Five Favorite Films

Dave Franco's Five Favorite Horror Films

The 21 Jump Street and The Disaster Artist star and first-time director of The Rental talks about tasteful gore and torturing his wife Alison Brie.

by | July 28, 2020 | Comments

(Photo by James Atoa for Everett Collection)

Dave Franco has been a working actor in Hollywood for over 15 years with no shortage of high profile gigs, from his breakout role alongside Jonah Hill and Channing Tatum in 21 Jump Street to his work with his brother James in the Oscar-nominated The Disaster Artist. Though he’s no stranger to horror either, his previous forays were genre hybrids like the rom-com Warm Bodies or the comedy Fright Night with Colin Farrell, so it might seem strange to learn he chose the genre for his directorial debut. When we spoke to him, though, he confessed that horror was not just a genre he had an affinity for but one he specifically wanted to work in for his first time in the director’s chair.

The Rental follows a pair of couples as they embark on a getaway to a remote vacation rental on the seaside. Once there, they discover that they may be under surveillance, and as the couples begin to war with each other and old secrets are exposed, the once idyllic retreat turns sinister. The ensemble cast, led by Franco’s wife Alison Brie, The Guest star Dan Stevens, Shameless’ Jeremy Allen White, and indie darling Sheila Vand, shine in the thriller, which serves as perfect — or perhaps torturous — viewing for those quarantining at home. 

Ahead of the movie’s release, Franco spoke with Rotten Tomatoes about his five favorite horror films and how he approached directing his wife in some harrowing horror sequences. The movie is available to download now on various platforms and available to watch on-screen at select drive-in theaters across the country.

It Follows (2014) 95%

Let’s start with It Follows. it’s such a simple, brilliant concept, and it’s hard to believe that no one had ever done it before. It feels timeless. And the filmmaking is incredible. The lighting, the camera moves, the music, and the slightly heightened performances that feel like they belong in a throwback ’80s horror film. It just knows exactly what it is, and it somehow manages to feel nostalgic and extremely modern at the same time. I don’t know how David Robert Mitchell pulled that off. That opening sequence of that girl running away from the house and getting killed on the beach really sets the tone for the whole film, and you know that you’re in for a really unique ride.

Blue Ruin (2013) 96%

I love that Blue Ruin is practically a silent film for the first act. Yet it’s still one of the more intriguing setups I’ve seen in a thriller. I also love how Jeremy Saulnier approaches gore in his films. For example, in Blue Ruin, there’s the scene in the bathroom where Macon Blair’s character stabs the guy in the neck with a knife, and it’s raw and shocking, but it shows the audience the lengths his character is willing to go to get revenge. And after that scene, the rest of the violence in the film is more subdued, because we already know what this character is capable of, and we can use our imagination to fill in the gaps. Brilliant.

Martha Marcy May Marlene (2011) 90%

Martha Marcy May Marlene is probably more of a thriller than a horror film, but I think it’s nearly a perfect film. I tracked down the director, Sean Durkin, and somehow convinced him to be a producer on The Rental. He was somewhat of a mentor to me throughout the whole process. And he gave me the confidence to make a horror film that doesn’t rely on jump scares. Instead, I tried to mimic what he did in Martha, where he manages to set an eerie tone with the music and his visuals that makes an audience think that something jarring could happen at any moment, even when there’s nothing overtly scary happening on screen. The movie takes its time to really draw you in, and then when it finally takes its punches, they land really hard.

Rosemary's Baby (1968) 96%

I feel like Rosemary’s Baby inspired all of the smart genre films that we see today. It takes the scares seriously, but it also prioritizes everything else. The acting, the visuals, the music, the production design, and approach everything in a tasteful, elevated way. It’s nuanced and atmospheric, and it takes its time to get under your skin, as opposed to leaning too heavily on cheap jump scares. And it’s the perfect example of how a well-made thriller or horror movie has just as much merit as the heavy dramas that are typically recognized during award season.

Goodnight Mommy (2014) 85%

Finally, I will go with Goodnight, Mommy. I was going to say The Shining, but it’s probably better for me to highlight a lesser-known film. Goodnight, Mommy is an Austrian thriller that’s so beautifully shot, that features those incredible performances, the story so dense in an unpredictable way. It starts with a quiet indie vibe, and then before you know it, the characters are being fed cockroaches and getting their eyelids super glued shut. It’s a pretty wild ride.

Jacqueline Coley for Rotten Tomatoes: Why did you want to make a horror film your first time out? You’ve done comedy and drama, but this is not necessarily a genre that you’ve done a ton of previous work in. So why horror first?

