Catharsis and "Nerdgasms": Rotten Tomatoes Users Weigh in on Endgame

Check out some of the most insightful user reviews for Endgame, from the overjoyed to the underwhelmed.

by | April 29, 2019 | Comments

With a Tomatometer score of 96%, Avengers: Endgame is a hit with the critics. And with more than $350 million in the bank on just its first weekend, we know it’s a box office smash. But what do fans think about the movie now that they’ve gone out in droves to see it?

Well, they mostly love it: Avengers: Endgame has a current Audience Score of 92%, slightly above Infinity War‘s Audience Score of 91%. But while the praise is overwhelming, it’s not universal. And how could it be, with the weight of 21 films and 11 years of expectations on its shoulders?

We combed through the user reviews that RT fans have submitted since Endgame‘s release and picked out some of the most insightful takes, and those which speak to some of the major themes we’re seeing in user feedback, and put them in one place below. Check out these great user reviews and then let us know what you thought of the film, and these reviews, in the comments. (Note, some of the reviews have been slightly edited for length and grammar/spelling.)

Marvel Studios
(Photo by @ Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, @ Marvel Studios)

A Love Letter to the MCU, with “Nerdgasms” to Boot

[A] culmination of 22 films since 2008 led by the visionary mind of Kevin Feige and complex integration of the Russo Brothers as directors. This movie is not just incredible on its own but a step back to memory lanes of the movies done in the past – it is quite mind boggling how they’ve done it. But they have and this is the fitting end this chapter of MCU. It is still packed with a lot of surprises despite all the fan theories – and they are BIG ONES. It still gives you that roller coaster ride of emotions but at a deeper and more serious tone. For millions of fans who have followed MCU since 2008 and decided to stop watching Marvel movies (I can’t imagine why) this is really a great end for our superheroes journey. Any gaps from previous movies are filled. This one although bitter sweet is [a] fitting end.
– Michael, 5 Stars

Amazing love-letter from Marvel to the world. A breathtaking and emotional viewing of quick shots of action and humour, but impactful long-lasting satisfactory moments from its dramatic beats and character interactions. It’s an end that has been bathed in pure Marvel gold and magic.
– Tengku N., 5 stars

The first and second act are an absolute love letter to the MCU movies that came before this one. The third act is an emotional roller coaster ride of nerdgasms and cry time which I never thought I will see and feel from a superhero movie. The final scene hits home big time. If you are not very familiar with the MCU, the first two acts may feel a bit slow for you. But the payoff in the third act is just awesome.
– Patrick B., 4.5 stars

(Photo by @ Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, @ Marvel Studios)


I’m one of the people who came away from Infinity War restless and discontent. I really wasn’t sure how the Russos were going to resolve all the hanging threads, much less reverse the snap. I have to say they surpassed my wildest dreams. While I didn’t love every character arc, I can appreciate them all….. and my favorite? That one was so far beyond anything I could have hoped for.
– Kelly L., 5 stars

I gotta admit…..I’ll probably be the only one who feels this way……..but I’d be lying if I didn’t say……….I liked Infinity War better. On a personal level, Infinity War kept me more consistently engaged and invested (key word: consistently) than this one did. Granted, this one does have some truly glorious aspects, my two favorites being: 1) the most epic battle sequences in Endgame feel multitudes more tremendous than those in Infinity War for a number of reasons (the most memorable involving Captain America); and 2) Thanos returns here with a vengeance in a wonderfully written way. The plot, as implied by the trailer(s) and without revealing any details, chooses to cater more heavily to the past as opposed to the quickest possible way to solve the problem presented at the end of Infinity War, resulting in the hefty runtime and some filler moments but ultimately creating a movie that feels more complete overall in terms of the entire franchise… a fitting conclusion, a proper resolution, the end of an era. 
– John S., 4.5 stars

Marvel Studios
(Photo by @ Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, @ Marvel Studios)

