News

Is mother! a Masterpiece or a Mess? Fans and Critics Sound Off

Check out some of the best reactions to the film, and tell us which side of the fence you're on in our poll.

by | September 18, 2017 | Comments

(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

Moviegoers might not be in agreement about Darren Aronofsky‘s mother!, but polarization is a popular topic for conversation. The new thriller, which stars Jennifer Lawrence and Javier Bardem as a couple dealing with unwanted houseguests in their remote country home, received an F grade from opening night audiences polled by CinemaScore, but not everyone considers it to be a failure.

In fact, while the the 14 releases with an F grade via CinemaScore have an unfortunate average Rotten Tomatoes score of 36%, mother! is on the positive end of the spectrum for the bunch with a 69% Fresh rating from nearly 200 reviews. That’s still a considerable split for critics, while ticket buyers have also been mixed on their reactions.

To see just how divisive this movie is, here are some of the most striking positive and negative comments about the movie from the pros and the fans:


IT’S A MASTERPIECE!

A masterpiece that might make even fans of extreme horror movies wince.
Charles Ealy, Austin American-Statesman

If the sole purpose of art is to create an emotional response, mother! is a masterpiece.
Bryan Bishop, The Verge

An unquestionably brilliant movie.
Jeffrey M. Anderson, Combustible Celluloid

A hugely ambitious, brilliantly made movie.
John Powers, Vogue

It’s a terrific horror movie and the most twisted improv game you’ve ever seen.
Scott Mendelson, Forbes

It’s thrilling to see a major filmmaker and major movie stars explore [these ideas] so boldly and with so little regard for convention.
Eric D. Snider, EricDSnider.com

Something truly magnificent, the kind of visceral arthouse experience that comes along very rarely.
Jessica Kiang, The Playlist

What makes mother! brilliant is that it is open enough to read and project your own experiences onto it, which makes it deeply personal and universal.
Katie Walsh, Tribune News Service

mother! is a brilliant film.
Richard Kelly, director of Donnie Darko

Oh my god I loved mother! — are people talking about how insanely funny it is?
Rian Johnson, director of Looper and Star Wars: The Last Jedi

The most powerful and terrifying film I’ve seen all year. I loved it.
Brian Altano, host/producer for IGN

mother! is a masterpiece no doubt.
Isaiah Thomas, movie fan

mother! was an absolute masterpiece. Hands down one of the best films of this decade.
Zack Perez, movie fan


IT’S A MESS!

I hesitate to label it the ‘Worst movie of the year’ when ‘Worst movie of the century’ fits it even better.
Rex Reed, New York Observer

The movie’s grasp of experience feels tenuous, trippy, and, dare one say, adolescent.
Anthony Lane, The New Yorker

A big WTF yawn.
Dana Barbuto, The Patriot Ledger

A pretentious mess of a film.
Caryn James, BBC.com

It would be difficult to find a filmmaker who has more contempt for his audience.
Michael Heaton, Cleveland Plain Dealer

Aronofsky is giving us the finger as well as an axe to the forehead.
Katherine Monk, Ex-Press.com

May be the vilest movie ever released by a major Hollywood studio.
Kyle Smith, National Review

Makes Black Swan look like The Care Bears Movie. Oy vey!!!!!
– Leonard Maltin, LeonardMaltin.com (via daughter Jessie Maltin)

Pretentious, self-indulgent torture-porn.
Susan Granger, SSG Syndicate

Did we mention this movie is pretentious?
Robert Horton, HeraldNet

A mess.
Jackie K. Cooper, Huffington Post

Just wasted two hours seeing mother! Most nonsensical mess of a film I’ve seen in a long time.
Martha Meyer, movie fan

Straight up, Mother is a mess.
Jacque, movie fan


THE OFFICIAL DEFENSE

Here is Aronofsky’s personal statement (via Fandango) responding to all the negative reactions:

Look, anytime you throw a punch at the audience, there are going to be people who appreciate it and love it and want more. There’s going to be other people that are going to try to hit back. What bums me the most is that people who are reacting negatively are not responding at all to the craftsmanship and to the incredible performances and dedication of my actors, because they’re undeniably great.

It’s funny, those are the same people who also write about how there’s nothing ever new going on in film. Suddenly, you do something really new and some people don’t dig it.

Look, we knew what we were doing. We knew that we were going to get strong reactions. With all that, there’s also people who are writing really beautiful things about the film that are very inspired and mean a lot. I don’t really follow any of that. I just get the vibe. I knew, when we began this project, it was going to be an intense ride for people.

And here is Paramount’s official statement (via president of marketing and distribution Megan Colligan) responding to all the negative reactions:

This movie is very audacious and brave. You are talking about a director at the top of his game, and an actress at the top of her game. They made a movie that was intended to be bold. Everyone wants original filmmaking, and everyone celebrates Netflix when they tell a story no one else wants to tell. This is our version. We don’t want all movies to be safe. And it’s okay if some people don’t like it.


mother! is currently playing everywhere. Which side of the fence are you on?

