Showdowns

Robert De Niro vs. Al Pacino: Who Wins Our Epic Actor Battle?

We're crunching the numbers to see which actor-gangster is the bestfella.

by | November 27, 2019 | Comments

Robert De Niro reunites with Al Pacino this month in Martin Scorsese’s The Irishman, the epic and Certified Fresh new Netflix gangster flick. The two actors – who last shared the screen in Michael Mann’s Heat – have been getting plenty of Oscar buzz for the movie in which Pacino plays infamous Teamster leader Jimmy Hoffa and De Niro plays his right-hand man, Frank “The Irishman” Sheeran. If either wins big this awards season, they will be adding to an already heaving trophy shelf. But who between Pacino and De Niro is the ultimate king of the big screen? We’re looking to settle that question by looking at their Tomatometer scores, box office performance, iconic roles, and one wild card category. Did we get it right? Let us know in the comments. (Yes, we’re talking to you.)

The Irishman is currently available on Netflix. 

#1

The Irishman (2019)
96%

#1
Adjusted Score: 115.7%
Critics Consensus: An epic gangster drama that earns its extended runtime, The Irishman finds Martin Scorsese revisiting familiar themes to poignant, funny, and profound effect.
Synopsis: This biographical crime thriller follows Frank Sheeran (Robert De Niro) as he recalls his past years working for the Bufalino... [More]
Directed By: Martin Scorsese

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Holidays Opinion justice league X-Men Sundance travel VICE zombies screenings cars Pirates TBS cancelled TV series video comics stoner BBC One Apple Oscars IFC comic Heroines sag awards MSNBC Pet Sematary vampires book Rocky American Society of Cinematographers Song of Ice and Fire FX on Hulu DC Universe spider-man satire Star Trek Cartoon Network animated FOX Disney comedies talk show 2017 Freeform golden globes Peacock adaptation cancelled television Sci-Fi cancelled technology E3 diversity History Dark Horse Comics adventure Nominations Captain marvel romantic comedy FX renewed TV shows CBS Vudu Tubi Disney streaming service spinoff Trivia OWN Sneak Peek toy story Food Network television Music hist quibi YouTube Premium what to watch reviews Ghostbusters Pop TV Interview witnail supernatural Infographic foreign Walt Disney Pictures Sundance TV films The Arrangement Baby Yoda Acorn TV best Fox News stop motion Amazon dceu WarnerMedia Rocketman breaking bad emmy awards Year in Review BET Awards Crackle south america rotten movies we love die hard President award winner politics Television Critics Association APB Marvel Television christmas movies children's TV comiccon social media Cannes Star Wars The Witch mockumentary crossover joker Amazon Prime Video romance twilight FXX Schedule crime drama YA teaser Nat Geo ratings Bravo rotten concert Disney Plus mutant spain Polls and Games BAFTA Reality A&E Film Black Mirror zero dark thirty Video Games YouTube HBO harry potter robots dark indie Turner Discovery Channel Mary Poppins Returns 45 CBS All Access canceled TV shows TV Land Classic Film political drama spanish language SXSW Lifetime Christmas movies Horror Universal Esquire TCM 21st Century Fox DirecTV Reality Competition news Spectrum Originals Tarantino child's play Winter TV batman Spring TV First Look facebook worst GoT 24 frames Amazon Studios true crime Fantasy medical drama cinemax boxoffice NBC ITV Family Travel Channel nature Amazon Prime dramedy psychological thriller PaleyFest series Set visit The Walking Dead Academy Awards sports critics Chernobyl PlayStation TCA 2017 franchise Summer MTV Disney Channel Film Festival First Reviews Trailer HBO Go OneApp Ellie Kemper police drama VOD New York Comic Con National Geographic Comics on TV documentary ESPN Martial Arts doctor who hollywood A24 CW Seed binge Netflix Christmas movies blaxploitation E! Super Bowl Quiz zombie movies spy thriller Hulu SDCC Thanksgiving Western transformers VH1 cartoon a nightmare on elm street latino Marathons Nickelodeon SundanceTV dogs USA Endgame dc AMC festivals Elton John WGN historical drama The CW Sundance Now TCA Awards Musicals Animation 4/20 Arrowverse finale Apple TV+ hispanic movie 72 Emmy Awards cancelled TV shows serial killer indiana jones scary movies crime San Diego Comic-Con Fall TV Hallmark based on movie NYCC LGBT Winners PBS RT History Shudder jamie lee curtis Hallmark Christmas movies Television Academy CNN singing competition YouTube Red Valentine's Day Ovation space superhero Logo documentaries El Rey IFC Films Shondaland casting Red Carpet fast and furious DGA 2020 classics chucky strong female leads nbcuniversal disaster 2018 TruTV Musical TNT revenge GLAAD Best and Worst criterion See It Skip It elevated horror theme song Grammys Marvel Studios Awards Tour 2019 TCA Winter 2020 Comedy Central Spike streaming Starz ghosts Avengers Country name the review obituary Extras USA Network Character Guide docudrama tv talk mission: impossible Mystery Podcast Writers Guild of America Showtime blockbuster Tumblr DC streaming service TLC DC Comics canceled Pride Month Calendar BBC America Election psycho Stephen King Emmys Holiday game of thrones anime Netflix Lucasfilm green book Disney+ Disney Plus TCA composers reboot Mudbound TV stand-up comedy Mary poppins sitcom CMT Superheroe war TV renewals versus aliens Anna Paquin Biopics independent Columbia Pictures HBO Max universal monsters cops Binge Guide free movies Cosplay Comedy sequel Women's History Month Christmas Kids & Family Syfy laika 71st Emmy Awards cooking Countdown screen actors guild 20th Century Fox 007 Creative Arts Emmys asian-american werewolf Rom-Com directors richard e. Grant Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Box Office Marvel Masterpiece Drama Adult Swim Photos Mindy Kaling Pop LGBTQ Paramount Funimation Emmy Nominations cats ABC Family Comic Book cults Epix 2016 Brie Larson TIFF MCU slashers unscripted Pixar all-time Apple TV Plus Superheroes miniseries Crunchyroll game show Paramount Network ABC GIFs anthology period drama Hear Us Out kids parents Toys Black History Month Rock BBC BET Lionsgate crime thriller video on demand Action Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dragons discovery Britbox natural history RT21 halloween Premiere Dates Teen Tomatazos Watching Series science fiction biography Certified Fresh The Purge Turner Classic Movies Trophy Talk Lifetime 2015 Sony Pictures Mary Tyler Moore Warner Bros. Awards thriller