Total Recall

Billy Bob Thornton's 10 Best Movies

We look back at the best-reviewed work of the Bad Santa 2 star.

by | November 23, 2016 | Comments

Actor, writer, director, recording artist: there’s nothing Billy Bob Thornton can’t do, including bringing a sequel to a cult comedy to the screen over a decade after the original played in theaters. In celebration of the latter achievement, playing out in this weekend’s Bad Santa 2, we turn our attention to Mr. Thornton’s estimable filmography, whose critical highlights boast eclectic riches you may not suspect. It’s time for Total Recall!

10. Primary Colors (1998) 81%


Based on a thinly fictionalized account of the 1992 presidential campaign written by Joe Klein (who hid, for a time, behind the nom de plume “Anonymous”), and featuring cameos by Geraldo Rivera, Charlie Rose, Larry King, and Bill Maher as themselves, 1998’s Primary Colors could easily have been overshadowed by the real-life circus that followed Bill Clinton’s administration during both of his terms — but director Mike Nichols and screenwriter Elaine May had been a creative team for decades, and their comfort with one another, as well as a terrific cast, made Colors one of the better-reviewed films of the year. Thornton, tasked with providing a caricature of Democratic strategist James Carville that was still layered enough to make sense in an ostensibly grounded drama, passed with flying colors; as Stanley Kauffmann wrote for the New Republic, “Sheerly as film, Primary Colors generally sizzles.”

Watch Trailer

9. Chrystal (2004) 80%


As a guy who habitually writes and directs his own movies, perhaps Billy Bob Thornton is predisposed to have a soft spot for films led by triple-threat talents — or maybe he just appreciated Chrystal, the 2004 directorial debut from actor-screenwriter Ray McKinnon, on its own merits. Either way, this drama about an Arkansas ex-con (Thornton) grappling with the painful aftereffects of his crimes earned a number of positive reviews during its limited release; despite its dark themes, wrote Duane Byrge of the Hollywood Reporter, the movie comes across as “A grand story of redemption, laced with barbecued wit and slopped with intrigue.”

Watch Trailer

8. The Man Who Wasn't There (2001) 81%


The Coen brothers went neo-noir for 2001’s The Man Who Wasn’t There, drafting a stellar batch of character actors (including Thornton, Richard Jenkins, Tony Shalhoub, and Frances McDormand) to tell the story of a barber (Thornton) whose placid-seeming suburban post-WWII existence unravels into a crazy tangle of blackmail, murder, and one very precocious teenage girl (Scarlett Johansson). The black-and-white Man failed to make much of an impression at the box office, but it enthralled critics like ReelViews’ James Berardinelli, who praised it as “An unconventional, unpredictable thriller that Hitchcock probably would have enjoyed.”

Watch Trailer

7. Friday Night Lights (2004) 82%


Before it was an acclaimed cult favorite on the TV dial, Friday Night Lights was a Buzz Bissinger non-fiction book about life on the Texas high school gridiron — and then it was a Peter Berg drama starring Billy Bob Thornton as a football coach with the weight of a small town’s hopes and dreams on his program’s shoulders. In hindsight, it seems awfully easy to say Lights was always destined to play out more powerfully on the small screen, but the film stands up pretty well on its own; as Michael O’Sullivan wrote for the Washington Post, “The movie is full of both crushing disappointment and hope, resignation and joy, ugliness and great beauty.”

Watch Trailer

6. Daddy and Them (2001) 86%


Thornton and Miramax enjoyed a fairly fruitful relationship (see Sling Blade), but the industry is always changing — as are studio fortunes. You’d think the guy who won an Oscar for writing, directing, and starring in Sling Blade would have a blank check, but 2001’s Daddy and Them — made for a paltry $4 million — barely eked out a limited release before heading off to DVD. As far as critics were concerned, it was a shame: starring Thornton and Laura Dern as an Arkansas couple embroiled in family drama after his uncle gets carted off to the hoosegow for attempted murder, it earned praise from scribes such as Variety’s Edie Cockrell, who wrote, “Beneath its deadpan and often absurdist exterior, Daddy and Them feels like a very personal piece of work about how family really does come first, warts and all.”

