Legion Creator Noah Hawley Prepares Fans for a Reinvention in Season 2

Why the trippy X-Men series is starting over, and when you can expect more dancing (hint: it's soon). Plus, a note on Fargo and his upcoming film Pale Blue Dot.

by | April 1, 2018 | Comments

Viewers new to Legion aren’t at much of a disadvantage to fans who obsessed over the entire first season. Noah Hawley’s X-Men series is so trippy, often ambiguous, and focused on tone that you might still be unlocking its secrets after multiple viewings.

Legion is a sort of origin story of David Haller (Dan Stevens), who, in comic books, becomes a mutant with big hair named Legion. In season 1 of the show, David is in a psychiatric institution after a childhood of powers-related trauma. If one felt possessed by other consciousnesses, institutionalization would be the real-world treatment, but this is the world of Legion— absorbing consciousnesses is one of David’s mutant powers.

Just when things started to make sense — relative to Legion — David got sucked into an orb in the post-credits scene of the season finale. Season 2 finds David one year later in Division III custody, so David is back to piecing together his missing past again, at least for the last 362 days. The good news is, Hawley agrees this is the perfect time to jump into Legion.

“If you look at that first season, what actually happened, it’s not a lot of plot on a lot of levels,” Hawley said. “David was worried he was mentally ill and then it turned out he had this other consciousness inside of him. They got it out for him and now it’s out there on the loose, and they’ve got to go get it. You could know that and you would be just as oriented as someone who’s watched the first season.”

That demonic parasite was Amahl Farouk, the Shadow King. In season 1 Farouk appeared as the devil with the yellow eyes in David’s visions. In season 2, Navid Negahban plays Farouk’s true form.

“That’s not to say there aren’t masks from time to time, but now it’s time to invest in him as a character,” Hawley said. “No one should just be a villain. You have to be able to understand the world from his point of view as someone who was basically kicked out of his body, kicked out of his home by David’s dad and went into David’s body. From his point of view, he’s the good guy and that’s always more interesting.”

Legion could be a different show from week to week, so drastic changes between seasons aren’t totally out of character. Division III were villanous agents in season 1, trying to capture David for his powers. Now David’s friends — Syd (Rachel Keller), Melanie (Jean Smart), Cary (Bill Irwin), Kerry (Amber Midthunder) and Ptonomy (Jeremie Harris) — have teamed up with Division III to stop Farouk.

“I always feel like a new season of a show is an opportunity to reinvent the show on some level, which doesn’t work for every show,” Hawley said. “I think it works for this one. I don’t think you would want to watch Game of Thrones and have Game of Thrones be a different show. You want it to be what you want it to be. Breaking Bad’s hallmark [was] it’s in real time, and you’re going to pick up the moment you left off for the most part. This isn’t that show.”

Even upon reinvention, most of the things you loved about Legion are still there, and sometimes even more of them. Everyone loved the Bollywood dance number, so there’s more dancing in season 2. David was still tracking Oliver (Jemaine Clement) and Lenny (Aubrey Plaza) at the end of season 1, so when he finally finds them, it’s all expressed on the dance floor with no words. Episode two has a song Oliver and Lenny sing.

“I want to expand the definition of what an action scene is,” Hawley said. “Can an action scene be dialogue? Can an action scene be musical? That idea that David is confronting Oliver and Lenny for the first time, there is some fighting to it and some posturing to it and some courtship to it on some level. It’s really hard to do that with violence. It’s a lot easier to do that with dance which is an expressive medium. That’s just fun too, I think.”

In the X-Men movies, action is usually Wolverine going berserk or Magneto flying bridges or stadiums. That’s not how Legion will do action.

“On those moments where the characters crash against each other, and he crashes against his own inner demons, that feels like action to me,” Hawley said. “I feel like the season is building towards these moments where plot and character come together because the plot is basically which path is David going to take? Is he going to be a hero? Is he going to be a villain? Has the damage he suffered doomed him? Can he overcome those things?”

So can dialogue be action? When your main character is a mutant with multiple consciousnesses, yes.

“David can be in a dialogue scene with himself,” Hawley said. “Now suddenly that inner monologue becomes an outside conversation.”

The visual manifestations of David’s mind gave Legion some trippy visuals like a giant volume knob and entire episodes taking place within the span of a single gunshot. Tune in to season 2 for frozen people with chattering teeth, something you can never unsee or unhear.

