RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... The Oscars' 'Best Picture' Winners

Is our Tomatometer ranking of the greatest Best Picture winners of all time right? We're breaking down the top 10 and beyond in the latest episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong.

by | April 22, 2021 | Comments

The Godfather

(Photo by courtesy Everett Collection)

This Sunday, a new Best Picture Oscar winner will join the club of 93 movies that have taken out the Academy’s highest honor since the awards were first held in 1929. Will it be frontrunner Nomadland? Will Judas and the Black Messiah make history with an upset? Will Netflix finally get a Best Pic win with Mank or The Trail of the Chicago 7?

Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

Those are all fun questions – and questions that will be answered in short time. With Oscars in the air, though, we decided to ask a different question in the latest episode of our podcast, Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong: What are the greatest Best Picture winners of all time? And does Rotten Tomatoes’ ranking of the 93 movies to win Best Picture so far stack up to scrutiny?

That list, which ranks the past Best Picture winners by Tomatometer – weighting for factors like year of release and the number of reviews available for each film – places screwball classic It Happened One Night in top position, just ahead of last year’s groundbreaking South Korean winner, Parasite. Also in the top 10: Expected classics like Casablanca and The Godfather, along with a few surprises (The Shape of Water?).

Is that the right top 10? Should “Big” winners Lawrence of Arabia, Titanic, Ben-Hur and more be placed higher up the list? Should Forrest Gump really be so close to the bottom of the pile? Joining regular hosts Jacqueline Coley and Mark Ellis is Indiewire executive editor and chief film critic, awards expert, and co-host of podcast Screen Talk, Eric Kohn: together, they will break down our epic list of Best Picture winners – and give us their predictions for the performances and films they think will win big this year.

