RT's Top 20 Halloween Movie Countdown, Part 1

by | October 26, 2006 | Comments

Just what does Rotten Tomatoes deem the all-time scariest horror flick? Is it a gruesome slasher that results in heightened anxiety and sudden spine-tingling jolts and jumps? Or, is it a psychological thriller that plagues the subconscious for weeks to come?

Author: Christina Troup

We searched the site for the top 20 horror/suspense movies to reveal the numero uno cinematic scare just in time for a frightful Halloween film fest.**

Today’s installment kicks off the countdown; check in every day ’til October 31 as we serve up the best reviewed frightening flicks for your Halloween viewing pleasure!

Oh, and be afraid. Be very afraid.

Top Horror/Suspense Films by Tomatometer, #20-16


20) Open Water (2004) 72%

It might as well be space because in the Caribbean Sea no one can hear you scream. Well, save for the circling sharks below. In the slow-paced psychological thriller "Open Water," married couple Susan and Daniel embark upon a deep sea adventure to rest, relax and reconnect. Unfortunately for the twosome, they are accidentally left behind by their diving team, smack dab in the middle of the deep blue. The pair struggle to survive amid tumultuous elements and inhospitable oceanic critters. Oh, and get this, it’s based on a true story, so you may want to rethink that next seaside getaway.

Starring: Blanchard Ryan, Daniel Travis
Directed by: Chris Kentis

19) Joy Ride (2001) 73%



Breaker, breaker 1-9. If there’s a lesson to be learned from the horror meets the highway jaunt "Joy Ride," it’s that one should never mess with a guy who goes by the name "Rusty Nail." Tetanus, people. Tetanus. Of course, on-screen bros Paul Walker and Steve Zahn didn’t get the memo and end up messing with a mentally unstable truck driver via CB radio. Essentially, a mean-spirited joke goes awry and the two brothers, along with potential love interest Leelee Sobieski, find themselves in the path of a madman’s quest for revenge.

Starring: Steve Zahn, Paul Walker, Leelee Sobieski
Directed by: John Dahl

18) George A. Romero’s Land of the Dead (2005) 74%



After a lengthy hiatus, horror master George A. Romero returned in 2005 with yet another unsettling tale of life among zombies in "Land of the Dead." This time around, the living dead and humans co-exist, but not without a structured caste system in place. Romero’s societal commentary tackles the issue of the "haves" and "have-nots," where the wealthy live in luxury, safe behind walls of protection while the not-so fortunate are relegated to life in streets. Regardless, no amount of money can keep the ever-evolving lineage of zombies at bay for too long.

Starring: Simon Baker, John Leguizamo, Dennis Hopper, Asia Argento
Directed by: George A. Romero

17) Signs (2002) 75%



Honestly, which is scarier: the little girl that asks for a glass of water or the bobble-headed aliens lurking about in M. Night Shyamalan‘s "Signs?" Beyond the suspense of who, or perhaps what, is behind the crop circles in the cornfield, "Signs" digs a little deeper and brings up issues of faith and religion. The tale of the Hess family and the series of peculiar events that have lately befallen them is a perfectly chilling romp for the whole family to enjoy.

Starring: Mel Gibson, Joaquin Phoenix, Rory Culkin
Directed by: M. Night Shyamalan

16) Audition (1999) 76%



The first half of "Audition" is slow-moving, like a glob of peanut butter lodged in the back of your throat. But by the latter half, chances are you’d prefer that things had kept at their leisurely pace. Not for the faint of heart, Takashi Miike‘s disturbing tale of courtship is a perfect example that it’s never wise to mislead a woman. After all, it’s all fun and games until someone severs a limb.

Directed by: Takashi Miike
Starring: Ryo Ishibashi, Eihi Shiina

Tune in tomorrow for the next five titles, in our four-day countdown to Halloween’s #1 rated horror flick!

**These are our top-Tomatometer picks with at least 40 reviews counted, which is why some of the classics of spooky cinema aren’t included.