Watch Trailer

5. Monster's Ball (2002) 85%


There are dark indie dramas, and then there’s Monster’s Ball. Starring Halle Berry as a widow raising her child after the death of her husband — and Thornton as the former prison guard who strikes up an affair with her after helping supervise his execution — it’s a film whose characters are flawed to the point that most of them spend much of the film doing awful things to the few who aren’t predisposed toward unspeakable cruelty. But if it didn’t leave most viewers feeling fuzzy inside, Ball was certainly warmly received: Berry won a Best Actress Oscar for her work, and Arizona Republic critic Bill Muller echoed the thoughts of many of his peers when he called it “A textbook example of fearless filmmaking, exhibiting a brand of gritty realism that’s hard to watch but impossible to ignore.”

Watch Trailer

4. A Simple Plan (1998) 90%


Are people inherently good or evil, or are their morals and ethics driven by the choices available to them? That’s the devilishly grim question at the heart of Sam Raimi’s A Simple Plan, an adaptation of the Scott Smith book about a pair of brothers (played by Thornton and Bill Paxton) who happen upon a downed plane full of cash during a hunting expedition with a friend (Brent Briscoe). One secret and one lie seem like a small price to pay for a $4.4 million windfall split three ways, but their simple plan begins to unravel surprisingly quickly, making the trio — and, by extension, the audience — helpless witnesses to an increasingly gruesome tumble into darkness. “A Simple Plan is a suspenseful, unnerving movie that ranks as one of the best thrillers in recent years,” marveled Mike McGranaghan for Aisle Seat. “The plot and characters converge nicely, and by the end, you are left to wonder how much money is enough to entice you to sell your soul.”

Watch Trailer

3. The Apostle (1998) 90%


Two years after Robert Duvall appeared in Billy Bob Thornton’s labor of love Sling Blade, Thornton repaid the favor, taking on a role as a town resident whose views and temperament threaten to cause problems for Duvall’s titular man of the cloth. Like Sling Blade, The Apostle found its leading man working behind the camera, directing from his own screenplay — and also like Thornton’s film, Duvall’s passion project united an unusual but well-seasoned ensemble that included Miranda Richardson, Farrah Fawcett, June Carter Cash, and Walton Goggins. The result, wrote Roger Ebert, “is like a lesson in how movies can escape from convention and penetrate the hearts of rare characters.”

Watch Trailer

2. Sling Blade (1996) 96%


Thornton had been around for awhile by the time he made Sling Blade, but it really marks the spot where he became a known quantity for moviegoers — and for power players in Hollywood, who sat up and took notice when it turned into an Oscar-winning sleeper hit. He wrote, directed, and starred in the rural-set drama, which centers on a developmentally disabled man who returns to his hometown years after being institutionalized for murdering his mother and her lover; not exactly cheerful stuff, but it was a story that resonated with filmgoers through its telling — and partly thanks to an eclectic cast that also included Robert Duvall, John Ritter, and Dwight Yoakam. “The lure of Sling Blade is both elemental and hauntingly familiar,” wrote’s Tom Keogh, “and I would not be surprised if Thornton’s breakthrough film is one day considered a classic in its own right.”

Watch Trailer

1. One False Move (1992) 94%


Its commercial prospects were fatally hobbled by a lack of studio faith so profound that it wasn’t even originally supposed to have a theatrical release, but thanks to overwhelmingly positive reviews, 1992’s One False Move — starring Thornton as the ringleader of a gang of criminals that runs afoul of an Arkansas sheriff (Bill Paxton) who teaches them a thing or two about small-town justice — ended up sneaking into theaters long enough for Gene Siskel to call it his favorite movie of the year. Siskel’s enthusiasm for the Carl Franklin-directed thriller was shared by the majority of his peers, including Michael Upchurch of the Seattle Times, who enthused, “Franklin’s convincing portrait of life on both sides of the color line isn’t quite like anything I’ve come across before, making One False Move one very assured directorial move. We need more filmmakers like him.”

