Couch Tomatoes

Watchmen: Loving Remix or a Step Too Far From the Source?

Couch Tomatoes host Naz Perez is joined by Collider's Roxy Striar and Buzzfeed's Unsolved's Shane Madej and Ryan Bergara to talk Watchmen's best moments, most killer performances, and the biggest changes from the source material.

by | October 30, 2019 | Comments

The world is currently obsessed with HBO’s Certified Fresh Watchmen, the new TV series based on Alan Moore’s landmark graphic novel of the same name. But it’s that “based on” part that has some fans engaged in feverish debates following the show’s first two episodes. Showrunner Damon Lindelof‘s series takes bold risks, extending Moore’s universe rather than recreating the novel’s narrative and characters. For some the payoffs have been rewarding: Critics are loving this interpretation, with its risky dive into current affairs, narrative switch-ups, and killer performances – especially from Regina King and Don Johnson. For some Watchmen devotees, however, eyebrows have been raised. The series has become something of an, ahem, Rorschach Test.

Who’s right? Who’s wrong? And can’t we all just get along? We’re going deep on Watchmen in the latest episode of Couch Tomatoes. Host Naz Perez is asking the big questions and talking the series’ best moments with Collider’s Roxy Striar as well as Buzzfeed’s Unsolved‘s Shane Madej and Ryan Bergara; plus the panel is poring over fan theories and Easter Eggs and sharing the directions in which they’d like to see Lindelof steer the show.

With each episode of Couch Tomatoes, we dig into a major series or event and provide Fresh picks of great shows to help you cut through the clutter and only binge the best.

Watchmen airs Sundays on HBO. 

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Watchmen: Season 1 (2019)

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Bold and bristling, Watchmen isn't always easy viewing, but by adding new layers of cultural context and a host of complex characters it expertly builds on its source material to create an impressive identity of its own.

