Video Interviews

Best Toy Story Movie Yet?: The Ultimate Toy Story 4 Debate

Mark Ellis, Scott Mantz, Jacqueline Coley, and Alex Vo are split on Forky – and on how the fourth entry in the series stacks up against the rest.

by | June 22, 2019 | Comments

Toy Story 4 is now out in theaters, and there’s no doubt it’s super Fresh – Certified Fresh, in fact, at 98% on the Tomatometer. That’s on par for now with Toy Story 3, and just below the first two Toy Story movies, which are both at 100%. But the big question everyone is asking is: Tomatometer aside, is it the best entry in the series so far? Or maybe the worst? Or maybe somewhere in between? We decided to dive deep into the franchise and debate the new film’s merits and how it stacks up against its predecessors in a special episode of the spoiler-filled Rotten Tomatoes Aftershow. Host Mark Ellis is joined by Scott Mantz and Rotten Tomatoes’ own Jacqueline Coley and Alex Vo for the lively discussion that also covers who the best new characters are (Forky? Ducky? Bunny?), whether the movie will indeed be the last (doubtful), and whether the movie really needed to exist in the first place?

Toy Story 4 is in theaters now.


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Thumbnail image: ©2019 Disney/Pixar. All Rights Reserved.

Tag Cloud

Hallmark ghosts spy thriller Pride Month Election elevated horror DirecTV Instagram Live Discovery Channel DC Universe Adult Swim Musicals Star Trek james bond serial killer New York Comic Con festival TV One crime thriller Netflix new zealand Apple critics cooking rotten Food Network name the review MCU President RT21 Trailer psychological thriller superman ViacomCBS American Society of Cinematographers Trophy Talk films rotten movies we love romance die hard Mindy Kaling singing competition science fiction satire remakes TLC dragons Pixar parents japanese canceled MSNBC Spike medical drama YouTube Red DGA Christmas FOX Infographic Action Amazon Prime Video Emmys USA Network Black History Month docuseries PBS chucky CMT lord of the rings Shudder aliens free movies VICE Tubi Premiere Dates Winter TV mcc kids ABC Signature critic resources war mission: impossible documentary talk show Turner Classic Movies movies Women's History Month Comic Book History true crime crime Academy Awards fresh Marvel Television dogs classics popular Tarantino spider-verse comic books streaming Year in Review rom-coms Tomatazos Fantasy hispanic heritage month obituary harry potter worst movies godzilla worst revenge First Reviews high school Freeform Pet Sematary WarnerMedia supernatural legend football technology Biopics black SundanceTV Comics on TV Reality nfl IFC TCA Winter 2020 Kids & Family Spring TV finale anthology book AMC casting live action Character Guide Superheroes IMDb TV Image Comics cancelled DC streaming service cults Rom-Com 2020 Reality Competition 45 spinoff Brie Larson TV Land 24 frames Rock USA emmy awards The Walking Dead Interview young adult comiccon feel good posters TV movies Podcast facebook Photos Wes Anderson Watching Series theme song scary Holiday ESPN laika royal family Lionsgate Nat Geo VH1 reboot children's TV strong female leads Calendar series concert YouTube A24 Mudbound ABC spanish language robots SDCC TBS marvel cinematic universe Comedy Central rt archives Thanksgiving 20th Century Fox teaser 73rd Emmy Awards criterion period drama BBC cinemax X-Men japan werewolf Classic Film NBC sag awards BAFTA BET hispanic First Look Paramount Plus Starz sopranos BET Awards adaptation 72 Emmy Awards Ellie Kemper Masterpiece dreamworks hidden camera See It Skip It The Walt Disney Company NYCC boxoffice Warner Bros. witnail Valentine's Day Marvel Universal Pictures reviews Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Rocky 71st Emmy Awards television new star wars movies spain screen actors