The Nightmare Before Christmas Turns 25 and Boys and Girls of Every Age Still Love It

As Tim Burton's Nightmare marks its 25th anniversary, we look back at why the story of Jack, Sally, and poor Sandy endures.

by | October 12, 2018 | Comments

Twenty five years ago, Tim Burton released one of the greatest Christmas movies of all time – and perhaps the greatest kid-friendly Halloween flick. The Nightmare Before Christmas, which Burton produced and Henry Selick directed, is cherished by the now thirtysomethings who grew up on it and worshipped by the Millennials who came after them and found, in Jack Skellington, an angsty, spindly brooder they could relate to (and plaster their jackets and backpacks with).

And it was almost not meant to be.

When first presented with the idea of adapting Nightmare — which had originated as a lengthy poem written by a 24-year-old Burton – Disney was hesitant. The kids were used to singing crustaceans and fish-tailed princess, not tearaway-faced clowns and pumpkin kings, whatever they were. Eventually, though, the studio would relent, and they’ve never turned back. The film opened in limited release on October 13, 1993, before going wide and becoming sleeper hit at the box office and the toy counter. More than just a merchandising machine, though, A Nightmare Before Christmas has become a holiday classic, recognized as a landmark in animation, and arguably the first claymation blockbuster. It’s been re-issued multiple times, and is set to sell out theaters again this month with a series of special anniversary screenings, including a set of double-feature screenings with Hocus Pocus for members of the D23 fan club. How has Burton and Selick’s film had legs as long as its troubled protagonist’s? We’ve got five reasons right here.

That Danny Elfman Score

(Photo by @ Buena Vista Pictures/courtesy Everett Collection)

Henry Selick said early in production there wasn’t even a script – “We had three songs by Danny Elfman but no real screenplay,” he told the Daily Beast’s Marlow Stern in 2013. One of those songs was “What’s This?”, which is the first sequence the filmmakers worked on, even as the screenplay was being completed. Still, if anything could inspire enough confidence to start production on something as laborious as a stop-motion film without a script, it would be Elfman’s Nightmare songs. Nearly all have become classics of some sort – anthems for moody teens (“Sally’s Song”), karaoke favorites (“Oogie Boogie’s Song”), some even holiday radio fixtures (“What’s This?”). It’s proven a lucrative project for the former Oingo Boingo frontman. Elfman voiced Jack Skellington in the movie (when singing) and continues to rake in the bullion traveling the world and performing the soundtrack in live concerts (we saw him in Adelaide, Australia, with a symphony orchestra and he was spectacular). In 2006, on the wave of all that Hot Topic Nightmare love, the soundtrack was re-issued with covers by the likes of Marilyn Manson and Fiona Apple, and a complete covers version, Nightmare Revisited, was released in 2008. The latter features a Korn cover of “Kidnap the Sandy Claws” that is all nightmare, no Christmas. You’ve been warned.

It’s So Freaking Beautiful

(Photo by @ Buena Vista Pictures/courtesy Everett Collection)

The painstaking work that went into crafting The Nightmare Before Christmas is the stuff of movie legend: the 20 sound stages the filmmakers used; the 400 different Jack Skellington heads deployed to convey emotions ranging from “I Jack the Pumpkin King!” fury to “What’s This?” wonder. And it’s work that pays off. Burton and Selick’s Halloween Town is a kind of ode to German Expressionism, all gray and winding and surreal, while Christmas Town is a freakish, exaggerated take on the visuals of Rankin/Bass. Perhaps the most indelible image from a movie filled with indelible images – Oogie’s unraveling, a snake scarfing down a Christmas tree – is the “spiral hill,” which rises, and unspools, somewhere outside of both towns and is where so many of the movie’s key moments take place.

