How Mystery Men Planted the Seeds for the MCU Template

On its 20th anniversary, we look back at how the goofy superhero comedy unknowingly paved the way for the future and why it remains so memorable.

by | August 6, 2019 | Comments

Although the opening shot of 1999’s Mystery Men is pure DC Cinematic Universe – the strange semi-futuristic cityscape that echoes Tim Burton’s Batman, the worshipful but also terrifying statue of local hero Captain Amazing that feels straight out of Zack Snyder’s world – what follows actually lays out a template for what would eventually be Marvel’s complete and utter dominance in the superhero movie space.

Two movies that were released just prior to Mystery MenBlade in 1998 and The Matrix in March 1999 – are most often credited with kickstarting the comic book movie revival. The Wachowskis’ anime-inspired sci-fi blockbuster showed how super-powered action could and should look, while Wesley Snipes’ vampire crusader proved you could find success beyond Marvel’s A-list roster. But looking back, neither of those films really fit tonally with what the MCU would become. The real seeds were planted in a silly and underrated Ben Stiller comedy that celebrates its 20th birthday on August 6. Here’s how.

The Cast

One of the hallmarks of Marvel movies is that they are littered with big and unexpected names, from Gwyneth Paltrow in Iron Man to Robert Redford in Captain America: The Winter Soldier to Matt Damon in Thor: Ragnarok. For a superhero goof, Mystery Men shared similar out-of-the-box thinking, resulting in even the smaller roles being surprisingly memorable. The main team was comprised of an Avengers-level mix of mid- to late-’90s indie and comedy stars, including Stiller, Janeane Garofalo, William H. Macy, Hank Azaria, and Paul Reubens; the main villain was a supremely hammy Oscar-winner Geoffrey Rush, and the periphery was dotted with “whoa, really” names like Eddie Izzard, Ricky Jay, Cee-Lo Green, Dane Cook, and Tom Waits. Superhero movies had come a long way from a time when they were the last refuge of stuntmen and up-and-comers, and Mystery Men took the baton from Tim Burton (who went way outside the box with Michael Keaton in Batman) and ran with it for a bit before Marvel took over.

The World Building

Universal courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by Universal courtesy Everett Collection)

Although Iron Man and Captain America: The First Avenger hit some of the expected story points, by and large Marvel got away from doing traditional origin stories. Rather than having each new hero start off in a blank slate world where they’re the only ones with superpowers, Marvel built a world where multiple heroes and villains existed in various points throughout history. Mystery Men, too, drops you right into the thick of it with a superteam fighting supervillains in a city that is so comfortable with its own Superman that he has corporate sponsors.

There is a sequence about midway through the movie in which the Mystery Men hold open tryouts (a gag that would be recycled in Deadpool 2), and they are swarmed with wannabes. This is a world as used to seeing this sort of thing as the people of MCU New York are to seeing Spider-Man.

The Humor

Naturally, Mystery Men was never intended to be anything but a superhero spoof. But its willingness to embrace the core silliness of the superhero concept helped show Marvel how to overcome a major obstacle. The knock against the DC movies is that they are dark, plodding, largely humorless affairs. And if you start to take the idea of people in fancy suits flying around cities too seriously, the whole thing begins to falls apart. The self-awareness to know that humor makes comic book storytelling go down a lot easier fuels Marvel even at its darkest. Avengers: Infinity War or Avengers: Endgame would have been too much to take without the relief supplied by Dr. Strange and Tony Stark’s catty bickering, or Korg’s epic Fornite battle against Noobmaster69.

The Team Dynamics

And speaking of the bickering… A team of noble heroes who all share an unshakable respect for one another, and who treat each other with courtesy and dignity at all times… is boring. Like Mystery Men, Marvel understands that teams like the Avengers or the Guardians of the Galaxy thrive when they don’t get along. Likewise, the Mystery Men treat each other more like co-workers than real friends. Post-battle, they sit in diners and complain like they just clocked out of a factory job (and coincidentally, the original Avengers ends with… the team sitting around in a diner eating).

The (Lack of) Secret Identities

MCA courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by MCA courtesy Everett Collection)

This is an extension of the world-building idea, but it’s no coincidence that Marvel ditched the concept of “secret identities” as soon as it could. It’s a hindrance more than it is a help – watch how they bend over backwards to get Tony Stark fighting helmetless, or how many times Captain America takes his mask off so you can see his face. Mystery Men doesn’t even bother with masking its heroes. They exist in a world that’s gotten used to the idea of superheroes, just as the MCU seems to be pretty OK with one of the world’s most successful tech billionaires occasionally running off to fight Thanos, and where kids think nothing of asking Hulk for a selfie.