Watch Trailer

Tag Cloud

Set visit Holiday politics remakes based on movie casting See It Skip It hist Red Carpet Binge Guide Premiere Dates Hulu Extras Adult Swim Emmy Nominations Sundance Now talk show nbcuniversal revenge toronto cops Showtime Sony Pictures latino kids Lifetime political drama venice GoT Dark Horse Comics Disney streaming service ESPN Netflix 2015 SXSW Ellie Kemper television a nightmare on elm street FXX PlayStation independent Hallmark Christmas movies unscripted Cartoon Network CBS Endgame video Film Festival Elton John Stephen King 4/20 Sundance Disney Plus TV renewals Box Office PBS Mary poppins Brie Larson stand-up comedy Esquire discovery Pop TV cars El Rey true crime festival space Interview adaptation versus DirecTV Hear Us Out indie movies transformers San Diego Comic-Con Classic Film Mary Tyler Moore Rocky emmy awards Amazon FX Year in Review TCM sequel DC Comics reboot Schedule directors Rocketman Chernobyl Hallmark Election sequels Fantasy RT21 2019 Action serial killer BET vampires Mindy Kaling Reality Competition sag awards Walt Disney Pictures Video Games harry potter A&E Emmys Spectrum Originals Watching Series Rock Lifetime Christmas movies The Arrangement Syfy slashers finale psycho theme song nfl disaster PaleyFest Lucasfilm werewolf Thanksgiving Spring TV Pet Sematary ratings The CW Reality Black History Month Pride Month robots cancelled TV shows Character Guide YouTube Red Arrowverse docudrama Star Wars WarnerMedia Countdown TIFF Family romantic comedy medical drama CW Seed Amazon Prime Video Women's History Month zero dark thirty 2017 Winners TNT NYCC Starz 20th Century Fox Paramount Network hollywood Horror animated blaxploitation foreign south america Acorn TV name the review worst movies spinoff scorecard HBO Max Television Critics Association TCA 2017 comedies 2018 Comic Book Tubi scary movies 24 frames The Purge Writers Guild of America 007 biography Tarantino cancelled TV series series Star Trek USA Network Winter TV Ovation Creative Arts Emmys Crackle science fiction President ITV quibi documentary TruTV mutant universal monsters FX on Hulu Fall TV Sundance TV all-time spain Ghostbusters YouTube Premium teaser Warner Bros. award winner boxoffice green book dc Quiz LGBTQ satire VICE halloween reviews hispanic Tumblr joker Marvel Television Mary Poppins Returns Best and Worst Columbia Pictures singing competition Teen 71st Emmy Awards CNN laika dramedy Masterpiece Disney Channel X-Men Biopics Certified Fresh Vudu Nominations cartoon supernatural IFC Films Trailer comics Apple TV+ YA Television Academy dark Comedy game show FOX Britbox Marathons ABC OWN MTV jamie lee curtis Super Bowl Disney American Society of Cinematographers Anna Paquin Grammys batman anime dogs Crunchyroll Shudder AMC TCA Awards video on demand Cannes Calendar History cinemax documentaries LGBT mission: impossible TV crime thriller justice league DC Universe worst tv talk Black Mirror OneApp VH1 IFC BET Awards asian-american game of thrones Food Network crossover thriller football Awards screen actors guild Valentine's Day TCA Song of Ice and Fire BBC Apple TV Plus VOD classics Nickelodeon sports GIFs psychological thriller Avengers travel children's TV E! Captain marvel First Reviews parents canceled TV shows cats 21st Century Fox USA BBC One Funimation A24 Mystery Film criterion elevated horror CMT Musical Trivia Shondaland 72 Emmy Awards HBO Go best Heroines binge Mudbound MCU Spike historical drama screenings DGA renewed TV shows Kids & Family 2016 Oscars Drama Epix Comedy Central romance facebook ghosts streaming chucky Sci-Fi spider-man Musicals Disney+ Disney Plus witnail die hard zombies franchise Christmas TCA Winter 2020 crime drama critics golden globes WGN Freeform christmas movies Marvel Studios diversity social media canceled Opinion free movies Paramount RT History Turner Classic Movies superhero APB book dragons spy thriller Netflix Christmas movies Superheroe news blockbuster Trophy Talk concert period drama Logo aliens Cosplay Animation Country Western nature Chilling Adventures of Sabrina child's play Martial Arts Lionsgate strong female leads TBS 45 Travel Channel NBC National Geographic SundanceTV E3 Fox News stoner festivals dceu technology comiccon Podcast DC streaming service adventure Toys Summer breaking bad doctor who Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt rotten movies we love Rom-Com Amazon Prime mockumentary crime Holidays TLC Comics on TV MSNBC Turner YouTube miniseries New York Comic Con Music composers Nat Geo Baby Yoda Discovery Channel rotten Marvel films TV Land BAFTA cults Pop anthology Infographic war Amazon Studios First Look Sneak Peek 2020 toy story GLAAD cooking Academy Awards The Walking Dead HBO richard e. Grant BBC America SDCC indiana jones Tomatazos CBS All Access spanish language Pirates obituary ABC Family Bravo Universal comic Awards Tour Pixar Peacock movie natural history Photos Polls and Games fast and furious zombie police drama stop motion twilight cancelled television sitcom The Witch what to watch Apple cancelled Superheroes