Guy Pearce and Andy Serkis Give Us A Christmas Carol Like We've Never Seen

The stars of writer-producer Steven Knight's dark adaptation offer five ways in which this retelling veers dramatically away from previous efforts.

by | December 18, 2019 | Comments

Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol is one of the most-adapted tales in the history of the English language, and Steven Knight, creator of gritty period series Peaky Blinders and Taboo, is the latest talent to have taken on the task.

We all know the story: crotchety miser Ebenezer Scrooge has a Christmas Eve night visitation from his dead former partner Jacob Marley, who warns him of three ghosts who will attend him as he walks through visions of Christmases past, present, and future.

This new FX presentation, directed by Nick Murphy (The Awakening), stars Guy Pearce as Scrooge and Andy Serkis as a grumpy Ghost of Christmas Past and promises a darker take on the 1843 novella that made a superstar of its author: “A Christmas Carol is a spine-tingling immersion into Scrooge’s dark night of the soul,” the promotional materials promise.

“It is a darker retelling. There’s no question,” Serkis told Rotten Tomatoes. “It’s a unique retelling in that respect because… Scrooge in this is not some sort of old miser character. He’s actually a tough businessmen… who is in denial and doesn’t want to really engage with his own moral relativism.”

We caught up with the stars to get a feel for the new adaptation — and it indeed feels scary. Here are five ways this Christmas Carol one-ups previous efforts.

1. This Cool Scrooge Resonates With Modern Audiences

A CHRISTMAS CAROL -- Pictured: Guy Pearce as Ebenezer Scrooge. CR: Kurt Iswarienko/FX
(Photo by Kurt Iswarienko/FX)

Scrooge is not as crotchety here as in previous interpretations of the character; in fact, the character may resemble more real-life people than ever before. Pearce offered a personal assessment of his character.

“They really wanted somebody this time who still had been affected in life the way that we know Scrooge has been, but that his demeanor and his presence in the world was more of a businessman, as a leader who is a kind of a cocky, confident, swaggering kind of asshole, basically,” Pearce told Rotten Tomatoes. “I think it was important for Nick, our director, and for Steven, our writer, to get away from the crotchety old man who exhibits on the surface the pain and damage that he’s experienced in his life. And the fact that he’s turned away from the world and plays somebody who’s actually up front to the world and says, ‘Come on, bring it on. Bring on your questions about who I am and what it is, because I’ve got a really good response for you.’ And kind of like that, be a little bit more affronting and aggressive. And so, in a way, we still get to the point where we drag him through his past, and we make him look at the things he’s done to people, and we crack open the soul that is a damaged soul.”

2. This Ghost of Christmas Past Plays Dirty

A CHRISTMAS CAROL -- Pictured: Andy Serkis as Ghost of Christmas Past. CR: Robert Viglasky/FX
(Photo by Robert Viglasky/FX)

But his Scrooge will face a harder fight in Knight’s version, Pearce confirmed: “It’s a tougher journey because the Ghost of Christmas Past is a really hard nut to crack.”

“The Ghost of Christmas Past is jaded,” the character description offers. “He’s been sent to make lost souls repent before, why should Scrooge be any different? He prods and pokes where it hurts, transforming himself into those known to his charge, finding a place of pain, shame and self-knowledge. But can he get Scrooge to recognize himself, and repent?”

3. The Ghost of Christmas Present Has a Much More Personal Relationship With Scrooge

A CHRISTMAS CAROL -- Pictured: Charlotte Riley as Lottie/Ghost of Christmas Present. CR: Robert Viglasky/FX
(Photo by Robert Viglasky/FX)

Charlotte Riley appears as the Ghost of Christmas Present, while Jason Flemyng is the Ghost of Christmas Future. Both ghosts are updated here with new twists on the characters.

