News

Hamilton First Reviews: Better than a Front-Row Seat

Critics say the filmed version of Lin-Manuel Miranda's Broadway sensation lives up to the hype and captures what makes the stage production so compelling.

by | June 30, 2020 | Comments

With this week’s news that Broadway will remain shuttered through the year, Disney’s presentation of Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Hamilton couldn’t be more essential. The filmed version of the stage show, documented from a few performances by the mostly original cast in 2016, arrives on Disney+ this Fourth of July weekend, allowing fans and newbies alike a chance to see the musical phenomenon in the comfort of their own homes. Of course, critics are happy to recommend this next best thing to the live production, whether they’d seen it before or are finally getting a first taste themselves. Some are even saying this is the film we need right now.

Here’s what critics are saying about Hamilton:


Does the film do the live show justice?

Hamilton on streaming… reveals once again the brilliance at its core — and confirms it as foundational myth worth treasuring time and time again.
– Angie Han, Mashable

[It] captures the widely-beloved show’s infectious vigor and electrical charge, spinning it into a renewed powerful, affecting, and immersive experience.
– Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

The filmed version of the Broadway sensation makes for immersive, exhilarating, magnificent cinema.
– Richard Roeper, Chicago Sun-Times

[It] is the greatest translation, democratization and preservation of any Broadway show, ever.
– Chris Jones, Chicago Tribune

The film adaptation is a marvelous and welcome addition to the show’s legacy in spite of a few imperfections.
– Linda Holmes, NPR

Hamilton is as monumental a thing as ever.
– David Ehrlich, IndieWire


Lin-Manuel Miranda in Hamilton
(Photo by ©Disney+)

How is it for those who have seen the show before?

Absolutely, positively, there is new insight and new excitement here for people who already know that they love this show.
Linda Holmes, NPR

Experiencing the complete production on film for the first time, I was affected by parts of it more piercingly than ever before.
David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

Hamilton‘s biggest show-stopping numbers are just as impactful on the small screen.
Brent Hankins, The Lamplight Review

For those who have seen the show live, the biggest added value here is the expanded revelation of the vulnerability displayed by the actors.
Chris Jones, Chicago Tribune


Does it live up to the hype for the first-timers?

Against all odds, lives up to its hype. Breaking news, I know. But… I’d convinced myself that Hamilton couldn’t be nearly as good as the rest of the world was proclaiming.
Sean O’Connell, CinemaBlend

For those of us who have never seen the stage show… it’s a particular pleasure to be figuratively ushered into the live Richard Rodgers Theater audience.
Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

For those who do get to experience Hamilton for the first time with the original cast, you really couldn’t have a better experience.
Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

The lone time I – as a newbie – felt ever so slightly removed from this live show’s fanfare is when the die-hards in the audience audibly chuckle at King George III’s first appearance.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction


Leslie Odom Jr. in Hamilton
(Photo by ©Disney+)

Which performances stand out most in this version?

Audiences seeing this cast for the first time will be bowled over by the depth of the performances, notably so with Leslie Odom Jr. as Aaron Burr.
David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

It’s Leslie Odom Jr., who plays the antagonist Aaron Burr, who emerges as the great emotional force of the film.
Chris Jones, Chicago Tribune

Arguably its most humane, deeply felt performance is by Leslie Odom, Jr. playing Aaron Burr.
Linda Holmes, NPR

Daveed Diggs shines while pulling double-duty as both Marquis de Lafayette and Thomas Jefferson.
Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

Phillipa Soo and Renée Elise Goldsberry are superb as the Schuyler sisters.
Thom Geier, The Wrap


How does the filmed format affect the experience?

There’s more gained by harnessing the intimate undercurrents of these numbers with close-ups and medium shots.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

Due to the abundance of long shots and smooth cutting, the intermittent closeups are all the more striking in their intimacy. And sometimes their comedy.
Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

Better than a front-row seat, Kail’s film is just cinematic enough to amplify and accentuate the show’s emotional undertow without messing with the carefulness of its stage direction.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire

[It] emphasizes the individual performances, albeit sometimes at the expense of the show’s staging and choreography… Still, it’s an effective way to capture the show’s emotions, if not its sweep.
Angie Han, Mashable

The camera that’s necessary for a Hamilton movie limits what you can look at… We’re controlled by director Thomas Kail’s eye.
Sean O’Connell, CinemaBlend


Daveed Diggs in Hamilton
(Photo by ©Disney+)

Could this actually be better than seeing it live?

