Hear Us Out

Hear Us Out: Without Lost, We Wouldn't Have Game of Thrones

Fifteen years after the expensive, groundbreaking Lost pilot, there's a direct line to the worldwide phenomenon of Game of Thrones.

by | September 20, 2019 | Comments

LOST, (front, l to r): Dominic Monaghan, Matthew Fox, Evangline Lilly, (middle): Josh Holloway, Yun Jin Kim, Daniel Dae Kim, Malcolm David Kelley, Harold Perrineau, (back): Terry O'Quinn, Jorge Garcia, Ian Somerhalder, Maggie Grace, Naveen Andrews, Emilie De Ravin, 2004-2010. photo: Reisig & Taylor/© ABC/Courtesy: Everett Collection
(Photo by Reisig & Taylor/© ABC/Courtesy: Everett Collection)

It’s been 15 years since Oceanic Flight 815 went down. At the time of its premiere, on Sept. 22, 2004, J.J. Abrams‘ iconic series Lost was a major risk for ABC. It was expensive, it was long, and it left plenty of questions about the group of plane crash survivors who landed on a mysterious island. Now, it’s clear that Lost didn’t just change the way audiences watched television — it forever altered the way TV shows are created.

The show’s epic pilot showed audiences and networks alike just what type of stories can be told in primetime. Up until that point, procedural staples (like CSI, Law & Order, or House) and multi-camera sitcoms (think Two and a Half Men and Will & Grace) were the go-to styles of programming. But Lost presented a plethora of deep concepts in a story format mostly unseen by television audiences. On the surface, it was a primetime soap opera about a diverse group of castaways as they fought for survival after a violent plane crash. But underneath that was a layered exploration of the human condition — with the concepts of free will, good vs. evil, and faith regularly playing an important part in this deeply mythologized journey.

It was the beginning of a Mystery Box trend in programming, all thanks to Abrams’ vision and ace showrunners Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse. And once it all caught on — Lost was the first program with an official TV podcast, its showrunners broke down episodic details weekly, TV recappers wrote thesis-length investigations into each episode, and internet chat forums became a hotbed for fan theories — the demand for more high-concept programming set in.

LOST, Matthew Fox, Emilie De Ravin, Jorge Garcia, 'Pilot', (Season 1, epis. #101), 2004-2010. photo: Mario Perez/© ABC/Courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by Mario Perez/© ABC/Courtesy Everett Collection)

TV budgets blossomed, production quality became cinematic, and, almost overnight, serialized narratives began popping up in plenty of small-screen stories. Seven years after Lost premiered, and one year after its polarizing series finale, another ambitious program hit television: Game of Thrones.

While there are stark differences between the two programs, one can easily draw a straight line from Lost to Game of Thrones.

Hear us out: Yes, George R.R. Martin’s books existed long before the series even entered development at HBO. Lost, on the other hand, was cobbled together in such a haphazard manner that its success was baffling to Lindelof and ABC. The channel had been struggling for a hit and, after network exec Lloyd Braun watched the Tom Hanks movie Cast Away, he had an idea.

“What if there was a plane that crashed and a dozen people survived, and nobody knew each other,” Braun told Grantland. “Your past was almost irrelevant. You could reinvent who you were. You had to figure out — how do you survive? What do you use for shelter, for water? Is it like Lord of the Flies? How do we get off the island, how do you get home? And I start to get very excited about the idea, and I start thinking about the title Lost.”

LOST, Harold Perrineau, Malcolm David Kelley, 'Tabula Rasa', (season 1), 2004-2010. photo: Mario Perez/© ABC/Courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by Mario Perez/© ABC/Courtesy Everett Collection)

Lost‘s two-part pilot came with a reported price tag of $13 million, the most expensive of any TV episode at that time. Combine that high cost with how the ongoing story was told, processed, regurgitated, and theorized, and the only other program in recent memory to capture the same caliber of attention was Game of Thrones. Swap out the Dharma Initiative, the Smoke Monster, and the Others with White Walkers, dragons, and the Dothraki and the similarities become clearer. There’s also the fact that every episode in GoT‘s final season cost $15 million apiece. It cost HBO about $10 million to produce each episode in the show’s previous two seasons. That’s pretty crazy when you think about the budgetary restrictions television producers had to work with just a decade ago.