The Balancing Act

MCA courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by MCA courtesy Everett Collection)

In the end, though, Mystery Men still allows its crew of misfit heroes to have their moment. They’ve been the butt of the joke for most of the movie’s runtime, but they’re ultimately still allowed to be heroic and win the day. There’s just enough earnestness there to get away with it – had the movie gone more cynical, it would have piled on the jokes regardless of whether or not anyone saved anything. It’s a delicate balance, and a Marvel entry like Thor: Ragnarok actually feels right in line with it. It never quite tips completely over into out-and-out Thor parody, though it comes close. But Marvel had, by that point, settled so comfortably into a tone that both celebrates and pokes fun at the concept of superheroes that it all managed to work.

And who would have thought it would be the Mystery Men who’d light the way?

Mystery Men was released in theaters on August 6, 1999.


Mystery Men (1999)

Adjusted Score: 64.307%
Critics Consensus: Absurd characters and quirky gags are brought to life by a talented cast, providing this superhero spoof with lots of laughs.
Synopsis: Based on the Dark Horse comic, Mystery Men. Seven lame superhero wannabes, who are called upon to use their dubious... [More]
Directed By: Kinka Usher

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Trivia Bravo YouTube Red Nat Geo Action cooking Cartoon Network CNN festivals nature ghosts Lifetime TruTV SXSW war kids Paramount Network DirecTV Mary poppins GIFs BBC Valentine's Day diversity PBS award winner YA History Mindy Kaling DC Universe SundanceTV Rocky Animation Stephen King Spectrum Originals green book Thanksgiving historical drama TNT Mary Tyler Moore Polls and Games HBO spain Amazon Sony Pictures NYCC Character Guide boxoffice cancelled VH1 Logo See It Skip It Writers Guild of America revenge Spike blaxploitation elevated horror Lucasfilm joker tv talk Grammys Oscars Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Marvel Awards Peacock Trophy Talk The Witch 2016 Year in Review TBS Fall TV zombie Heroines Women's History Month CBS Captain marvel richard e. Grant zombies Schedule Netflix Anna Paquin halloween Television Academy X-Men ratings Holidays Marathons Chernobyl Amazon Prime USA Song of Ice and Fire Mystery Arrowverse cancelled television doctor who cinemax BET finale GLAAD spinoff IFC Films Shudder 21st Century Fox Disney Plus 71st Emmy Awards Opinion Ellie Kemper Musicals adventure Pet Sematary Music TCM Interview hist science fiction Paramount Winners sequel police drama TV Crackle Rocketman batman Western USA Network Brie Larson 24 frames talk show mockumentary 2019 National Geographic free movies Pride Month Film Pop San Diego Comic-Con cults Musical politics Photos Awards Tour Shondaland Pirates Lionsgate disaster Apple psycho SDCC First Reviews LGBTQ television toy story social media WGN space Nickelodeon CBS All Access MTV 007 NBC dceu Cannes Video Games Teen FOX Kids & Family Syfy Comedy canceled TV shows supernatural Summer unscripted Comics on TV harry potter theme song Disney docudrama TCA Rock Columbia Pictures Masterpiece sitcom Reality 45 BBC America anime justice league teaser Rom-Com Emmy Nominations game show TV Land canceled stand-up comedy slashers Tomatazos ABC Family GoT zero dark thirty MCU anthology Fox News technology Starz Mary Poppins Returns cops Ghostbusters mutant The Arrangement political drama Spring TV Superheroe Warner Bros. CW Seed renewed TV shows DC Comics spy thriller Universal facebook Sundance Now Infographic The CW quibi Disney Channel Amazon Prime Video FX casting singing competition Food Network YouTube Adult Swim Emmys thriller First Look Film Festival Comedy Central HBO Max APB IFC Red Carpet Watching Series sports The Walking Dead YouTube Premium Podcast Disney streaming service Ovation New York Comic Con E3 Country animated Creative Arts Emmys dramedy cars Freeform RT21 psychological thriller movies dc ABC vampires Biopics crime thriller Black Mirror Super Bowl medical drama Certified Fresh natural history Toys VICE golden globes romance comic video Superheroes binge series Drama Countdown cancelled TV series Box Office A&E Nominations Extras Martial Arts latino DGA crime serial killer Binge Guide TIFF spider-man MSNBC ESPN Sci-Fi what to watch Star Trek Winter TV Best and Worst Vudu PaleyFest Elton John biography DC streaming service Showtime cats Fantasy 2017 Esquire Hulu adaptation TCA 2017 composers Set visit Britbox CMT streaming book based on movie E! ITV Tarantino game of thrones Mudbound Calendar witnail Premiere Dates 20th Century Fox OWN Epix Trailer President Cosplay Sneak Peek Acorn TV Apple TV+ foreign TV renewals travel discovery period drama Pixar American Society of Cinematographers crime drama Star Wars Quiz spanish language south america cancelled TV shows hispanic crossover miniseries FXX RT History TLC children's TV 2015 WarnerMedia Christmas 2018 Horror Sundance robots Family Election aliens Tumblr Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt jamie lee curtis comiccon transformers AMC El Rey strong female leads LGBT Walt Disney Pictures dragons true crime Comic Book Reality Competition Dark Horse Comics