The film also has the advantage of showcasing the stagecraft in ways arguably not even equaled by a front row seat.
David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

The thing that’s so amazing about watching Hamilton on the small screen is that it gives everyone the best seat in the house.
Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

No filmed version could ever be a suitable substitute for a live performance, but… Kail’s movie gets the audience pretty close to the same exhilaration and wonder.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

Even with your sound system turned up, the movie can’t fully convey the raw energy and passionate spirit that no doubt leapt off of the stage during a live Hamilton performance.
Sean O’Connell, CinemaBlend


Does the film have any major issues?

Revisiting Hamilton now, with the benefit of distance, it becomes more possible to see both its flaws and its strengths… I’d forgotten, for instance, the extent to which Angelica, one of the most compelling characters in Act I, is sidelined in Act II.
Angie Han, Mashable

They should’ve just filmed [“Satisfied”], with its tremendous performance by Renée Elise Goldsberry; you lose something here that’s special.
Linda Holmes, NPR


Is Hamilton more relevant than ever right now?

It’s exactly what we need this summer.
Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

This is a show that acquires unique shadings at any given moment, and it might never be more impactful than in America in 2020.
David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

Feels like a time capsule… But the underlying message of the show, its call for inclusivity and for grappling the messier aspects of our American history, has never been more urgent.
Thom Geier, The Wrap

I still hesitate to call Hamilton the film we need right now, partly because it deserves better than boilerplate hype.
Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

Even just half a decade after its debut, Hamilton plays like a fossil imprint of a more optimistic time.
Peter Debruge, Variety

Hamilton in 2020 crashes into Black Lives Matter and comes off less powerful, less revolutionary.
Mark Kennedy, Associated Press


Daveed Diggs, Okieriete Onaodowan, Lin-Manuel Miranda, Leslie Odom Jr., and Anthony Ramos in Hamilton
(Photo by ©Disney+)

How does it feel to be able to watch Hamilton at home?

Watching Hamilton in the comfort of my own home means I get to sing along or dance, which is frowned upon at the theater.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

Home viewers, especially newbies, have a distinct advantage over paying theatergoers: You can stop and rewind for any details or turns of phrase you may have missed.
Thom Geier, The Wrap

I couldn’t stop watching [Daveed Diggs’] entrance as Lafayette in the song “Guns and Ships.” I kept rewinding it.
Linda Holmes, NPR

Theatre geeks inspired by the masterpiece can spend hours breaking it down, then building it back up, hopefully igniting a spark that helps them become the next Lin-Manuel Miranda.
Sean O’Connell, CinemaBlend

This is Hamilton as you always wanted to see it, and it always will be.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire


Hamilton premieres on Disney+ on Friday, July 3.

#1

Hamilton (2020)
98%

#1
Adjusted Score: 106.236%
Critics Consensus: Look around, look around at how beautifully Hamilton shines beyond Broadway - and at how marvelously Thomas Kail captures the stage show's infectious energy.
Synopsis: An unforgettable cinematic stage performance, the filmed version of the original Broadway production of "Hamilton" combines the best elements of... [More]
Directed By: Thomas Kail

