Video Interviews

Best Toy Story Movie Yet?: The Ultimate Toy Story 4 Debate

Mark Ellis, Scott Mantz, Jacqueline Coley, and Alex Vo are split on Forky – and on how the fourth entry in the series stacks up against the rest.

by | June 22, 2019 | Comments

Toy Story 4 is now out in theaters, and there’s no doubt it’s super Fresh – Certified Fresh, in fact, at 98% on the Tomatometer. That’s on par for now with Toy Story 3, and just below the first two Toy Story movies, which are both at 100%. But the big question everyone is asking is: Tomatometer aside, is it the best entry in the series so far? Or maybe the worst? Or maybe somewhere in between? We decided to dive deep into the franchise and debate the new film’s merits and how it stacks up against its predecessors in a special episode of the spoiler-filled Rotten Tomatoes Aftershow. Host Mark Ellis is joined by Scott Mantz and Rotten Tomatoes’ own Jacqueline Coley and Alex Vo for the lively discussion that also covers who the best new characters are (Forky? Ducky? Bunny?), whether the movie will indeed be the last (doubtful), and whether the movie really needed to exist in the first place?

Toy Story 4 is in theaters now.


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Thumbnail image: ©2019 Disney/Pixar. All Rights Reserved.

Tag Cloud

golden globes science fiction 007 Marvel Music Tomatazos CBS RT21 space Premiere Dates Comics on TV Toys stand-up comedy APB docudrama asian-american Spectrum Originals Musical Peacock name the review Sci-Fi comedies directors Lifetime Christmas movies Academy Awards free movies television Pirates Dark Horse Comics ratings social media reboot independent child's play Winners critics documentary FX on Hulu Pop mission: impossible Pride Month cartoon Emmy Nominations zero dark thirty Paramount Network finale comiccon Awards Tour VH1 Logo PlayStation NYCC romantic comedy Television Academy book Opinion sag awards Hear Us Out Polls and Games The CW USA Network Family Nickelodeon Song of Ice and Fire talk show 2016 GoT Cosplay Epix anime crime drama medical drama transformers National Geographic Mystery Western batman Crackle Quiz FX YouTube Red 45 Lifetime Emmys movie Reality Competition CNN Fox News Fantasy Cartoon Network animated Black Mirror Writers Guild of America SXSW Holidays historical drama binge FOX Baby Yoda Action Biopics Tumblr psycho Disney streaming service Britbox Set visit Nominations Warner Bros. stoner 2017 Pop TV TBS travel DC Comics BBC One A&E criterion RT History streaming canceled BET Awards Ovation Countdown Discovery Channel Starz MTV Trophy Talk Chilling Adventures of Sabrina LGBT Creative Arts Emmys 2020 Paramount green book disaster 21st Century Fox Tarantino anthology Disney+ Disney Plus PBS Kids & Family Avengers political drama Film Festival scary movies X-Men Disney Channel chucky psychological thriller dceu Cannes Teen El Rey spider-man New York Comic Con cancelled Netflix Ellie Kemper children's TV Animation Shondaland DirecTV Mary poppins Amazon Prime Video indie cancelled TV series news Freeform blockbuster cancelled television Esquire politics Box Office Elton John war period drama adventure Columbia Pictures Netflix Christmas movies OWN serial killer reviews foreign cops Hallmark Grammys Apple Marvel Television breaking bad ABC Family CMT Stephen King south america franchise technology Nat Geo hist zombies screenings DC streaming service Trailer Shudder Acorn TV Valentine's Day Rom-Com Travel Channel American Society of Cinematographers dragons ESPN game of thrones 2018 best cats Women's History Month NBC festivals Anna Paquin The Purge quibi screen actors guild Turner Classic Movies thriller aliens Binge Guide Interview jamie lee curtis BBC VICE DGA LGBTQ Rocketman dogs TCM GLAAD satire Schedule Rocky TNT Oscars rotten movies we love cults series Character Guide Tubi award winner Amazon Studios Masterpiece mockumentary singing competition Podcast toy story Brie Larson CBS All Access Comedy miniseries Mudbound Bravo BBC America canceled TV shows video Heroines Trivia Hallmark Christmas movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt teaser documentaries TCA richard e. Grant Mary Poppins Returns Pixar Ghostbusters Christmas Lucasfilm Marathons HBO Go Martial Arts Winter TV Spike Country TV President DC Universe See It Skip It Apple TV Plus dark mutant kids WarnerMedia crime thriller unscripted SDCC biography Funimation Star Wars romance Marvel Studios Superheroe joker Classic Film halloween GIFs BET Infographic Summer true crime Chernobyl cars IFC Year in Review parents Fall TV Rock ghosts cinemax boxoffice spinoff BAFTA MSNBC Mindy Kaling Lionsgate Turner Extras robots vampires Adult Swim comics 24 frames Film tv talk 71st Emmy Awards TruTV video on demand Amazon Prime Spring TV dramedy latino crime 2015 Disney Plus YouTube Disney Sneak Peek HBO harry potter Watching Series VOD The Arrangement Musicals Best and Worst The Walking Dead Walt Disney Pictures MCU Apple TV+ TV renewals Endgame Black History Month Calendar Sundance TV San Diego Comic-Con Election Universal Sundance what to watch films Pet Sematary sitcom strong female leads Video Games YouTube Premium WGN Comedy Central spy thriller christmas movies Syfy PaleyFest 4/20 2019 game show comic justice league Crunchyroll supernatural Vudu Star Trek indiana jones Captain marvel Reality YA Drama TIFF First Look universal monsters elevated horror Food Network Sundance Now spain Horror Awards ABC crossover adaptation HBO Max CW Seed composers OneApp nature theme song concert casting TLC zombie versus Holiday all-time Hulu Photos twilight natural history cooking TCA Winter 2020 witnail TV Land History renewed TV shows revenge 20th Century Fox A24 hispanic Arrowverse a nightmare on elm street Red Carpet E3 die hard spanish language Amazon sports First Reviews movies blaxploitation facebook werewolf discovery based on movie dc Superheroes FXX ITV slashers Thanksgiving sequel E! SundanceTV TCA 2017 Super Bowl USA diversity Showtime IFC Films The Witch Mary Tyler Moore Comic Book Certified Fresh doctor who Sony Pictures cancelled TV shows AMC police drama