Know Your Critic

Know Your Critic: Rolling Stone Senior Editor David Fear

Fear talks screening and reviewing habits, all-time favorites, and what movie he thinks best represents the 2010s.

by | January 17, 2020 | Comments

(Photo by Paramount Vantage, 20th Century Fox, Universal Pictures)

“Know Your Critic” is a new column in which we interview Tomatometer-approved critics about their screening and reviewing habits, pet peeves, and personal favorites.

When David Fear moved to New York 16 years ago, he was intending to continue freelance writing and keep his “day job.” Fate had other plans.

He decided to move from California on a Friday, and on the following Monday, a position opened up at entertainment and “things-to-do” magazine, Time Out New York. When it came time for his move across the country, things fell right into place: By the time he got the call for an interview, he could already tell them his new address in the city.

“You can be a film critic anywhere,” he told Rotten Tomatoes, “but there really is something about being in New York and being at the Film Forum, seeing a recently restored version or our print of Army of Shadows that you really just kind of feel like, Oh, I’m in Film Nerd Heaven.”

David Fear is now a Senior Editor and critic at Rolling Stone, and the former Film Editor of Time Out New York.


What’s your personal record for most movies seen in a day?

When I was younger and much, much more full of piss and vinegar, I think I did a six-film day at Sundance once. It might have been my first or second Sundance back in 2004, 2005. I don’t recommend it.

If you ate six meals in a day, they could be the greatest meals in the world. They could be five-star chef meals. But you’ve stopped tasting it after a while and it just becomes shoveling food into your mouth and going, “Oh my God, when is this going to end?”

I found that when I would start doing more than three, maybe four movies a day at a festival, I would stop tasting the food.

Do you prefer 3-D or non–3-D screenings?

Do you even have to ask that? I’ve actually gone out of my way to see to 2-D screenings because, here’s the thing, with very rare exceptions, there’s only really three movies that you absolutely, positively need to see in 3-D.

There’s really no point to seeing Avatar unless you’re seeing it in 3-D. It’s a bad movie, but how he uses 3-D to really immerse you in a bad movie that he’s made is remarkably impressive.

Are you pro– or anti–note-taking?

I don’t understand how you can do this gig and not take notes. If you’re really serious about potentially wanting to do this, practice writing stuff in a notebook without looking at your notebook. I’m very, very pro-note taking – so long as it’s not with one of those light pens. Man, f–k those light pens.

You’re sitting down to write. Would you prefer a shot of espresso or alcohol? What’s your spirit of choice?

Espresso for writing and then bourbon for transcribing. It makes the activity of transcribing so much less painful.


(Photo by Paramount Vantage)

What’s the hardest review you’ve ever written?

If I still had a chance to work on and revise my There Will Be Blood review, I would still be doing it. Not only because it’s just one of my favorite films ever, but there’s so much going on and it’s such a slippery film for me to try and really grasp and write about in a way that feels articulate and as close to complete as possible.

I still have nightmares about writing that review and really feeling like I hadn’t quite gotten it yet. Not that I hadn’t got the movie – I knew exactly how I felt about the movie – but to try and translate that into a piece, and explain why I think it’s one of the great artworks of the 21st century to date was… I still have nightmares about it.

Someone that everyone should follow on Twitter?

I’m biased because I know him, but Justin Chang [of the Los Angeles Times]. To my money, there’s just not a better film critic working today than Justin. You should follow him on Twitter for the puns – not just the fact that he’s one of the smartest, funniest film writers today, but he is like a God-level pun maker. His punny games, his punny business is just absolutely insane.

Up-and-coming critic that you think people should read?

There are two young critics that I hope people are paying attention to.

I hope people are reading Kameron Austin Collins, he’s one of the film critics for Vanity Fair. I ended up meeting him and found out he was only in late 20s. I was just like, “Oh my God. If you’re writing at this level in your late 20s, you’re going to be a f–king monster in the next 10 years.”

I would say the same about Monica Castillo. She’s all over the place byline-wise, but she’s one of those people I feel she’s maturing really beautifully as a writer.


(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

Do you have a favorite classic film?

I could watch The Lady Eve every single day for the rest of my life and never get tired of it. There are a handful of films that I feel are as close to perfect as humanly possible, and The Lady Eve is one of them.

