Robert De Niro vs. Al Pacino: Who Wins Our Epic Actor Battle?

We're crunching the numbers to see which actor-gangster is the bestfella.

by | November 27, 2019 | Comments

Robert De Niro reunites with Al Pacino this month in Martin Scorsese’s The Irishman, the epic and Certified Fresh new Netflix gangster flick. The two actors – who last shared the screen in Michael Mann’s Heat – have been getting plenty of Oscar buzz for the movie in which Pacino plays infamous Teamster leader Jimmy Hoffa and De Niro plays his right-hand man, Frank “The Irishman” Sheeran. If either wins big this awards season, they will be adding to an already heaving trophy shelf. But who between Pacino and De Niro is the ultimate king of the big screen? We’re looking to settle that question by looking at their Tomatometer scores, box office performance, iconic roles, and one wild card category. Did we get it right? Let us know in the comments. (Yes, we’re talking to you.)

The Irishman is currently available on Netflix. 


The Irishman (2019)

Adjusted Score: 115.654%
Critics Consensus: An epic gangster drama that earns its extended runtime, The Irishman finds Martin Scorsese revisiting familiar themes to poignant, funny, and profound effect.
Synopsis: This biographical crime thriller follows Frank Sheeran (Robert De Niro) as he recalls his past years working for the Bufalino... [More]
Directed By: Martin Scorsese

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Disney 2018 crime werewolf hist Countdown romantic comedy Acorn TV Winners BAFTA independent Reality Emmys BBC films binge Interview Walt Disney Pictures Character Guide Apple TV+ Amazon Fantasy Funimation National Geographic SDCC X-Men Musicals anthology Comics on TV miniseries Captain marvel AMC Disney streaming service a nightmare on elm street HBO Go Mary Tyler Moore Awards versus italian mockumentary Sundance MCU all-time south america indiana jones fast and furious Super Bowl natural history Marvel Studios golden globes A24 universal monsters American Society of Cinematographers Baby Yoda IFC Hear Us Out worst movies DC streaming service venice remakes Spring TV President Vudu Polls and Games First Reviews Mudbound Food Network NYCC Stephen King BBC America TV casting news E3 Winter TV Country Trailer Showtime Trophy Talk Endgame See It Skip It jamie lee curtis ID animated Arrowverse adventure adaptation Hallmark Christmas movies Holidays Certified Fresh TCA Awards Anna Paquin Pop strong female leads Universal 71st Emmy Awards zombie Kids & Family ITV free movies Shudder DC Comics Comic Book discovery cancelled TV shows politics Academy Awards Mystery CMT WGN quibi blaxploitation Amazon Prime TCA 2017 deadpool doctor who IFC Films Spike boxoffice Film Festival Crunchyroll die hard Comedy scary movies slashers latino Warner Bros. child's play streaming mission: impossible historical drama SXSW name the review worst LGBT TV Land Box Office Christmas Lifetime Superheroe rt archives Sci-Fi Lucasfilm Awards Tour anime japanese Travel Channel TV renewals thriller sequel joker richard e. Grant Year in Review PaleyFest OneApp archives zombies french Summer Thanksgiving NBC halloween directors Marvel Television sitcom First Look Writers Guild of America Disney Plus Music Creative Arts Emmys comic books Black Mirror Comedy Central Women's History Month Nickelodeon true crime Podcast Pride Month TruTV 2015 stand-up comedy Fall TV Opinion 20th Century Fox indie cinemax hollywood based on movie The Purge Family 72 Emmy Awards Columbia Pictures psycho criterion vampires Premiere Dates Martial Arts game show ABC Family Tomatazos BET Biopics MSNBC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt stoner YA Amazon Studios technology The Arrangement Apple Song of Ice and Fire talk show 2019 Binge Guide Best and Worst Cosplay obituary 45 Masterpiece sag awards satire Mary Poppins Returns video on demand Animation critics television children's TV dogs Marathons TLC 21st Century Fox Video Games comics travel serial killer psychological thriller Schedule Trivia Apple TV Plus DirecTV A&E El Rey Avengers USA Network VOD Fox News green book Netflix stop motion MTV ESPN unscripted disaster Election Toys scorecard comedies Rocketman Western Tarantino mutant cats Drama Chernobyl batman Syfy Turner Classic Movies rotten BET Awards movies concert police drama 2016 Holiday zero dark thirty cancelled television The Walking Dead transformers hispanic TCA Disney Channel FXX Hulu Photos crossover twilight FOX Ghostbusters Mindy Kaling parents kids Rock Black History Month TCM social media ghosts Set visit tv talk Sundance Now book Pop TV TIFF YouTube Red franchise History CW Seed Tumblr FX Red Carpet Discovery Channel HBO Max dramedy dragons breaking bad CBS All Access Netflix Christmas movies foreign Reality Competition award winner Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cancelled TV series james bond festival romance GIFs Emmy Nominations rotten movies we love GoT VH1 DGA DC Universe Sony Pictures dceu Adult Swim superhero comic E! witnail political drama Grammys The Witch TNT period drama Brie Larson Peacock medical drama Star Wars HBO canceled dark Ovation Nominations USA science fiction OWN 24 frames elevated horror Quiz comiccon football theme song GLAAD game of thrones 2017 Sneak Peek YouTube Premium Watching Series emmy awards blockbuster Lifetime Christmas movies Paramount Network Spectrum Originals Dark Horse Comics documentary toy story Pixar Sundance TV dc Star Trek cancelled nbcuniversal Hallmark Rocky composers WarnerMedia Pet Sematary canceled TV shows cults Logo spy thriller halloween tv screen actors guild asian-american Starz VICE Classic Film nature spain Oscars spinoff Mary poppins finale Nat Geo APB Britbox 007 toronto Paramount San Diego Comic-Con Infographic Horror Heroines black spider-man Action cartoon Pirates series Elton John cooking laika Fox Searchlight RT21 nfl Tubi Bravo festivals The CW teaser Amazon Prime Video movie Extras Film Rom-Com revenge aliens BBC One Musical reboot christmas movies documentaries spanish language reviews Epix Superheroes space 4/20 TCA Winter 2020 chucky ABC SundanceTV The Academy best supernatural what to watch Crackle facebook crime drama Television Academy TBS Esquire cars 2020 video Shondaland LGBTQ Television Critics Association PBS classics harry potter docudrama biography New York Comic Con Marvel Disney+ Disney Plus cops renewed TV shows australia CBS Freeform singing competition PlayStation Lionsgate war robots YouTube CNN Ellie Kemper sports justice league FX on Hulu Teen crime thriller RT History sequels Cannes ratings Calendar Cartoon Network Turner diversity spanish Valentine's Day screenings