Rotten Tomatoes' Early Oscar Predictions: Best Supporting Actress

Margot Robbie leaps into the race alongside Laura Dern, Annette Bening, and a surprising newcomer.

by | November 4, 2019 | Comments

Charlize Theron, Nicole Kidman, Margot Robbie (Photo by Courtesy of Lionsgate (Hillary Bronwyn Gayle))

Recent screenings of the Fox News sexual harassment feature Bombshell have forced pundits to recalibrate the Oscars race. Charlize Theron’s uncanny transformation into Megyn Kelly is now a major contender for Best Actress. And we still have Greta Gerwig’s Little Women to come; first reactions for that film have been heralding the work of Saoirse Ronan and Florence Pugh. What was once thought to be a light year for female performances – and one in which Renee Zellweger was looking like a lock – is suddenly shaping up to be a powerhouse.

And it’s not just in the lead actress category.

Supporting performances often prove the hardest to predict because the category can be stacked with leading performances positioned for “supporting” mostly to up their chances of winning (see Alicia Vikander’s win for The Danish Girl). But we’re going to give it a shot.

The 2020 race now features three high-profile female-led efforts with Oscar-worthy supporting performances (BombshellHustlers, and Little Women) – this is in addition to impressive works from earlier in the year, like The Farewell. As with our Best Actress predictions, our list of supporting female performances runs deep, with several marquee names and several newcomers in contention. It will be interesting to see who cuts through as critics groups start releasing their honors lists and we move towards the Indie Spirit Awards.

If history tells us anything, it is that most of these names won’t make it to Oscar night, but we’re pretty confident many of them will be right up there in the awards chatter. So read on as we break down our early picks for 2020 Best Supporting Actress contenders.

Don’t agree with our picks? Have at us in the comments.

Laura Dern, Marriage Story (2019) 94%

(Photo by Netflix)

Newly announced to join original Jurassic Park co-stars Sam Neill and Jeff Goldblum in the upcoming Jurassic World sequel, the Big Little Lies star also features prominently in two Oscar-caliber films in the fall: She plays the matriarch in Greta Gerwig’s Little Women and a no-nonsense lawyer with a talent for dispensing prescient Yoda-like advice in Noah Baumbach‘s Marriage Story. Having two bites at the apple usually serves potential nominees well, with voters picking the strongest of the two to nominate. And though she’s being praised for her performance in Little Women, her work with longtime friend and collaborator Baumbach is what’s getting the most buzz. Dern, who’s on the Board of Governors for the Academy, is also a very active and well-liked member, so it would be a significant upset for her not to make it to Oscar night.

Jennifer Lopez, Hustlers (2019) 87%

Kristin Callahan/Everett Collection
(Photo by Kristin Callahan/Everett Collection)

Most pundits are still not fully sold on Hustlers star Jennifer Lopez’s Oscar chances, but you can place us firmly in the “J-Lo for an Oscar nom” camp. Lopez, who plays the acrobatic stripper-turned-“mini mob boss” Ramona in the flick, is seductive, hilarious, and deadly. Also, she’s showing early that she has no intention of coasting through the season. (And yes, we include her recent walk down the Versace runway wearing a reimagining of her iconic green dress and her highly anticipated Super Bowl performance as part of an overall “campaign.”) Looking forward, perhaps the former In Living Color Fly Girl’s biggest obstacle is getting everyone to recognize how exceptional she is in the role. We don’t need convincing. Enjoying her best reviews since Steven Soderbergh’s Out of Sight, Lopez switches from charismatic mom-like figure to lethal crime boss with no more effort than she’d take to slide on a new pair of pumps. So yeah,  it’s time “Jenny from the Block” got her due.