“She plays my sister who has died some years before,” Pearce said, “and she has now come back as the Ghost of Christmas Present. And — particularly after the ruthlessness of Andy Serkis’ Ghost of Christmas Past, who shape-shifts into all sorts of characters through my past, and he’s really tough on me — then she comes in as the Ghost of Christmas Present, and it’s my long lost dead sister, so it’s so emotional and so touching and painful. And then it’s capped off with Jason playing sort of ruthless again, but silent like the silent-killer kind of attitude, as the Ghost of Christmas Future.”

4. Steven Knight’s Take Is Indeed Chilling

A CHRISTMAS CAROL -- Pictured: Jason Flemyng as Ghost of Christmas Future. CR: Robert Viglasky/FX
(Photo by Robert Viglasky/FX)

One of the most unsettling features of the new story is how closely it hews to issues — and personalities — we face today, which is a very intentional choice. Serkis said he knew he was in for something special when he heard Knight was attached.

“When I heard that there was another version of Christmas Carol being made, I kind of thought, ‘Wow, OK. Again? Another one?'” he said. “But as soon as I knew that Steven Knight was writing it, I knew that now, ‘This is going to be an interesting take,’ because I knew this was going to be the beginning of a journey into his exploration of Dickens in other stories as well, which is the case.”

Knight and the stars had previously talked about “stripping down” the story, which Serkis expounded on for Rotten Tomatoes.

“When we say ‘stripping down,’ it was more about not getting bogged down in the sort of tropes of a costume drama, Victorian drama, and allowing it to live afresh as a really contemporary piece of writing,” he said. “And therefore, and so, even though you’re what you, of course, allowing the visuals, you do that work, you want to feel that the character is alive and very present and not sort of imagining what it might be like to have been alive in the 19th century. You’re not doing that. You’re actually saying these are people, people are people, and we still have the same issues, problems. We need to unpack the difficulties of the human condition in this, in a very modern way to make this story resonate with a fresh audience.”

5. Serkis’ Costuming Challenge Continues Here Even If He’s Not a CG-Enhanced Character

A CHRISTMAS CAROL -- Pictured: Guy Pearce as Ebenezer Scrooge, Andy Serkis as Ghost of Christmas Past. CR: Robert Viglasky/FX
(Photo by Robert Viglasky/FX)

Serkis, known especially for his CG-enhanced performances like Gollum and Caesar in the Lord of the Rings and Planet of the Apes franchises, faced a different sort of challenge here.

“[The costume] was so heavy. It was like going from the sublime to the ridiculous. I couldn’t possibly have more makeup or costume to bear, but it was great, actually. It was nice to play a character in the flesh, and it was a particularly challenging character, not least because it was like sensory deprivation actually wearing this costume. I had long locks of hair and an additional beard. I had an eye that I couldn’t see out of. I had scars all over my face. I had long nails, so once I got into costume, I was able to kind of get into the character and stay there. I had to.”

To compound his costuming issues, they filmed in summer.

“It was pretty brutal at times,” Serkis said. “I just had to at least take the hat off and get the top layer off as much as I could. But — actor problems.”