Lost featured an ensemble of mostly unknown actors who were cast without a finalized script (which is a head-scratch–worthy detail unto itself). But the characters were instantly iconic and their International diversity became an important component to the story being told as well as the representation it provided for the global audience with which the series ended up connecting. Charlie (Dominic Monaghan) was British, Claire (Emilie de Ravin) was from Australia, Mr. Eko (Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje) was Nigerian, Sun (Yunjin Kim) and Jin (Daniel Dae Kim) were from South Korea, Desmond (Henry Ian Cusick) was Scottish, and let’s not forget the former Iraqi Republican Guard member, Sayid Jarrah (Naveen Andrews).

The diverse nature of the cast not only appealed to a global fandom, the characters helped break down preconceived notions regarding citizens from certain parts of the world.

LOST, Naveen Andrews, Evangeline Lilly, (Season 1), 2004-2010. photo: © ABC/Courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by © ABC/Courtesy Everett Collection)

While the majority of Game of Thrones‘ cast may be white (and British), there is a similarity here in the sense that both shows gave their actors celebrity status the world over. Going from barely getting recognized to packing Hall H at Comic-Con is a feat worth recognition.

The cinematic style of Lost also put ABC in a spot it wasn’t expecting to be in. Suddenly the network, which boasted plenty of reality programs and game shows, was competing with premium cable entertainment like The Sopranos or The Wire. It was a high concept risk that almost never saw the light of day, and once it did ABC scrambled to bring in Lindelof and Cuse to keep the show afloat.

Before HBO offered its own standalone streaming service, and before Hulu was a word that even existed, ABC made new episodes of Lost available to watch on its website just one day after broadcast. This type of digital availability of programming wasn’t something audiences or networks were used to. But ABC experimented with this early business model. Two years later, Hulu took that baton and ran with it.

LOST, Matthew Fox, Evangeline Lilly, 'All The Best Cowboys Have Daddy Issues', (Season 1, epis. #111), 2004-2010. Photo: Mario Perez/ABC/Courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by Mario Perez/ABC/Courtesy Everett Collection)

This wasn’t the only way Lost engaged with its audience. In 2005, as free episodes became available to watch online, the network invested its time in a new means of storytelling: the podcast. With Cuse and Lindelof regularly appearing on the “Official Lost Podcast,” along with members of the cast, to provide insight to the drama and mysteries as they unfolded, a new means of engaging with fans was born. Lost premiered during a time when Facebook and MySpace were the social networks of choice. The iTunes Store was in its infancy, and it would be a few more years before Twitter launched (and Game of Thrones fans would subsequently harness the platform to discuss episodes in real time). And yet the character drama, intricate puzzles, and island mythology that unfolded on ABC’s groundbreaking series connected with audiences on a level unlike ever before.

Lindelof and Cuse (or Darlton, as the internet began to call them), helped start the trend of putting showrunners in the spotlight. Before Lost, viewers weren’t granted such a peek behind the proverbial curtain. D.B. Weiss and David Benioff became the faces of Game of Thrones like Lindelof and Cuse before them. The actors were no longer the only celebrities in the room.

ABC broke ground with Lost, giving us an odd string of numbers, a mysterious hatch, and an island full of possibilities to ponder week in and week out. It was an existential story that plucked heartstrings and inspired wonder. This layered exploration of life vs. death and good vs. evil captured the imaginations of audiences and content creators alike. Once Lost ended, HBO took the mantel with Game of Thrones, further breaking down the barrier of what is possible to achieve on the small screen.