It Left Some People Disappointed

My expectation and anticipation for this film were sky-high, buoyed by positive responses by critics and fans. However, having spent hours and hours on character and plot analysis with other MCU nerds, I had extremely high expectations, which were not met. I’m not disappointed because they didn’t make a movie that solely exists in my head, but the film wasn’t what it could have been. I wanted to be surprised, shocked, and moved – exclaiming “you sneaky bastards, I see what you did there,” and find fruition to the many clues, dangling threads and character arcs that were laid out in previous films, most notably Infinity War. Instead, the resolution “oh. ok. so that’s it. fine.” The film abandoned several important characters, neglecting what seemed to be important setup and development (Loki), inferred strategic importance to the meta-story (Strange, Captain Marvel) or have just devolved the characters into punchlines (Thor, Quill). Moments that were supposed to move emotionally were diffused by familiarity (seen that before!) or anti-climax (we pause this death for a joke). For a series that always emphasized team work, the concluding gesture undermined it. Lots of plot holes and more questions unanswered.
– Lynne D., 3.5 stars

This is going to feel weird. I have been a hardcore MCU fan since the start. I thought there were amazing moments in this movie. Definitely plenty to get hyped about with my MCU friends. Something about it as a whole was lackluster. Maybe it was because it felt like they flew through certain major plot elements despite it’s extremely long run-time. I appreciate that they gave conclusions to our major heroes, but I wasn’t crazy about how they seemed to rush and skip over certain things that I’d rather have seen fleshed out more. I don’t want to criticize it too heavily because it was an impossible task to fit all this into this conclusion movie and flesh everything out, I just personally felt a bit underwhelmed. I honestly went into this movie thinking it would easily become my favorite MCU movie to date, but it’s definitely not. Still think it’s very good, don’t get me wrong.
– Stephen I. 3.5 stars

The good: Fun action scenes that are more creative than many similar films. Genuinely great moments of comedy. All characters, though some have very short appearances, are treated well. The bad: The dialog is clunky and lacks any subtlety. The movie also has an unfortunate habit of throwing mildly funny one liners in that ruin moments of natural tension. Many, seemingly insurmountable, problems faced by the heroes are solved so quickly and easily that it gives an odd feeling of pace at some points of the movie.
– Billy P. 2.5 stars

Marvel Studios
(Photo by @ Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, @ Marvel Studios)

It’s a “Cathartic” Conclusion to the Infinity Saga

A cathartic, satisfying experience for all MCU fans that have been around from the start, Endgame is full of callbacks and emotional payoffs years in the making. The stakes are real. The character arcs justified, balanced, and well-executed. The emotions tangible, delivered fantastically by every actor, particularly the original six. The action is exciting, but doesn’t take center stage until it needs to. The humor and heart truly make this movie.
– Caitlin B., 5 stars

As a diehard comic book fanboy, this a dream fulfilled experience. I grew up loving these characters from the comics as a child. I love both DC and Marvel respectively. That being said the astonishing work done by Kevin Feige and the creative team at Marvel Studios is beyond amazing. They brought new life to these legendary characters for audiences to watch and enjoy. The MCU has been an exciting experience throughout the course of 22 films telling a narrative with unique creativity and wonderful memories by a cast that have transcended to super stars. This is a great tribute to Stan Lee, Jack Kirby and the founding fathers of the Marvel Comics…
– Shamar L., 5 stars

