Marvel Vs. DC on TV: Which Comic Book Giant Reigns Supreme?

Find out which comic book TV universe comes out on top and which series fans prefer in the results from Rotten Tomatoes' Fall TV Survey.

by | November 2, 2018 | Comments

Daredevil keyart and Robin from Titans character poster (Netflix; DC Universe)

When Rotten Tomatoes asked users about their television viewing habits in our Fall TV Survey, we got intel on how much TV they watch, how they watch it, and other details. We also asked them one very important question: Marvel or DC?

In the battle of the comic book titans, the percentage of RT users who prefer Marvel’s shows just barely edged out the diplomatic among you (a.k.a. the ones who prefer both). Interestingly, the number of users who prefer DC to Marvel is far lower. The RT user breakdown is 31.54% Marvel, 31.39% both, 26.63% neither, and just 10.44% DC.

Among Marvel viewers, the most popular show for RT users is also the No. 1-ranked show on the Tomatometer (which means the critics agree!): Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., with 19.85% of users saying it’s their favorite. Marvel’s Daredevil is next, with 14.56% of RT users saying it’s their favorite, followed by Marvel’s Jessica Jones with 11.43%, Legion with 8.10%, and Marvel’s The Punisher with 6.16%. Marvel’s Iron Fist comes in last among RT users (with 0.88% saying it’s their favorite) and on the Tomatometer (with a 37%, followed only by the one-season series Marvel’s Inhumans).

David Lee/Netflix
(Photo by Netflix)

Daredevil also ranks second among RT users’ favorite Netflix series (with 6.24% of users saying it’s their favorite, behind Stranger Things).

On the DC side, 11.64% of RT users said The Flash is their favorite, and 11.16% say they like Gotham best. Interestingly, while Black Lightning is in the top 3 DC shows by Tomatometer (with a 98% score, and a Certified Fresh first season), it comes in second-to-last among RT users’ favorites (with only 3.26% saying it’s their favorite). Krypton comes in second-to-last on the Tomatometer (with a 59% score, followed only by the one-season sitcom Powerless), and last among RT users’ faves (with 1.30% of respondents calling it their favorite).

Gender affected the Marvel vs. DC results by just a few percentage points, but in key ways: more women preferred neither (33.56%), then both (31.39%), then Marvel (24.77%), and finally DC (10.28%). Among male respondents, 34.49% prefer Marvel, 34.03% prefer both, 20.14% prefer neither, and 11.35% prefer DC.

The Flash -- "We Are The Flash" -- Image Number: FLA423b_0449.jpg -- Pictured: Grant Gustin as The Flash -- Photo: Shane Harvey/The CW -- 2018 The CW Network, LLC. All rights reserved
(Photo by The CW)

For DC fans, the top show among women was Lucifer (10.76%), then Gotham (9.26%), then The Flash (7.48%). For men, it was The Flash (16.39%), then Gotham (13.67%), then Preacher (9.45%). For Marvel fans, the top show among women was S.H.I.E.L.D. (19.27%), then Jessica Jones (13.61%), then Daredevil (6.89%). For men, it was S.H.I.E.L.D. (24.87%), Daredevil (19.43%), and Legion (9.02%).

Want to know where the series rank on the Tomatometer? Check out the Marvel and DC guides below!

