Chucky vs. Annabelle: Who Wins the Ultimate Murder Doll Showdown?

We crunch the numbers to see who emerges victorious when these toys of terror face off.

by | June 20, 2019 | Comments

Earlier this month we compared two cinematic titans in our Godzilla vs. King Kong showdown; this week we’re looking at two smaller-scale destroyers, Chucky and Annabelle. Both are returning to screens this month: First up, Chucky arrives rebooted – and with the voice of Mark Hamill – in the new Child’s Play; then the Conjuring Universe’s mischief-making little cutie returns in Annabelle Comes HomeBut which doll is the most terrifying? Our host Mark Ellis pits them against each other in a special episode of Vs., comparing the two dolls and their film histories by Tomatometer, box office, kills, and in one special bonus round. Check out who gets top shelf position above.

Child’s Play is in theaters June 21 | Annabelle Comes Home is in theaters June 26

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

christmas movies slashers Mary poppins Hallmark Film Festival Showtime Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Trailer Toys Pride Month TBS GIFs TLC Freeform The Walking Dead asian-american Lifetime IFC Films vampires X-Men Amazon hist NYCC Interview Rocky USA Network YouTube Red miniseries 2015 streaming chucky Disney Star Wars Grammys IFC social media Arrowverse Song of Ice and Fire sag awards New York Comic Con Horror screen actors guild richard e. Grant Anna Paquin El Rey die hard Travel Channel Polls and Games Pixar DC streaming service historical drama Spectrum Originals spain Esquire Photos YA tv talk San Diego Comic-Con reboot First Look Creative Arts Emmys Universal Country E3 Superheroe MCU Cannes Netflix Christmas movies Britbox Ellie Kemper dc justice league Adult Swim BBC America RT21 Epix Ghostbusters zombie werewolf DGA 2019 blaxploitation Elton John Cosplay VH1 Tumblr what to watch Animation concert cats jamie lee curtis children's TV dogs WGN mission: impossible HBO Max Tomatazos USA child's play Holidays Discovery Channel Hear Us Out mockumentary Marvel Television MSNBC crime drama finale FXX National Geographic Trophy Talk Podcast political drama casting LGBT technology Tubi best Mystery History Pet Sematary crime Certified Fresh Apple TV+ period drama Dark Horse Comics Pirates strong female leads crime thriller TV Land Emmys The Witch Cartoon Network A24 name the review Crunchyroll Video Games spanish language series natural history Winners GoT Election Tarantino First Reviews Crackle travel Holiday Paramount Network PBS dramedy Comedy Central Biopics WarnerMedia 007 police drama Apple dark Sundance TV versus Sneak Peek See It Skip It 4/20 Watching Series comedies all-time book CMT Baby Yoda stand-up comedy Lionsgate cults Hulu Nominations ghosts FOX Film Premiere Dates cooking festivals Logo kids stoner Music binge Winter TV DirecTV cars Walt Disney Pictures Comedy Chilling Adventures of Sabrina CBS All Access romance comics Apple TV Plus television medical drama SXSW DC Universe VICE cancelled Emmy Nominations Television Academy Rocketman Star Trek The CW Infographic Black History Month dceu award winner franchise TCA 2017 Drama transformers Warner Bros. TIFF Awards screenings NBC science fiction 45 breaking bad Countdown Avengers supernatural comiccon directors Mudbound spy thriller Disney streaming service Western Amazon Prime Video Spike zombies cops Ovation Binge Guide movie animated cancelled TV shows disaster Peacock Women's History Month thriller mutant scary movies Martial Arts Family Set visit foreign theme song APB TruTV Captain marvel Opinion Mindy Kaling romantic comedy cancelled television ESPN Funimation parents canceled TV shows Sci-Fi Sundance facebook YouTube Premium Turner green book ABC Family cancelled TV series Lucasfilm criterion The Arrangement ABC 2018 Mary Tyler Moore Masterpiece Marvel Paramount composers President teaser Thanksgiving Starz cinemax elevated horror canceled Pop renewed TV shows hispanic OWN diversity universal monsters Teen Action TCA Disney+ Disney Plus batman Super Bowl OneApp adventure RT History 21st Century Fox MTV based on movie TCM Food Network Fall TV E! south america 2020 singing competition discovery Amazon Studios Quiz reviews anthology Columbia Pictures Fantasy Rom-Com psycho Rock AMC joker spinoff spider-man Musicals sports 2017 Chernobyl harry potter 2016 Reality video adaptation golden globes robots Disney Plus Writers Guild of America Fox News latino Shondaland boxoffice Heroines biography Extras Trivia Classic Film Sundance Now Academy Awards ITV Awards Tour CW Seed psychological thriller Valentine's Day sitcom witnail Summer Hallmark Christmas movies movies Sony Pictures Year in Review true crime crossover halloween Turner Classic Movies Black Mirror serial killer TV FX CBS Character Guide game show A&E space SundanceTV doctor who Nickelodeon DC Comics toy story Christmas free movies rotten movies we love Marvel Studios TNT Syfy BET Spring TV FX on Hulu 24 frames Bravo TV renewals Schedule HBO SDCC nature Pop TV documentary unscripted Calendar Oscars critics American Society of Cinematographers PaleyFest Kids & Family zero dark thirty Reality Competition LGBTQ Netflix YouTube Vudu revenge Lifetime Christmas movies aliens Endgame Brie Larson 20th Century Fox indie The Purge Mary Poppins Returns GLAAD Shudder TCA Winter 2020 blockbuster anime a nightmare on elm street Box Office Best and Worst BBC cartoon talk show politics Disney Channel CNN Stephen King Amazon Prime Musical comic independent Comic Book 71st Emmy Awards Superheroes Red Carpet docudrama Comics on TV sequel game of thrones ratings Acorn TV war Marathons Nat Geo dragons quibi