Critics Consensus

Mary Queen of Scots: A Period Political Thriller With Smarts

Plus, Ben is Back and Season 2 of The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel are Certified Fresh.

by | December 6, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got a royal rivalry (Mary Queen of Scots, starring Saoirse Ronan and Margot Robbie) and a number of other films in limited release. What are the critics saying?


Mary Queen of Scots (2018) 63%

There aren’t any new films opening in wide release this week, but we do have one hotly anticipated limited release that is generating a lot of awards chatter. Academy Award nominees Saoirse Ronan and Margot Robbie co-star in this period historical drama about Mary Stuart (Ronan), Queen of France and heir to the Scottish throne, who challenged English Queen Elizabeth I’s (Robbie) claim over Scotland. Expectations were high for the film, with a spotlight aimed squarely at its two celebrated young stars and accomplished theater director Josie Rourke at the helm, and while critics concede it isn’t quite as captivating as some had hoped, it still looks spectacular and succeeds as a showcase for Ronan and Robbie’s considerable talents. Mary Queen of Scots may not serve up the most explosive political thrills, but it’s a smart, brilliantly acted slice of history with themes that should still ring true to contemporary audiences.


What’s New on TV

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel: Season 2 (2018) 91%

Like Midge herself, The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel charges full speed ahead in a second season brimming with warmth, empowerment, and a whole lot of laughs.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Amazing Grace (2019) , a concert documentary of Aretha Franklin’s 1972 Los Angeles performance of the titular gospel album, is at 100%.
  • The Charmer (Charmoren) (2018) , about an Iranian ex-pat in Denmark whose quest to marry into citizenship takes an unexpected turn, is at 88%.
  • Ben is Back (2018) , starring Julia Roberts and Lucas Hedges in a drama about a mother reconnecting with her newly returned drug-addict son, is Certified Fresh at 83%.
  • Divide and Conquer: The Story of Roger Ailes (2018) , a documentary about the controversial Fox News founder’s political influence, is at 83%.
  • Back Roads (2018) , a drama about the relationship between a married woman and a younger man caring for his three younger sisters, is at 82%.
  • Asher (2018) , starring Ron Perlman and Famke Janssen in a drama about an aging hitman who begins an unexpected romance, is at 75%.
  • Vox Lux (2018) , starring Natalie Portman as a pop superstar attempting a comeback whose rise to fame is marked by tragedy, is at 74%.
  • Clara's Ghost (2018) , a comedy-drama about the non-acting matriarch of a showbiz family and the spirit she may or may not be seeing, is at 67%.
  • Tyrel (2018) , about a black man who accompanies a friend to a weekend party and begins to feel uneasy about being the only minority present, is at 60%.
  • Great Great Great (2018) , about a bored woman who cheats on her boyfriend out of fear that they’re heading for a mediocre life, is at 60%.
  • Dumplin' (2018) , about the plus-sized daughter of a beauty queen who upends her mom’s pageant by entering it, is at 50%.
  • Swimming with Men (2018) , about a frustrated accountant who finds brotherhood in the other men like him in a synchronized swimming group, is at 45%.

