Critics Consensus

Despite Visual Flash, Pixels Isn't Worth Your Quarters

Plus, Paper Towns is thin but likeable; Southpaw is so-so despite Jake Gyllenhaal's astonishing performance; and The Jim Gaffigan Show is Certified Fresh.

by | July 23, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got video game invaders (Pixels, starring Adam Sandler and Kevin James), teenage mystery buffs (Paper Towns, starring Nat Wolff and Cara Delevingne), and a down-and-out pugilist (Southpaw, starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Rachel McAdams). What do the critics have to say?


Pixels (2015) 17%

At first glance, Pixels sports more ambition than your typical Adam Sandler vehicle, blending the plot of Ghostbusters with beloved characters from 1980s video games. Unfortunately, critics say that while the film has moments of visual invention, it’s ultimately undermined by a slack narrative and a lack of comic momentum. Back in the 1980s, Sam (Sandler) and his buds were masters of the arcade. But when a race of aliens mistake Pac-Man, Donkey Kong, and the like for a threat — and reverse-engineer said icons for destructive purposes — its up to our slacker heroes to save the day. The critics say Pixels contains a few good ideas, but it never quite coalesces into anything other than a middling special effects blockbuster with a few passable gags.

Paper Towns (2015) 57%

The Fault In Our Stars scored big last summer so now we’re treated to Paper Towns, the second in what’s sure to be a long line of films adapted from John Green’s young adult novels. Critics say it’s a mild success — its familiar story and relatively thin characters are elevated by witty dialogue and strong performances. Quentin (Nat Wolff) has harbored a lifelong crush on his next-door neighbor Margo (Cara Delevingne), who enlists him for a series of late-night pranks. But when Margo disappears suddenly, she leaves a series of clues for Quentin to decipher, which culminate in a life-changing road trip. The pundits say Paper Towns is a likeable wisp of a film, one that’s melancholy and well-intentioned without being particularly profound.

Southpaw (2015) 59%

Can great acting transcend a so-so movie? Critics say Jake Gyllenhaal’s muscular, committed performance is easily the best thing about Southpaw, an otherwise routine portrait of a troubled prizefighter that goes the distance without landing a knockout blow. Gyllenhaal stars as Billy Hope, a boxing champ who’s blindsided by personal tragedy, losing his title and his family in the process. But with the help of a committed trainer, Billy seeks redemption in the ring. The pundits say Southpaw is mostly made up of rags-to-riches sports movie cliches, but  Gyllenhaal is so good that he almost makes it a contender.

What’s Hot On TV:

The Jim Gaffigan Show: Season 1 (2015) 80%

The Jim Gaffigan Show benefits from an abundantly likable star in a setting that, albeit familiar, adds a new, natural energy to the standard struggling-dad-sitcom genre.

BoJack Horseman: Season 2 (2015) 100%

Bojack Horseman truly comes into its own during season two, maturing into an ambitious comedy that sensitively blends wackiness with dark, nuanced drama.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Horse Money (2015)Pedro Costa‘s drama about an elderly Lisbon resident haunted by his past, is at 100 percent.
  • Phoenix (2015) , a drama about a Holocaust survivor who finds herself ensnared within postwar Berlin’s demimonde, is Certified Fresh at 98 percent.
  • A Gay Girl in Damascus: The Amina Profile (2015) , a documentary about a mysterious blogger who purported to file dispatches from within war-torn Syria, is at 91 percent.
  • The Outrageous Sophie Tucker (2015) , a documentary portrait of the bawdy singer and comedian, is at 83 percent.
  • Unexpected (2015) , starring Cobie Smulders in a dramedy about a high school teacher and a student who bond over their unplanned pregnancies, is at 67 percent.
  • Samba (2015) , starring Omar Sy and Charlotte Gainsbourg in a romantic dramedy about an immigrant’s rights advocate who falls for a Senegalese kitechen worker, is at 59 percent.
  • The Young Kieslowski (2015) , a comedy about two mismatched college students who find themselves parents-to-be, is at 50 percent.
  • Dark Was The Night (2015) , a horror film about an isolated town that’s bedeviled by a shadowy creature in the surrounding woods, is at 40 percent.
  • The Vatican Tapes (2010) , starring Michael Peña and Djimon Hounsou in a supernatural horror film about a woman whose demonic possession is serious enough to attract the attention of the Holy See, is at 29 percent.
  • American Heist (2015) , starring Adrien Brody and Hayden Christensen in a thriller about an ex-con who forces his younger brother to participate in a daring bank robbery, is at 25 percent.
  • Big Significant Things (2015) , a dramedy about a twentysomething who uses a road trip as an excuse to put off making any big life decisions, is at 22 percent.
  • Frank The Bastard (2015) , starring Rachel Miner and William Sadler in a horror film about a young woman who discovers terrifying secrets lurking in her hometown, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