“It’s a way to try to make stillness into something dynamic,” Hawley said. “Certainly a bunch of people standing around like statues can be scary if executed the right way, but the teeth adds a visceral and sonic quality to it. It’s unnerving because it’s not behavior that people are supposed to do. We know innately what’s natural and what’s unnatural. There’s something so unnatural about it that I think it has a visceral impact on the audience.”

LEGION -- Season 2, Episode 2 -- Dan Stevens (Suzanne Tenner/FX)

Other visuals are more pleasant, like boats carrying waffles in a restaurant. David wakes up asking for waffles, so you gotta get the man some waffles.

“When you’re thinking about sets, all right, Division III, they need a place where they can have a conversation,” Hawley said. “I start thinking about those Japanese sushi restaurants you’ll see with the boats. I thought that’s interesting because it has movement to it now. It’s dynamic and it was a great set that Michael Wylie built, really fun to film in.”

Legion asks philosophical questions, like is a man dreaming he’s a butterfly or is the butterfly dreaming it’s a man? Melanie suggests that the saddest words in the English language are “vacant lot.” Some would say “if only” are the saddest words, but Hawley makes the case for “vacant lot.”

“Sometimes you write the first half of a sentence and you gotta finish it,” Hawley said. “Those words, ‘vacant,’ which means empty, and ‘lot,’ which is often used to mean the opposite: to have a lot of something. I don’t know, ‘You have a whole lot of nothing.’ Her delivery was so great it made me feel smarter.”

Between Fargo and Legion, Hawley has been working nonstop. He hasn’t ruled out a fourth season of Fargo, but with shows like these he can only focus on one at a time.

“I feel like I have an idea, but it’s something I’m seeing mostly out of the corner of my eye at this moment,” Hawley said of Fargo. “I haven’t started to open it up and figure it out.”

Hawley is also embarking on a film career. He is set to direct Pale Blue Dot starring Natalie Portman and Jon Hamm.

“It’s a movie sort of based on a true story of a female astronaut who comes back to Earth and she melts down a bit,” Hawley said. “For me, it’s a great tableau to explore a lot of ideas about her character and that experience of going out into space. We don’t send poets into space. We send left-brain engineer types, and they have these celestial experiences that they don’t know how to articulate a lot of the time. You just learn that no matter how complicated the universe is, it’s still simpler than life on Earth.”

Legion returns Tuesday, April 3 at 10 p.m. on FX.