Check out all of the user reviews for Avengers: Endgame so far

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

2016 Reality Competition Rom-Com Marvel NYCC Year in Review Awards romance Summer nbcuniversal rotten movies we love Rock E3 television Paramount justice league green book Star Trek video mission: impossible all-time TV Land docudrama twilight black spinoff revenge Opinion Apple TV Plus composers Hear Us Out El Rey spanish language political drama venice Elton John Baby Yoda slashers satire Spike Sundance MCU Cannes quibi MSNBC Walt Disney Pictures Super Bowl Reality Arrowverse YA History based on movie cancelled TV shows child's play Peacock kids cops theme song space dramedy SXSW USA criterion 20th Century Fox IFC 45 71st Emmy Awards Academy Awards war best Film travel comics Pirates werewolf australia SDCC crime thriller Food Network chucky USA Network TIFF indiana jones documentaries spain screenings Ellie Kemper cars Spectrum Originals VICE crossover Comic Book Black History Month Nominations zero dark thirty New York Comic Con Horror serial killer Video Games what to watch BBC One children's TV Showtime casting dc Bravo Crunchyroll Premiere Dates Sundance TV award winner strong female leads Logo Classic Film biography PaleyFest FX on Hulu The Walking Dead binge sequel parents james bond Infographic Pet Sematary Nickelodeon Best and Worst Disney Channel elevated horror BAFTA Character Guide TCM A24 Black Mirror Acorn TV The Purge CBS All Access Comedy reviews sequels anthology Oscars The Witch Tarantino ID Musical Sci-Fi science fiction archives 2019 Awards Tour batman aliens superhero 2020 The Arrangement Quiz unscripted Comedy Central rotten politics book cartoon game of thrones golden globes social media Mindy Kaling universal monsters football Disney+ Disney Plus Trailer Syfy series medical drama rt archives richard e. Grant FXX Emmys Stephen King worst movies Election ESPN Sundance Now ABC Family OWN Lifetime Sneak Peek Sony Pictures OneApp indie Martial Arts Hallmark Christmas movies french Emmy Nominations Britbox Epix south america TCA Awards Disney Creative Arts Emmys breaking bad halloween tv scorecard Pride Month historical drama technology Mary poppins stop motion Netflix Television Critics Association festivals DC streaming service cults Music dragons SundanceTV name the review diversity Travel Channel Comics on TV American Society of Cinematographers Family doctor who CNN Mary Poppins Returns movies Holiday latino mutant HBO Go die hard independent Disney streaming service TNT Cosplay ITV films Apple TV+ WGN canceled Crackle AMC Avengers Polls and Games stoner Anna Paquin discovery Lifetime Christmas movies 24 frames canceled TV shows Certified Fresh Hulu Universal APB Rocketman thriller The Academy RT History screen actors guild Schedule Captain marvel Superheroes DC Comics Hallmark Binge Guide Trophy Talk Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt video on demand classics a nightmare on elm street LGBT witnail Ghostbusters GIFs BET Awards HBO Max remakes Action VH1 Animation spider-man Netflix Christmas movies cancelled TV series X-Men versus PlayStation Thanksgiving dceu TV critics Rocky halloween Toys Valentine's Day jamie lee curtis Calendar worst Marvel Television hollywood TruTV Amazon Studios blaxploitation Adult Swim zombie Apple foreign First Reviews concert GoT harry potter Starz zombies Podcast comiccon Writers Guild of America Interview miniseries supernatural FOX Discovery Channel Mary Tyler Moore hist Shondaland ghosts Chilling Adventures of Sabrina emmy awards YouTube Premium Drama FX NBC Tumblr Columbia Pictures Pop TV Kids & Family dark stand-up comedy 2017 CBS Spring TV mockumentary Pop boxoffice spanish Disney Plus Chernobyl DGA Endgame BBC America 72 Emmy Awards Cartoon Network toronto nature Amazon Prime Video finale Extras deadpool anime Marvel Studios documentary Christmas TCA 2017 Dark Horse Comics Red Carpet Television Academy TCA Winter 2020 BBC cooking HBO CMT Lionsgate Countdown cinemax dogs festival franchise Nat Geo spy thriller renewed TV shows Mystery sag awards Marathons Paramount Network 2015 news 2018 streaming Fall TV Winter TV Women's History Month cats Mudbound natural history Teen italian asian-american sitcom See It Skip It Tubi christmas movies Shudder 21st Century Fox hispanic YouTube YouTube Red adventure VOD Winners psycho Vudu ratings Musicals comedies fast and furious vampires DirecTV TLC Heroines San Diego Comic-Con Esquire free movies period drama blockbuster psychological thriller Amazon disaster IFC Films directors tv talk talk show Superheroe romantic comedy Fantasy President DC Universe First Look comic books sports Star Wars transformers Holidays 007 RT21 Set visit robots Amazon Prime Turner true crime National Geographic animated Masterpiece Freeform Watching Series scary movies Funimation Film Festival Country MTV Lucasfilm Photos WarnerMedia Turner Classic Movies Pixar police drama Fox News japanese crime PBS TCA toy story cancelled television teaser CW Seed nfl E! facebook cancelled 4/20 Box Office LGBTQ ABC game show movie Brie Larson TV renewals Tomatazos Song of Ice and Fire comic Trivia obituary Grammys Ovation Warner Bros. adaptation A&E joker Western Biopics singing competition crime drama TBS The CW Fox Searchlight reboot laika BET GLAAD