RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Suicide Squad (2016)

It failed to enchant critics at the time of its release, but Suicide Squad's defenders still go to bat for it to this day. On the eve of its sequel, we're looking back at David Ayer's infamous take on DC's ultimate villain team-up.

by | August 5, 2021 | Comments

Suicide Squad

(Photo by © Warner Bros. / courtesy Everett Collection)

This week, everyone is talking about The Suicide Squad, director James Gunn’s gory, hilarious, and so-far very critically beloved take on DC’s bad-guys-turned-good(ish) group of world-savers. The movie hits theaters and HBO Max this Friday with a Certified Fresh Tomatometer score in the high 90s – which is very “nom, nom” indeed.

Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

With the “squad” back in theaters, we thought we’d revisit the film that first introduced Amanda Waller and some of DC’s most beloved kinda-villains to moviegoers: 2016’s Suicide Squad. (What a difference a “the” makes.) Where Gunn’s film rides towards audiences buoyed by almost universal acclaim, director David Ayer’s original… well, it was something of a different story.

Expectations were high among fans for the 2016 movie off the back of a killer marketing campaign that included what might be one of the most effective trailers ever made, as well as swirling excitement about a new Joker and that killer cast (Will Smith! Viola Davis! Jared Leto! Margot Robbie!). But when the movie crash-landed into theaters – to the sound of so many rock hits – it failed to… erm, enchant.

Critics lauded some of the chemistry between cast members as well as the arrival of a “fantabulous” new DCEU character in Robbie’s Harley Quinn, but they also largely roasted the film for its muddy story and music-video feel. It stands with a current Rotten Tomatometer score of 26%. Fans were slightly more forgiving, but hardly blown away – the movie’s Audience Score is 59%, one point shy of Freshness. Even its most die-hard defenders took issue with a clunky final act and weak villain.

Recently, even the movie’s own director has come out against the version Warner Brothers’ released in theaters, recently going so far as saying studio interference resulted in something that was ”not my movie.” And for those who took issue with all those rock hits, he noted his movie had “not a single radio song in the whole thing.”

But is the original Suicide Squad deserving of its villainous reputation? Or, much like its surprisingly big-hearted lead characters, was this a film too harshly judged – by critics, fans, and now its creator? That’s what we’re asking in the latest episode of our podcast, Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast from Rotten Tomatoes). And to take on such a mission, we had to recruit the deadliest group of bad guys (OK, insightful film buffs) we could find – and so it is that our regular hosts Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley have been fitted with their explosive devices and are joined by movie and TV junkie, actress, host, and one third of YouTube’s Whirl Girls, Roxy Striar. Does she, like a certain pale-faced and pigtailed jail bird, have a soft spot for something others find so problematic? Tune in to find out.

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:

