Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Superbad is Certified Fresh; The Invasion Crash-Lands

Last Legion Not Screened; Guess the Tomatometer!

by | August 16, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got some McLovin
starring Michael
and Jonah
), pod people (The
, starring
Nicole Kidman
and Daniel Craig),
and swordplay (The
Last Legion
, starring
Ben Kingsley
and Colin Firth).
What do the critics have to say?

It’s been a very good year for
Judd Apatow.
After directing Knocked
, he’s the producer on another gross-out comedy with heart,
, and both are big hits with critics. Superbad tells the
story of two geeks (Michael Cera and Jonah Hill) on the cusp of graduation who
really, really want to change their luck with the ladies. The pundits say
is as raunchy and cheerfully vulgar as any comedy you’re likely to
see this summer, but it’s also remarkably wise and poignant regarding the
awkwardness of the high school years. At 92 percent, Superbad surpasses
Knocked Up
‘s Tomatometer score, which means that it’s one of the best
reviewed films of the year. (Check out our interview with the Superbad
gang here.)

“Those RT critics crack me up.”

arrives in theaters with plenty of baggage. The film, helmed
by Oliver
originally wrapped in 2006, but the studio allegedly balked at what they saw,
and it’s rumored that a good portion of the final product is the result of a
retooled script by the
and reshoots by
V for Vendetta
. Such Hollywood intrigue may ultimately prove more interesting than
the film itself, as critics say The Invasion is a pretty tepid,
unsuspenseful remake of an already thrice-adapted story (Invasion
of the Body Snatchers
). After a space shuttle crash, Nicole Kidman and
Daniel Craig discover that an infection is taking over peoples’ bodies in their
sleep, turning them into unemotional quasi-zombies. The pundits say the film is
slick but unfocused, lacking psychological complexity and thrills. At 16 percent
on the Tomatometer, The Invasion sits far below the precedent set by the 1956 and
1978 Body Snatchers, both at 100 percent.

They couldn’t hide their horror upon seeing the Wachowski Bros. re-cut.

It appears the folks behind The Last Legion are afraid the number of
pundits who wouldn’t dig their movie would be, ahem, legion. Perhaps that’s the
reason the film wasn’t screened before hitting theaters. Featuring a pretty
impressive cast that includes Colin Firth, Ben Kingsley, and
Aishwarya Rai,
Last Legion
tells the story of a boy with the responsibility to save the
Roman Empire. Put down your copy of Livy’s From the Founding of the City and
Guess the Tomatometer.

Both sigh as they attempt to guess the Tomatometer.

Also opening this week in limited release:

The King of Kong: A Fistful of Quarters
, a documentary about the
competition between Donkey Kong experts, is at 100 percent on the
Tomatometer; The 11th
, a global warming doc narrated by
, is at 90 percent (check out our review from Cannes
a tale of small-time paparazzi starring
Steve Buscemi
and Michael Pitt,
is at 89 percent (check out our San Francisco International Film Festival review
Manda Bala
, a doc
about class divisions in modern Brazil, is at 89 percent;
Primo Levi’s
, a doc about the great writer’s trek after WWII, is at 75 percent;
Death at a Funeral,
a farce about a funeral interrupted by a dark family secret starring
Peter Dinklage,
is at 71 percent; and Ils,
a tale of a French couple terrorized by a haunted house in Romania, is at 71
percent; Love
for Sale
, a Brazilian import about a woman who leaves Sao Paulo for her
hometown, is at 67 percent;
Takashi Miike‘s
Zebraman, a spoof
of Japanese superheroes, is at 60 percent; and
Zhang Yang‘s
tale of a 30-year relationship starring
Joan Chen, is
at 60 percent.

Attack its weak point for massive damage!

Finally, props to

for correctly guessing
‘ 13
percent Tomatometer. Congrats, BSK. Now you won’t have to write in all caps to
be heard.

Recent Nicole Kidman Movies:
81% — I
Have Never Forgotten You
90% — God Grew
Tired of Us
30% — Fur: An Imaginary Portrait
of Diane Arbus
74% — Happy Feet
25% — Bewitched (2005)

