Critics Consensus

Dark Waters Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Playmobil is flashy but underwhelming, while Portrait of A Lady on Fire, In Fabric, and The Aeronauts are all also Certified Fresh.

by | December 5, 2019 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a man on a mission (Dark Waters, starring Mark Ruffalo and Anne Hathaway) and an animated adventure (Playmobil: The Movie, featuring the voices of Anya Taylor-Joy and Daniel Radcliffe). What are the critics saying?


Dark Waters (2019) 90%

As if we didn’t already have enough reasons to be fed up with gigantic, multinational corporations, director Todd Haynes‘ drama Dark Waters reminds us there’s plenty more to keep the fires stoked. Based on a 2016 New York Times Magazine article, the film recounts how a corporate attorney named Robert Bilott (played by Mark Ruffalo), whose firm represented corporations like the DuPont chemical company, transformed into an environmental crusader when he discovered what DuPont’s production of Teflon was doing to farm cattle — and later, humans — in West Virginia. Part mystery, part courtroom drama, Dark Waters has earned high praise from critics, who call the film a powerful, timely, and ultimately infuriating condemnation of predatory corporate practices. Not prone to extravagant dramatic touches, Haynes manages to craft a heady underdog story that maintains a steady course, sticks to the facts, and pulls an understated but moving performance from Mark Ruffalo. If you’re looking for fireworks, you won’t get those here, but this story is an important one, and it manages to shine all the same.


Playmobil: The Movie (2019) 17%

In 2014, The LEGO Movie proved it was possible, however improbable, to craft an engaging, entertaining film from source material that isn’t inherently narrative in nature. That film wasn’t the first to make the attempt, and it certainly won’t be the last, as evidenced further by this week’s Playbmobil: The Movie. Adapted from the popular German toy line first introduced in the 1970s, the film centers on a young woman (played by Anya Taylor-Joy) whose younger brother (Gabriel Bateman) is magically transported to an animated dreamland, compelling her to follow him and traverse landscapes populated by pirates, gladiators, and other fanciful creatures to rescue him. Unfortunately, critics say Playmobil is a regrettably mediocre outing that offers little aside from a barrage of colorful images and a brisk but ultimately generic and uninspired story. Never mind that Harry Potter himself (Daniel Radcliffe) lends his voice to James Bond-like secret agent, or that singers like Meghan Trainor and Adam Lambert are on hand to belt out musical numbers; according to the reviews, Playmobil is a whole lot of flash and glitter with very little behind it.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Midnight Family (2019) , a documentary about a family running a private ambulance business in Mexico City, is at 100%.
  • The Disappearance of My Mother (2019) , a documentary about Italian actress, model, and activist Benedetta Barzini by her son, Beniamino Barrese, is at 100%.
  • After Class (Safe Spaces) (2019) , starring Justin Long in a comedy about a family learning to cope when their matriarch is suddenly hospitalized, is at 100%.
  • Portrait of a Lady on Fire (Portrait de la jeune fille en feu) (2020) , a period drama about a woman hired to secretly paint the portrait of a reluctant bride, only for the two to fall in love, is Certified Fresh at 98%.
  • In Fabric (2019) , a comedic supernatural thriller about a woman who slowly succumbs to the sinister powers of a new dress she’s purchased, is Certified Fresh at 95%.
  • Daniel Isn't Real (2019) , a psychological thriller about a college freshman whose childhood imaginary friend suddenly reappears and begins to take over his life, is at 84%.
  • The Aeronauts (2019) , starring Felicity Jones and Eddie Redmayne in a historical drama about the pioneering 19th century meteorologists who utilized hot air balloons to learn more about the weather, is Certified Fresh at 78%.
  • Knives and Skin (2019) , a mystery chronicling the way a suburban own unravels in the wake of a teenage girl’s disappearance, is at 75%.
  • Little Joe (2019) , a sci-fi thriller about a scientist who develops a therapeutic flower species and quickly discovers its unexpected side effects, is at 69%.
  • I See You (2019) , a twisty thriller about a small-town detective and his family, who are plagued by unseen forces in their home that may or may not be real, is at 69%.
  • The Wolf Hour (2019) , starring Naomi Watts in a thriller about a reclusive woman suffering from paranoia during a citywide black out in New York in 1977, is at 67%.
  • A Million Little Pieces (2019) , starring Aaron Taylor-Johnson in a drama based on the controversial memoir of James Frey, is at 26%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