Tag Cloud

cancelled television DGA Black Mirror stop motion Christmas dark Disney Apple Cosplay kong biopic south america cooking travel Masterpiece screenings batman Disney Channel 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards San Diego Comic-Con Sci-Fi Amazon Prime Video dexter 24 frames comiccon miniseries joker politics die hard HBO Max Toys Logo documentaries unscripted NBA superman Arrowverse monster movies archives comic book movie classics Countdown stand-up comedy YouTube Spectrum Originals news period drama Premiere Dates HBO fresh jamie lee curtis Sundance Now Podcast debate movie Opinion target BBC Infographic Epix japan BET Comic-Con@Home 2021 Universal Oscars green book Amazon Studios black comedy Family Elton John talk show Thanksgiving Sundance TV DirecTV children's TV action-comedy RT21 robots technology OneApp teaser best Martial Arts Superheroe Black History Month sports Nickelodeon critic resources comedies ESPN kids The Walking Dead WarnerMedia cancelled TV shows VH1 cops PaleyFest Vudu GIFs 45 australia disaster FXX Comedy Central spy thriller black football 2020 emmy awards dc 2021 A&E Sony Pictures films The Walt Disney Company Grammys sag awards italian RT History Summer USA Network streaming movies Star Wars game show DC Universe DC Comics scary movies BBC America festival book adaptation Emmys mockumentary Discovery Channel OWN space Disney+ Disney Plus slasher Anna Paquin FX on Hulu ITV franchise comic book movies X-Men Video Games 4/20 Shondaland Nat Geo justice league elevated horror E! 99% legend VOD Instagram Live indiana jones japanese Star Trek tv talk video on demand History Hallmark Christmas movies Universal Pictures adaptation 93rd Oscars dogs canceled spanish language finale Photos Fox News Peacock hispanic Writers Guild of America Fall TV Trailer transformers Rocketman Travel Channel Holiday IFC Spike A24 cartoon CNN video hidden camera sopranos Pirates versus Apple TV+ olympics Hallmark theme song CMT telelvision discovery Horror golden globe awards criterion nature Bravo Interview spider-verse ABC Signature Avengers chucky toy story Marvel basketball cinemax Funimation Amazon Prime ABC Family TIFF 2017 composers Rom-Com dreamworks Ghostbusters Schedule The Arrangement Awards Tour Box Office animated Comics on TV Exclusive Video supernatural Emmy Nominations king arthur Biopics 90s international 72 Emmy Awards 2016 mcc Binge Guide SXSW Endgame critics new star wars movies USA marvel cinematic universe ViacomCBS Shudder medical drama Quiz Ovation PBS LGBTQ wonder woman Holidays sitcom CW Seed Walt Disney Pictures SDCC Adult Swim sequel spinoff DC streaming service zombies scorecard YouTube Premium IFC Films FOX Polls and Games YA blaxploitation Marvel Studios First Reviews french Marvel Television docuseries Apple TV Plus CBS All Access anime Broadway facebook directors biography godzilla psychological thriller BBC One Cannes hist TCA 2017 breaking bad 2019 binge SundanceTV serial killer toronto Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 007 comic stoner superhero Alien Freeform indie The CW The Witch crossover deadpool Spring TV spain boxing aapi Heroines halloween tv aliens Amazon VICE pirates of the caribbean fast and furious Film cults Tumblr Musicals political drama Country universal monsters BAFTA scene in color Pacific Islander Paramount Network MCU First Look cancelled TV series E3 posters Lifetime ratings young adult hispanic heritage month women Trophy Talk Superheroes crime drama Showtime reviews Watching Series PlayStation comic books Legendary 1990s Lionsgate NYCC Sneak Peek Pride Month concert rom-coms 20th Century Fox TLC vampires WGN Best and Worst Hulu Lucasfilm richard e. Grant spanish Pop live action Esquire james bond 73rd Emmy Awards Reality New York Comic Con Reality Competition Britbox IMDb TV comics Drama rt labs quibi Set visit APB Turner zero dark thirty Wes Anderson Mystery Pixar revenge harry potter Starz TCA Winter 2020 series mob Kids & Family royal family nbcuniversal Film Festival laika TruTV 21st Century Fox Acorn TV Valentine's Day Classic Film NBC science fiction razzies slashers boxoffice 71st Emmy Awards Musical CBS name the review 2018 Pet Sematary Fantasy Baby Yoda child's play Television Academy cats AMC President obituary book Winners Music Hear Us Out Syfy YouTube Red The Purge festivals blockbuster vs. halloween Paramount Plus king kong Crackle lord of the rings dragons hollywood AMC Plus singing competition Disney Plus ghosts TCM Animation anthology Winter TV Tokyo Olympics prank suspense FX thriller BET Awards Sundance Mary Poppins Returns asian-american cancelled Chernobyl romance Neflix feel good remakes Mudbound free movies casting Calendar nfl TV movies know your critic Tubi Netflix twilight Mindy Kaling Tarantino rt archives Disney streaming service saw MTV reboot Election romantic comedy screen actors guild TCA Song of Ice and Fire Extras zombie what to watch parents TV renewals 2015 Rocky all-time Paramount renewed TV shows docudrama American Society of Cinematographers high school streaming documentary latino diversity strong female leads blockbusters rotten TBS historical drama war Ellie Kemper Fox Searchlight Awards Trivia spider-man mission: impossible witnail Western Netflix Christmas movies Teen Mary Tyler Moore Comedy Creative Arts Emmys Brie Larson Turner Classic Movies popular gangster Action jurassic park See It Skip It Captain marvel rt labs critics edition National Geographic Rock Columbia Pictures scary a nightmare on elm street Year in Review Warner Bros. Women's History Month foreign adventure werewolf dramedy rotten movies we love ID social media trailers Dark Horse Comics Super Bowl The Academy television Certified Fresh Cartoon Network christmas movies Image Comics El Rey natural history Academy Awards movies GoT Stephen King marvel comics Character Guide MSNBC Lifetime Christmas movies worst Crunchyroll new zealand TNT sequels live event Marathons adenture Mary poppins genre TV crime thriller dceu canceled TV shows TV Land based on movie satire art house kaiju venice Television Critics Association independent heist movie Pop TV police drama TCA Awards doctor who Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ABC game of thrones Tomatazos true crime new york Red Carpet Food Network mutant Comic Book crime GLAAD cars psycho LGBT worst movies TV One Nominations HBO Go award winner golden globes