Know Your Critic

Know Your Critic: Robert Daniels, Freelance Film Critic

Daniels talks what he’s been watching while quarantined, describes the work he finds most challenging, and shares his love of ambitious filmmaking.

by | August 19, 2020 | Comments

Buena Vista Distribution Company, Netflix, Walt Disney Pictures
(Photo by Buena Vista Distribution Company, Netflix, Walt Disney Pictures)

Since becoming a Tomatometer-approved critic in 2018, Robert Daniels has written for some of the most popular film- and culture-centric sites out there. No matter where he’s writing – RogerEbert.com, Polygon, his own site (812filmreviews), or Rotten Tomatoes, where he recently traced Ben Affleck’s career and deemed him one of the best actors of his generation – Daniels’ voice consistently resonates as both approachable and incisive. Reading his work feels like having a conversation with an exceptionally witty, thoughtful friend, one who seems to have read and watched just about everything out there.

“I’m lucky, I write pretty fast,” Roberts said in an interview with Rotten Tomatoes. “Usually the first draft is basically the draft.”

But it’s not for lack of effort. He goes in cold to screenings so that his opinions are fresh, jots down minimal notes to keep his eyes on the screen – unless he’s not enamored of what he sees (“I can always tell when I don’t like a film because I will actually long hand write my reviews while I’m watching,” he said) – and does all his background research before sitting down to write.

“It’s not something that you can just fall out of bed and do,” Roberts said of writing reviews. “Things are easiest when you feel like you have all the answers around you and you just have to order all the elements together in a cohesive way.”

Robert Daniels is a freelance film critic based in Chicago, IL. Find him on Twitter: @812filmreviews.


What have you been watching during quarantine?

It’s been a mixed bag. I’ve been heavy on Criterion Channel. They had a lot of noirs, so I watched a film called The Sniper, if I remember correctly. I’ve been watching a lot of new releases, like The Old Guard, The Beach House, Relic, some of the recent stuff. I rewatched First Cow for the first time in a while. I loved that film so much. I saw it at the New York Film Festival and I was waiting for it to come out so everyone else could see it – I love Kelly Reichardt‘s work.

What do you think makes a good movie?

I don’t think I can give an answer to that. I know what I personally like, but I don’t equate personal evaluation with universal, with greatness, anything. Some films that I hold dear to my heart – Cats, Cloud Atlas, Jupiter Ascending – those are movies that probably a good number of people wouldn’t call “great.”

I personally gravitate toward creatives who take risks; even if they don’t stick the landing, I love the ambition. So, I know what makes a great movie for me. Great movies always arise from the unlikeliest of places.


Criterion Collection
(Photo by Criterion Collection)

What do you consider required viewing?

The Passion of Joan of Arc, the silent film version, that’s always an oldie but a goodie. I think when people watch silent films, they automatically think that silent films are lesser than current sound films, whether visually or narratively. But that film, just every portion of it, it’s a study in editing. It’s a study of pathos and empathy and the narrative just works. It’s classic. The story of Joan of Arc, I don’t think has ever been done better than that film, which – all these decades later – is saying something.

What are you most proud of in your career so far?

I wasn’t really one of those kids who watched the films growing up and thought, “Oh, I’m going to be involved with that one day.” Movies weren’t really a big part of my childhood, whether going to them or owning them on VHS because my parents just didn’t have the disposable income for that. So, the only escapism I had was really books from the library.

In my childhood, I bounced around from my grandmother to my aunt’s house and for a time, I was homeless and we didn’t really have enough money to buy stuff like movies. I knew of Siskel and Ebert – they were Chicago institutions. But the idea that I, a Black kid from the west side of Chicago who’s probably partly destitute… The idea that I could become a critic never entered my mind.

