Chilling Adventures of Sabrina First Reviews: A Dark Heroine for a New Generation

Kiernan Shipka leads a stellar cast in a bewitching new series, say critics.

by | October 15, 2018 | Comments

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina season 1 keyart (Netflix)
(Photo by Netflix)

A few may have cried “Sacrilege!” when TV super-producer Greg Berlanti and Riverdale showrunner Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa threatened to makeover magical teen darling Sabrina, the Teenage Witch — a career-defining role (for better or worse) for star Melissa Joan Hart. But naysayers needn’t worry: This is not your mom’s Sabrina.

Kiernan Shipka (Mad Men) inhabits the titular role in Netflix horror offering Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, a version of the Archie Comics title that finds Sabrina Spellman in a much darker universe, one that is closer in tone to Rosemary’s Baby than the perky 1990s teen witch some might remember. Even the introduction of Sabrina’s “familiar,” a demon who takes animal form — in Salem’s case, a black house cat — is sufficiently scary to advise against the youngest viewers tuning in.

The series opens as Sabrina approaches her 16th birthday, a time when, tradition in her family of witches dictates, she must sign the Book of Night, become Satan’s bride, and inherit vast powers. This rebellious teen has other ideas, however; she’s half mortal and wants to continue life with her Baxter High classmates, including boyfriend Harvey Kinkle (Ross Lynch) and friends Roz Walker (Jaz Sinclair), and Susie Putnam (Lachlan Watson). Her cousin Ambrose (Chance Perdomo), under house arrest for illegal witch activities, tries to temper Sabrina’s more radical plans, while her aunts Hilda (Lucy Davis) and Zelda (Miranda Otto) manage the fallout when Sabrina inevitably chooses her own ill-informed path. Richard Coyle appears as Father Blackwood, the sinister head of the Church of Night and its magical Academy of the Unseen Arts, while Tati Gabrielle‘s Prudence leads a trio of bitchy witches, the Weird Sisters.

The horror, suspense, and wicked mayhem from Shipka and her stellar costars — especially devilishly delightful Davis, Otto, and Michelle Gomez — are exactly what’s called for this time of year, and critics so far heartily approve, branding the series 94%  Fresh with 17 reviews so far (updated). Here’s more of what they had to say:

How’s the Horror?

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina more than lives up to its title — sometimes too well, as when spells go awry and the nights are stalked by demons, ghosts, and zombies.

With plenty of scares and heaping helping of style, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina is a wicked and wonderful concoction. — Julia Teti, The Playlist

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina will still give you moments of comic relief, but the dichotomy between Sabrina’s mortal and witch identity is far weightier here, offering true moments of horror and macabre developments. — Arusa Qureshi, The List

Those of us who enjoyed the perkier version from our youth will tune in out of curiosity, while a new generation of Netflix junkies can take this sexier, more sinister version at face value. — Isabel Mohan, Daily Telegraph (UK)

Its intoxicating mix of supernatural thrills and deadpan one-liners approaches the heights of Buffy the Vampire Slayer … and I realize that’s high praise indeed. — Dave Nemetz, TV Line

Is Shipka’s Sabrina Up to Snuff?

CHILLING ADVENTURES OF SABRINA season 1 PHOTO CREDIT Diyah Pera/Netflix PICTURED Kiernan Shipka, Miranda Otto

Critics are not scared of this casting. They also offer high praise for Shipka’s costars.

Star is Kiernan Shipka, Sally from Mad Men, and she brings an appealingly sincere touch as she mixes phrases such as “dark baptism” into her teen lexicon. Her aunts, played by Miranda Otto and Lucy Davis, are kooky excellence. — Matthew Gilbert, Boston Globe

Kiernan Shipka leads the series with growing confidence … By the end of the first season, Shipka has more than lived up to the teen hellion promise of her famous Mad Men role — but as Sabrina, she’s far more empowered to revolt against regressive social conventions … Perdomo [gives] his pansexual character a slinky, almost feline energy … [W]hen Gomez, who was once menace incarnate on Doctor Who, finally comes out of the periphery, Chilling Adventures becomes spellbinding. — Danette Chavez, AV Club

The cast is a big perk — Lucy Davis and Miranda Otto, in particular. — Ben Travers, indieWire

What’s the Catch?


