Couch Tomatoes

Watchmen: Loving Remix or a Step Too Far From the Source?

Couch Tomatoes host Naz Perez is joined by Collider's Roxy Striar and Buzzfeed's Unsolved's Shane Madej and Ryan Bergara to talk Watchmen's best moments, most killer performances, and the biggest changes from the source material.

by | October 30, 2019 | Comments

The world is currently obsessed with HBO’s Certified Fresh Watchmen, the new TV series based on Alan Moore’s landmark graphic novel of the same name. But it’s that “based on” part that has some fans engaged in feverish debates following the show’s first two episodes. Showrunner Damon Lindelof‘s series takes bold risks, extending Moore’s universe rather than recreating the novel’s narrative and characters. For some the payoffs have been rewarding: Critics are loving this interpretation, with its risky dive into current affairs, narrative switch-ups, and killer performances – especially from Regina King and Don Johnson. For some Watchmen devotees, however, eyebrows have been raised. The series has become something of an, ahem, Rorschach Test.

Who’s right? Who’s wrong? And can’t we all just get along? We’re going deep on Watchmen in the latest episode of Couch Tomatoes. Host Naz Perez is asking the big questions and talking the series’ best moments with Collider’s Roxy Striar as well as Buzzfeed’s Unsolved‘s Shane Madej and Ryan Bergara; plus the panel is poring over fan theories and Easter Eggs and sharing the directions in which they’d like to see Lindelof steer the show.

With each episode of Couch Tomatoes, we dig into a major series or event and provide Fresh picks of great shows to help you cut through the clutter and only binge the best.

Watchmen airs Sundays on HBO. 

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Watchmen: Season 1 (2019)

Adjusted Score: 105.104%
Critics Consensus: Bold and bristling, Watchmen isn't always easy viewing, but by adding new layers of cultural context and a host of complex characters it expertly builds on its source material to create an impressive identity of its own.
Synopsis: Damon Lindelof (The Leftovers, Lost) creates a modern-day re-imagining of Alan Moore's groundbreaking graphic novel about masked vigilantes.... [More]

Tag Cloud

justice league festival free movies PlayStation Rock FXX FX on Hulu blockbuster Quiz toy story DGA Calendar Disney Plus Valentine's Day Sundance CNN Christmas remakes The Purge robots Comic Book dogs rotten VICE scary movies space Lionsgate Election LGBTQ stop motion Star Trek HBO Go Columbia Pictures Rocketman Ghostbusters Creative Arts Emmys parents golden globes Adult Swim medical drama Esquire 21st Century Fox sports Polls and Games strong female leads History Awards DC Universe Character Guide worst YouTube Red Disney cancelled TV series Trophy Talk asian-american best Super Bowl nature diversity DC streaming service Trivia Podcast Amazon travel blaxploitation ABC Family mockumentary concert Pet Sematary toronto TCA 2017 laika Film technology Winners Elton John movies fast and furious documentaries docudrama aliens directors Lifetime Christmas movies cops singing competition Reality SXSW President natural history Heroines Comedy zero dark thirty Reality Competition Netflix indie Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Awards Tour See It Skip It Spring TV TCM American Society of Cinematographers Anna Paquin joker screenings Stephen King harry potter GoT VH1 First Look TCA Awards Countdown Winter TV Infographic jamie lee curtis HBO criterion zombies book TV renewals Turner cartoon a nightmare on elm street WarnerMedia Emmys worst movies miniseries Pixar GLAAD Hallmark venice halloween 20th Century Fox 4/20 game of thrones die hard Freeform Martial Arts Nominations Travel Channel USA Network ghosts binge Television Academy SDCC New York Comic Con biography politics Apple TV Plus IFC Films anthology cancelled television sag awards animated TruTV Disney Channel Chernobyl CMT festivals documentary Discovery Channel USA MTV Oscars Cannes TCA discovery doctor who superhero chucky Teen Rocky sequels BBC One psychological thriller 2015 cooking VOD TLC IFC Vudu breaking bad serial killer Fall TV ESPN TBS rotten movies we love NYCC spain Set visit vampires cars DirecTV Animation Mary Poppins Returns movie reboot facebook SundanceTV Film Festival CBS All Access zombie Women's History Month social media AMC spy thriller children's TV theme song Sneak Peek classics Amazon Prime Video romance Superheroes what to watch X-Men TV Walt Disney Pictures all-time Black Mirror Masterpiece cats nbcuniversal hispanic stoner Toys Marvel Cosplay disaster comic Apple TV+ APB video hist Syfy Star Wars Disney+ Disney Plus E3 Watching Series dragons Mystery Sony Pictures witnail Box Office Song of Ice and Fire Holidays tv talk Logo RT21 BBC TCA Winter 2020 anime Mudbound Sundance Now 2018 Tarantino The CW BET Awards Warner Bros. independent MCU The Arrangement versus Arrowverse historical drama composers Netflix Christmas movies universal monsters Grammys adventure El Rey Marvel Studios BAFTA Interview boxoffice TNT slashers obituary Action series cancelled werewolf Fox News television Lucasfilm FOX true crime Britbox Pirates Extras casting comiccon Amazon Studios NBC unscripted Biopics war Sundance TV OWN Summer Year in Review crime drama Bravo Universal E! Tubi FX cinemax YouTube elevated horror Photos Turner Classic Movies latino franchise A&E A24 Premiere Dates Amazon Prime 71st Emmy Awards Pop TV Dark Horse Comics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Superheroe foreign Mindy Kaling 72 Emmy Awards romantic comedy Schedule Paramount Network Thanksgiving First Reviews 007 reviews Musical Family Best and Worst Hulu video on demand National Geographic 2019 Hallmark Christmas movies Marathons Tomatazos child's play Spectrum Originals HBO Max Drama 2016 Comedy Central Disney streaming service spinoff Food Network renewed TV shows spanish language supernatural Comics on TV Captain marvel Classic Film TV Land mutant 24 frames Funimation police drama name the review Musicals Pride Month news Fantasy Ellie Kemper Marvel Television ABC quibi Rom-Com Western GIFs dark CW Seed RT History Academy Awards The Witch sequel CBS PaleyFest Crunchyroll Acorn TV ratings transformers MSNBC dceu batman BET TIFF satire stand-up comedy cults Holiday finale canceled streaming kids sitcom nfl Nickelodeon Trailer Mary Tyler Moore LGBT 45 dramedy thriller Music crime thriller political drama based on movie Spike Epix Horror ITV Lifetime Certified Fresh Writers Guild of America films Television Critics Association Showtime YA twilight Opinion OneApp emmy awards San Diego Comic-Con Black History Month teaser Binge Guide south america DC Comics Red Carpet 2017 period drama richard e. Grant YouTube Premium Nat Geo crossover cancelled TV shows Apple Tumblr Hear Us Out hollywood mission: impossible Endgame scorecard Video Games 2020 canceled TV shows Paramount The Walking Dead comics award winner science fiction Kids & Family Shudder BBC America adaptation indiana jones Cartoon Network dc Avengers spider-man Brie Larson Mary poppins game show screen actors guild revenge green book critics Shondaland crime PBS Crackle Country football Starz Peacock WGN Pop comedies talk show Sci-Fi Ovation psycho Baby Yoda Emmy Nominations christmas movies