube Premium breaking bad Shondaland name the review blockbusters halloween Vudu Arrowverse king kong high school robots romantic comedy elevated horror Chernobyl news Logo TLC Superheroes Elton John CNN australia composers wonder woman Comic-Con@Home 2021 scorecard award winner anime Quiz Awards finale hispanic heritage month docuseries Instagram Live reviews cooking The Walt Disney Company DC streaming service Kids & Family cancelled TV series OWN fresh VOD Video Games versus Teen renewed TV shows Showtime DC Comics FOX Black Mirror TruTV concert new zealand black comedy young adult Martial Arts critic resources Spring TV Walt Disney Pictures docudrama Pride Month spy thriller critics japan Legendary Superheroe Alien AMC MTV ViacomCBS CMT hist teaser talk show true crime independent USA dc 2020 Star Trek popular BET Awards Amazon Prime Video Red Carpet fast and furious worst movies dceu Netflix Christmas movies stoner thriller Premiere Dates nfl rom-coms Spike Pet Sematary biopic streaming biography Film politics Mindy Kaling Tumblr YA war A24 monster movies criterion Infographic PaleyFest YouTube Red mutant Hallmark cops ITV AMC Plus zero dark thirty what to watch hollywood best Masterpiece TV Land TIFF zombie movies all-time NYCC ID DGA Universal Pictures diversity Crackle comic book movies international vs. crossover theme song comedies Syfy Lionsgate Brie Larson police drama Opinion FX on Hulu jurassic park Creative Arts Emmys Fox News Columbia Pictures spider-verse transformers period drama Valentine's Day adaptation feel good mcc Britbox Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Podcast BBC ABC Signature halloween tv know your critic Disney comic books serial killer SundanceTV game of thrones comiccon political drama 21st Century Fox trailers Universal indie Animation TCA Winter 2020 genre strong female leads asian-american Travel Channel justice league 71st Emmy Awards sag awards sequels Rock miniseries Year in Review Mudbound TV Hulu Amazon Studios christmas movies Cannes Christmas Pop superman latino festival golden globe awards Starz dogs Funimation prank south america discovery Broadway Writers Guild of America royal family BBC One based on movie reboot MCU rt labs See It Skip It Exclusive Video ABC Family game show kaiju harry potter new star wars movies Watching Series dexter 007 cancelled TV shows live action Nickelodeon jamie lee curtis die hard facebook 2019 cars worst video DirecTV GoT Apple comics Comedy olympics telelvision USA Network unscripted E! satire The CW Biopics Cartoon Network Paramount Network Western book adaptation Trophy Talk Freeform TCM 99% TBS adventure Paramount Plus PBS Emmys Star Wars Turner Music OneApp RT History Tubi Stephen King scary TNT Hear Us Out binge gangster Action Sundance TV 20th Century Fox Mary poppins stop motion marvel comics Holiday vampires The Witch art house new york Country psychological thriller laika Captain marvel TV movies Women's History Month Polls and Games Thanksgiving legend cancelled Mary Tyler Moore Crunchyroll child's play Box Office Grammys Character Guide lord of the rings Black History Month james bond stand-up comedy ratings Comics on TV Interview Nominations Ghostbusters screen actors guild boxing HBO Max travel space a nightmare on elm street ESPN Nat Geo BET 4/20 Holidays social media A&E ghosts toronto CBS All Access Sneak Peek Wes Anderson Apple TV+ classics Ellie Kemper Disney+ Disney Plus Emmy Nominations Discovery Channel spider-man chucky HBO FXX Musical TCA 2017 Dark Horse Comics Anna Paquin First Reviews APB films El Rey werewolf technology Spectrum Originals basketball HBO Go Classic Film debate 2017 E3 SXSW posters Reality Competition Television Academy CW Seed crime drama aliens obituary Hallmark Christmas movies 2015 PlayStation 72 Emmy Awards BAFTA batman Marvel Studios historical drama Sci-Fi Disney Plus IMDb TV BBC America Tarantino Marvel canceled football blaxploitation television National Geographic Pirates comic cinemax 73rd Emmy Awards Tomatazos ABC Epix IFC Musicals Marvel Television Family black disaster Winter TV Television Critics Association emmy awards 2021 supernatural Winners Apple TV Plus VICE witnail Trailer LGBTQ anthology Fantasy suspense Comic Book 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 90s animated TCA Awards Pixar green book SDCC dramedy live event dreamworks 45 psycho sequel Fall TV The Walking Dead Food Network golden globes sopranos sitcom book San Diego Comic-Con History DC Universe cults Reality Certified Fresh rt archives twilight Super Bowl remakes free movies Acorn TV Pacific Islander FX italian Lifetime Christmas movies casting The Purge saw blockbuster Sony Pictures American Society of Cinematographers GLAAD directors Endgame 93rd Oscars Sundance Now Avengers Mystery Set visit children's TV women TV One Oscars Adult Swim Lucasfilm archives medical drama GIFs NBA Film Festival Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt zombies Amazon kong Mary Poppins Returns video on demand Netflix Peacock Song of Ice and Fire Extras Best and Worst Ovation screenings Baby Yoda The Academy Election Warner Bros. RT21 Marathons series Trivia universal monsters Toys comic book movie rotten indiana jones action-comedy LGBT movie aapi festivals NBC Paramount TCA pirates of the caribbean razzies tv talk