Critics Consensus

It: Chapter Two Is Satisfying Enough

Critics say the horror follow-up is a bit overlong with some pacing issues, but the cast is fantastic, and Pennywise is as freaky as ever.

by | September 5, 2019 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got the return of a killer clown (It: Chapter Two, starring Jessica ChastainJames McAvoy, and Bill Hader). What are the critics saying?


It Chapter Two (2019) 63%

In September of 2017, the Stephen King novel adaptation It debuted to widespread critical acclaim and a number of box office records, but as fans of the book already knew, it only told half of the story. In other words, a sequel covering the other half was inevitable, and now, two years later, that conclusion has arrived. It: Chapter Two catches up with the so-called Losers Club 27 years after the events of the first film; the kids have all grown-up and, with the exception of Mike (Isaiah Mustafa), left town to move on with their lives elsewhere. However, when children begin to go missing in Derry again, the gang reunites to end the evil for good. The sequel hasn’t resonated with critics the way the first installment did, with several reviews calling out the heavy use of CGI, the hefty 169-minute runtime, and the lack of truly chilling moments among the film’s shortcomings. But most still found it a worthy finale, thanks largely to its impeccable casting — which includes Jessica Chastain, Bill Hader, James McAvoy, Mustafa, Jay Ryan, and James Ransone, as well as the returning younger stars, and, of course, Bill Skarsgård as Pennywise — and its efforts to recreate what made the source material so terrifying and surprisingly poignant. This one probably isn’t going to break any records, but it should bring satisfying closure for most fans.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Ága (2019) , a family drama about a married indigenous couple in Siberia trying to reconnect with their estranged daughter, is at 91%.
  • Ms. Purple (2019)Justin Chon‘s drama about two siblings who reunite to care for their terminally ill father, is at 87%.
  • Linda Ronstadt: The Sound of My Voice (2019) , a documentary portrait of the versatile singer’s remarkable life and career, is at 83%.
  • Strange But True (2019) , a mystery about a family that loses one of its sons to an accident, only to have his ex-girlfriend show up five years later, claiming she’s pregnant with his baby, is at 83%.
  • The Blonde One (2019) , a romantic drama about two men who become roommates and discover a mutual attraction, is at 80%.
  • Blink of an Eye (2019) , a documentary about the friendship between NASCAR racers Michael Waltrip and Dale Earnhardt Jr., is at 67%.
  • Satanic Panic (2019) , a horror-comedy about a pizza delivery driver who unwittingly makes a house call to a satanic cult looking for a young woman to sacrifice, is at 65%.
  • Edie (2019) , about a woman who decides to embark on a mountain climbing adventure after her controlling husband passes away, is at 65%.
  • Becoming Nobody (2019) , a documentary about the life and teachings of Harvard psychologist-turned-spiritual leader Ram Dass, is at 57%.
  • Night Hunter (Nomis) (2019) , starring Henry Cavill and Ben Kingsley in an action thriller about a police officer and a vigilante who are on the trail of murderer, is at 8%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Masterpiece Teen richard e. Grant NBC films Turner Classic Movies adventure DC Comics Britbox medical drama Certified Fresh reviews Superheroe chucky Oscars Black Mirror political drama kids Disney Channel First Look streaming breaking bad TCM indie adaptation Watching Series SXSW cancelled television technology crime thriller Funimation DirecTV mission: impossible strong female leads sports Food Network Captain marvel scary movies twilight FX on Hulu toy story Character Guide dark Video Games CNN Netflix Christmas movies dc Sneak Peek screen actors guild Reality Competition cartoon Lucasfilm RT History ratings Elton John OWN Polls and Games Comics on TV Western thriller Musical Year in Review tv talk crossover TruTV 71st Emmy Awards NYCC Logo Horror USA Network Rocketman Lionsgate venice halloween docudrama LGBTQ 21st Century