Tag Cloud

YouTube Red comic Winter TV Podcast Crunchyroll reboot jurassic park Disney comiccon Fall TV science fiction YA game show ABC Signature transformers Starz New York Comic Con politics OWN Apple TV+ Arrowverse Disney streaming service BET Awards romantic comedy all-time 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Baby Yoda boxoffice NBA die hard 45 mutant asian-american stoner Classic Film Spring TV Brie Larson DC Comics biopic period drama Instagram Live cancelled ABC Family travel social media PlayStation animated Hulu screenings 2019 TCA E3 TV movies fast and furious Rock parents Wes Anderson renewed TV shows Elton John streaming Character Guide Premiere Dates Spectrum Originals IMDb TV Country Super Bowl mcc PBS ID 2018 ITV Comedy Central romance composers ghosts Amazon The Purge SXSW Amazon Studios target archives VH1 Grammys scene in color Cannes 93rd Oscars Dark Horse Comics sequel zombie technology 2020 The Walt Disney Company classics Crackle spanish discovery IFC Films Summer festival Emmys cancelled TV series french zombies Avengers TLC concert mockumentary monster movies films TruTV Mary Tyler Moore Alien 20th Century Fox free movies Thanksgiving batman GoT Toys cults Vudu telelvision posters venice Tubi CBS 21st Century Fox Comic Book adventure Legendary Logo spanish language Polls and Games true crime Quiz The Witch 72 Emmy Awards Shondaland comedies TV renewals aliens superhero Photos Acorn TV Showtime Winners Mary poppins james bond docuseries space blockbusters japan vs. hollywood HBO Max Endgame Pet Sematary Food Network Awards Tour cancelled television strong female leads WGN WarnerMedia toronto The Arrangement revenge Nominations History crossover Reality Competition mob TV Land women Biopics Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt genre spider-verse Comics on TV Film Festival comic book movies Sundance sports spinoff godzilla marvel cinematic universe Discovery Channel criterion AMC Plus basketball Cartoon Network Sundance Now BBC Box Office rom-coms young adult Pride Month Exclusive Video anime DC streaming service Nickelodeon Binge Guide scary movies Star Wars comic books Television Academy trailers video on demand Christmas Warner Bros. christmas movies VICE Apple lord of the rings Pirates LGBTQ TNT Valentine's Day Watching Series supernatural dogs stand-up comedy Year in Review Western Universal green book HBO Go Columbia Pictures A&E Star Trek Superheroes TIFF Best and Worst Trophy Talk Emmy Nominations Rocketman NBC Cosplay Paramount Network Mystery Chernobyl GIFs comic book movie talk show biography Anna Paquin TV One TCA Awards Captain marvel Opinion football ViacomCBS Shudder AMC 2016 medical drama USA Network finale Image Comics SDCC Pixar DirecTV 2015 Set visit children's TV live action aapi diversity Neflix Tomatazos book Family YouTube Premium 2021 breaking bad Walt Disney Pictures worst movies dceu black dc Pop Ellie Kemper action-comedy know your critic Heroines Television Critics Association Creative Arts Emmys LGBT slashers italian king arthur art house crime thriller joker El Rey Tarantino kids foreign indiana jones sequels casting game of thrones Hallmark Christmas movies Turner Classic Movies legend Broadway Marvel Spike marvel comics hist high school cancelled TV shows boxing 24 frames fresh facebook Hear Us Out feel good Calendar Funimation Sony Pictures critic resources popular PaleyFest President spain Kids & Family Music book adaptation war 73rd Emmy Awards 1990s Pacific Islander Nat Geo halloween blockbuster scary Mudbound rt archives Syfy dark robots FX on Hulu worst hispanic Peacock OneApp television dreamworks movies toy story suspense golden globe awards Mindy Kaling TV Rocky mission: impossible FOX SundanceTV obituary thriller Interview BET disaster slasher Freeform Paramount universal monsters adenture Marvel Studios Netflix Christmas movies 007 dramedy FX Stephen King miniseries Animation historical drama Horror rt labs critics edition a nightmare on elm street GLAAD USA YouTube Holidays halloween tv Sci-Fi hispanic heritage month 4/20 new york Extras Esquire BAFTA emmy awards cooking Comic-Con@Home 2021 Drama Disney Channel The CW Tokyo Olympics comics stop motion nbcuniversal RT21 cops movie A24 Oscars Red Carpet nature anthology zero dark thirty doctor who Academy Awards binge razzies HBO Superheroe rotten Holiday Lifetime Christmas movies Pop TV TCM blaxploitation quibi Marathons name the review Fantasy wonder woman indie Musicals Action See It Skip It 71st Emmy Awards First Look saw Sneak Peek screen actors guild japanese cinemax deadpool streaming movies TCA 2017 MCU FXX based on movie Mary Poppins Returns Schedule Netflix rotten movies we love APB Musical sag awards pirates of the caribbean Fox Searchlight crime australia directors Turner Disney+ Disney Plus cats jamie lee curtis award winner theme song The Walking Dead remakes serial killer MSNBC Disney Plus psychological thriller Masterpiece NYCC best independent rt labs Universal Pictures dexter Amazon Prime Video IFC new zealand Women's History Month DC Universe dragons Trailer Ovation Lifetime video Marvel Television Writers Guild of America Teen olympics ESPN Sundance TV superman MTV Comedy werewolf tv talk E! Tumblr Certified Fresh news prank The Academy justice league Film twilight RT History unscripted Amazon Prime Reality Rom-Com psycho TCA Winter 2020 adaptation new star wars movies TBS Apple TV Plus Ghostbusters spy thriller Lucasfilm DGA Paramount Plus BBC One Black Mirror BBC America canceled Martial Arts CBS All Access 2017 Election documentaries Video Games cars kong versus National Geographic CMT First Reviews reviews San Diego Comic-Con ratings VOD American Society of Cinematographers nfl harry potter crime drama royal family police drama teaser natural history 90s Britbox black comedy richard e. Grant child's play Awards sopranos king kong Fox News south america Countdown political drama Song of Ice and Fire X-Men golden globes 99% kaiju spider-man Lionsgate Trivia Bravo latino critics CW Seed elevated horror live event Adult Swim debate international vampires franchise Chilling Adventures of Sabrina canceled TV shows sitcom singing competition cartoon Black History Month satire festivals witnail Epix ABC CNN docudrama laika chucky Hallmark documentary hidden camera scorecard what to watch Travel Channel gangster Infographic heist movie series