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

El Rey doctor who Film Festival series Calendar Sci-Fi RT History FX independent Ghostbusters Brie Larson Comedy Central Western singing competition Disney+ Disney Plus Opinion comic blaxploitation History Winners Pirates psychological thriller psycho Cannes cooking WGN Toys Teen Rock spanish language Rocketman reboot Fox News Awards Tour Year in Review Starz free movies Grammys National Geographic finale ratings movies Sundance Now Reality Competition RT21 Thanksgiving New York Comic Con Comic Book First Reviews casting canceled TLC Animation 2017 DC Universe Musicals Fantasy Logo Hulu E3 Tomatazos American Society of Cinematographers Mystery AMC Showtime Disney Warner Bros. politics Rocky sequel composers Food Network docudrama MSNBC Columbia Pictures Countdown Cosplay unscripted theme song 24 frames crime animated dogs comiccon Character Guide streaming Song of Ice and Fire Watching Series game of thrones natural history Nat Geo Winter TV Amazon Studios science fiction E! Superheroe IFC Films dragons Disney streaming service LGBTQ Tumblr romantic comedy space rotten movies we love TCA Winter 2020 Writers Guild of America spy thriller serial killer First Look Mudbound FOX boxoffice mutant Nominations Sony Pictures vampires GLAAD Fall TV joker The Purge Film Sneak Peek Spring TV Superheroes Pop Turner Classic Movies Comedy teaser 007 period drama Red Carpet Women's History Month Sundance Marvel Studios 2020 war Captain marvel Universal canceled TV shows Baby Yoda CBS All Access sports MTV award winner Apple TV+ zero dark thirty Musical historical drama crime drama zombie Kids & Family supernatural breaking bad CBS Extras Sundance TV Oscars revenge Syfy TIFF police drama USA cancelled TV series Dark Horse Comics toy story TV renewals APB Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt talk show Marvel Television Infographic OWN TCA Marvel Lifetime Christmas movies what to watch cancelled television Amazon Prime cancelled TV shows DC streaming service YouTube Election Pet Sematary Trophy Talk name the review Crackle YouTube Red IFC technology President Anna Paquin dc crossover Action The Witch batman harry potter USA Network christmas movies Ovation book festivals TCM jamie lee curtis Binge Guide 20th Century Fox ghosts cancelled Amazon Prime Video adaptation Nickelodeon Polls and Games TruTV Video Games zombies VICE Mary Poppins Returns Drama The Arrangement Certified Fresh quibi documentary versus Cartoon Network Disney Plus aliens GoT facebook Lucasfilm nature cars Shondaland directors SDCC spinoff Pixar Endgame renewed TV shows kids Emmys CNN CW Seed spain witnail slashers LGBT Holiday anime Hallmark Christmas movies PBS latino Britbox OneApp romance Marathons Awards 71st Emmy Awards crime thriller cats Quiz video social media Summer television travel Black Mirror blockbuster Masterpiece Mary Tyler Moore Mindy Kaling TBS Stephen King cops YouTube Premium Netflix Christmas movies VH1 Horror ITV Comics on TV Box Office Martial Arts Interview The Walking Dead Biopics justice league Pride Month A&E biography 2019 NYCC richard e. Grant Holidays ABC Family cinemax Paramount south america 2015 HBO Max foreign YA Super Bowl DirecTV disaster robots sag awards TNT mockumentary Spectrum Originals HBO spider-man movie Valentine's Day based on movie SundanceTV Ellie Kemper children's TV Paramount Network Podcast NBC PaleyFest DGA DC Comics Peacock Hallmark Elton John TV Esquire Avengers Disney Channel The CW Chernobyl thriller indie Premiere Dates Shudder BBC America FXX elevated horror Crunchyroll medical drama Star Wars halloween binge Tarantino SXSW A24 miniseries dramedy sitcom comics cartoon San Diego Comic-Con Turner Heroines Freeform Lionsgate true crime Netflix discovery Adult Swim Apple TV Plus screenings cults Arrowverse Walt Disney Pictures MCU tv talk 21st Century Fox Epix Christmas Music BBC TCA 2017 ESPN werewolf Amazon Schedule Photos Mary poppins 45 anthology hispanic Discovery Channel Television Academy Set visit Lifetime X-Men Rom-Com Acorn TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Bravo political drama Reality See It Skip It golden globes screen actors guild game show Country Academy Awards Emmy Nominations GIFs strong female leads Spike BET 2018 Best and Worst Star Trek adventure 2016 Apple transformers Creative Arts Emmys Trailer dceu ABC Family Tubi CMT Classic Film diversity green book Vudu stand-up comedy WarnerMedia Trivia hist TV Land