Amazon Prime Video Rock Infographic BBC America ratings movie BBC Tomatazos finale Sundance composers TV Land DirecTV miniseries what to watch The Witch casting Fall TV Oscars TIFF SXSW Holidays 20th Century Fox Schedule Sundance TV USA MTV Election Country serial killer book Action SDCC Super Bowl Marvel Television spy thriller Pirates television The Arrangement DC streaming service LGBTQ Trophy Talk hollywood Universal mutant Nominations FOX Stephen King free movies Tubi Brie Larson Paramount Epix Chernobyl OneApp FXX BET Awards Podcast social media Disney a nightmare on elm street technology diversity Ellie Kemper name the review dc dceu series scary movies zombie Marvel Studios latino Black History Month Character Guide Rocketman E! Rom-Com USA Network ABC Superheroe Chilling Adventures of Sabrina natural history adventure CW Seed Elton John Disney Plus zombies crime drama Crunchyroll President CBS romantic comedy Academy Awards Emmys Marvel canceled Reality Competition Song of Ice and Fire 4/20 TCA 2017 45 Summer discovery best Holiday Musical Shondaland cars TV renewals vampires Biopics science fiction emmy awards doctor who Spike GoT Television Critics Association Freeform true crime Sneak Peek adaptation thriller AMC DGA Bravo Mystery Comedy Central Mary poppins breaking bad Spring TV Watching Series Ghostbusters Drama YouTube streaming Toys Sony Pictures TV Winter TV TBS quibi Awards Tour Sci-Fi Set visit blockbuster jamie lee curtis DC Comics comics CBS All Access anime die hard Comic Book Turner Classic Movies medical drama period drama politics facebook Crackle Britbox superhero canceled TV shows Martial Arts asian-american Winners Red Carpet hispanic Amazon Prime golden globes Pride Month cats unscripted American Society of Cinematographers directors GLAAD FX on Hulu Baby Yoda Family Marathons based on movie Syfy A&E green book news Film Rocky robots reviews Fox News Captain marvel dark Amazon Studios Valentine's Day franchise crime thriller ESPN historical drama spinoff Best and Worst anthology Food Network Calendar stand-up comedy rotten Animation cinemax Fantasy 007 ITV Disney Channel Writers Guild of America justice league werewolf IFC Binge Guide Tarantino revenge Certified Fresh comic Cannes Star Wars YouTube Premium Pop cancelled television south america Star Trek worst Polls and Games children's TV E3 X-Men San Diego Comic-Con Pop TV zero dark thirty Starz indie TCA OWN Thanksgiving Music PlayStation Comics on TV Lifetime Christmas movies cooking cancelled TV series reboot 2018 BBC One A24 renewed TV shows Netflix cops Masterpiece screen actors guild Showtime GIFs foreign comiccon New York Comic Con nature video on demand spain sitcom 2020 tv talk TLC BAFTA Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Disney streaming service Netflix Christmas movies animated biography RT History Television Academy NYCC TruTV Christmas crossover TCA Winter 2020 LGBT Ovation Box Office HBO Max Funimation HBO Go documentaries indiana jones National Geographic mission: impossible classics sag awards joker VICE slashers 2015 Reality teaser Apple versus cancelled TV shows hist police drama Amazon dramedy Acorn TV Warner Bros. WGN FX Heroines Mindy Kaling Apple TV Plus Travel Channel screenings elevated horror romance strong female leads toy story Lucasfilm Turner NBC witnail TNT Adult Swim all-time cartoon Emmy Nominations space TCM Video Games kids Peacock Tumblr video award winner sequels universal monsters cancelled Trivia 21st Century Fox Quiz Esquire RT21 El Rey Pixar Nat Geo Sundance Now supernatural political drama Arrowverse Film Festival ghosts talk show Lionsgate crime Cosplay Avengers Teen laika Countdown Western psycho rotten movies we love Women's History Month Interview chucky Mary Poppins Returns MCU Comedy APB PaleyFest First Look WarnerMedia Classic Film CMT Columbia Pictures nbcuniversal Hulu sequel The CW The Walking Dead docudrama VH1 Spectrum Originals Hallmark stop motion sports war BET concert Discovery Channel 2016 harry potter Walt Disney Pictures Vudu Awards See It Skip It DC Universe Nickelodeon dragons 2017 Premiere Dates Photos Mudbound spanish language CNN HBO independent Lifetime binge richard e. Grant aliens The Purge SundanceTV 2019 Paramount Network Extras critics christmas movies Year in Review Superheroes festivals halloween Black Mirror parents obituary Grammys 24 frames child's play PBS cults YA Dark Horse Comics Cartoon Network psychological thriller films First Reviews game show Pet Sematary documentary Musicals spider-man VOD YouTube Red Hear Us Out Hallmark Christmas movies Disney+ Disney Plus disaster Anna Paquin theme song History criterion Logo IFC Films mockumentary singing competition fast and furious Shudder transformers ABC Family Opinion comedies satire stoner TCA Awards Endgame game of thrones Horror 72 Emmy Awards MSNBC boxoffice twilight 71st Emmy Awards dogs movies Trailer Apple TV+ blaxploitation Mary Tyler Moore batman Creative Arts Emmys Kids & Family travel