It’s such a cliché answer, but I’ve probably seen The Godfather close to a hundred times and that’s barely an exaggeration. Between that and the second Godfather film, I almost feel like I can quote most of them off the top of my head.

Is that the movie you’ve watched more than any other?

Yeah, that would have to be it. There’s a couple of movies that I’ve definitely gotten into the double digits with. I’ve seen Dazed and Confused a lot because it’s a comfort movie. I can sink into that movie.

Is there an actor, director, or screenwriter whose work you always love?

The closest thing I would say I have to a favorite filmmaker – and take that phrase with a huge grain of salt – would be Yasujirō Ozu. I feel the movies he makes were reverse-engineered for me.


Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope, 1977 (20th Century Fox Film Corp.)
(Photo by 20th Century Fox)

Do you have a favorite movie from your childhood?

I remember seeing Monty Python and the Holy Grail on PBS one night… I watched that constantly as a kid. You know when you found something that’s your sense of humor?

And then, because I’m a child of the ‘70s, Star Wars. My parents actually took me out of school to go see a matinee of it the first week that it was open. I had no idea what I was going into and as a six-year-old kid and then walked out of it a changed human being.

Is there anything that you consider “required viewing”?

Yeah. Actually, I think it’s out of print now… Visions of Light. It’s a documentary about cinematography and covers the gamut, talks a lot about cinematographers in the ’30s and ’40s, talks a lot about the new Hollywood guys, talks a lot about British cinematographers. It really is this incredible primer that not only is just a beautiful film, obviously, because it’s talking about people who’ve shot movies beautifully. It’s an extraordinary gateway drug.


(Photo by Universal Pictures)

You recently wrote a piece on the 20-year resonance of Fight Club. I’m wondering if there’s a movie released this decade that you think in 10 or 20 years we’re going to look back and think, “That was the 2010s.”

If I had to be honest, I think the movie would be Get Out. It feels like it’s very much a movie for the end of the Obama era and very, very much a movie for the beginning of the Trump era. Never mind that it’s also a really great move and it’s a movie that keeps giving the more you see it, and it’s so beautifully constructed. It works well as a horror film, works well as a satire, works well as social commentary, and worked well as a personal expression of the sensibility of the person who made it.

What’s the biggest misconception you hear about critics?

That we hate movies. It’s really the opposite. I think a lot of us love the art form enough that when we see it used badly, we feel we need to call it out. I don’t trust the critic that doesn’t live, breathe, eat, and s–t movies.

What are you most proud of in your career so far?

As an editor, I’m not a religious person but, I think blessed is really the only word I can think of… When I get something from a good writer and think like, “Oh, this is good but there’s a great piece in here. Let’s find this great piece.”

In a way, it’s like you’re not the mother, you’re the midwife – being able to help a really beautiful baby be born into the world by trying to be a good editor. Getting back a second, or a third, or sometimes a fourth draft and finally having the moment where you’re like, “Yes! Holy s–t! You found it.”


David Fear is a Senior Editor and critic at Rolling Stone. Find him on Twitter: @davidlfear.