Fox Mystery Trophy Talk independent 2017 comics south america LGBT Opinion ghosts Summer worst movies Sundance GLAAD Reality name the review IFC anime movie Emmys science fiction elevated horror Comedy Central singing competition football transformers discovery Bravo Ovation Avengers History The Arrangement a nightmare on elm street HBO Max El Rey Cannes TNT IFC Films Spring TV remakes Superheroes comiccon FX ABC Family Marvel Television diversity spanish language Disney Plus SundanceTV biography Holidays cooking VH1 Awards Warner Bros. dceu VICE BBC Baby Yoda SDCC Country Comedy Pet Sematary Netflix Sundance Now Writers Guild of America Sundance TV period drama zombies joker game show Apple TV Plus X-Men CW Seed Disney+ Disney Plus PlayStation Emmy Nominations E3 Heroines cops Shudder Crackle universal monsters Apple TCA Winter 2020 Anna Paquin toronto Action dramedy space BBC One scorecard DC streaming service news Endgame spy thriller festival Tarantino sitcom Hallmark Christmas movies true crime hispanic Pride Month game of thrones franchise First Reviews best Sony Pictures robots San Diego Comic-Con Acorn TV Marvel Studios batman Infographic Box Office romance Ghostbusters hist television cars renewed TV shows dogs Premiere Dates politics Mudbound laika TCA 2017 2019 Christmas ABC Trailer Peacock Nat Geo documentaries festivals Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Star Wars screenings The Witch The CW Television Academy ITV Extras Grammys USA Star Trek supernatural BBC America sequel nbcuniversal Winners Apple TV+ sequels Pixar serial killer 2016 24 frames werewolf justice league canceled TV shows natural history parents boxoffice romantic comedy RT21 indiana jones Podcast green book Fox News talk show ESPN FOX Amazon DC Universe Academy Awards Spike Interview mockumentary Hulu Television Critics Association video Lifetime Christmas movies Calendar vampires Lifetime Cartoon Network golden globes Shondaland cancelled teaser disaster Vudu The Walking Dead slashers Awards Tour OneApp child's play TV Land Mindy Kaling Black History Month doctor who Trivia 2015 Starz CMT Chilling Adventures of Sabrina BET rotten Hallmark GoT YouTube comic psychological thriller casting Schedule rotten movies we love Syfy MCU Brie Larson American Society of Cinematographers Red Carpet children's TV TBS blockbuster cancelled TV shows Chernobyl Paramount Network anthology WGN Universal what to watch Disney streaming service Winter TV Song of Ice and Fire Columbia Pictures TCA Awards police drama stand-up comedy YA comedies Amazon Prime Video directors PaleyFest movies Set visit Fall TV Martial Arts Binge Guide TV Hear Us Out TIFF Marathons Thanksgiving aliens Showtime Creative Arts Emmys cats Sci-Fi Film Festival spinoff VOD critics DGA Pirates Fantasy dragons Women's History Month psycho Adult Swim 45 witnail TCA Biopics satire Kids & Family free movies Animation nature all-time HBO Go 007 blaxploitation Countdown war cancelled TV series hollywood Stephen King Holiday unscripted fast and furious Rock Tubi National Geographic based on movie sag awards President Arrowverse WarnerMedia FXX AMC Toys zombie latino obituary 2018 travel Mary poppins Cosplay See It Skip It Spectrum Originals MTV Super Bowl 20th Century Fox social media Disney Amazon Studios E! harry potter emmy awards Drama superhero Film GIFs 72 Emmy Awards Election PBS theme song YouTube Red A&E APB series Crunchyroll A24 Esquire composers CBS Marvel crime historical drama Turner revenge stop motion MSNBC reboot HBO BET Awards book TLC nfl Music Best and Worst cults documentary christmas movies Dark Horse Comics Valentine's Day The Purge 2020 CBS All Access New York Comic Con Discovery Channel criterion jamie lee curtis miniseries concert quibi Photos Comic Book worst Tumblr YouTube Premium BAFTA Paramount Amazon Prime stoner Ellie Kemper Family video on demand cinemax Rom-Com finale Musicals Epix binge zero dark thirty die hard animated versus spider-man foreign Mary Poppins Returns mutant classics Nickelodeon 4/20 facebook Rocky spain Tomatazos canceled award winner Pop Freeform Pop TV Mary Tyler Moore asian-american Quiz Nominations crime drama Travel Channel Walt Disney Pictures TV renewals Classic Film