P-Valley Goes Beyond the Twerk, New Series' Creator Says

Series creator Katori Hall and lead Brandee Evans want to tell the story of strippers through the female gaze.

by | July 10, 2020 | Comments

One of the first scenes in P-Valley shows a scantily clad woman on a pole — but she’s not gyrating or enticing some horny onlookers in the audience. No, this woman – Mercedes, star Brandee Evans’ queen bee of The Pynk strip club – is backstage mocking one of the patrons she so easily cons into parting with his hard-earned cash.

After performing show-stopping routines all night, she is also sore and tired.

Starz series P-Valley centers on exotic dancers in the swampy Mississippi Delta, and — make no mistake — nudity and sex scenes definitely occur. But the show is less about tantalizing and twerking and more about the talented (and often voiceless) women who work hard to make it look like they can fulfill sexual fantasies while barely breaking a sweat.

And it’s getting rave reviews for its efforts.

P-Valley blends the profane, the sacred, and the politics of the almighty dollar to tell engrossing stories about Black women on the margins who use their bodies to keep families and communities afloat. It’s also one of the year’s best new shows,” TV Guide’s Malcolm Venable wrote about the first season, which is currently Fresh on the Tomatometer at 100% with 10 reviews.

Series creator Katori Hall told Rotten Tomatoes that one of the intentions of her show was to explore the female gaze.

“We have inherited this huge box of hyper-sexualized images of women,” said Hall, who made a point of only hiring female directors for the eight-episode first season. But on P-Valley, Hall said, “we were just adamant that all sexuality was going to be in service to plot, and it was always going to be a reflection of characters in the world.”

Brandee Evans and Elarica Johnson in Starz's P-Valley.

(Photo by Starz)

Hall adapted the drama from her play, P—y Valley, which uses the missing letters of that title. The show’s opening credits also show the full title, but Hall said that they are officially using this “little, clean nickname” because that will make it easier for things like billboards and TV listings. Hall developed the play’s story by conducting research and interviews in visits to more than 40 strip clubs over a span of six years. She met the female performers and was able to “really get behind the scenes with them — not only at the club, but [be] really interested in their lives. I’ve met their husbands, their sons, their daughters, and really got to know them on an intimate level.”

“When people think of the strip club, they don’t think of a theatrical experience,” Hall added. “They don’t think of strength. They just think of exploitation, and we wanted to show there’s flight in this space, and there’s also falling in this space. And there is a dance between exploitation and liberation.”

The opening credits song, which Hall wrote with Memphis rapper Jucee Froot — and which Froot performs — includes taunting lines like “we make falling on the sky look easy,” but also “green on the floor/money talk/can you hear me?”

The show features a predominately Black cast, which is authentic to what Hall experienced in these clubs during her research, but may look different to viewers in other parts of the world.

Series star Evans explained: “On P-Valley, we’re showing you the Southern style; we’re showing you the Black experience in the South. So you’re going to hear people say ‘that’s not how we are’ and that’s OK. But that’s how this is. In the South. In the Black club. This is what’s truly going on, and I hope that you look beyond the ladies on the pole and on the stage and go, ‘What’s in their heart?’”

Vickie Eng and Nicco Annan in P-Valley season 1

(Photo by © Starz)

Beyond the dancing, a mysterious new girl, Autumn Night (Elarica Johnson) joins The Pynk’s ranks, and another plot involves talk of a shady corporate takeover. An LGBTQIA love story centers on Nicco Annan’s Uncle Clifford, the Pynk’s madam who identifies as gender fluid, uses “she/her” pronouns, and knows how to rock some eyeliner and heels. This character could easily have become a stereotype with one false step, but Hall said she and the other writers made a point of grounding her by showing how she reacts in various environments — be it as a mom, a pimp, a savvy business person, or simply a comforting friend.

“It’s this very kaleidoscopic lens that we’re viewing this character from,” she said. “That’s why Uncle Clifford feels like this fully fleshed-out human being instead of this walking stereotype with the hair and nails. We actually see when the hair and nails come off.”

Uncle Clifford is just one of many ways the show is fighting preconceived prejudices – and not just from potential audiences. Although star Evans taught a dance class called Hip Hop in Heels, which was meant to help inspire confidence in its women attendees, she told Rotten Tomatoes that exotic dancing was a whole other matter, and she had to learn to twerk for the part. She eventually did almost all of her own stunts and dances in the show.