Tag Cloud

biography Mystery Shudder 2017 First Reviews remakes cancelled Marvel Television Oscars Crunchyroll streaming superhero PBS Box Office Superheroes Countdown teaser Epix SundanceTV rotten movies we love 2019 Avengers Rocky venice universal monsters politics anthology foreign Holidays Logo zombies historical drama movies Hulu Pixar documentary harry potter Universal tv talk cops dragons Marathons Peacock Women's History Month SDCC transformers See It Skip It Disney streaming service renewed TV shows twilight Academy Awards emmy awards Schedule Disney Plus Toys comiccon RT History elevated horror TV Land President Pop docudrama natural history nbcuniversal festivals FX joker sports Television Critics Association Horror Sundance psycho game show werewolf period drama Rocketman Opinion Hear Us Out BET what to watch richard e. Grant ratings award winner cults 2016 cancelled TV shows Comedy reviews Ghostbusters stop motion USA Network based on movie Trivia CBS All Access true crime spider-man OWN PaleyFest Apple TV+ Interview TCA 2018 The Witch MCU 20th Century Fox GoT Ellie Kemper First Look Disney Channel FXX YA Baby Yoda adventure casting Funimation TLC Winter TV medical drama blockbuster political drama stoner USA LGBT Fall TV Country Super Bowl El Rey Captain marvel Holiday Martial Arts miniseries Spring TV Sneak Peek batman mockumentary Nominations Photos Comic Book christmas movies concert YouTube independent NBC Rom-Com Awards Tour Grammys blaxploitation 007 Hallmark Christmas movies hist Sony Pictures crime thriller National Geographic Summer Amazon Prime Spike obituary Tomatazos WGN psychological thriller TCA Awards facebook witnail latino Bravo canceled green book Spectrum Originals TBS spinoff Paramount diversity anime Travel Channel Ovation Quiz Black History Month Tumblr Showtime Hallmark chucky cancelled TV series ABC mission: impossible CBS science fiction cooking rotten space sequel Biopics video on demand A&E satire Comics on TV adaptation Star Wars DC Universe sitcom TCM DirecTV Sundance TV HBO Go films crime drama name the review TIFF Mudbound A24 Pet Sematary spain Fantasy GIFs quibi Teen jamie lee curtis The Arrangement San Diego Comic-Con IFC Best and Worst MTV Paramount Network composers best Apple Amazon television zombie The Walking Dead supernatural 72 Emmy Awards TV renewals singing competition hollywood Winners 4/20 aliens Certified Fresh ITV sag awards comic HBO Max Lifetime FOX Polls and Games TV Trophy Talk Music Mary poppins Mary Poppins Returns CW Seed Chernobyl dark CMT 2015 football Tarantino movie Election Film cars canceled TV shows Cannes Mindy Kaling finale DC Comics Christmas Podcast disaster child's play criterion nfl fast and furious Cartoon Network Sci-Fi sequels Chilling Adventures of Sabrina discovery Britbox south america AMC worst Columbia Pictures Brie Larson Reality worst movies Kids & Family dc vampires Cosplay Marvel Studios DGA Netflix ABC Family laika thriller Red Carpet cancelled television crime boxoffice toronto Extras screen actors guild MSNBC indie dogs Warner Bros. ESPN romance robots book BET Awards BBC reboot Turner Starz Anna Paquin strong female leads Character Guide Comedy Central Lifetime Christmas movies Thanksgiving Lucasfilm TruTV PlayStation Song of Ice and Fire Netflix Christmas movies Star Trek Reality Competition Pop TV VOD zero dark thirty unscripted Musical The Purge 71st Emmy Awards Watching Series mutant LGBTQ slashers Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt die hard Marvel Classic Film Tubi Rock Valentine's Day game of thrones Set visit Mary Tyler Moore Masterpiece critics Animation screenings Drama animated cinemax APB news Creative Arts Emmys Adult Swim halloween Nickelodeon Heroines Turner Classic Movies TCA Winter 2020 X-Men Discovery Channel scorecard children's TV talk show 21st Century Fox cartoon Musicals Pride Month 2020 revenge toy story nature dceu RT21 VH1 Elton John stand-up comedy American Society of Cinematographers YouTube Premium Infographic classics Family Syfy crossover The CW a nightmare on elm street Trailer franchise NYCC spy thriller travel doctor who Binge Guide Action Film Festival Sundance Now video SXSW CNN 24 frames Video Games Arrowverse social media golden globes HBO romantic comedy comedies BBC America cats BBC One Fox News Western Stephen King IFC Films all-time TNT Acorn TV police drama OneApp Food Network Walt Disney Pictures Lionsgate kids E3 scary movies New York Comic Con asian-american Disney+ Disney Plus Shondaland indiana jones ghosts GLAAD comics History dramedy technology Emmys TCA 2017 YouTube Red hispanic spanish language Esquire justice league E! Freeform Premiere Dates Amazon Studios VICE Nat Geo parents DC streaming service Pirates Black Mirror 45 Endgame binge Superheroe Writers Guild of America free movies Vudu breaking bad Emmy Nominations Crackle festival Awards Amazon Prime Video FX on Hulu directors Year in Review Dark Horse Comics Television Academy Calendar theme song WarnerMedia versus series BAFTA Apple TV Plus war Disney documentaries serial killer