And It’s So Freaking Dark

(Photo by @ Buena Vista Pictures/courtesy Everett Collection)

Disney was reluctant to touch Nightmare. They had toyed with making it a TV holiday special in the 1980s, when Burton was working there as an animator, but balked because it was considered a touch too weird. When the Mouse House did eventually agree to produce it, they distributed it through Touchstone Pictures, which typically distributes Disney-made films with darker edges. “Their biggest fear, and why it was kind of a stepchild project, was they were afraid of their core audience hating the film and not coming,” Selick told IGN in 2006 while promoting a 3D re-release of the movie. “But it was very much, ‘We don’t have high expectations. It’s kind of too dark and too scary.’” Thematically, there’s no doubt that the film is several shades darker than most of what Disney was releasing at the time (though The Lion King‘s big Mufasa moment and Scar’s “Be Prepared” would come close a year later). There was death and bogeymen, the vicious kidnapping of Sandy Claws, and shrieking suburban children. Of course, what Burton, Selick, and Elfman knew was that it was precisely this darkness that would capture the imaginations of kids who loved the costumes, imagery, and stories of Halloween. And who had grown up watching horror movies on TV and VHS. The special darkness the filmmakers conjured was essential to the movie’s overall message, too. Here was a film that was all about embracing your differences, your otherness, your oddness; and here was a movie that itself looked and felt as different from the rest of what was being offered in cinemas as its central character had felt in Christmas Town. Like Jack, it would eventually be heartily embraced.

It’s a Really Moving Love Story

(Photo by @ Buena Vista Pictures/courtesy Everett Collection)

If Skellington was looking for another holiday to take over, he could do worse than Valentine’s Day. The terrifying pumpkin king reveals his mushier side in Nightmare not just through his fascination with Christmas, but through his adoration of Sally, and their love story anchors the movie. Jack is a less unlikely source of Sally’s affections – and those of goth girls all across the world – than you might initially think. He’s a kind of manic pixie dream ghoul: sensitive, inventive (those chalkboard formulas!), and has a good heart; plus he knows how to dress. And don’t be deceived by Sally’s lilting voice, courtesy of the great Catherine O’Hara – she’s no sewn-together Snow White. Sally proves herself time and again to be practical, brave, and resourceful, whether escaping the clutches of her mad creator or saving Sandy Claws from Oogie Boogie with a distracting — and, for a Disney flick, disarmingly sexy – leg. Jack’s the wild dreamer, the frustrated genius; Sally’s the level-headed partner ready to catch him when he eventually, and literally, falls. Plain as anyone can see, they’re simply meant to be.


(Photo by ©Focus Features/Courtesy Everett Collection)
Stop-motion animation has a long and storied history, but it wasn’t until Nightmare that it became a fixture at American multiplexes. Which is not surprising: the movie made $50 million domestically in its initial theatrical run (it has since added about $25 million to that total with various re-issues). And then there’s all that merch. Needless to say, the lights started turning green. Henry Selick followed Nightmare up with James and the Giant Peach (Certified Fresh at 92%), and then the stop-motion/live-action film, Monkeybone (the less said the better). He hit his stride again working with Oregon studio Laika, releasing Coraline in 2009. That studio is a kind of spiritual successor to Nightmare, focusing on darker and consistently acclaimed stop-motion fare like ParaNormanThe Boxtrolls, and Kubo and the Two Strings. Burton himself would return to the medium with Corpse Bride, this time co-directing with Mike Johnson; the movie is Certified Fresh at 84%, but hasn’t quite endured in the same way Nightmare has. Across the pond, Aardman Animation had been producing claymation animated series like Wallace and Gromit for decades before Nightmare‘s release, but it was only in its wake that they released their first feature, Chicken Run – which remains one of the best-reviewed animated movies ever. Lately, Wes Anderson has taken to the form for two canine-centered stories, applying his signature particularism to Fantastic Mr Fox and, this year, Isle of Dogs. Stop-motion films perform particularly well on the Tomatometer, too: stop-motion movies released over the last 10 years have an average Tomatometer of almost 90%.

Do you still watch Nightmare every Christmas – and Halloween? Ever dressed as Jack or Sally? Still remember the lyrics to “This is Halloween”? Share your Nightmare Before Christmas memories below.

The Nightmare Before Christmas was released October 13, 1993

Adjusted Score: 102.702%
Critics Consensus: The Nightmare Before Christmas is a stunningly original and visually delightful work of stop-motion animation.
Synopsis: Despite having recently presided over a very successful Halloween, Jack Skellington, aka the Pumpkin King, is bored with his job... [More]
Directed By: Henry Selick, Tim Burton

