Critics Consensus

Mary Queen of Scots: A Period Political Thriller With Smarts

Plus, Ben is Back and Season 2 of The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel are Certified Fresh.

by | December 6, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got a royal rivalry (Mary Queen of Scots, starring Saoirse Ronan and Margot Robbie) and a number of other films in limited release. What are the critics saying?


Mary Queen of Scots (2018) 62%

There aren’t any new films opening in wide release this week, but we do have one hotly anticipated limited release that is generating a lot of awards chatter. Academy Award nominees Saoirse Ronan and Margot Robbie co-star in this period historical drama about Mary Stuart (Ronan), Queen of France and heir to the Scottish throne, who challenged English Queen Elizabeth I’s (Robbie) claim over Scotland. Expectations were high for the film, with a spotlight aimed squarely at its two celebrated young stars and accomplished theater director Josie Rourke at the helm, and while critics concede it isn’t quite as captivating as some had hoped, it still looks spectacular and succeeds as a showcase for Ronan and Robbie’s considerable talents. Mary Queen of Scots may not serve up the most explosive political thrills, but it’s a smart, brilliantly acted slice of history with themes that should still ring true to contemporary audiences.


What’s New on TV

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel: Season 2 (2018) 91%

Like Midge herself, The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel charges full speed ahead in a second season brimming with warmth, empowerment, and a whole lot of laughs.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Amazing Grace (2019) , a concert documentary of Aretha Franklin’s 1972 Los Angeles performance of the titular gospel album, is at 100%.
  • The Charmer (Charmoren) (2018) , about an Iranian ex-pat in Denmark whose quest to marry into citizenship takes an unexpected turn, is at 88%.
  • Ben is Back (2018) , starring Julia Roberts and Lucas Hedges in a drama about a mother reconnecting with her newly returned drug-addict son, is Certified Fresh at 83%.
  • Divide and Conquer: The Story of Roger Ailes (2018) , a documentary about the controversial Fox News founder’s political influence, is at 83%.
  • Back Roads (2018) , a drama about the relationship between a married woman and a younger man caring for his three younger sisters, is at 82%.
  • Asher (2018) , starring Ron Perlman and Famke Janssen in a drama about an aging hitman who begins an unexpected romance, is at 75%.
  • Vox Lux (2018) , starring Natalie Portman as a pop superstar attempting a comeback whose rise to fame is marked by tragedy, is at 74%.
  • Clara's Ghost (2018) , a comedy-drama about the non-acting matriarch of a showbiz family and the spirit she may or may not be seeing, is at 67%.
  • Tyrel (2018) , about a black man who accompanies a friend to a weekend party and begins to feel uneasy about being the only minority present, is at 60%.
  • Great Great Great (2018) , about a bored woman who cheats on her boyfriend out of fear that they’re heading for a mediocre life, is at 60%.
  • Dumplin' (2018) , about the plus-sized daughter of a beauty queen who upends her mom’s pageant by entering it, is at 50%.
  • Swimming with Men (2018) , about a frustrated accountant who finds brotherhood in the other men like him in a synchronized swimming group, is at 45%.