And so, when I got to high school, I did a lot of catching up to fill blank spots with films that people had grown up with, but I hadn’t. And so, it took years before I had the confidence to undo any intellectual shortcomings I told myself that I had, because I didn’t vacation in whatever country. I didn’t have whatever major experience and see such-and-such movie title. That seed of inadequacy never leaves you. So, every day you feel like you have to prove yourself. I think that’s why I love movies so much today, because I didn’t have them when I was growing up.

The fact that I’m even doing this is what I’m proud of.

What do you think is the biggest misconception about critics?

That our reviews and the pieces that we write are born out of an ether. I think in the purest sense, we’re always providing our opinion, and opinions can be made up of internalized values with regards to quality and interest. But, I think we couple that prior knowledge with research.

I always find it interesting that when someone comments on one of my reviews, they’ll be like, “Did you look up this? Did you look up that? It’d be really helpful if you read this.” And it’s like, well, I did my research before I wrote it. I didn’t just jump off a trampoline.


Universal Pictures
(Photo by Universal Pictures)

Do you have a favorite book-to-film adaptation?

That’s easy: Alfonso Cuarón’s Children of Men. I love the adaptive work for that film mostly because he throws the book out. Because of fanbases today, there is this fear that you have to show some fidelity to the original work. And, I think some of the most interesting adaptations are the ones that throw away everything and go down a different road.

Who is an under-the-radar director or screenwriter that you think more people should know about?

Sarah Gavron. She did Suffragette, and her first film was This Little Life. I watched her newest film Rocks, which hasn’t been released yet, but it played at TIFF this past year. Her stories are just so specific, but they’re built out in a way that they’re entities, intimate worlds that are separate from our own experiences and yet they feel universal.

What is the hardest review that you’ve ever written?

That’s hard because so many things have different valuations. My first thought would be, I did a listicle about the top 20 black director films of the decade for Consequence of Sound. I would say listicles are harder than they seem because if you do them right, you have to do rewatches. You have to do research. You have to have introspection and put them in the context, everything like that. And they can actually be, if you do it right, they could be difficult.

Any personal cultural piece that I write based around race is always difficult just because those pieces tend to either deal with Black Lives Matter or they deal in trauma. I’m always happy that I can write about those kinds of subjects and give them a wider voice. They take a lot out of me, mostly because it’s confronting things that are buried and they’re buried for a reason.

Writing about trauma, it’s not like rolling out of bed. There are some days when even rolling out of bed is a difficult act. I don’t know, it’s difficult because you feel like you have to speak for a community. At least, I feel like I have to speak for a community. And, that’s a dangerous trap to fall into when you feel like you’re speaking for more than yourself. When I’m writing these pieces, the tight rope always feels higher and the fall feels bigger and that’s a terrible place to write from. Words should begin with their importance to you.

The John Boyega Star Wars piece for Polygon was pretty challenging. I had one of the best editors with Matt Patches, and he was just fantastic. And, I kept trying to run away from giving definitions or from taking things down to their simplest terms because I was afraid what those definitions would say. But Matt, to his credit, pushed me – and through all of his queries, the piece ended up with what I wanted to say and not the easy way I wanted to say it.

Honestly, when that piece got released, I thought, “Oh my God, the Star Wars fandom is really toxic. I’m going to get ripped apart.” And then, I woke up and then I saw John Boyega was doing the protest through the streets of London. And I was like, “Oh my God, perfect timing.” It was phenomenal timing.


Buena Vista Distribution Company
(Photo by Buena Vista Distribution Company)

What’s a Rotten film you love?

Oh, Reign of Fire. I love Reign of Fire. I love mythology. That’s not like a mythological movie, but it does have a mythological beast with dragons. It’s over the top and it’s Matthew McConaughey at his peak – shirtless Matthew McConaughey era – and Christian Bale in his grumpy cat era. I love every component of it. It’s a film that I definitely don’t think got a fair shake on its first time out.

Is there an actor or a director or screenwriter whose work you always love?

