Critics Consensus

Deadpool 2 Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Book Club is reasonably entertaining, Show Dogs has no bite, and First Reformed is also Certified Fresh.

by | May 17, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have the return of cinema’s most meta mutant (Deadpool 2, starring Ryan Reynolds and Josh Brolin), some frisky friends (Book Club, starring Diane Keaton and Jane Fonda), and a spiritual sequel to Turner & Hooch (Show Dogs, starring Will Arnett and Ludacris). What are the critics saying?


Deadpool 2 (2018) 83%


The first Deadpool movie had to pull off a tricky juggling act, setting up the origin story for a character who’d already been introduced (underwhelmingly, in X-Men Origins: Wolverine) and whose signature comics aesthetic seemed far too raunchy and profane to fly at the cineplex. If the filmmakers embraced this beloved anti-hero’s R-rated roots, they’d have a hard time making enough money to turn a profit; if they made him safe enough for the PG-13 crowd, then there’d be no point in making a movie at all. Wonder of wonders, Deadpool went for the hard R and ended up being a huge hit anyway — and with this weekend’s Deadpool 2, the franchise continues defying the odds, delivering a second installment that critics are actually enjoying even more than the first. This time out, Deadpool (Ryan Reynolds) meets up with his frequent comics foil Cable (Josh Brolin), a time-traveling cyborg on a quest to prevent a catastrophic future involving a young mutant (Julian Dennison). Needless to say, the trio link up in typically violent, foulmouthed style, all in the service of a plot that introduces some new characters (including Zazie Beets‘ Domino and Terry Crews‘ Bedlam) and sets up future superpowered adventures without forgetting to tell an entertaining story. If you’re a fan — and judging by the box office numbers, the odds are fairly good that you are — grab a chimichanga and head to the theater in confidence.

Book Club (2018) 53%


The British film industry has made a habit out of periodically rounding up its most beloved veteran actors for light romantic comedies that get by on the strength of their stars, and that’s pretty much the vibe given off by Book Club, which unites a powerhouse quartet of female leads (Jane Fonda, Diane Keaton, Candice Bergen, and Mary Steenburgen) to play lifelong friends who enjoy an unlikely sexual reawakening after their titular gaggle decides to read Fifty Shades of Grey. It’s a featherweight premise that isn’t designed to challenge the audience (or the cast), but critics say the end result is still reasonably entertaining — and even has a handful of affecting moments, thanks to the all-around excellent work this ensemble turns in. Major studio films don’t deign to explore this stage of life terribly often, and it’s hard not to wish Book Club hadn’t done more with an unfortunately rare opportunity — but if you’re in the mood for some laughs and a few feels courtesy of some very talented people, go ahead and make time for a matinee.

Show Dogs (2018) 17%


Plenty of family-friendly comedies rely on plots that feature talking animals, but as of this weekend, only one of them stars Will Arnett as a human detective paired with a canine partner voiced by Chris “Ludacris” Bridges. We’re talking about Show Dogs, of course, a puppy-powered caper that somehow also features the talents of Alan CummingNatasha Lyonne, and Stanley “Tooch” Tucci. Only a handful of reviews have trickled in for this release, but they’re pretty unforgiving thus far. If you’re just looking for an excuse to get out of the house with the kids this weekend, Show Dogs may keep the youngest viewers occupied for a little while, but there are far better examples of this familiar breed that you can watch at home.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • First Reformed (2018) , a Paul Schrader drama starring Ethan Hawke as a pastor whose counsel of a radical environmentalist could have severe repercussions, is Certified Fresh at 96%.
  • Sollers Point (2018) , about a Baltimore man struggling to regain his footing under house arrest after being released from prison, is at 88%.
  • Saving Brinton (2018) , a documentary about the amazing mass of possessions accrued by lifetime collector Mike Zahs, is at 88%.
  • That Summer (2018) , which reveals unused footage filmed during the making of landmark documentary Grey Gardens, is at 88%.
  • Pope Francis - A Man of His Word (2018) , a presumably positive documentary look at the Pope, is at 86%.
  • On Chesil Beach (2018) , starring Saoirse Ronan and Emily Watson in the adaptation of a an Ian McEwan about a young couple in 1962, is at 68%.
  • Dark Crimes (2018) , starring Jim Carrey as a police detective whose murder investigation draws him into the mysterious path of a bestselling author, is at 0%.

Tag Cloud

FOX Spring TV Fall TV mutant sitcom AMC YouTube Premium 2015 spy thriller DC Comics Marvel blaxploitation streaming period drama Mystery NYCC TV Land NBC historical drama ABC Family Epix RT History justice league zombie Paramount travel Musical Comedy Drama Animation Awards APB science fiction Cosplay SDCC Universal 2017 TNT TLC Nominations unscripted Lifetime Britbox Spike Kids & Family Rom-Com doctor who GoT Sci-Fi comiccon thriller finale Freeform Columbia Pictures zombies crossover TruTV sports cults docudrama PaleyFest San Diego Comic-Con YA Crackle cops Certified Fresh YouTube Red Photos war ratings Reality Set visit talk show crime drama LGBTQ Red Carpet Masterpiece President Horror 21st Century Fox Winners Superheroes Netflix Winter TV what to watch The CW cinemax DC Universe Nickelodeon dceu ESPN Acorn TV Cartoon Network Biopics discovery golden globes Best and Worst Starz Musicals Sundance aliens Star Trek Amazon psycho Western Year in Review technology romance Watching Series transformers Walt Disney Pictures A&E Trailer Toys TCM USA Network MTV Extras Character Guide E3 20th Century Fox Ghostbusters Election GIFs TV CMT HBO First Look FXX CNN politics IFC Fantasy 007 Nat Geo 2016 Reality Competition American Society of Cinematographers SundanceTV GLAAD Trivia TIFF based on movie Country TCA Hulu binge Infographic festivals OWN VICE medical drama biography Tomatazos Adult Swim WGN 24 frames 45 Song of Ice and Fire Fox News Star Wars MSNBC Premiere Dates CW Seed Teen Calendar Tumblr Bravo Podcast Sundance Now Sneak Peek supernatural Action Sony Pictures X-Men Oscars Countdown Pixar Thanksgiving Comic Book Lucasfilm Emmys Mindy Kaling political drama VH1 Food Network SXSW Esquire Christmas Polls and Games cooking DC streaming service Dark Horse Comics police drama TBS Creative Arts Emmys Box Office Shondaland singing competition TCA 2017 History cats Writers Guild of America Comedy Central Ellie Kemper Opinion Apple Schedule hist composers Super Bowl Holidays dramedy Superheroe Syfy BBC America CBS Interview IFC Films Video Games Summer DirecTV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Martial Arts Rocky boxoffice Pop Disney Channel Paramount Network serial killer BBC harry potter crime Logo El Rey National Geographic vampires FX social media crime thriller USA Valentine's Day PBS dc Warner Bros. ITV Music The Arrangement Lionsgate adventure Pirates Rock Mary Tyler Moore E! robots CBS All Access Showtime Grammys Ovation BET Disney diversity See It Skip It Marathons ABC