Tag Cloud

cats romantic comedy halloween Rocky Mary poppins Turner Classic Movies mockumentary New York Comic Con 2016 Drama Mary Poppins Returns comics mutant hispanic Logo Biopics travel Tomatazos Grammys Rom-Com Vudu Star Trek Ghostbusters Syfy Cartoon Network Amazon Prime jamie lee curtis Trivia Paramount Network Animation directors video Marathons breaking bad YouTube Spike war Walt Disney Pictures Endgame Britbox TV TV renewals Starz MSNBC award winner Ovation Best and Worst facebook Star Wars south america Disney Channel SXSW miniseries comiccon ABC Family Columbia Pictures screenings 21st Century Fox discovery Martial Arts hist Comics on TV Christmas Horror Marvel Television disaster Elton John TNT Pride Month American Society of Cinematographers Masterpiece cartoon psychological thriller HBO Comic Book game of thrones Disney streaming service Netflix Christmas movies Tarantino Pop Avengers Rock quibi 45 dramedy children's TV what to watch police drama Nickelodeon X-Men Apple TV+ Anna Paquin USA Network DGA diversity harry potter The Arrangement Film Festival FXX Tumblr GIFs foreign ITV Nat Geo robots SDCC composers talk show Cannes LGBTQ RT21 Opinion Paramount Oscars DirecTV Photos rotten movies we love movie National Geographic finale anime casting Infographic Acorn TV Apple 2015 canceled Holidays BET green book anthology USA Marvel E! Sundance Now adventure OneApp GoT CBS All Access spain Reality Sundance Video Games joker 2018 A&E Film sitcom renewed TV shows Adult Swim animated spider-man slashers Countdown adaptation Teen Premiere Dates Hallmark Christmas movies boxoffice Disney+ Disney Plus zombie ghosts Lionsgate blockbuster free movies richard e. Grant toy story zombies Trailer blaxploitation Spring TV BBC series Netflix Classic Film San Diego Comic-Con Freeform science fiction Crunchyroll Amazon DC Universe The CW Cosplay Marvel Studios cancelled TV series Amazon Prime Video vampires Sneak Peek FX comic El Rey MCU Quiz natural history NYCC Action A24 Trophy Talk doctor who Comedy Character Guide Warner Bros. Superheroe period drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Apple TV Plus Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Red Carpet DC streaming service YouTube Red Captain marvel TruTV Writers Guild of America cancelled television Hallmark DC Comics Epix Brie Larson christmas movies Chernobyl Winners Musicals politics Shondaland Sci-Fi Reality Competition name the review 20th Century Fox Western Spectrum Originals Shudder TCA Winter 2020 NBC technology reboot dceu singing competition golden globes television Awards Mudbound social media Extras Peacock 71st Emmy Awards Discovery Channel crime aliens OWN TCM biography cars Crackle Year in Review Musical 2019 supernatural crime drama Nominations festivals CBS cinemax cooking Pirates docudrama zero dark thirty thriller Arrowverse Holiday spinoff SundanceTV cults cancelled TV shows Emmy Nominations Set visit ABC dragons CNN medical drama WGN romance First Look PaleyFest Heroines strong female leads 24 frames Song of Ice and Fire LGBT 2020 Pet Sematary kids game show Valentine's Day independent IFC President Superheroes Fantasy book YA witnail Calendar Turner theme song CMT Baby Yoda TBS Women's History Month tv talk werewolf psycho VH1 Fox News batman Disney Sony Pictures The Witch Winter TV justice league The Purge Toys streaming Disney Plus teaser canceled TV shows Thanksgiving Election 007 cops Food Network Music Academy Awards latino Showtime Binge Guide Ellie Kemper BBC America Hulu revenge spanish language stand-up comedy cancelled HBO Max Esquire See It Skip It Mindy Kaling indie Summer Dark Horse Comics Fall TV spy thriller dc Polls and Games FOX historical drama Universal TIFF Emmys Rocketman crime thriller GLAAD Lifetime Christmas movies Super Bowl versus APB RT History true crime Lifetime unscripted TCA 2017 screen actors guild Kids & Family Awards Tour elevated horror Pixar Stephen King Interview Black Mirror IFC Films transformers crossover sequel Sundance TV Lucasfilm ESPN Comedy Central CW Seed nature Watching Series E3 TLC TCA Schedule Box Office sports VICE Amazon Studios Tubi First Reviews MTV TV Land binge History The Walking Dead Podcast ratings serial killer WarnerMedia sag awards based on movie space YouTube Premium Creative Arts Emmys Television Academy Mary Tyler Moore Country AMC movies PBS Certified Fresh Family documentary political drama Mystery 2017 Bravo