A Christmas Carol airs Thursday, December 19 at 7:30 on FX.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Syfy adventure Tubi transformers ESPN Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Elton John CBS All Access sitcom game show Women's History Month zombie Cartoon Network Polls and Games PaleyFest Rocketman Mary Tyler Moore CMT Hallmark Sundance TV 24 frames Oscars HBO foreign harry potter elevated horror LGBT Anna Paquin Ovation Musical 2016 Netflix Christmas movies Lifetime Binge Guide Animation spy thriller PBS Pirates TV renewals slashers Stephen King screen actors guild First Reviews BET Awards 71st Emmy Awards cinemax Emmys Amazon spain toy story Apple TV+ Biopics discovery halloween Emmy Nominations Warner Bros. DC Universe latino HBO Go Opinion Horror NBC Spring TV animated USA Network AMC Martial Arts Toys Universal Baby Yoda Film Festival parents cartoon mission: impossible Schedule adaptation TLC Mystery documentary Winter TV Lucasfilm IFC Paramount TCA Winter 2020 Mary poppins The Walking Dead GIFs Britbox DirecTV Spectrum Originals spanish language thriller anime Red Carpet aliens Avengers Walt Disney Pictures Acorn TV Rocky TV Land FOX 2020 ABC Family medical drama Reality Competition Disney Channel Sneak Peek television WGN Watching Series crime Pet Sematary Bravo E! Holiday independent political drama cops romantic comedy GoT Esquire OneApp YouTube Red spider-man Apple PlayStation disaster Television Critics Association MCU Pop Disney streaming service Podcast Tumblr Marvel Television Amazon Studios 007 The Arrangement President Mudbound hispanic IFC Films TCA TruTV award winner Ghostbusters GLAAD DC Comics DC streaming service dramedy 2018 Rock comedies indie Black History Month concert Shudder ratings BET binge Reality Black Mirror FX Apple TV Plus FX on Hulu singing competition Turner Classic Movies Turner technology Sony Pictures New York Comic Con Quiz RT History Shondaland true crime Ellie Kemper Fantasy reviews news nature crime drama Television Academy 4/20 RT21 20th Century Fox TCM docudrama universal monsters YA TIFF 2017 talk show Cannes TCA 2017 Song of Ice and Fire directors Freeform Fall TV all-time Chernobyl facebook Disney+ Disney Plus American Society of Cinematographers free movies Marathons comic Premiere Dates documentaries dogs Captain marvel 2019 CBS Holidays Mindy Kaling blaxploitation VICE Netflix jamie lee curtis Hear Us Out TNT Paramount Network Set visit Lifetime Christmas movies dc teaser revenge Action Star Wars Creative Arts Emmys cooking Heroines criterion crossover Columbia Pictures Discovery Channel Starz Trivia Dark Horse Comics 21st Century Fox canceled TV shows child's play Video Games Brie Larson Vudu SXSW breaking bad robots batman Classic Film space Certified Fresh zombies Year in Review cancelled TV shows Infographic casting Calendar Character Guide Crunchyroll crime thriller psychological thriller Comics on TV OWN cats vampires stand-up comedy Interview witnail History what to watch canceled scary movies Masterpiece 45 reboot Election Hallmark Christmas movies franchise politics USA christmas movies Epix composers Tarantino south america book golden globes Spike Travel Channel social media Thanksgiving theme song 2015 Logo Pixar VH1 cars Arrowverse Crackle hist DGA miniseries Endgame Nickelodeon streaming mutant comiccon Drama chucky video on demand ITV quibi Showtime serial killer cancelled TV series screenings Comic Book First Look Peacock VOD YouTube satire series BBC America movie die hard The CW war CNN kids Teen richard e. Grant Lionsgate a nightmare on elm street Amazon Prime Funimation Disney stoner Best and Worst supernatural BBC One green book Sundance Now TCA Awards sag awards romance Nat Geo boxoffice historical drama SDCC cancelled television science fiction Grammys anthology Trailer Mary Poppins Returns finale based on movie Marvel versus werewolf best FXX travel Fox News Superheroe critics police drama NYCC spinoff WarnerMedia SundanceTV Music indiana jones YouTube Premium tv talk Superheroes dragons APB BAFTA doctor who Winners TV Western psycho unscripted justice league blockbuster Christmas Countdown MTV strong female leads movies children's TV video Comedy Family The Purge twilight sports cancelled Marvel Studios asian-american HBO Max Academy Awards Valentine's Day Trophy Talk Tomatazos festivals rotten movies we love A&E Hulu Musicals LGBTQ Food Network sequel Film MSNBC game of thrones Amazon Prime Video El Rey The Witch Cosplay zero dark thirty Kids & Family Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Awards Tour TBS Adult Swim National Geographic BBC A24 Comedy Central ghosts Country joker ABC See It Skip It San Diego Comic-Con Summer comics films period drama Awards Sci-Fi Sundance mockumentary Nominations Extras Box Office Photos Rom-Com cults biography diversity dceu CW Seed E3 Pride Month Super Bowl Star Trek Writers Guild of America dark renewed TV shows name the review X-Men Pop TV natural history Disney Plus