The first person who pops in my mind is Barry Jenkins. I love all of his work from Medicine for Melancholy, to Moonlight, to If Beale Street Could Talk – all those works. He just does them from such a personal place and you would think something so personal wouldn’t feel universal, and yet it does. Not only does it feel universal, but it feels personal to me watching it and his eye and his taste for colors and the way that he films Black skin. He’s just amazing. That’s probably not the most inventive answer, because I’m pretty sure a lot of people say Barry Jenkins, but it’s the best answer I can give.

What’s your favorite classic film?

8 1/2 by Federico Fellini. I think that was probably the moment where I realized that I am very much into ambitious directors and Federico Fellini very much obviously sticks the landing. The amount of surrealist stuff that he does in there… I watched it when I was a freshman in college and that was probably the first movie where I looked at it and I thought, “Oh, that’s what auteur theory is. That’s what it means to have a singular vision and to translate it to the screen. That’s what it means to take risks.”

Who are three people that you think everyone should follow on Twitter?

Soraya McDonald (@SorayaMcDonald). More than great movies, I love great writing. And her style – the way she expresses historical inequities and the way she puts it in such a compact style that breathes very easy, the knowledge and context comes across incredibly swiftly – I’m always amazed by it.

Joi Childs is another critic (@jumpedforjoi). Her interviews for The Hollywood Reporter are – they just all read incredibly. They’re all approachable and she accesses a personal side to celebrities that’s hard for most people. I usually envy her for that skill.

Roxana Hadadi (@roxana_hadadi). I can’t understand how she finds so many angles and new approaches to recent and past films that I would struggle to think of. Being frank: I just love the way her mind works.

Is there a non-critic in your life whose opinion you admire?

My mom, she is the universal barometer. If a movie plays well with her, then I know it plays well with anybody. Usually, if my mom really, really, really likes something – even if it’s something I think I’ll hate – I’ll take a look at it.


Robert Daniels is a freelance film critic based in Chicago, IL. His reviews have appeared at RogerEbert.com, The Playlist, Consequence of Sound, Polygon, and Mediaversity Reviews, among others. Find him on Twitter: @812filmreviews.

