Video Interviews

Best Toy Story Movie Yet?: The Ultimate Toy Story 4 Debate

Mark Ellis, Scott Mantz, Jacqueline Coley, and Alex Vo are split on Forky – and on how the fourth entry in the series stacks up against the rest.

by | June 22, 2019 | Comments

Toy Story 4 is now out in theaters, and there’s no doubt it’s super Fresh – Certified Fresh, in fact, at 98% on the Tomatometer. That’s on par for now with Toy Story 3, and just below the first two Toy Story movies, which are both at 100%. But the big question everyone is asking is: Tomatometer aside, is it the best entry in the series so far? Or maybe the worst? Or maybe somewhere in between? We decided to dive deep into the franchise and debate the new film’s merits and how it stacks up against its predecessors in a special episode of the spoiler-filled Rotten Tomatoes Aftershow. Host Mark Ellis is joined by Scott Mantz and Rotten Tomatoes’ own Jacqueline Coley and Alex Vo for the lively discussion that also covers who the best new characters are (Forky? Ducky? Bunny?), whether the movie will indeed be the last (doubtful), and whether the movie really needed to exist in the first place?

Toy Story 4 is in theaters now.


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Thumbnail image: ©2019 Disney/Pixar. All Rights Reserved.

Tag Cloud

San Diego Comic-Con dceu natural history DGA Teen doctor who Ghostbusters Best and Worst Rock science fiction Certified Fresh psycho slashers foreign Comics on TV Freeform FX video Opinion Extras 2020 Pixar screenings Nominations YouTube Premium Song of Ice and Fire Hallmark Christmas movies Marathons Epix Walt Disney Pictures golden globes Horror El Rey NYCC DC Universe GoT singing competition comic LGBT crime CNN werewolf Elton John Sundance Now RT History History Polls and Games Fox News Premiere Dates Bravo Paramount Network Shondaland Amazon Prime book MSNBC screen actors guild Amazon President indie Sony Pictures Universal Creative Arts Emmys cops Apple TV+ historical drama 20th Century Fox TCA Winter 2020 Disney+ Disney Plus Apple TV Plus IFC Films elevated horror Shudder Arrowverse BBC Countdown harry potter APB 2018 Mystery Family Spectrum Originals psychological thriller TLC TV 24 frames Turner Classic Movies Brie Larson television Musicals GLAAD Thanksgiving children's TV TV renewals Academy Awards Lionsgate Cannes adaptation Rocky Disney Channel Video Games Amazon Studios Britbox The CW Sci-Fi Tumblr political drama kids justice league Baby Yoda OWN mockumentary Trailer HBO Max revenge 2017 ghosts Writers Guild of America Action Stephen King cars docudrama MCU Super Bowl quibi Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt VH1 2015 Rocketman Cartoon Network FOX Food Network IFC true crime Acorn TV what to watch 45 American Society of Cinematographers politics aliens Masterpiece Syfy animated canceled TV shows cats The Walking Dead jamie lee curtis E! Western supernatural Emmys ratings festivals Crunchyroll Endgame stand-up comedy DC Comics Spike Star Trek toy story spain Film Festival Hallmark zombies Esquire sag awards First Look Marvel Television directors Christmas discovery Fall TV sequel VICE diversity Pet Sematary Netflix Christmas movies PBS Red Carpet Amazon Prime Video medical drama Photos Animation Spring TV Warner Bros. Hulu comics cinemax unscripted robots Logo Turner TIFF Year in Review SDCC nature OneApp Calendar war Tomatazos Quiz Summer X-Men social media award winner documentary GIFs sports CBS ESPN New York Comic Con serial killer YouTube latino Set visit Sundance rotten movies we love Emmy Nominations Paramount transformers movie Starz Mudbound game of thrones movies travel TCM Rom-Com Avengers independent batman 21st Century Fox Holiday Superheroes Captain marvel crime drama Crackle facebook BBC America mutant breaking bad Podcast Disney SXSW Pride Month Vudu TNT CW Seed Tarantino Ellie Kemper Sneak Peek south america Comedy halloween Peacock based on movie TCA spy thriller finale game show technology CMT Sundance TV cancelled television spider-man Trivia Chernobyl Columbia Pictures cooking BET Election talk show CBS All Access strong female leads reboot Adult Swim Valentine's Day Interview First Reviews richard e. Grant Netflix YouTube Red cartoon romance Musical crossover anime period drama dramedy blockbuster Grammys Mary Tyler Moore MTV zombie USA space Film A&E blaxploitation PaleyFest Character Guide Mindy Kaling Infographic cancelled ITV anthology National Geographic Watching Series 007 NBC composers Superheroe Ovation free movies The Witch Showtime zero dark thirty Fantasy Kids & Family Classic Film Nickelodeon sitcom USA Network binge E3 The Arrangement TV Land Cosplay Marvel Studios Box Office Country WarnerMedia casting Anna Paquin Reality Competition See It Skip It Apple Nat Geo Comedy Central Trophy Talk miniseries Awards Black Mirror Awards Tour Lifetime Christmas movies YA 71st Emmy Awards theme song DC streaming service HBO Winter TV Winners Binge Guide DirecTV RT21 SundanceTV Music Biopics ABC Family cults cancelled TV series Tubi crime thriller TCA 2017 witnail teaser LGBTQ spinoff cancelled TV shows Holidays The Purge biography Disney streaming service TBS spanish language hist Marvel joker hispanic romantic comedy Martial Arts 2019 Pop adventure FXX comiccon Television Academy Pirates Mary poppins police drama Toys 2016 name the review Women's History Month Lifetime vampires streaming thriller Comic Book Star Wars Chilling Adventures of Sabrina renewed TV shows Oscars Lucasfilm dc Drama WGN TruTV Schedule disaster Reality ABC series Heroines A24 versus boxoffice Disney Plus AMC canceled green book Mary Poppins Returns dragons tv talk Dark Horse Comics christmas movies Discovery Channel