Brandee Evans in P-Valley season 1

(Photo by Starz)

Evans is also a preacher’s daughter from Memphis. She remembers tentatively telling the wife of her current pastor about the part, worried she’d be shunned by her community. Instead, the other woman excitedly asked for the show’s time and channel.

Evans’ Mercedes, however, does not have such a positive experience with the church. P-Valley discusses the character’s relationship with her mother, Patrice (Harriett D. Foy), who has found Jesus in her later years. Patrice dreams of her turn at the pulpit, just as Mercedes dreams of leaving the pole behind to open a gym where she can build out her other business as a cheerleading coach. Although the two women do not see eye-to-eye, P-Valley argues that they have a similar ability to hustle.

“The church is held up because it is this patriarchal system, and the fact that you have this woman who really wants to have her own business and be on her pulpit,” Hall explained. “Juxtapose that with Mercedes. She wants to be with her own studio; on her own stage. They’re actually striving for the same thing, just in two completely different worlds.”

Hall added that though many women have to struggle to break into most arenas, “this show really demonstrates that you can be a woman of high moral regard in one space, but you’re still gonna struggle as much, if not more than, the woman that you look down upon.”

Stories of exotic dancers have long struggled for legitimacy. The 1995 film Showgirls is heralded for its camp, and 1998’s The Players Club is frequently left out of the conversation all together. The Jennifer Lopez–starring 2019 film Hustlers is Certified Fresh on the Tomatometer, but neither she nor others involved with the film received any Oscar nominations as many had predicted.

The public has also been fascinated by the rise of musician Cardi B, a former stripper who Hall followed during her days in the clubs. The series creator describes her as “one of the queens of rap now.”

“Without Cardi B, you just continue to think of the women as objects,” Hall said. “But when she ascended to her rightful throne, I think it really showed that there is a way out of this world and that the women who end up passing through are complicated … I think this is a very powerful message to society. Oftentimes, this this space is used as a as a stepping stone and it has led to a lot of financial freedom.”

P-Valley premieres on Sunday, July 12 at 8 p.m. on Starz.

P-Valley: Season 1 (2020)

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: A stunning, lyrical piece of neon noir, P-Valley explores the unseen lives of strippers in Mississippi through Katori Hall's singular gaze, celebrating the beauty of the craft without sugarcoating the challenges.