Tag Cloud

quibi cats Character Guide french Turner Classic Movies Disney streaming service Paramount festival RT21 Freeform YouTube Premium TruTV indie blaxploitation BAFTA USA all-time period drama ghosts nfl Netflix godzilla Nat Geo Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Calendar Fox Searchlight werewolf true crime Infographic comic books james bond Pop TV Interview Red Carpet Sundance Now women 45 best Pop dceu YA sequel ID casting stand-up comedy venice New York Comic Con BET films strong female leads binge 2019 Emmys Country Walt Disney Pictures Masterpiece archives justice league Thanksgiving spanish language kong diversity documentary Ovation ABC monster movies Apple mockumentary Hallmark Christmas movies Star Wars Syfy PBS dragons Fox News E3 unscripted anime scorecard children's TV Premiere Dates remakes A&E twilight harry potter FX Fantasy GoT franchise Reality series Holidays First Look Disney Channel hist Drama Emmy Nominations Pirates rom-coms Black Mirror Quiz Trophy Talk SDCC TCM The Purge Tubi asian-american Comic Book social media crossover Marathons nbcuniversal Film Warner Bros. Marvel Trivia The CW 2020 TCA 2017 Hallmark concert sequels 99% space Paramount Plus Christmas Showtime child's play Marvel Television See It Skip It YouTube Red 72 Emmy Awards IFC Films DC Comics robots The Walking Dead chucky romance golden globes Spring TV Britbox disaster ABC Family deadpool parents Tarantino Amazon classics television cancelled television Avengers Tomatazos Amazon Prime Video romantic comedy Disney+ Disney Plus WarnerMedia animated travel OneApp king kong 2017 GIFs italian VOD Shondaland reboot japanese Podcast singing competition war spy thriller game show sag awards cults based on movie die hard Spike WGN golden globe awards American Society of Cinematographers a nightmare on elm street fresh hollywood Marvel Studios Comics on TV 007 spider-man The Witch versus news Tumblr SundanceTV SXSW emmy awards Election RT History TCA Winter 2020 TV Land screen actors guild anthology crime FXX Exclusive Video Rocky Dark Horse Comics laika Action movies BBC America police drama hidden camera book HBO political drama richard e. Grant latino Turner Biopics Certified Fresh Sci-Fi popular Broadway TBS TV renewals Elton John DC streaming service Anna Paquin Kids & Family Set visit Awards Tour Academy Awards Song of Ice and Fire Rom-Com comedies TV Women's History Month Starz Writers Guild of America docudrama Countdown FOX doctor who streaming mutant docuseries Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt IFC Music joker First Reviews trailers telelvision cooking Legendary Box Office slashers ABC Signature Shudder Logo video on demand witnail Cartoon Network crime thriller black dogs Sony Pictures Best and Worst supernatural 2018 Mary poppins batman Rocketman stoner Extras OWN Disney Plus adaptation sports foreign video Crunchyroll zero dark thirty Binge Guide LGBT scary movies Amazon Prime Western critics Sundance comic boxoffice Mary Poppins Returns blockbusters Acorn TV miniseries psychological thriller GLAAD worst jamie lee curtis free movies Mindy Kaling canceled TV shows Fall TV Captain marvel serial killer Arrowverse USA Network MSNBC Baby Yoda Teen LGBTQ Esquire cinemax universal monsters YouTube Oscars satire Food Network spinoff award winner President HBO Max APB australia medical drama PaleyFest comiccon festivals finale Nominations Valentine's Day cartoon Winter TV Funimation superhero A24 theme song biography CW Seed Hear Us Out mission: impossible cars Family DC Universe south america screenings thriller MCU sitcom 21st Century Fox Super Bowl Grammys Ellie Kemper cancelled TV shows politics boxing Photos Year in Review canceled elevated horror 4/20 Hulu TV One Mudbound worst movies 2015 green book indiana jones natural history Musical 2016 24 frames psycho ViacomCBS pirates of the caribbean Television Critics Association dark DirecTV toy story blockbuster Toys talk show Alien CMT VICE Summer christmas movies spain Nickelodeon renewed TV shows cancelled Columbia Pictures Polls and Games Disney VH1 breaking bad Awards Creative Arts Emmys rotten historical drama hispanic Sundance TV MTV National Geographic Holiday Mary Tyler Moore documentaries composers Brie Larson Cannes prank Rock Heroines DGA zombies tv talk The Arrangement 71st Emmy Awards Reality Competition science fiction 20th Century Fox Ghostbusters 2021 vampires Comedy kids Superheroes jurassic park E! Endgame Trailer kaiju Animation BBC One Bravo Vudu Amazon Studios adventure HBO Go El Rey Schedule Lionsgate Universal Pixar teaser ESPN football rotten movies we love Pride Month PlayStation Spectrum Originals Peacock Television Academy rt archives Mystery Film Festival Comedy Central Horror The Academy TLC The Walt Disney Company Star Trek NYCC FX on Hulu game of thrones Apple TV Plus discovery Epix AMC technology ratings Chernobyl BET Awards fast and furious reviews Superheroe name the review what to watch cancelled TV series dramedy obituary criterion halloween tv 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards independent San Diego Comic-Con Sneak Peek Winners Apple TV+ Classic Film Black History Month nature revenge Discovery Channel NBC Video Games X-Men Stephen King Crackle History directors crime drama transformers halloween CBS All Access Lifetime CNN Pet Sematary cops movie facebook Musicals Adult Swim Cosplay TCA Awards TIFF Martial Arts Opinion Lifetime Christmas movies Lucasfilm BBC stop motion aliens razzies Watching Series Travel Channel spanish TCA superman TNT ITV zombie CBS Paramount Network toronto dc Netflix Christmas movies comics