Tag Cloud

The CW X-Men Pirates The Walking Dead aliens natural history tv talk Paramount zombie stand-up comedy Oscars Academy Awards BBC movie Sundance dc political drama GLAAD Sundance TV Freeform video on demand Vudu Fall TV Kids & Family Endgame Cartoon Network blockbuster batman BET Awards Horror 2018 IFC reviews game show christmas movies FX on Hulu OneApp CW Seed book San Diego Comic-Con strong female leads Super Bowl Funimation RT History children's TV HBO Max mockumentary E! Amazon Studios Animation Anna Paquin YouTube Premium documentary Lionsgate YA BBC One science fiction Infographic National Geographic CNN History WarnerMedia Valentine's Day Lifetime Christmas movies Sundance Now Amazon Christmas werewolf Television Critics Association comedies Pop TV Opinion 2017 Shudder 2020 cancelled television free movies Spectrum Originals dogs Mary Tyler Moore Dark Horse Comics indie richard e. Grant Lucasfilm DC Universe Cannes Netflix A24 romance BAFTA Universal NYCC Summer dceu Amazon Prime canceled TV shows BET dragons TruTV independent Masterpiece Thanksgiving Marvel Studios Star Wars indiana jones Photos Ellie Kemper Apple Sci-Fi die hard doctor who The Purge vampires Premiere Dates Disney Channel Ghostbusters Watching Series politics psychological thriller Tubi Emmys 71st Emmy Awards Star Trek Syfy TCA Winter 2020 Starz adaptation supernatural VH1 Brie Larson ghosts NBC Disney Discovery Channel Year in Review Trivia Paramount Network Marathons festivals Rocketman Tomatazos USA Superheroe ITV Grammys Biopics transformers latino Crackle satire Binge Guide Winners Musicals toy story Black History Month adventure Awards Tour cults Box Office Rom-Com directors ABC Family robots DC Comics BBC America Holiday spanish language Spring TV jamie lee curtis Polls and Games anthology nature sports Trophy Talk Extras cancelled TV shows foreign TCA 2017 sitcom Character Guide miniseries FOX TV APB Fox News comiccon GoT witnail hist Reality blaxploitation social media chucky YouTube best Shondaland composers Warner Bros. television Marvel Martial Arts Disney streaming service Nat Geo sequel romantic comedy Hallmark canceled finale streaming Chernobyl dramedy Britbox elevated horror OWN TCA Awards YouTube Red Heroines Mudbound See It Skip It screen actors guild Ovation Video Games Sony Pictures Peacock Elton John child's play Quiz 2015 HBO renewed TV shows TV renewals Rock boxoffice TCA cooking TV Land universal monsters twilight Comedy Central crime thriller ABC Fantasy Action singing competition scary movies cops crime drama historical drama medical drama Interview what to watch A&E quibi spinoff Captain marvel travel Mary poppins Comic Book Spike binge El Rey biography Avengers Awards hispanic Family LGBT police drama a nightmare on elm street Rocky Stephen King Schedule PBS Adult Swim Sneak Peek VICE Acorn TV Certified Fresh MSNBC war Classic Film Walt Disney Pictures Mary Poppins Returns comics Amazon Prime Video psycho animated DC streaming service Mystery Women's History Month TIFF discovery 007 ESPN reboot GIFs Song of Ice and Fire 4/20 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt talk show Comedy WGN PaleyFest 21st Century Fox diversity LGBTQ series Pop SDCC Arrowverse HBO Go New York Comic Con Food Network Cosplay Musical Film Festival slashers crime crossover 24 frames Disney+ Disney Plus Teen movies spider-man Podcast ratings revenge space Countdown Hulu 2019 Film SXSW based on movie TNT critics cancelled cancelled TV series criterion mission: impossible anime Mindy Kaling SundanceTV Calendar VOD rotten movies we love Epix First Reviews theme song name the review Turner CBS President Travel Channel green book Baby Yoda TCM Holidays Hallmark Christmas movies Drama comic true crime Red Carpet Pet Sematary award winner Chilling Adventures of Sabrina MTV spain Apple TV+ breaking bad DirecTV parents Trailer teaser casting Pixar films disaster Toys RT21 joker Comics on TV Logo serial killer Reality Competition asian-american 20th Century Fox game of thrones 2016 south america Black Mirror MCU technology stoner sag awards TLC Showtime Bravo Marvel Television AMC Crunchyroll cartoon Writers Guild of America E3 harry potter Esquire dark news franchise zombies Hear Us Out PlayStation Emmy Nominations justice league CBS All Access unscripted American Society of Cinematographers golden globes IFC Films zero dark thirty documentaries Best and Worst spy thriller kids Television Academy thriller Country Creative Arts Emmys all-time The Witch Winter TV Tarantino First Look cats Pride Month Tumblr Nominations Western cinemax screenings Nickelodeon FXX Columbia Pictures USA Network Superheroes 45 facebook concert mutant video CMT Turner Classic Movies versus Music The Arrangement Election halloween DGA docudrama cars Apple TV Plus TBS FX Disney Plus Netflix Christmas movies period drama Set visit Lifetime