Dave Franco: I wanted my directorial debut to be a horror film for a couple of reasons. As a viewer, there’s nothing I enjoy more than a smart genre film. You know, I think about this young group of genre filmmakers that I mentioned in my top five favorite films, people like David Robert Mitchell, Ari Aster, Jeremy Saulnier, Amy Seimetz, people who are doing projects that are very artful and just happen to be scary too. And I think there’s a general stigma against horror films where people tend to look down on them and write them off as being schlocky. But I think they have just as much artistic merit as any serious drama out there.

There were also logistical reasons. I could make it with a small cast and crew and make it relatively cheap as long as we primarily shot in a single location. And the horror genre tends to deal with extreme scenarios and emotions, so I was able to have fun with the overall style. I could push boundaries, take risks, and make bold choices that would ultimately make the film feel unique to me.

You’ve worked with a lot of directors in your career. Did you hit any of them up for advice? 

Franco: I basically reached out to most of the directors I’ve worked with to pick their brains before I started. I also reached out to the directors I’ve really been inspired by over the years, or Seth Rogen and his crew, Barry Jenkins, my brother, obviously. They all create a very comfortable environment on set where they encourage everyone to voice their opinion if they think it will help the film. There are no egos on their sets, and the main rule is the best idea wins no matter who it’s coming from. That creates a warm environment where everyone feels heard, and it’s very collaborative. I tried to keep that going for The Rental.

You’ve acted with your wife, Alison Brie, before, but I’m just curious, did you find it worse to torture her through this movie or better? Was she mad at you at the end of the day?

Franco: [Laughs] Weirdly enough, we were both kind of indifferent to the torture. In a way, it was fun, because in horror movies, you get to have fun and let loose, show your range and just go crazy. I saw how much Alison was enjoying being a part of this genre that she’s not typically in, and her enjoyment was infectious. So I was giddy when we were filming the scenes of carnage that involved her.

You also co-wrote the screenplay. Was there something you wrote as “the writer” that you were kicking yourself for writing as “the director?” Because there’s always something.

Franco: The cliff sequence was challenging to film — it was really dangerous. You know, there’s a lot of wirework. We had so many extensive conversations about the storyboard or the sequence. We were constantly just making sure that we can get everything we needed creatively while keeping everyone safe. We ended up getting lucky and somehow pulled it off in one day. I look back at that sequence and really can’t process how we accomplished it, but I’m proud of it. And I also hate myself for writing it.

The Rental is available to rent or buy digitally now.


The Rental (2020)

Adjusted Score: 82968%
Critics Consensus: Some tricky genre juggling makes The Rental a bit of a fixer-upper, but effective chills and a solid cast make this a fine destination for horror fans.
Synopsis: Two couples on an oceanside getaway grow suspicious that the host of their seemingly perfect rental house may be spying... [More]
Directed By: Dave Franco

Thumbnail image: James Atoa/Everett Collection, Fox Searchlight, Radius-TWC, Paramount Pictures. 

