Critics Consensus

Guess Winchester's Tomatometer

Plus, Netflix's Altered Carbon is ambitiously pulpy and Chliean drama A Fantastic Woman is Certified Fresh.

by | February 1, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, Hollywood’s sitting out the Super Bowl with a potential prestige horror picture inspired by the Bay Area’s most infamous haunted house (Winchester, starring Helen Mirren and Jason Clarke) as well as a handful of limited releases. What are the critics saying?


Winchester (2018) 13%


While we tend to think of her as the type of award-winning talent who’s mostly seen in serious adult fare, Helen Mirren — on the stage and screen just as, we presume, in real life — does whatever the heck she wants. Yes, she’s one of the most acclaimed working actors in the business, and yes, she can command an arthouse audience with the best of ’em — but sometimes she feels like rolling up her sleeves and firing off a few rounds in some genre fare, and this weekend marks just one such occasion. Winchester presents a fictionalized — and presumably pretty scary — take on the story of Sarah Winchester, who inherited her husband’s vast fortune after the pioneering arms manufacturer’s sudden death in 1881. Convinced her family was haunted by the vengeful spirits of the countless people killed by her family’s wares, the widow Winchester was said to have kept crews working on her mansion constantly throughout the latter decades of her life, all in an attempt to keep the other side at bay. It all adds up to the stuff of a compelling paranormal feature, and Mirren is absolutely up to the task; unfortunately, the review embargo for Winchester hasn’t been lifted yet, so we can’t tell you what the critics think. It would seem to portend a spooky fate for this film’s critical reputation, but we don’t know for sure — and in the meantime, you know what that means: it’s time to play a chilling round of Guess the Tomatometer!


What’s New on TV

Altered Carbon: Season 1 (2018) 68%

Altered Carbon leans hard into its cyberpunk roots, serving up an ambitiously pulpy viewing experience that often overwhelms, but never bores.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

Best and Worst Food Network 4/20 Television Critics Association classics Avengers Film television fast and furious Columbia Pictures Disney streaming service Lifetime Christmas movies justice league Mystery Interview Polls and Games finale See It Skip It Shudder TruTV cinemax Hallmark Christmas movies Red Carpet mission: impossible PaleyFest Acorn TV witnail Photos DC Universe Extras foreign The Purge Holidays Ellie Kemper cats LGBT political drama movies what to watch TV MSNBC biography zombie singing competition Winter TV TNT spanish language TCA TBS LGBTQ DC streaming service documentary war cancelled TV shows Stephen King Mindy Kaling ghosts Tumblr Winners Superheroes Women's History Month Amazon Prime Video Epix Comedy CBS rotten movies we love transformers YouTube Premium Mary poppins VOD stop motion Heroines Walt Disney Pictures sequels Comics on TV TLC canceled spider-man ABC batman crossover FX Amazon Prime Warner Bros. Black Mirror documentaries Disney talk show Star Trek San Diego Comic-Con free movies ratings Trivia harry potter Pet Sematary news rotten police drama halloween dceu worst movies Awards Tour Biopics diversity spain 72 Emmy Awards strong female leads ABC Family Chilling Adventures of Sabrina versus game show Dark Horse Comics boxoffice USA Network die hard Brie Larson cults superhero discovery Hulu cooking Opinion theme song BBC America critics dragons book Mary Tyler Moore Funimation Bravo comics vampires 2020 PlayStation video Box Office Action Spring TV latino elevated horror The CW BBC One dramedy First Reviews concert tv talk MTV spy thriller X-Men Comedy Central Musical Disney Plus Anna Paquin cars Western crime thriller Super Bowl cartoon movie Podcast toy story Comic Book asian-american Ovation mockumentary Pixar FXX 24 frames TCM dogs Video Games CMT History Certified Fresh adaptation nature screenings AMC psychological thriller Lifetime independent Music TCA 2017 OWN worst Nickelodeon anime Vudu Lucasfilm El Rey festival 45 emmy awards 2019 venice Summer Logo The Walking Dead DirecTV renewed TV shows USA Marathons 20th Century Fox DC Comics CNN mutant binge MCU Paramount BAFTA Creative Arts Emmys 2016 Sneak Peek casting Trophy Talk jamie lee curtis Black History Month SXSW NYCC zero dark thirty Sony Pictures reboot Crackle Writers Guild of America CW Seed Nat Geo Crunchyroll Infographic Martial Arts all-time TCA Awards Thanksgiving spinoff obituary football Sundance TV E! Fox News Hallmark Nominations SundanceTV Song of Ice and Fire Turner Classic Movies sequel scary movies Ghostbusters GoT A&E The Arrangement Showtime films Mary Poppins Returns Masterpiece romantic comedy APB Character Guide crime drama toronto Sundance Now Valentine's Day Set visit serial killer Britbox social media Sundance BET Awards TV Land thriller laika WarnerMedia child's play Toys Turner Holiday zombies facebook 2017 GIFs indie ESPN Year in Review Fantasy National Geographic 71st Emmy Awards docudrama quibi hist miniseries space green book comic Rom-Com DGA composers streaming Amazon Academy Awards twilight Paramount Network revenge GLAAD FOX Spectrum Originals Shondaland VH1 Captain marvel YA Schedule screen actors guild First Look Cartoon Network true crime Apple ITV Hear Us Out Teen FX on Hulu TV renewals hollywood SDCC series RT21 adventure Binge Guide HBO Max Star Wars Travel Channel Disney+ Disney Plus sports Discovery Channel kids Arrowverse blockbuster disaster Netflix Animation The Witch Freeform dark VICE sag awards OneApp Quiz IFC festivals A24 canceled TV shows Oscars Film Festival NBC Superheroe Emmys Marvel Studios chucky Election Mudbound medical drama Tomatazos a nightmare on elm street universal monsters President Pop comedies award winner comiccon breaking bad Syfy RT History children's TV Marvel Television BBC Netflix Christmas movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Trailer Apple TV Plus WGN historical drama Television Academy Country Countdown criterion cops YouTube psycho New York Comic Con indiana jones Cosplay blaxploitation Horror nbcuniversal PBS Premiere Dates remakes Amazon Studios Family Emmy Nominations Calendar teaser animated Rocky cancelled television supernatural romance name the review cancelled Pirates Reality HBO Reality Competition Apple TV+ video on demand unscripted 007 Adult Swim based on movie Spike Awards scorecard IFC Films directors aliens golden globes parents sitcom robots Fall TV Disney Channel doctor who Rock Endgame christmas movies Starz BET satire Kids & Family stand-up comedy Watching Series science fiction Tubi south america game of thrones Elton John Baby Yoda HBO Go dc slashers technology TCA Winter 2020 CBS All Access joker franchise 2015 Chernobyl werewolf richard e. Grant reviews Lionsgate 21st Century Fox Universal 2018 Classic Film Grammys anthology Pride Month E3 crime Esquire Rocketman Sci-Fi Drama Peacock hispanic nfl American Society of Cinematographers travel natural history YouTube Red Christmas best stoner cancelled TV series Tarantino politics Musicals Pop TV Cannes TIFF Marvel period drama