If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Best and Worst werewolf war anthology Pixar spain action-comedy crime drama Apple TV Plus Discovery Channel streaming movies Holiday 1990s Biopics spider-man space period drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Crunchyroll comiccon Musical Interview all-time Writers Guild of America Disney Plus quibi Calendar Baby Yoda Pet Sematary 93rd Oscars Anna Paquin sequels Ellie Kemper Wes Anderson scary movies Starz 72 Emmy Awards YouTube Red Film Festival President TLC unscripted National Geographic San Diego Comic-Con robots deadpool Turner Classic Movies Epix justice league 90s dark superhero TCA Awards batman Rocky DC Comics Walt Disney Pictures Fox News Pop TV Character Guide 45 HBO Go lord of the rings indiana jones Logo Comedy ESPN Freeform child's play football Universal Pictures Musicals LGBTQ rt archives laika CBS All Access zero dark thirty Broadway Holidays The CW canceled Mary poppins LGBT Stephen King supernatural richard e. Grant black comedy boxing stop motion biopic composers USA christmas movies scene in color Cartoon Network E! Emmy Nominations The Purge monster movies blockbuster live action king arthur anime PBS Grammys Spectrum Originals ABC Family comics TruTV versus olympics new star wars movies Pacific Islander Britbox book adaptation Marvel Television video aapi revenge cancelled disaster X-Men Sundance Now marvel comics book cars Trophy Talk CW Seed APB Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Exclusive Video movies Extras Sony Pictures ITV Nat Geo Tubi Western south america dragons dc hidden camera films Mary Poppins Returns Neflix theme song mutant documentary remakes Marvel VH1 71st Emmy Awards target 73rd Emmy Awards FXX Paramount Plus Hulu IFC Films adventure docudrama 2018 trailers 24 frames fresh Amazon Prime Video comic book movie Thanksgiving Creative Arts Emmys 20th Century Fox live event crime thriller new york hist psychological thriller Certified Fresh Winter TV Funimation rotten latino sopranos Country name the review IFC VICE YouTube Premium SundanceTV Esquire PlayStation Arrowverse joker Countdown The Arrangement OneApp mob serial killer Syfy franchise 2015 Shudder emmy awards Heroines vampires Pop Watching Series Fox Searchlight Song of Ice and Fire ViacomCBS prank political drama cancelled TV shows Vudu basketball dexter SDCC Amazon Drama 99% American Society of Cinematographers canceled TV shows Black Mirror strong female leads rt labs critics edition free movies Peacock MTV YouTube movie YA Nominations science fiction 2016 worst rom-coms feel good screen actors guild Superheroes genre cats mcc talk show Video Games Captain marvel 2021 Paramount Network hispanic heritage month E3 Cosplay nfl DC streaming service Lionsgate Universal psycho CNN animated cartoon politics Disney+ Disney Plus dramedy 007 The Witch Red Carpet Mindy Kaling Hallmark Christmas movies nature james bond Alien docuseries Academy Awards Hallmark BBC Star Trek Quiz screenings japanese venice cancelled television tv talk popular RT21 Disney streaming service casting Family TV movies Dark Horse Comics obituary Lifetime Teen Tomatazos young adult children's TV spanish language Election Schedule AMC Plus Summer Premiere Dates spider-verse Endgame art house Sundance TV international diversity women chucky high school GIFs rt labs superman fast and furious Ovation Star Wars green book FX on Hulu know your critic kids Television Critics Association WarnerMedia wonder woman black blockbusters Avengers Box Office ghosts A24 australia Disney Channel 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards award winner transformers Superheroe Sneak Peek thriller GoT asian-american Mudbound Sci-Fi Mary Tyler Moore Horror Turner USA Network halloween BBC America VOD FOX sports HBO discovery Animation adenture golden globe awards telelvision Rock Food Network ABC Signature Comic Book Showtime Lucasfilm Elton John mission: impossible Masterpiece Apple satire royal family Rom-Com Marathons razzies renewed TV shows Bravo french Toys reviews Polls and Games classics New York Comic Con First Look Sundance scorecard Opinion godzilla halloween tv Brie Larson NBA NYCC Amazon Prime TCA Winter 2020 Cannes ID worst movies true crime die hard spy thriller Mystery streaming TCA FX HBO Max historical drama spanish comic Christmas TCA 2017 Shondaland festival sitcom Pirates rotten movies we love Image Comics zombies finale comedies Winners TIFF archives scary Oscars cinemax Film travel The Walking Dead Emmys Music TBS elevated horror saw heist movie golden globes TV Awards DGA A&E adaptation Instagram Live festivals TV Land MSNBC WGN concert Fall TV Legendary RT History Rocketman Spike indie First Reviews marvel cinematic universe Reality what to watch hollywood Paramount slasher Acorn TV independent crime news Ghostbusters cooking Set visit aliens Classic Film BET Awards Netflix 2020 criterion Tarantino a nightmare on elm street TCM jurassic park 2017 Columbia Pictures game of thrones Women's History Month harry potter witnail sequel kaiju El Rey facebook Chernobyl IMDb TV Comedy Central teaser nbcuniversal singing competition Netflix Christmas movies 2019 zombie The Walt Disney Company medical drama SXSW based on movie ratings game show Adult Swim blaxploitation suspense boxoffice Kids & Family Tokyo Olympics cops BBC One Infographic series Tumblr Spring TV toy story Crackle OWN documentaries comic book movies debate Pride Month legend reboot dreamworks TNT romance Black History Month cults italian breaking bad binge Fantasy Trailer universal monsters biography dceu posters toronto CBS Year in Review foreign critics Action DC Universe History Photos 4/20 twilight Television Academy ABC stand-up comedy best dogs The Academy jamie lee curtis AMC spinoff mockumentary BAFTA kong PaleyFest police drama See It Skip It japan TV renewals Comic-Con@Home 2021 Awards Tour king kong Warner Bros. Trivia Amazon Studios slashers romantic comedy Reality Competition miniseries directors NBC stoner video on demand vs. CMT Binge Guide Lifetime Christmas movies hispanic Hear Us Out Apple TV+ Marvel Studios social media Podcast DirecTV television cancelled TV series technology crossover natural history Valentine's Day gangster BET Comics on TV parents sag awards MCU GLAAD new zealand Martial Arts TV One 21st Century Fox doctor who Disney Travel Channel pirates of the caribbean comic books critic resources Super Bowl Nickelodeon