Tag Cloud

cops Comics on TV cults justice league AMC Hallmark ESPN DC streaming service Photos Super Bowl Extras supernatural strong female leads Animation cancelled TV shows HBO Max anime Valentine's Day YouTube Premium TBS free movies Reality Competition Podcast Universal Bravo Calendar Marathons MSNBC Trophy Talk American Society of Cinematographers award winner DGA Teen Avengers Dark Horse Comics Disney Plus Rom-Com Trailer casting Nickelodeon Christmas adventure The Walking Dead Winners medical drama MTV Grammys Best and Worst Showtime comiccon FXX Turner Classic Movies Drama Captain marvel crime drama Creative Arts Emmys serial killer Masterpiece Paramount psycho psychological thriller E! spinoff Mystery Infographic The Arrangement binge Schedule Television Academy Disney streaming service Polls and Games Writers Guild of America CBS All Access halloween Sony Pictures politics jamie lee curtis 2016 docudrama CMT period drama Winter TV streaming movies OneApp Food Network Certified Fresh book Mary Poppins Returns discovery Summer technology Disney+ Disney Plus Starz spanish language Disney Lucasfilm breaking bad historical drama movie cancelled television Shondaland latino IFC Women's History Month biography spy thriller transformers name the review television dramedy Superheroes Shudder Endgame teaser Anna Paquin IFC Films mutant cancelled Trivia based on movie Cannes New York Comic Con game show OWN cats YouTube stand-up comedy Columbia Pictures Black Mirror RT History Toys documentary cancelled TV series Warner Bros. Fall TV Mary Tyler Moore aliens dc TCA kids Emmys LGBT true crime Western TCM First Reviews Country boxoffice zombie dragons Logo Fantasy GIFs directors Tomatazos Apple TV Plus Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt miniseries natural history Tubi joker E3 Marvel Sneak Peek Marvel Television Brie Larson Kids & Family San Diego Comic-Con Rocketman green book Netflix Christmas movies Chernobyl comic 71st Emmy Awards Ellie Kemper 2019 Hallmark Christmas movies social media diversity ABC Family cinemax Video Games 21st Century Fox Amazon Prime DC Universe Tarantino anthology cooking A24 crime Superheroe Cartoon Network spain Lifetime SXSW 24 frames CNN christmas movies crime thriller space witnail sequel what to watch animated Action foreign The Witch Quiz DirecTV Elton John Disney Channel Awards History rotten movies we love NYCC Year in Review robots Apple TV+ Reality Ghostbusters zombies mockumentary quibi 2017 ratings screen actors guild Crunchyroll tv talk Holidays Amazon Studios Sundance Paramount Network Spring TV versus Adult Swim X-Men BBC reboot Esquire vampires Mudbound werewolf Peacock Sundance TV canceled war ABC Awards Tour unscripted blaxploitation 2018 CW Seed President First Look zero dark thirty Epix screenings Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 2020 Rocky Film Festival Interview festivals 45 Countdown VICE thriller Song of Ice and Fire indie 007 Biopics independent spider-man Holiday harry potter NBC Nat Geo Stephen King VH1 police drama Tumblr Oscars Musicals Pirates Netflix theme song sports The CW travel PaleyFest Walt Disney Pictures YA talk show Classic Film BET Academy Awards Box Office BBC America El Rey Vudu Arrowverse Pop Comedy Central LGBTQ blockbuster crossover Character Guide Baby Yoda Horror TLC TCA Winter 2020 Britbox The Purge RT21 Syfy Mindy Kaling batman Marvel Studios series game of thrones FX Binge Guide TCA 2017 cars romance TV Land HBO Watching Series National Geographic Comedy 20th Century Fox CBS Turner Pet Sematary composers Mary poppins Red Carpet Pixar Martial Arts Nominations MCU Opinion TV renewals USA revenge sitcom Freeform dceu TruTV Hulu See It Skip It Lifetime Christmas movies Crackle science fiction Ovation USA Network Amazon nature Sundance Now singing competition SDCC ITV TNT WarnerMedia children's TV adaptation Cosplay FOX WGN Emmy Nominations Film Comic Book Music Premiere Dates toy story facebook Pride Month Star Wars slashers cartoon finale hispanic Musical Spectrum Originals DC Comics 2015 renewed TV shows Fox News Apple TV Amazon Prime Video video Family ghosts A&E GLAAD south america Acorn TV hist Set visit sag awards richard e. Grant Sci-Fi Star Trek Discovery Channel APB TIFF Heroines golden globes PBS Spike comics Lionsgate Thanksgiving SundanceTV YouTube Red disaster Election GoT political drama romantic comedy doctor who Rock canceled TV shows elevated horror