Annette Bening, The Report (2019) 82%

Amazon Studios
(Photo by Amazon Studios)

There are several films on the fall slate that deal with political themes, and it’s yet to be seen how that will play with Academy voters. Among them are Richard Jewell, Queen & Slim, Bombshell, Jojo Rabbit, and The Report. The voters do sometimes embrace the political – Alejandro Iñárritu’s The Revenant looked unbeatable at the 2016 Oscars but was nevertheless defeated by the quiet newspaper procedural Spotlight – and Supporting Actress contender Annette Bening will be hoping they do so this year for her transformative portrayal of Senator Dianne Feinstein in the Amazon feature about the 9/11 torture report.

Shuzhen Zhao, The Farewell (2019) 98%

(Photo by A24)

Before last year’s Oscar campaign, a film like The Farewell, its lead actress Awkwafina, and the script/direction from newcomer Lulu Wang would have been hopeful but unlikely to vie for a golden statuette. Then Roma proved anything is possible, particularly in what the film signaled for actresses Marina de Tavira and Yalitza Aparicio, who were both nominated for Oscars. This is why we’re confident in the chances of the hilarious and heartfelt performance by Shuzhen Zhao as The Farewell’s Nai Nai, the elderly matriarch who is kept unaware of her own terminal illness to spare her unwanted pain. The film is based on an actual lie from the life of director Lulu Wang – the family gathers in China to say goodbye to Nai Nai under the guise of a family wedding – and Zhao is astonishingly good at its center, delivering cutting one-liners and intimate life lessons. Zhao also comes with the kind of Cinderella story voters love: this is her first on-screen performance.

Nicole Kidman & Margot Robbie, Bombshell (2019) 69%

(Photo by Lionsgate)

Early word on this Fox News sexual harassment drama is nothing but raves for lead actress Charlize Theron and supporting stars Margot Robbie and Nicole Kidman. Robbie was already a contender for her work as Sharon Tate in Once Upon a Time In Hollywood, but those who have seen Bombshell say this is the performance more likely to get her nominated. The I, Tonya actress’s portrayal of a young, impressionable Fox News staffer who’s harassed by founder Roger Ailes is the stuff that Oscar highlight reels are made of. As Gretchen Carlson, the first woman to raise concerns at the network and who eventually filed suit for harassment and wrongful termination, Nicole Kidman is equally noteworthy. Both are a serious threat for nomination.

Also in contention: 

  • Maggie Smith (Downton Abbey)
  • Jennifer Hudson (Cats)
  • Thomasin McKenzie (Jojo Rabbit)
  • Octavia Spencer (Luce)
  • Da’Vine Joy Randolph (Dolemite is My Name)
  • Florence Pugh (Little Women)
  • Meryl Streep (Little Women)