Tag Cloud

Set visit A&E Tarantino Dark Horse Comics Awards 71st Emmy Awards Turner Mary Tyler Moore Arrowverse BAFTA Travel Channel Star Trek strong female leads Drama Netflix Christmas movies Vudu Captain marvel Marvel Television medical drama cars adaptation YA indie TBS Nickelodeon National Geographic comics video NYCC universal monsters Box Office TCA 2017 obituary boxoffice cancelled television SundanceTV TV Land technology Fox News Disney Channel casting Mary Poppins Returns independent 2015 2016 movie psychological thriller First Look dragons Columbia Pictures reviews Creative Arts Emmys Apple Pixar ITV President Superheroe Lionsgate batman 2018 Family asian-american cops Trailer Classic Film Trophy Talk zero dark thirty concert talk show Biopics Sci-Fi true crime Elton John Video Games Country harry potter psycho BET cats travel crime Emmys TLC teaser science fiction dceu foreign Hallmark directors historical drama El Rey Pirates political drama Animation Spectrum Originals Avengers Paramount Network Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Tumblr Winners YouTube book Walt Disney Pictures romance dc serial killer CBS All Access DC Universe rotten transformers police drama Marathons Rom-Com Marvel Studios CMT 24 frames sitcom VOD TCA Winter 2020 Lifetime Turner Classic Movies Mindy Kaling Showtime series Martial Arts Marvel MSNBC Winter TV aliens all-time Universal Peacock DGA First Reviews GoT 2017 Pop TV NBC a nightmare on elm street comiccon franchise IFC Quiz spain unscripted Emmy Nominations Tubi DirecTV space Heroines Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Comics on TV Black History Month E3 toy story American Society of Cinematographers Pet Sematary cancelled TCM Disney Plus stand-up comedy ABC Family docudrama OneApp 4/20 ESPN OWN facebook slashers Tomatazos Anna Paquin quibi See It Skip It Action BET Awards Holidays game show Logo zombies APB The Arrangement 2019 nature cooking SDCC Holiday Mystery HBO The Witch indiana jones composers Starz mockumentary Cosplay hollywood natural history Hear Us Out stop motion Hulu 20th Century Fox BBC America spider-man Syfy free movies latino Fall TV christmas movies Sundance Now Valentine's Day Rocky twilight Amazon Prime Video blockbuster A24 spinoff HBO Go Horror Hallmark Christmas movies Spike Lucasfilm Super Bowl comic AMC Film BBC Cannes laika green book Bravo diversity IFC Films Disney streaming service Awards Tour anime robots Academy Awards canceled Summer Watching Series TNT Music RT21 Sony Pictures tv talk Cartoon Network crime thriller blaxploitation Best and Worst Red Carpet TCA Awards FX on Hulu Food Network VH1 TV renewals politics E! revenge supernatural scary movies Adult Swim Infographic Reality Competition emmy awards cancelled TV shows Thanksgiving Brie Larson MCU Polls and Games Netflix VICE breaking bad History Amazon Prime Warner Bros. Sneak Peek Song of Ice and Fire critics Stephen King Apple TV+ LGBTQ Writers Guild of America Shudder Superheroes Disney TV Interview rotten movies we love ratings Extras discovery Musical WGN Comedy dogs finale Fantasy mission: impossible adventure 45 children's TV Photos Spring TV singing competition cancelled TV series Amazon television sag awards movies Western chucky what to watch Toys comedies criterion Lifetime Christmas movies fast and furious The Purge ABC Ovation cinemax Binge Guide Acorn TV crossover renewed TV shows Chernobyl streaming social media documentaries mutant cults 007 satire Apple TV Plus spanish language DC Comics FX CBS sports Esquire hispanic anthology TruTV theme song Christmas BBC One Baby Yoda 72 Emmy Awards Film Festival DC streaming service disaster versus LGBT screenings Black Mirror sequel child's play Nominations CW Seed Podcast Funimation Calendar 21st Century Fox game of thrones Countdown Kids & Family RT History spy thriller joker kids Mary poppins award winner festivals Nat Geo based on movie Amazon Studios CNN Television Critics Association MTV Certified Fresh crime drama FOX Grammys Musicals cartoon nbcuniversal USA Network Disney+ Disney Plus PaleyFest Teen biography GIFs Freeform Star Wars Election south america werewolf Oscars Rock USA X-Men romantic comedy PBS Women's History Month Ellie Kemper YouTube Red vampires best screen actors guild films San Diego Comic-Con worst elevated horror Sundance TV The CW Comedy Central Comic Book classics richard e. Grant Ghostbusters Crackle superhero HBO Max YouTube Premium Schedule doctor who period drama The Walking Dead hist Pop witnail WarnerMedia Character Guide Crunchyroll FXX thriller 2020 golden globes Sundance parents Endgame miniseries Pride Month Epix die hard animated halloween Premiere Dates Shondaland Reality ghosts Paramount Discovery Channel Masterpiece zombie documentary Mudbound PlayStation justice league binge stoner war New York Comic Con TIFF reboot video on demand Rocketman Year in Review Opinion jamie lee curtis news Britbox Trivia dramedy dark name the review canceled TV shows TCA SXSW Television Academy GLAAD