Tag Cloud

critic resources Chilling Adventures of Sabrina stand-up comedy Winners sequel Disney Plus obituary Cartoon Network children's TV History Paramount Plus Rocky crime Horror new zealand halloween tv cinemax superman richard e. Grant Legendary teaser Awards Tour SDCC anthology Disney+ Disney Plus basketball Christmas Calendar facebook TV movies composers Image Comics FXX true crime TV renewals 90s Creative Arts Emmys See It Skip It Apple TV Plus Musical Crunchyroll SundanceTV Nominations halloween BET Awards Awards movie sitcom superhero Sony Pictures rt labs Western rotten saw Comedy Television Critics Association aapi The CW boxing social media Comics on TV IFC book target Action Hallmark Valentine's Day Fox News Countdown docudrama festivals criterion FX dogs Music mutant E3 24 frames police drama MTV Elton John Biopics TIFF PBS Sci-Fi historical drama TCA Awards tv talk TLC Certified Fresh war dragons The Purge Alien adaptation Song of Ice and Fire The Academy Binge Guide nfl golden globes theme song Marvel kids Showtime batman video on demand Tomatazos Ghostbusters spanish ABC Signature Tubi television YouTube Red Mystery RT History news Spring TV Shondaland diversity Sundance Now Mary Tyler Moore green book animated Emmys Netflix Christmas movies new york video spain young adult joker archives spinoff Holidays name the review Pirates dramedy streaming Best and Worst crime drama cartoon unscripted Tokyo Olympics ViacomCBS cancelled TV shows VOD suspense feel good Pacific Islander cancelled TV series free movies disaster stop motion posters Amazon Studios The Witch SXSW CW Seed CBS All Access WarnerMedia Schedule harry potter Broadway Walt Disney Pictures The Walking Dead psychological thriller Drama NBA indie football Winter TV hispanic venice documentaries Sneak Peek italian Freeform Lifetime nbcuniversal strong female leads President Kids & Family movies cancelled discovery 2016 45 HBO telelvision LGBT Comic-Con@Home 2021 Fall TV Lifetime Christmas movies screen actors guild gangster rt labs critics edition USA Network LGBTQ independent slasher casting worst toy story aliens doctor who olympics razzies satire Election japanese FX on Hulu Trailer Superheroe miniseries spider-man serial killer Arrowverse screenings crossover 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Epix jurassic park Holiday rt archives Paramount Network Reality Competition TV Land GoT politics Shudder Black Mirror comic books ratings lord of the rings Photos DGA Syfy Black History Month universal monsters Exclusive Video Hallmark Christmas movies First Look Acorn TV DirecTV jamie lee curtis AMC Ellie Kemper directors rotten movies we love Marvel Television medical drama Turner Classic Movies E! Super Bowl Adult Swim south america 2019 new star wars movies Mindy Kaling A&E Netflix cars singing competition Summer Tarantino reboot DC streaming service Universal Britbox Apple TV+ CBS action-comedy international Spectrum Originals Travel Channel rom-coms Ovation quibi Trophy Talk mcc 007 Film Festival Year in Review a nightmare on elm street blockbuster child's play Quiz BBC America USA Heroines YouTube Premium what to watch boxoffice MCU parents golden globe awards scene in color breaking bad robots Nat Geo Video Games Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt legend Cosplay Tumblr Spike renewed TV shows GIFs comic book movie Rocketman TNT 71st Emmy Awards live action kaiju YA Baby Yoda talk show BBC spy thriller slashers trailers MSNBC Superheroes ghosts Vudu debate Musicals 93rd Oscars X-Men king kong docuseries elevated horror franchise Martial Arts psycho Thanksgiving HBO Max marvel comics Comedy Central dark classics Warner Bros. Marvel Studios Disney Channel biography Starz black PlayStation Set visit Animation critics Premiere Dates TV concert BAFTA TV One First Reviews ITV dceu Marathons Teen finale christmas movies Television Academy VICE Lucasfilm Esquire Captain marvel Reality Rock zombies hist A24 deadpool Grammys hollywood 2018 monster movies Apple PaleyFest justice league crime thriller Hear Us Out Masterpiece emmy awards FOX OWN Lionsgate mission: impossible CMT Fox Searchlight biopic Amazon Prime Video Character Guide Star Trek Wes Anderson Extras 73rd Emmy Awards sports laika DC Universe Podcast Country wonder woman Crackle Red Carpet 72 Emmy Awards cooking Emmy Nominations Pixar The Arrangement popular BBC One french worst movies political drama Comic Book San Diego Comic-Con romantic comedy TCA 2017 New York Comic Con Avengers hispanic heritage month The Walt Disney Company blaxploitation documentary TBS Pop cops 2017 4/20 toronto Pop TV YouTube nature series australia comics RT21 Mary Poppins Returns Nickelodeon TCA WGN DC Comics 99% mockumentary Cannes romance ESPN chucky canceled TV shows Watching Series comiccon award winner OneApp 2020 zero dark thirty Amazon BET cults Rom-Com Turner revenge adenture 21st Century Fox 2015 foreign 20th Century Fox streaming movies Sundance TV stoner 2021 based on movie prank godzilla Paramount Mudbound Infographic Toys scary movies game of thrones ID APB Classic Film game show marvel cinematic universe fast and furious comedies comic book movies high school Columbia Pictures pirates of the caribbean Brie Larson witnail royal family natural history CNN twilight American Society of Cinematographers transformers Discovery Channel National Geographic sequels book adaptation zombie latino Amazon Prime Pride Month Disney streaming service Oscars ABC Family binge vampires dexter Writers Guild of America TruTV spanish language anime asian-american Mary poppins Fantasy El Rey GLAAD james bond comic Sundance films science fiction Stephen King TCM space know your critic adventure Disney indiana jones cats travel ABC Interview Box Office canceled Endgame VH1 Anna Paquin period drama Opinion Pet Sematary women reviews supernatural all-time thriller Polls and Games IFC Films die hard NBC hidden camera festival sag awards scorecard best Trivia fresh Logo HBO Go Food Network TCA Winter 2020 NYCC Women's History Month blockbusters heist movie Chernobyl cancelled television Funimation japan werewolf Hulu king arthur remakes versus Film dc Family Peacock technology Bravo Dark Horse Comics Academy Awards Star Wars 1990s kong