No tricks here. While a few critics didn’t shine to the more teen-melodrama moments of the show, most acknowledged that the series is a bingeable treat.

Sabrina mixes genres and offers believable performances, creative conceits and, duh, magic. The drawback is that you must endure the monotony of its more mundane story lines to get to the truly bewitching bits. — Brandon Katz, Observer

Loaded with great production design, and blessed with several strong performances, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina none the less succumbs to exhausting exposition, and uneven storytelling. It might still cast a spell over you, though. — Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

The series is skilled at building tension and leaves us eager to learn more about the spooky world of its protagonist. — Brian Lowry,

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina season 1 launches on Friday, October 26 on Netflix.

Tag Cloud

GIFs TruTV comiccon Ellie Kemper Rock award winner Pixar TCM Cosplay DC Universe harry potter Spring TV Sundance Now talk show Netflix crime thriller Holidays Tomatazos Paramount Network Marvel YA Marathons Shondaland 24 frames SDCC Cartoon Network TCA NBC FXX television Grammys Rom-Com finale Hulu Disney Winter TV diversity Sci-Fi 20th Century Fox BBC America ITV FOX Sundance YouTube Premium Trailer Crackle Spike docudrama Quiz San Diego Comic-Con Country golden globes Mary poppins Lionsgate Polls and Games miniseries Best and Worst Comic Book Superheroes Rocky Oscars Animation CW Seed RT History romance LGBTQ medical drama Creative Arts Emmys blaxploitation festivals Teen Horror Britbox biography Winners travel Esquire sports Star Trek political drama HBO serial killer TIFF ABC Family American Society of Cinematographers Lifetime USA Network Kids & Family GLAAD Sony Pictures OWN National Geographic IFC Awards green book comic Mystery Amazon TV A&E transformers vampires Pop crossover spy thriller Fox News binge Walt Disney Pictures crime drama Interview Writers Guild of America X-Men 45 Video Games NYCC Reality Competition adventure dc Awards Tour APB Lucasfilm Extras USA psycho Logo Summer Fall TV Box Office Toys PBS BBC police drama Watching Series cooking cinemax spider-man BET E! Musicals justice league ratings Columbia Pictures streaming Western 2015 Comedy First Look MTV Mary Tyler Moore what to watch DC Comics robots DirecTV SundanceTV doctor who anime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Christmas Adult Swim Warner Bros. Character Guide Trivia Masterpiece Bravo DC streaming service composers singing competition Year in Review Acorn TV dramedy TNT MSNBC Set visit Song of Ice and Fire Syfy unscripted Mindy Kaling TCA 2017 facebook Reality Food Network thriller Infographic See It Skip It zombies Apple discovery Nominations Ghostbusters Biopics CBS Drama technology CNN ABC Disney Channel Dark Horse Comics 2016 Calendar zombie Schedule Martial Arts Valentine's Day Paramount IFC Films Freeform SXSW supernatural sitcom crime Thanksgiving Comedy Central boxoffice CBS All Access GoT Opinion Shudder social media hist E3 Universal Emmys The CW based on movie CMT ESPN Black Mirror Ovation TLC TV Land Election Comics on TV Countdown Showtime Superheroe VICE dceu Star Wars AMC Premiere Dates Red Carpet TBS Mary Poppins Returns science fiction El Rey aliens YouTube Red jamie lee curtis Photos Super Bowl Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt VH1 Music History historical drama WGN cats period drama Epix 2019 Musical The Arrangement Action Tumblr 21st Century Fox New York Comic Con war 007 cults Sneak Peek Nickelodeon Certified Fresh Trophy Talk Fantasy 2018 Pirates President PaleyFest FX politics Nat Geo cops mutant Starz Podcast 2017