Tag Cloud

news Crackle criterion cops spider-man talk show 007 chucky TBS reboot Women's History Month Paramount Network Netflix green book animated rotten movies we love cults cancelled TV shows Valentine's Day Fantasy MSNBC cartoon Emmys 2016 reviews laika all-time ABC superhero Fox News Set visit Mystery Reality Competition breaking bad singing competition nature Comics on TV Turner BET venice dark Infographic Photos Opinion National Geographic TCA Awards canceled Red Carpet remakes stand-up comedy Thanksgiving comic romantic comedy BBC LGBTQ IFC Vudu Pop Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt politics TCM Marvel Studios latino A&E TNT transformers die hard worst TV renewals Tomatazos renewed TV shows Writers Guild of America New York Comic Con Trophy Talk ITV Reality what to watch independent versus Nat Geo stoner The Arrangement Oscars festivals Grammys TCA 2017 DC Comics best Musical Esquire adaptation Brie Larson golden globes VOD facebook Cosplay CBS All Access Classic Film video binge screen actors guild Apple TV+ Avengers Academy Awards Spring TV OneApp space Disney Channel X-Men Sundance Adult Swim TCA Mudbound RT History 72 Emmy Awards Winners thriller Anna Paquin diversity Fall TV Pet Sematary science fiction historical drama screenings Polls and Games foreign Schedule Music DirecTV Rom-Com Apple TV Plus ratings fast and furious CW Seed HBO Max TV Land BET Awards mission: impossible Summer obituary Holiday Tubi batman war satire Netflix Christmas movies elevated horror Chilling Adventures of Sabrina SDCC Sundance Now zero dark thirty social media Tumblr period drama Pirates witnail medical drama Extras Calendar FXX Comic Book Super Bowl sequel Food Network emmy awards USA Toys 20th Century Fox Paramount VH1 crossover halloween Rocky romance Stephen King comiccon indiana jones cats sports Cannes cinemax Horror richard e. Grant composers films comedies television revenge San Diego Comic-Con GoT psycho child's play 4/20 Nickelodeon finale rotten award winner Awards Tour FX Biopics Ovation TIFF streaming Watching Series Lionsgate Chernobyl Christmas Amazon Prime Video SXSW toy story Superheroe stop motion ABC Family Hallmark Christmas movies supernatural adventure discovery NYCC Star Trek 2015 The Witch canceled TV shows biography spanish language RT21 Universal PBS a nightmare on elm street joker WGN crime drama ghosts Binge Guide Nominations 2020 Travel Channel disaster Trailer Logo scorecard anthology serial killer AMC Crunchyroll toronto free movies Trivia Year in Review game of thrones BAFTA based on movie BBC One Britbox APB spy thriller natural history Interview Country MTV Sci-Fi 2019 spain Apple kids YouTube Red psychological thriller critics Pixar HBO Certified Fresh Arrowverse Star Wars FOX concert theme song mutant Premiere Dates worst movies Freeform dceu Lucasfilm Disney Plus blockbuster Syfy Lifetime Christmas movies Shondaland franchise Mary poppins TV cooking MCU Mindy Kaling Musicals The Purge TLC christmas movies Holidays Emmy Nominations Disney+ Disney Plus A24 YA NBC Cartoon Network mockumentary dc Quiz Creative Arts Emmys Action Black Mirror Spectrum Originals Mary Tyler Moore children's TV sag awards The Walking Dead GIFs Amazon Sony Pictures 2018 Dark Horse Comics Election See It Skip It indie Comedy Central football OWN Marvel FX on Hulu Peacock Turner Classic Movies video on demand Hallmark spinoff travel USA Network VICE Showtime Ghostbusters Shudder First Look justice league tv talk slashers technology political drama IFC Films series BBC America Black History Month doctor who movie scary movies CNN Disney streaming service YouTube Film Festival Western 24 frames blaxploitation nbcuniversal Television Critics Association Sundance TV El Rey Heroines Rock SundanceTV hispanic twilight TruTV 45 Television Academy ESPN Podcast Acorn TV Superheroes festival Columbia Pictures hollywood aliens Countdown zombie Song of Ice and Fire robots casting Kids & Family Box Office GLAAD President asian-american DC Universe Masterpiece Family Winter TV Funimation dramedy Amazon Prime name the review dragons police drama E3 Lifetime Walt Disney Pictures documentaries 71st Emmy Awards Spike Tarantino American Society of Cinematographers Baby Yoda LGBT Mary Poppins Returns Ellie Kemper werewolf documentary YouTube Premium sequels Discovery Channel Captain marvel TCA Winter 2020 CMT cancelled TV series Endgame DC streaming service universal monsters Disney Film Character Guide PlayStation Pride Month Best and Worst nfl Hear Us Out Marvel Television quibi strong female leads south america dogs teaser Starz hist 21st Century Fox Rocketman miniseries CBS Elton John comics Bravo jamie lee curtis 2017 HBO Go Epix Animation game show Video Games History DGA Warner Bros. anime Pop TV docudrama true crime Comedy unscripted cars vampires Teen PaleyFest zombies boxoffice Sneak Peek Martial Arts harry potter crime movies directors E! crime thriller Drama cancelled Hulu classics book parents Marathons Amazon Studios cancelled television WarnerMedia First Reviews The CW Awards sitcom