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

thriller SDCC CMT zombies FX on Hulu hollywood Sneak Peek jamie lee curtis Lucasfilm American Society of Cinematographers MTV disaster series PBS binge Nickelodeon Shondaland Emmys Reality 72 Emmy Awards VICE MSNBC anime Sundance stop motion New York Comic Con finale TV Land Kids & Family Turner foreign Action Watching Series casting mission: impossible Paramount Network National Geographic Logo venice war comiccon hist slashers YA Marvel discovery crossover toy story CW Seed unscripted FXX cancelled revenge Academy Awards romantic comedy Character Guide Mudbound Columbia Pictures cancelled television concert Elton John Trophy Talk Turner Classic Movies FOX Music Sundance Now mutant sitcom TruTV what to watch teaser Super Bowl nature 007 harry potter Winter TV streaming technology emmy awards Paramount documentary ABC hispanic screen actors guild Shudder remakes BBC America Crunchyroll toronto Toys OneApp rotten movies we love dragons Masterpiece IFC Films Teen natural history Apple TV+ BET Awards canceled TV shows strong female leads Pet Sematary satire Disney Channel Cartoon Network Certified Fresh Mystery Set visit 21st Century Fox VH1 A24 PlayStation Universal Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt festival CBS All Access Black Mirror Rom-Com Musicals Mindy Kaling true crime GoT ABC Family DC Universe latino Musical Country Rocketman Horror OWN dark TCM 2016 El Rey Apple TIFF cults serial killer Acorn TV Ghostbusters Summer Hear Us Out 71st Emmy Awards scorecard cops Food Network TCA worst movies ITV indie Walt Disney Pictures documentaries news Sundance TV Superheroe supernatural Martial Arts 2018 child's play Ovation WarnerMedia AMC Mary Tyler Moore Endgame Film Festival Election Warner Bros. Television Academy doctor who Pop cancelled TV series Nat Geo singing competition tv talk laika aliens composers E3 politics Ellie Kemper Video Games Comics on TV Esquire screenings Oscars obituary Crackle comedies Disney Plus First Look Netflix Christmas movies YouTube Premium medical drama Arrowverse comics joker History fast and furious Captain marvel YouTube Red period drama TBS Family Women's History Month Dark Horse Comics The Purge PaleyFest Hallmark Christmas movies transformers green book Amazon Prime Song of Ice and Fire Star Wars crime Starz superhero universal monsters twilight classics dceu television social media crime drama Creative Arts Emmys Emmy Nominations Grammys spy thriller BBC One award winner San Diego Comic-Con Baby Yoda FX Freeform Mary poppins Writers Guild of America theme song reboot Sci-Fi Holiday TV Apple TV Plus Black History Month best Tomatazos spanish language Discovery Channel Valentine's Day Fall TV WGN See It Skip It SXSW Cannes TNT Photos cinemax richard e. Grant sag awards Mary Poppins Returns Christmas Opinion game of thrones asian-american films dramedy Calendar children's TV adaptation nbcuniversal christmas movies Tumblr indiana jones Trivia 24 frames blaxploitation VOD spain Pop TV franchise HBO Pride Month video The Walking Dead The Witch SundanceTV Lionsgate Amazon Prime Video rotten ESPN Thanksgiving vampires psychological thriller name the review X-Men free movies Disney+ Disney Plus NBC police drama TV renewals IFC robots Film based on movie CBS game show TCA Winter 2020 adventure football anthology Cosplay DC Comics TCA 2017 Podcast USA Disney streaming service Star Trek The Arrangement kids a nightmare on elm street dc zero dark thirty psycho GLAAD Pixar Amazon Studios MCU festivals worst video on demand reviews BET Stephen King Lifetime sequel Avengers Winners Pirates APB facebook Syfy movie canceled versus stoner die hard Tubi RT21 Disney Anna Paquin comic Netflix animated mockumentary diversity Drama quibi Western DirecTV 2020 spinoff 20th Century Fox biography werewolf Red Carpet Brie Larson south america Showtime docudrama LGBT Box Office Lifetime Christmas movies sports Heroines Tarantino movies ghosts critics renewed TV shows Year in Review Spectrum Originals Awards Tour nfl Holidays 2015 Schedule criterion Bravo witnail Quiz Polls and Games ratings chucky romance Chilling Adventures of Sabrina President Superheroes Extras Comedy Vudu dogs cartoon science fiction Classic Film historical drama travel zombie Sony Pictures Reality Competition space 2017 book Infographic directors Marvel Television justice league Comedy Central Britbox Peacock Amazon E! GIFs BAFTA First Reviews Premiere Dates NYCC Awards USA Network LGBTQ The CW Spike cancelled TV shows breaking bad Travel Channel YouTube cats Marvel Studios parents boxoffice 45 Comic Book HBO Go stand-up comedy 4/20 blockbuster all-time talk show Interview cars spider-man TLC 2019 DGA BBC Biopics Animation Spring TV Hallmark RT History Fox News halloween Countdown Rock Trailer Best and Worst sequels Fantasy miniseries DC streaming service HBO Max Epix golden globes cooking Rocky A&E crime thriller elevated horror Adult Swim Marathons Funimation Chernobyl TCA Awards Binge Guide scary movies Nominations independent CNN Television Critics Association political drama batman Hulu