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

WarnerMedia Awards Pop CBS All Access The Academy zero dark thirty archives dark kong blaxploitation reboot blockbuster TCA 2017 Sundance Now The Witch video on demand romance OWN slashers Hallmark TV Land comic book movies Western Video Games cops Pop TV batman Sci-Fi YouTube Premium Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt scary movies mcc sequel Mindy Kaling Tubi quibi psycho Anna Paquin docuseries USA classics 007 President toronto Crunchyroll RT21 crime 20th Century Fox SXSW festivals legend Warner Bros. strong female leads 71st Emmy Awards telelvision ratings Valentine's Day Universal Pictures Martial Arts 90s Women's History Month Heroines Starz politics crime thriller Endgame Star Wars Thanksgiving Columbia Pictures 2021 kaiju Teen Year in Review obituary james bond MCU Holidays spider-verse screen actors guild crossover australia Rocketman CMT heist movie Photos video documentaries TV RT History travel finale Neflix science fiction talk show anthology FOX DC streaming service VOD king kong Countdown Schedule Awards Tour rom-coms cancelled television stop motion hidden camera unscripted aapi french Mary Poppins Returns facebook game of thrones LGBT biography robots monster movies cancelled TV shows Oscars CNN Avengers jurassic park Nat Geo Bravo technology all-time Tomatazos biopic IFC Walt Disney Pictures 45 cancelled king arthur war supernatural Tokyo Olympics El Rey witnail fast and furious X-Men Red Carpet Mudbound Travel Channel Emmy Nominations Black History Month Drama Instagram Live YouTube international Nickelodeon Hulu justice league Showtime composers Amazon Prime Pacific Islander werewolf Disney+ Disney Plus Grammys renewed TV shows new zealand Mary poppins GIFs directors TV movies First Look Election ID GoT social media anime Fox News NBA casting streaming movies posters franchise Tarantino golden globe awards Disney theme song godzilla free movies ABC Signature slasher elevated horror pirates of the caribbean animated Disney streaming service nbcuniversal documentary MTV south america versus what to watch nfl comics Pet Sematary Spectrum Originals Sneak Peek Academy Awards Shondaland FX on Hulu CBS cancelled TV series TNT Biopics target HBO Peacock football 21st Century Fox A24 sag awards action-comedy discovery art house criterion transformers reviews marvel cinematic universe Paramount Plus space adaptation spanish language Christmas Exclusive Video news parents best sitcom new star wars movies Disney Plus olympics Writers Guild of America Brie Larson ViacomCBS dexter Summer saw DGA 93rd Oscars BET Trailer 73rd Emmy Awards harry potter black 2016 Interview miniseries hispanic heritage month Marvel Studios child's play Nominations police drama disaster Arrowverse History japan laika See It Skip It mission: impossible canceled TV shows 72 Emmy Awards Paramount Britbox Extras Logo Opinion Box Office trailers Musical DirecTV Broadway Action 2019 hist Sundance Certified Fresh Superheroes streaming sequels A&E TIFF 4/20 Song of Ice and Fire fresh cults Comics on TV Comedy LGBTQ films Television Academy MSNBC book Rom-Com cooking twilight Ghostbusters Creative Arts Emmys indiana jones TBS Alien Quiz Musicals critics Watching Series spy thriller CW Seed dramedy kids comic book movie Discovery Channel BET Awards Film aliens Comedy Central TCM toy story Image Comics American Society of Cinematographers deadpool Shudder canceled vampires Rocky Lifetime Winter TV Podcast know your critic adenture APB AMC Acorn TV Amazon marvel comics Ovation golden globes Wes Anderson natural history comic books ghosts E! IFC Films emmy awards Vudu Black Mirror dreamworks movies based on movie BBC One Mystery game show TCA remakes period drama AMC Plus razzies superman zombie boxoffice award winner Trophy Talk USA Network concert gangster cartoon zombies name the review Adult Swim Pirates new york Sundance TV diversity Dark Horse Comics Premiere Dates prank HBO Max boxing Paramount Network rotten DC Universe Sony Pictures cinemax serial killer independent royal family Freeform lord of the rings Binge Guide WGN Universal comiccon superhero scene in color live event vs. BBC New York Comic Con ABC PBS Character Guide dceu spain Family Cosplay rt labs critics edition Marvel tv talk Lionsgate nature wonder woman indie jamie lee curtis Food Network YouTube Red basketball PlayStation satire 2020 Horror richard e. Grant stand-up comedy Film Festival Spring TV FX blockbusters Esquire romantic comedy mockumentary breaking bad Country scorecard rt archives Turner Classic Movies OneApp First Reviews latino Music series Reality Competition Marvel Television Infographic spinoff Stephen King television sopranos die hard chucky ESPN Baby Yoda Lucasfilm halloween tv The Arrangement Comic Book Captain marvel medical drama IMDb TV Funimation Comic-Con@Home 2021 HBO Go halloween San Diego Comic-Con dc Apple TV+ Syfy Fantasy NBC green book Legendary dragons YA Amazon Prime Video TLC black comedy Amazon Studios comic debate Mary Tyler Moore Set visit TCA Awards Winners dogs 24 frames Cartoon Network Holiday The Purge high school TV renewals cars venice Calendar FXX historical drama Best and Worst Fall TV comedies sports 99% DC Comics Hallmark Christmas movies scary NYCC stoner The Walking Dead worst movies Disney Channel BAFTA BBC America VICE 2018 genre docudrama Chernobyl screenings spanish rt labs binge Polls and Games a nightmare on elm street teaser Crackle Classic Film Animation revenge E3 1990s foreign mob ABC Family christmas movies GLAAD Superheroe women Star Trek book adaptation japanese TruTV VH1 Tumblr movie Lifetime Christmas movies Toys Masterpiece cats Reality Pixar hollywood rotten movies we love suspense crime drama critic resources Kids & Family Super Bowl true crime Cannes 2017 thriller The CW Trivia hispanic Spike children's TV TCA Winter 2020 Turner Television Critics Association Rock festival psychological thriller Pride Month young adult political drama Netflix Christmas movies Epix Apple TV Plus Marathons asian-american SundanceTV National Geographic The Walt Disney Company Apple PaleyFest italian Netflix Elton John spider-man singing competition worst doctor who SDCC live action Emmys feel good popular Ellie Kemper 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 2015 Hear Us Out universal monsters Fox Searchlight adventure TV One joker Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ITV mutant