Tag Cloud

series Sundance Now Nat Geo medical drama Nickelodeon Chilling Adventures of Sabrina YA Food Network BBC America unscripted Pop Peacock thriller Freeform Certified Fresh christmas movies Fantasy ABC Trophy Talk Academy Awards quibi discovery period drama name the review Pride Month SXSW Year in Review Song of Ice and Fire crime drama tv talk CNN Box Office Western blaxploitation TIFF Marvel Studios SDCC Spectrum Originals supernatural sag awards batman 21st Century Fox richard e. Grant VICE Election Schedule Television Academy Dark Horse Comics Musical Fox News The Purge comics Video Games Country book Infographic Writers Guild of America DC streaming service game of thrones Tomatazos Paramount Epix Binge Guide reboot cults spinoff Comic Book Masterpiece Star Wars USA Network Disney Plus LGBTQ ITV toy story Women's History Month independent Stephen King A&E adaptation Comedy Central Sundance game show Amazon Prime Video Elton John Superheroe Sundance TV DGA Creative Arts Emmys Netflix Christmas movies The Arrangement NYCC TNT Hallmark Christmas movies Emmy Nominations Awards rotten movies we love Podcast theme song Oscars Film Festival Rocky police drama 2016 revenge cinemax The CW dragons Nominations halloween First Look golden globes zombies breaking bad Discovery Channel psychological thriller RT History anime Comedy Netflix 2018 spider-man cancelled TV shows Cosplay cats Awards Tour Amazon Prime IFC Films New York Comic Con Winter TV Musicals screen actors guild facebook what to watch Rock children's TV versus Premiere Dates Disney psycho zombie DC Comics Vudu comiccon Fall TV Crackle joker Action USA indie 71st Emmy Awards Apple Best and Worst The Walking Dead Pet Sematary Paramount Network Mindy Kaling natural history singing competition Heroines Opinion The Witch Bravo TCA 2017 HBO Max LGBT American Society of Cinematographers PaleyFest Walt Disney Pictures CBS Holidays adventure Teen TCA canceled TV shows green book boxoffice anthology space OWN Music Black Mirror San Diego Comic-Con Sneak Peek ghosts travel E3 ABC Family Mary poppins crime thriller mutant Esquire Trailer true crime Animation Quiz Amazon Marvel Brie Larson Tumblr Emmys technology Arrowverse Shondaland slashers Logo romantic comedy Tubi OneApp Horror Holiday Syfy Columbia Pictures PBS movies YouTube cooking aliens Biopics Marathons ratings IFC MCU Baby Yoda TV Land Red Carpet directors CW Seed crime X-Men Ellie Kemper Adult Swim FX ESPN Kids & Family politics war DC Universe Disney Channel APB Anna Paquin canceled AMC Lucasfilm Set visit romance Superheroes History werewolf Disney streaming service sequel Lifetime Christmas movies Pixar Mary Poppins Returns Spring TV Mary Tyler Moore Valentine's Day Chernobyl Turner Classic Movies Crunchyroll Mudbound 007 Calendar zero dark thirty cars Apple TV Plus Starz GIFs Universal Watching Series Captain marvel elevated horror south america MTV cartoon Super Bowl hist YouTube Premium witnail Classic Film Drama festivals transformers composers BBC CMT Grammys Britbox teaser Extras Trivia NBC historical drama FOX 2017 BET jamie lee curtis dramedy sitcom SundanceTV Sci-Fi Cartoon Network TruTV television Lifetime spanish language Film Marvel Television Toys El Rey TLC 2020 Sony Pictures video 45 GLAAD social media WGN science fiction Summer streaming cops RT21 talk show Rom-Com Reality Comics on TV Reality Competition Ghostbusters screenings A24 HBO TV docudrama serial killer See It Skip It free movies political drama Rocketman spy thriller Cannes disaster TCM 24 frames DirecTV cancelled harry potter Turner FXX VH1 diversity foreign robots Lionsgate YouTube Red Winners National Geographic finale Thanksgiving Photos Apple TV+ Ovation dceu based on movie vampires doctor who cancelled television Martial Arts Christmas Spike crossover Pirates blockbuster 20th Century Fox Acorn TV E! mockumentary TBS 2019 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Hallmark Avengers nature binge Showtime WarnerMedia Shudder Disney+ Disney Plus First Reviews dc award winner TV renewals hispanic Family 2015 Hulu sports GoT latino strong female leads CBS All Access TCA Winter 2020 Endgame Warner Bros. kids spain Character Guide Interview animated stand-up comedy renewed TV shows MSNBC justice league casting cancelled TV series Mystery comic Star Trek Polls and Games miniseries Countdown Tarantino biography President