dc The Purge Shondaland New York Comic Con universal monsters Musicals talk show TCA reboot Superheroes stand-up comedy Anna Paquin dogs independent Trivia VH1 Quiz YouTube Premium SXSW mockumentary movie The CW Brie Larson BET Awards Cosplay DC Comics HBO Go FOX 2017 Heroines CNN comiccon Hallmark Christmas movies TV renewals supernatural Ghostbusters Mindy Kaling dark indiana jones Sundance Winners OWN Star Trek Cartoon Network Spike Spring TV asian-american true crime spanish language spider-man Marvel Television christmas movies Bravo National Geographic DirecTV cancelled television 2016 Election Opinion documentary Mudbound APB Sony Pictures Mystery parents book richard e. Grant Superheroe IFC miniseries Paramount Disney Pet Sematary Sneak Peek Lifetime Christmas movies Schedule 2020 sequel psycho Universal ABC cops concert TBS a nightmare on elm street Reality comic series slashers USA Network Hulu RT History sag awards cancelled TV series robots Holiday Women's History Month The Arrangement YA name the review Pirates Oscars Horror comedies Dark Horse Comics tv talk HBO Max Television Academy Tomatazos DGA 2019 television zero dark thirty psychological thriller Rock San Diego Comic-Con indie Trophy Talk TV 2018 Red Carpet Netflix Christmas movies Spectrum Originals Reality Competition Food Network SDCC Showtime Sundance TV 24 frames Apple Rom-Com batman Amazon Studios Walt Disney Pictures WGN Box Office Tubi TCA 2017 Holidays Stephen King screen actors guild Biopics Toys quibi crime thriller mission: impossible hist nature Syfy Baby Yoda finale Travel Channel TIFF FXX game show 4/20 BBC America facebook A24 harry potter ghosts video stoner sitcom green book travel medical drama crime drama Masterpiece MTV Certified Fresh Interview Pride Month Family scary movies GoT elevated horror Nickelodeon teaser justice league unscripted ITV films Animation cooking PBS Black Mirror romantic comedy golden globes Awards Tour adaptation President best Best and Worst Winter TV WarnerMedia Star Wars Awards See It Skip It technology First Reviews Funimation mutant Sundance Now Countdown screenings Paramount Network Comic Book casting OneApp transformers Action binge Lionsgate Hear Us Out PaleyFest what to watch Super Bowl Warner Bros. cults Christmas serial killer doctor who canceled 21st Century Fox breaking bad Arrowverse historical drama Captain marvel docudrama Tarantino social media Grammys Classic Film spain BAFTA Chilling Adventures of Sabrina animated Nominations documentaries Starz American Society of Cinematographers Amazon Prime Video streaming free movies witnail foreign anime cats franchise Freeform sports Ellie Kemper die hard A&E satire E3 Comics on TV thriller Western Disney streaming service Extras TNT halloween 007 adventure aliens Comedy Comedy Central award winner Netflix Sci-Fi LGBTQ Britbox GIFs BBC One crime hispanic spy thriller FX on Hulu strong female leads USA VICE BBC TruTV science fiction CBS south america cancelled dragons Mary Tyler Moore IFC Films Summer kids Apple TV+ Amazon Prime Watching Series cartoon Mary Poppins Returns MCU blaxploitation Esquire Shudder TCA Winter 2020 The Witch versus natural history Acorn TV Set visit Year in Review politics FX Academy Awards Marvel The Walking Dead Pop Valentine's Day Video Games chucky anthology Martial Arts dramedy Nat Geo cars Elton John TV Land History TLC dceu children's TV Calendar Infographic DC streaming service Emmys child's play HBO YouTube ESPN Polls and Games Epix CBS All Access YouTube Red all-time 45 blockbuster diversity Emmy Nominations Peacock Vudu rotten movies we love period drama festivals Film Festival Ovation Country Teen El Rey boxoffice Kids & Family First Look canceled TV shows discovery police drama Turner Classic Movies jamie lee curtis E! political drama game of thrones directors NYCC BET Trailer twilight Musical vampires Fantasy based on movie Fox News Crackle Disney+ Disney Plus Thanksgiving Marathons Premiere Dates Chernobyl 20th Century Fox SundanceTV Avengers theme song Logo zombie composers Adult Swim war LGBT werewolf ratings 71st Emmy Awards DC Universe Tumblr CMT reviews Pop TV TCM Endgame Turner critics CW Seed Columbia Pictures Music GLAAD Lifetime Hallmark cancelled TV shows movies AMC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt comics Photos VOD Crunchyroll Creative Arts Emmys Marvel Studios Rocketman Character Guide crossover Black History Month ABC Family Rocky Discovery Channel Amazon NBC Writers Guild of America Disney Channel news Disney Plus Fall TV criterion spinoff renewed TV shows Song of Ice and Fire Film cinemax singing competition revenge joker romance disaster toy story Drama Lucasfilm Apple TV Plus zombies biography MSNBC latino PlayStation 2015 Cannes video on demand space RT21 X-Men Mary poppins Binge Guide Podcast Pixar