guild Television Critics Association binge Chilling Adventures of Sabrina streaming movies scorecard book adaptation TCA 2017 movie Set visit Sundance TV LGBT ITV kong Sundance Now San Diego Comic-Con GoT Cosplay sitcom Stephen King BBC America Mary Poppins Returns animated Showtime festivals GIFs 93rd Oscars ratings 4/20 NBA Avengers TCA Awards richard e. Grant Apple TV Plus BBC One king arthur biography Mary poppins twilight dexter stop motion prank Country Broadway Spectrum Originals italian Awards gangster 2018 razzies CNN Hear Us Out Lifetime Disney Channel The Academy dc Musical anime WGN rt labs Emmy Nominations The Purge foreign Box Office Film Festival black comedy Amazon blockbuster Cannes Song of Ice and Fire comic Disney+ Disney Plus Amazon Studios best Walt Disney Pictures CBS canceled TV shows TCM adenture Logo Writers Guild of America Television Academy E3 FX 2019 Pop TV jamie lee curtis screenings Oscars 21st Century Fox monster movies indiana jones Drama asian-american comic book movie crossover Vudu Peacock new york boxing child's play Captain marvel Fox Searchlight SXSW TV disaster Marathons Film TV renewals space quibi Extras Creative Arts Emmys stoner Video Games Baby Yoda Horror police drama hist versus RT History know your critic AMC Plus Comedy art house documentaries breaking bad Columbia Pictures cancelled TV shows mob Nickelodeon mockumentary sports Fox News Endgame Alien political drama Cartoon Network spider-man natural history travel comedies IFC Films nbcuniversal Trivia sequels 007 ID 99% batman biopic dramedy toy story YA historical drama blaxploitation award winner docudrama Star Wars slashers Toys kaiju scene in color National Geographic The Arrangement green book christmas movies Paramount independent 1990s Legendary Best and Worst telelvision psycho marvel comics Tumblr Family PaleyFest venice FXX jurassic park mutant Universal cancelled TV series A&E miniseries Hulu crime drama Mary Tyler Moore target cops Disney Plus Polls and Games live event Sneak Peek ABC Family vampires Exclusive Video game show blockbusters comics Shondaland Pirates 2016 Sony Pictures action-comedy halloween tv Turner directors Super Bowl hollywood El Rey GLAAD zero dark thirty Ghostbusters Marvel Studios romantic comedy HBO Go Black Mirror Epix Summer all-time thriller Arrowverse E! deadpool unscripted Superheroe Teen zombie saw Syfy Elton John Acorn TV Ovation Opinion Schedule TNT The Witch OWN dark basketball genre video on demand slasher what to watch latino 2017 Crackle Animation spanish vs. international doctor who renewed TV shows dceu pirates of the caribbean cars TIFF indie Sci-Fi Winners toronto Lucasfilm Bravo sequel social media HBO Holidays universal monsters Dark Horse Comics 2015 Pop CBS All Access trailers Paramount Network Nominations stand-up comedy news Grammys golden globes Sundance composers Quiz 90s FX on Hulu aapi Rocketman cartoon Martial Arts Netflix Christmas movies politics joker golden globe awards TruTV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Certified Fresh archives Neflix Travel Channel based on movie Heroines cancelled television justice league Disney Anna Paquin LGBTQ king kong game of thrones Funimation VOD video YouTube Premium south america Chernobyl halloween Tokyo Olympics comic book movies Red Carpet Apple TV+ women DC Comics suspense Awards Tour australia cats MTV discovery Music franchise The CW transformers Pacific Islander 2021 wonder woman olympics Mystery fast and furious Comic-Con@Home 2021 tv talk Western Amazon Prime Hallmark Christmas movies superhero debate scary movies TCA Britbox diversity HBO Max adventure heist movie nature PlayStation a nightmare on elm street OneApp Esquire Crunchyroll Countdown CW Seed rt labs critics edition zombies APB Fall TV Lifetime Christmas movies Binge Guide french Disney streaming service