Tag Cloud

DC Universe Musicals Brie Larson Peacock satire Video Games comiccon crossover TIFF cars name the review comic christmas movies USA Network Music stoner cancelled Comedy Central Ellie Kemper festivals Lucasfilm spanish language science fiction Lifetime Christmas movies Reality werewolf Trivia Sony Pictures IFC Travel Channel First Reviews 2016 sitcom First Look Trailer Biopics Paramount Network BBC Awards Tour canceled TV shows spain Black History Month Apple TV Plus richard e. Grant LGBTQ BBC America Podcast Britbox Musical Marvel OWN latino jamie lee curtis Lifetime Cannes Disney Channel NBC scary movies game show E! Baby Yoda Chernobyl thriller Bravo Mindy Kaling revenge spider-man political drama PaleyFest TV Land 2020 disaster Winners Netflix Christmas movies Polls and Games cults Cosplay adaptation Disney Plus Pet Sematary dc Ovation Song of Ice and Fire aliens Sundance Film cops San Diego Comic-Con romantic comedy LGBT renewed TV shows binge justice league vampires comics documentaries what to watch The Arrangement serial killer Hulu TCA Awards theme song Columbia Pictures ABC Tarantino Tomatazos Walt Disney Pictures Hallmark YouTube Election E3 Crackle indie ABC Family WGN Amazon Prime Video Pride Month ITV Fox News Lionsgate screen actors guild dogs joker MCU boxoffice TCA award winner streaming true crime video on demand Film Festival Ghostbusters batman 2015 toy story Nickelodeon Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Horror Women's History Month New York Comic Con dramedy Spring TV quibi a nightmare on elm street supernatural Mystery GLAAD GIFs spinoff 21st Century Fox social media dragons TV Mudbound 2018 Television Critics Association Cartoon Network Comics on TV Super Bowl Calendar VH1 MTV Tubi foreign parents cinemax AMC mutant robots breaking bad teaser Anna Paquin CW Seed Warner Bros. SundanceTV animated BAFTA psychological thriller BBC One strong female leads Masterpiece Food Network films book doctor who RT History concert south america universal monsters critics President Superheroes TCA Winter 2020 game of thrones Turner Classic Movies CMT talk show Disney movie franchise Nat Geo all-time Thanksgiving MSNBC YA A&E Reality Competition See It Skip It FXX FX reviews docudrama The Purge witnail halloween nature Pop Christmas sequel child's play 2017 Pirates Pop TV best singing competition Countdown politics Classic Film Apple comedies Summer Pixar free movies DC streaming service BET Awards Amazon Prime chucky biography The Walking Dead Grammys Mary Tyler Moore Red Carpet discovery documentary Arrowverse Western Paramount RT21 sports ESPN zombie Comedy 4/20 sag awards independent American Society of Cinematographers Marathons TLC HBO Max indiana jones Crunchyroll TV renewals Endgame Creative Arts Emmys miniseries dceu romance cooking OneApp DirecTV Avengers 45 zombies elevated horror Captain marvel unscripted Valentine's Day diversity Teen GoT TCM hist spy thriller Sundance Now YouTube Premium Toys Spectrum Originals FX on Hulu composers kids Spike Infographic HBO Go Epix Trophy Talk Country green book nbcuniversal Shudder finale 007 WarnerMedia FOX historical drama Black Mirror SDCC Academy Awards cancelled TV shows facebook emmy awards Marvel Television Best and Worst anthology Fantasy medical drama criterion VICE period drama BET Oscars die hard slashers Extras Netflix Amazon Studios Marvel Studios Writers Guild of America Drama 71st Emmy Awards TCA 2017 IFC Films directors Quiz ratings Funimation mockumentary Shondaland TNT Animation NYCC Rocky Acorn TV casting VOD National Geographic war HBO Year in Review crime drama natural history TruTV Sci-Fi Opinion Television Academy Elton John tv talk Mary poppins Adult Swim children's TV Sneak Peek Photos crime asian-american ghosts space rotten movies we love twilight movies SXSW Premiere Dates versus Schedule Apple TV+ video cats Action X-Men Heroines cancelled TV series PBS Kids & Family The Witch Certified Fresh Stephen King Sundance TV Logo hispanic Box Office Star Trek 20th Century Fox Superheroe 24 frames Emmy Nominations Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cancelled television psycho news PlayStation police drama CNN Interview anime Watching Series Star Wars Character Guide Nominations Disney streaming service Freeform harry potter The CW Showtime Fall TV 2019 TBS Rom-Com cartoon DGA transformers Awards Winter TV reboot USA Universal Hear Us Out mission: impossible Hallmark Christmas movies History Martial Arts Family Amazon Disney+ Disney Plus CBS television CBS All Access Mary Poppins Returns crime thriller travel Binge Guide Syfy Discovery Channel golden globes Turner blaxploitation technology stand-up comedy dark Rocketman Tumblr A24 Holiday Esquire zero dark thirty Emmys El Rey APB Vudu Dark Horse Comics Starz screenings YouTube Red Comic Book series adventure canceled Rock blockbuster based on movie Set visit DC Comics Holidays