Critics Consensus

Incredibles 2 Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Tag is mildly entertaining and Superfly is more style than substance.

by | June 14, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have a belated sequel to a Pixar classic (Incredibles 2, featuring the voices of Holly Hunter and Craig T. Nelson), some of Hollywood’s funniest fellows trying to touch one another without permission (Tag, starring Ed HelmsJeremy Renner, and Jon Hamm), and a remade blast from the blaxploitation past (Superfly, starring Trevor Jackson and Jason Mitchell). What are the critics saying?


Incredibles 2 (2018) 94%

If you’re going to try and follow up an acclaimed blockbuster, you might as well take your time getting the sequel right — and in animation, where time can stand still forever, you have the added benefit of not needing to rush your cast back in front of the camera. Still, after waiting nearly 15 years for a second installment of The Incredibles, fans can be forgiven a certain amount of impatience; while the creative teams at formerly franchise-averse Pixar dreamed up new stories for the characters in Toy Story, Cars, Finding Nemo, and Monsters Inc., the ability to return to theaters continued to elude the superpowered Parr family. All that waiting has finally paid off with Incredibles 2, which reunites the original voice cast for a new adventure serving up more of the domestic turmoil, superhero satire, and brilliantly animated action that made the first one such a hit. It’d be tough to improve on the original Incredibles, and critics say that while this sequel doesn’t quite pull off that feat, it comes impressively close, adding yet another acclaimed entry to Pixar’s already estimable filmography. If you were a kid when The Incredibles came out, you might have kids of your own now — and like all the best stuff the studio has put out, the whole family can look forward to enjoying Incredibles 2.


Tag (2018) 56%

On one hand, it’s easy to believe Hollywood has long since exhausted most of the reasonable possibilities for comedy that exist in movies about grown men acting like boys. On the other, when you’ve got the Wall Street Journal writing about a real-life group of guys who take a month off every year to continue the game of tag they’ve been playing since they were kids, well, it’s awfully hard to resist the temptation to turn that into a film. Enter the descriptively titled Tag, starring Hannibal Buress, Jon Hamm, Ed Helms, Jake Johnson, and Jeremy Renner as the fellows in question — a talented bunch whose commitment to the story was reflected in the set injury Renner sustained, breaking both of his arms and necessitating some last-minute CGI limb replacements in post-production. It would be wonderful to report that Renner’s suffering came in service of one of the year’s best-reviewed action comedies; alas, the truth is that critics are kinda meh on Tag, which reviews describe as funny and engaging in fits and starts, but ultimately not consistent or committed enough to fully deliver on its premise. Still, this is one talented cast, and even the critical pans say the movie isn’t without its moments, so if you’re in the mood for some arrested development laughs, you may want to check your local listings.


Superfly (2018) 48%

Released in 1972, the original Superfly helped lead the blaxploitation wave with a thoughtful Harlem-set drama about a drug dealer looking for one last big score; the movie’s trappings may look somewhat dated today, but thanks to Ron O’Neal‘s performance as main character Youngblood Priest — not to mention a killer Curtis Mayfield soundtrack — it still feels fresh. It’s easy to understand why music video veteran Director X wanted to take a shot at updating the story, and its themes are just as relevant as they were more than 45 years ago; unfortunately, critics say those themes have mostly been lost in this new version, which is far more focused on style than substance. Starring Trevor Jackson as Priest, the 2018 edition moves the action to Atlanta, but the basic contours of the story remain the same — which is part of why a number of reviews have outlined pundits’ disappointment with the lost social subtext. This Superfly will make its fortune by and by, thanks to Director X’s way with an artfully arranged scene or set piece, but as is so often the case with remakes, the original still reigns supreme.


What’s New on TV

The Bold Type: Season 2 (2018) 100%

The Bold Type presents an aspirational yet refreshingly realistic portrait of young women’s careers, friendships and love lives in a big city.


Strange Angel: Season 1 (2018) 75%

A beautiful slow burn, Strange Angel shoots for the stars, but gets a little lost in its own orbit.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

SDCC American Society of Cinematographers Pirates based on movie 2019 TLC 24 frames E! anime ratings Rock BBC Comic Book Marvel Masterpiece Drama Super Bowl Trophy Talk Watching Series Photos E3 TCM hist GoT politics composers CNN Opinion Lionsgate DC Universe VH1 LGBTQ Disney Countdown 20th Century Fox Starz The CW Animation Winter TV CW Seed BBC America Holidays Reality Competition Rocky Summer Bravo singing competition APB Star Wars BET zombies Premiere Dates Grammys Nominations Interview TV Land USA Network Toys dramedy YouTube Red aliens A&E science fiction Martial Arts Character Guide dc WGN Comics on TV GIFs talk show Logo GLAAD HBO 2018 social media romance Superheroe National Geographic zombie discovery sitcom OWN Teen Emmys crossover Calendar Food Network travel psycho Awards Tour CBS All Access Set visit period drama Shudder YA justice league FX Valentine's Day Warner Bros. cats First Look TBS Biopics supernatural Awards Thanksgiving cults green book MSNBC Mary Poppins Returns Kids & Family Reality Pop cinemax 21st Century Fox Paramount Network Musicals mutant NYCC Universal unscripted Mary poppins DC streaming service Lucasfilm crime thriller Esquire VICE RT History 2015 doctor who ABC Family Podcast Ellie Kemper Nickelodeon 45 FXX historical drama Cosplay golden globes Dark Horse Comics boxoffice Sundance Now Marathons Mindy Kaling Action NBC Ovation IFC sports FOX Apple Showtime spider-man Oscars SundanceTV DirecTV dceu war Rom-Com History TIFF Pixar Nat Geo Polls and Games Syfy adventure TV Lifetime police drama Columbia Pictures Country Western Freeform spy thriller technology 2016 crime drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt political drama Ghostbusters Netflix Quiz robots MTV Acorn TV SXSW Horror comic Mystery Trivia Video Games Election Musical serial killer Red Carpet Fox News New York Comic Con crime IFC Films Sci-Fi Song of Ice and Fire Year in Review Spring TV television transformers 007 Comedy Tomatazos CBS CMT award winner Christmas Sneak Peek Tumblr Crackle Sundance El Rey festivals blaxploitation Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Star Trek Best and Worst Adult Swim vampires Mary Tyler Moore Schedule Infographic See It Skip It Sony Pictures Paramount TCA 2017 Spike Disney Channel USA ITV biography Box Office 2017 Creative Arts Emmys Extras AMC streaming thriller Music Winners Cartoon Network X-Men Fall TV Shondaland TNT President cops YouTube Premium diversity Writers Guild of America Britbox Comedy Central jamie lee curtis Certified Fresh TCA binge Walt Disney Pictures what to watch PaleyFest DC Comics San Diego Comic-Con medical drama Epix PBS TruTV Trailer The Arrangement comiccon Amazon Superheroes cooking harry potter Hulu Fantasy docudrama ESPN ABC finale