Lord of the Rings Vs. Harry Potter: The Ultimate Fantasy Franchise Face-Off

Does the Boy Who Lived out-magic the hobbits, orcs, elves, and dwarves of Middle-earth? Find out as we break both series down by Tomatometer, box office, character quality, and more!

by | May 21, 2020 | Comments

It’s the Super Bowl of fantasy series showdowns in the latest edition of Vs., in which we’re pitting the Lord of the Rings movies against the Harry Potter films – including, for both franchises, the prequels. (And no, this does not help either side on the scoreboard.) Do Peter Jackson’s big-screen takes on J.R.R. Tolkien’s novels walk all over the movie adaptations of J.K. Rowling’s books like so many Ents stampeding through a forest? Or does the Boy Who Lived snatch up victory as if it were some quick-darting Golden Snitch? Find out as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks down each franchise by Tomatometer and Audience Score, box office, heroes and villains, and one special wild card category.

The Lord of the Rings films are available to rent or buy on FandangoNOW, Vudu, iTunes, and AmazonThe Harry Potter films are available to rent or buy on FandangoNOW, Vudu, iTunes, and Amazon

Thumbnail images by Universal courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

Comedy Central name the review Country Nominations DC Comics theme song Western Marathons Shudder talk show period drama parents spy thriller BBC crime CNN Paramount Network tv talk DC Universe free movies Marvel Paramount National Geographic politics Sundance Columbia Pictures dogs Epix BBC America Holiday composers dc PBS Super Bowl Cartoon Network hist Biopics book Red Carpet Esquire Grammys news Chernobyl El Rey Rocketman Reality Competition Pet Sematary what to watch 20th Century Fox Peacock Tumblr MTV Ghostbusters The Arrangement Superheroe Amazon Prime twilight New York Comic Con Hear Us Out Warner Bros. justice league child's play Pirates documentary series Pride Month Watching Series 72 Emmy Awards Academy Awards Mary Tyler Moore blockbuster DGA Lucasfilm psycho LGBT critics Netflix anthology Photos Elton John Horror aliens Fantasy casting The CW criterion Lionsgate Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Trivia political drama stop motion worst screen actors guild USA Network robots romance spain NYCC DirecTV emmy awards foreign Drama nbcuniversal Polls and Games The Witch cartoon psychological thriller doctor who based on movie Hallmark VH1 Comedy christmas movies halloween Binge Guide Mindy Kaling werewolf Shondaland Star Wars adaptation FX game show Spring TV revenge BBC One PlayStation movies Set visit breaking bad quibi 007 Character Guide boxoffice Adult Swim unscripted sequels X-Men Amazon Studios spinoff superhero 2016 dramedy spider-man Showtime video on demand Heroines harry potter Rom-Com football binge Ellie Kemper toy story Musicals E! Sneak Peek Hallmark Christmas movies ITV Cannes RT21 mutant History comedies facebook Schedule Spectrum Originals transformers asian-american teaser TCM Universal IFC Films Disney Crunchyroll directors Year in Review VICE franchise cancelled TV shows Funimation CBS All Access Disney streaming service TCA Winter 2020 documentaries HBO Max mission: impossible streaming Interview TIFF ghosts The Walking Dead SXSW cats Hulu Family miniseries all-time children's TV AMC strong female leads technology Quiz See It Skip It stand-up comedy NBC Rock festival USA Captain marvel CMT Tarantino nature MSNBC E3 TCA TCA Awards Brie Larson Endgame remakes ABC Family Toys jamie lee curtis Video Games Freeform indiana jones RT History disaster travel sports natural history chucky Netflix Christmas movies Action cars Infographic rotten movies we love Walt Disney Pictures cancelled television sequel SDCC HBO Go anime universal monsters historical drama A24 vampires Lifetime Christmas movies 71st Emmy Awards fast and furious space Awards Reality Martial Arts television joker Nat Geo cops batman Countdown classics Food Network GLAAD CW Seed latino dceu BET Awards Comics on TV Marvel Television Rocky kids social media finale BAFTA TruTV crossover green book The Purge BET Emmy Nominations animated dragons 2019 Election TV Land crime drama President Music Travel Channel canceled scary movies YouTube Red VOD Dark Horse Comics nfl Oscars slashers FOX Stephen King Valentine's Day SundanceTV Emmys IFC Opinion CBS TCA 2017 Sundance Now Writers Guild of America true crime Song of Ice and Fire serial killer Fox News reboot 2018 docudrama GoT witnail versus die hard Winners First Look war Pop 24 frames rotten Film singing competition Mudbound Cosplay golden globes MCU dark Box Office adventure cancelled Discovery Channel TNT FXX Arrowverse biography Logo 2017 films comic stoner Turner 2020 comiccon hollywood Sundance TV blaxploitation Extras Sci-Fi Television Critics Association Disney+ Disney Plus science fiction medical drama thriller cinemax canceled TV shows A&E hispanic ESPN Kids & Family TBS PaleyFest Television Academy Premiere Dates Apple TV+ Baby Yoda Trailer ratings Tubi Amazon Winter TV mockumentary Vudu Mary Poppins Returns First Reviews sitcom 4/20 reviews a nightmare on elm street satire movie game of thrones venice renewed TV shows YA Christmas ABC obituary DC streaming service Disney Plus Women's History Month Mary poppins FX on Hulu Masterpiece Crackle LGBTQ south america HBO Acorn TV Black History Month zombies festivals Marvel Studios Teen TV TV renewals 21st Century Fox Avengers diversity indie Syfy award winner Thanksgiving Calendar Tomatazos OneApp concert 45 Fall TV best WarnerMedia OWN Creative Arts Emmys YouTube Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Podcast Sony Pictures video Britbox Disney Channel crime thriller worst movies Apple TV Plus sag awards Anna Paquin richard e. Grant discovery Best and Worst toronto Superheroes Animation Spike cancelled TV series Lifetime Bravo GIFs Amazon Prime Video romantic comedy YouTube Premium APB Certified Fresh Mystery 2015 Film Festival Apple Starz comics Pixar San Diego Comic-Con Trophy Talk Awards Tour laika TLC Ovation Nickelodeon American Society of Cinematographers Summer supernatural Black Mirror Holidays cults zero dark thirty WGN Turner Classic Movies Comic Book zombie independent Star Trek Classic Film cooking police drama spanish language Pop TV elevated horror screenings Musical scorecard