Tag Cloud

halloween tv pirates of the caribbean quibi Tumblr basketball latino Cosplay joker laika asian-american Winners TV know your critic live event discovery MTV comiccon biography Food Network news Disney+ Disney Plus DGA Podcast BAFTA The Purge MSNBC IFC kaiju toy story fresh 2019 CNN Calendar Photos aliens crime drama comic book movies A&E godzilla toronto Discovery Channel Lucasfilm Oscars Image Comics Film jamie lee curtis streaming movies scary movies political drama 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards BBC One crossover 007 Disney Channel stop motion Hallmark Christmas movies LGBTQ ITV new star wars movies cartoon Character Guide cancelled Comedy Central Cartoon Network Ellie Kemper die hard Thanksgiving TCM boxing italian anthology Star Trek E! romance Musicals worst Sundance Now 73rd Emmy Awards Hulu boxoffice Mary Tyler Moore festivals TCA Winter 2020 TCA Awards young adult vampires WarnerMedia debate Television Academy First Reviews films critic resources Rocky sports mcc travel GoT natural history ratings SXSW National Geographic jurassic park sitcom television TV renewals a nightmare on elm street X-Men 99% Superheroe Fox News Funimation christmas movies rom-coms documentary war based on movie revenge Quiz Rocketman dc Mystery Sundance nfl trailers science fiction popular obituary live action Vudu blaxploitation Disney streaming service Baby Yoda VH1 Anna Paquin Marathons genre Winter TV strong female leads blockbusters Academy Awards dexter Comic Book art house Trophy Talk 2018 ESPN scene in color mutant king kong Sci-Fi Freeform The Arrangement The Walt Disney Company FX on Hulu Super Bowl Elton John golden globe awards Disney franchise marvel cinematic universe comics cults Tomatazos Amazon SundanceTV Avengers 72 Emmy Awards anime harry potter what to watch FXX batman Wes Anderson stoner Netflix Christmas movies Drama rotten movies we love Lifetime Crackle Pop binge documentaries Travel Channel dramedy japanese kids new zealand green book 2016 name the review satire TV movies award winner Pride Month Amazon Studios Exclusive Video telelvision spain 93rd Oscars screen actors guild Marvel APB medical drama IFC Films Holidays Starz thriller Toys south america ID Chernobyl Teen Ovation YouTube streaming action-comedy BET Awards zombies Interview crime robots DC Comics technology razzies video on demand Crunchyroll adventure theme song Mindy Kaling Apple TV+ 45 21st Century Fox docuseries Comedy spider-verse prank dogs Amazon Prime Premiere Dates The Walking Dead crime thriller directors VICE composers Esquire nbcuniversal Action LGBT finale superhero American Society of Cinematographers Countdown El Rey Arrowverse hist Best and Worst posters Amazon Prime Video SDCC unscripted facebook Polls and Games NYCC gangster politics book adaptation E3 screenings Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Cannes Music Spike spinoff Ghostbusters dark Logo child's play Turner breaking bad Certified Fresh slashers TBS royal family Pixar Rom-Com critics Video Games GLAAD monster movies Summer Sundance TV TCA 2017 Endgame diversity versus A24 Television Critics Association black Nickelodeon CW Seed lord of the rings Comic-Con@Home 2021 The Academy true crime IMDb TV RT History Pirates Paramount 2017 new york cats BBC America transformers adaptation Neflix CBS All Access Writers Guild of America TV Land History video Universal Pictures emmy awards Family Paramount Plus Sneak Peek YA kong ABC Family Western comic book movie adenture TCA spanish police drama Awards DirecTV canceled TV shows scary Mary Poppins Returns FOX Broadway San Diego Comic-Con free movies biopic sequels Spectrum Originals Instagram Live indiana jones Fantasy Marvel Television space Red Carpet Dark Horse Comics YouTube Red feel good mob hispanic heritage month Alien twilight classics werewolf Black Mirror Walt Disney Pictures docudrama Schedule casting Comics on TV comedies remakes all-time HBO sag awards king arthur ViacomCBS spanish language olympics DC Universe indie venice Britbox Election slasher 20th Century Fox Apple mockumentary parents Columbia Pictures ghosts richard e. Grant comic suspense serial killer PlayStation Rock 4/20 psycho Fox Searchlight WGN james bond Turner Classic Movies Film Festival game show rotten teaser New York Comic Con Martial Arts Emmys animated wonder woman Horror football The CW TruTV dceu Country Year in Review legend Shondaland Captain marvel Awards Tour AMC Plus talk show Tokyo Olympics rt labs critics edition Legendary BET HBO Max historical drama superman Tarantino worst movies Hallmark target miniseries Mudbound BBC 90s scorecard PBS witnail TIFF doctor who tv talk hispanic TV One Trailer NBA festival Christmas Lionsgate OWN Bravo chucky Reality Competition deadpool series cars CMT best halloween cancelled television Set visit The Witch President 1990s Paramount Network Spring TV elevated horror Pop TV Adult Swim Valentine's Day cancelled TV series 2015 AMC hidden camera dragons concert social media YouTube Premium Infographic archives aapi Pacific Islander universal monsters Holiday mission: impossible Mary poppins spider-man Creative Arts Emmys OneApp zero dark thirty renewed TV shows Kids & Family Acorn TV hollywood Emmy Nominations See It Skip It Marvel Studios sequel 2020 cops Binge Guide Disney Plus criterion Pet Sematary nature rt archives Nominations 71st Emmy Awards psychological thriller Tubi GIFs period drama sopranos Trivia Stephen King comic books Lifetime Christmas movies Peacock black comedy stand-up comedy marvel comics Heroines Box Office NBC Grammys foreign cancelled TV shows Women's History Month children's TV ABC Signature Musical FX Nat Geo Star Wars cinemax CBS Netflix Fall TV PaleyFest blockbuster Extras USA Network 2021 Black History Month rt labs vs. zombie Song of Ice and Fire canceled Hear Us Out VOD game of thrones Sony Pictures heist movie romantic comedy supernatural reboot disaster Watching Series women Opinion TNT french Universal Showtime MCU First Look RT21 book DC streaming service Masterpiece japan Epix international spy thriller Reality HBO Go golden globes 24 frames independent australia USA Apple TV Plus Warner Bros. dreamworks singing competition Syfy movies Shudder ABC justice league Animation movie Brie Larson cooking Biopics reviews Superheroes fast and furious Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Classic Film saw high school TLC