Tag Cloud

2020 festivals RT History Disney+ Disney Plus game show Women's History Month 2019 book social media Television Academy Extras Britbox FX on Hulu best Rocketman satire parents FXX Netflix Christmas movies discovery President Rom-Com Baby Yoda science fiction green book Cannes Pixar Horror Captain marvel TCM Logo facebook screen actors guild crime thriller TLC Epix VOD period drama Comics on TV universal monsters sports Election BAFTA news Song of Ice and Fire Bravo 4/20 boxoffice historical drama Heroines ghosts crossover dragons sequel strong female leads Disney 007 Musical cooking Crackle biography Shudder Winter TV Ovation Warner Bros. doctor who See It Skip It asian-american YouTube Premium Elton John Pirates Endgame Nominations Sneak Peek cartoon aliens Vudu films dramedy Brie Larson Thanksgiving NYCC Emmys Black History Month MSNBC TCA Winter 2020 SundanceTV Grammys FOX Arrowverse Disney Plus unscripted 20th Century Fox comic batman latino Star Trek OWN TV Cartoon Network Mindy Kaling Premiere Dates comiccon robots composers CBS All Access The Purge Superheroes Television Critics Association USA DGA spanish language Holidays 2018 BBC children's TV spy thriller FX Columbia Pictures travel golden globes streaming Character Guide richard e. Grant Dark Horse Comics New York Comic Con psycho Discovery Channel WGN spain Syfy Marvel spinoff CBS DC streaming service Polls and Games mutant series based on movie Animation Mystery Turner cults justice league Disney streaming service Paramount die hard Amazon Studios technology zombie RT21 Amazon Prime canceled TV shows cars Esquire zombies Fox News werewolf Showtime 21st Century Fox hist Christmas Mary Tyler Moore Valentine's Day Fall TV comics Apple indiana jones Nat Geo 24 frames reviews History independent crime drama 71st Emmy Awards Sundance TV Marvel Studios A&E Spike Mary Poppins Returns MTV vampires LGBTQ HBO Max anime Emmy Nominations name the review game of thrones cats Best and Worst NBC SXSW space critics scary movies Creative Arts Emmys Sundance documentary Reality Competition mockumentary Pet Sematary talk show south america VH1 TV renewals twilight documentaries romantic comedy video adaptation Winners Awards Tour Pride Month Travel Channel Paramount Network movie comedies TCA Reality Crunchyroll binge Martial Arts rotten movies we love TNT Lucasfilm Countdown dark Trailer revenge BET Awards Trivia christmas movies transformers Mary poppins dceu Hulu singing competition all-time Classic Film National Geographic Oscars 2017 concert miniseries dc GoT DC Universe DC Comics docudrama cancelled TV shows Fantasy reboot anthology Holiday Superheroe First Look stand-up comedy Amazon Opinion TCA Awards Drama theme song tv talk Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt animated CW Seed Spring TV hispanic free movies Video Games Film Country Tubi Marathons true crime YouTube Teen Music Writers Guild of America stoner ESPN Adult Swim PlayStation Food Network ABC cancelled political drama Biopics Certified Fresh what to watch criterion IFC PaleyFest American Society of Cinematographers Apple TV+ Academy Awards award winner BBC America chucky natural history TIFF blaxploitation halloween spider-man Comedy Central Pop E! Black Mirror OneApp jamie lee curtis Interview movies video on demand Universal Comedy Podcast GIFs LGBT breaking bad TCA 2017 Cosplay teaser Awards The Witch crime Star Wars foreign indie ABC Family Comic Book psychological thriller ITV YA BBC One TBS harry potter The CW kids Disney Channel Chernobyl war child's play Ellie Kemper Ghostbusters adventure Kids & Family Trophy Talk Apple TV Plus E3 cinemax directors Action Avengers Hallmark BET 45 Tumblr serial killer PBS Western Sony Pictures X-Men Lionsgate Shondaland toy story zero dark thirty Pop TV WarnerMedia 2016 Tomatazos APB TruTV Hear Us Out Masterpiece Toys television police drama USA Network Mudbound Year in Review AMC franchise SDCC Lifetime Christmas movies quibi mission: impossible Quiz Rock diversity The Walking Dead Watching Series Box Office MCU Netflix Tarantino Film Festival HBO Go El Rey witnail TV Land medical drama finale Walt Disney Pictures Set visit Photos Freeform Nickelodeon Funimation Schedule renewed TV shows Binge Guide The Arrangement 2015 Family joker ratings Turner Classic Movies disaster politics GLAAD nature Lifetime blockbuster IFC Films Sundance Now casting a nightmare on elm street screenings cancelled TV series A24 sitcom Calendar Sci-Fi HBO VICE Rocky Spectrum Originals cancelled television CMT YouTube Red Stephen King Anna Paquin thriller slashers Super Bowl cops Peacock dogs Summer romance First Reviews Hallmark Christmas movies canceled Musicals Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Marvel Television Acorn TV elevated horror Infographic supernatural CNN DirecTV sag awards Amazon Prime Video Starz Red Carpet versus San Diego Comic-Con