Scream Queen Showdown: Who Is the Ultimate Final Girl?

It's Sigourney Weaver vs. Jamie Lee Curtis vs. Neve Campbell vs. Sarah Michelle Gellar as we break down Tomatometer, box office, performance, iconic moments, and more.

by | October 31, 2020 | Comments

In our latest episode of Vs. we’re paying tribute to cinema’s greatest scream queens… by making them battle it out to the final reel! (To be fair, something each of them has some practice in.) It’s slasher icon Jamie Lee Curtis against sci-fi icon Sigourney Weaver against ghostface killer Neve Campbell against fisherman’s not-friend Sarah Michelle Gellar as we seek to crown horror’s ultimate portrayer of the “final girl.” How will the battle play out? Well, first we’re trapping them in a mansion with about 30 escaped-from-a-mental-hospital serial killers… Oh wait, no, not that, that would be illegal. We’re actually comparing their box office performance, Audience and Tomatometer Scores, and the quality of their enemies, and adding a bonus round for good measure. Will it be Ripley, Laurie, Buffy, or Sidney who lives to earn that sweet sequel paycheck? Watch along as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks it down, then have at us in the comments.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

dexter LGBT DC Universe Certified Fresh festivals History Horror Quiz Lifetime Christmas movies godzilla The Purge Schedule sequels Mudbound Discovery Channel asian-american wonder woman natural history dogs twilight Photos Women's History Month Pixar Chernobyl Pacific Islander Avengers Reality nature 90s NYCC Character Guide saw golden globes TCM indie archives universal monsters talk show X-Men APB Oscars heist movie WarnerMedia Writers Guild of America Superheroe joker aliens miniseries doctor who Binge Guide teaser 45 indiana jones Chilling Adventures of Sabrina YouTube Premium stand-up comedy Hulu renewed TV shows Star Trek AMC Sundance Now critics Interview ABC screenings serial killer adventure TCA Awards biography 20th Century Fox The Walking Dead free movies ViacomCBS ABC Family cancelled Podcast Logo cancelled TV series E3 Pirates worst movies nbcuniversal Cannes book adaptation hidden camera dceu critic resources robots Rocky TV movies RT21 new star wars movies Election Starz 2016 Pop TV zero dark thirty Winners TCA 2017 Emmys french Infographic king arthur stoner TV renewals quibi WGN Disney streaming service movie Summer Shondaland travel jamie lee curtis NBA Pet Sematary GLAAD marvel cinematic universe 2017 sitcom YouTube blaxploitation a nightmare on elm street social media Mary poppins women kong dramedy razzies 4/20 rotten movies we love Esquire 2015 Masterpiece game of thrones Musicals Walt Disney Pictures Food Network japanese Tomatazos feel good BBC Country monster movies anime italian laika Toys NBC Tokyo Olympics USA Network Year in Review theme song Arrowverse Rom-Com Polls and Games aapi spanish HBO spain Superheroes DC Comics IFC ABC Signature 73rd Emmy Awards TCA Wes Anderson sag awards Video Games Stephen King boxoffice political drama black A24 live action Lifetime new zealand SXSW Freeform TV Land Tarantino Baby Yoda New York Comic Con RT History TV One Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt latino Spring TV Heroines series rom-coms 21st Century Fox television Emmy Nominations Nat Geo royal family based on movie Vudu docudrama Fantasy CBS All Access Action independent YouTube Red popular worst nfl police drama Syfy Amazon Prime Video Spike Lionsgate Fall TV casting versus Hallmark Christmas movies south america action-comedy sequel kaiju politics PlayStation CW Seed international Paramount Plus suspense BAFTA Dark Horse Comics disaster Crunchyroll FXX cancelled TV shows Marvel Television Critics Association Showtime olympics Adult Swim rt labs Mary Tyler Moore Mary Poppins Returns Netflix Christmas movies Thanksgiving rt labs critics edition FOX Comic Book Sony Pictures dark rt archives spy thriller Holidays children's TV Anna Paquin true crime 007 Sundance TV Countdown justice league CBS Columbia Pictures Western space Lucasfilm target PBS war crime drama Paramount Network GIFs comic book movie SundanceTV adenture Paramount Broadway werewolf historical drama The CW 2018 news Mystery Comic-Con@Home 2021 YA Netflix San Diego Comic-Con 2019 MTV Amazon Apple toronto TBS comic book movies dc TIFF Cartoon Network Warner Bros. batman TNT reboot cats cinemax 71st Emmy Awards Best and Worst Bravo chucky breaking bad FX IFC Films Christmas Spectrum Originals singing competition revenge Music BBC America Calendar hispanic heritage month Red Carpet GoT Turner streaming movies VOD concert video james bond Sci-Fi Trailer Nominations President Grammys Valentine's Day streaming young adult Turner Classic Movies Opinion king kong Animation PaleyFest Disney Channel Extras obituary mcc vampires Ellie Kemper psychological thriller japan strong female leads 2020 zombies know your critic Acorn TV marvel comics ghosts 1990s australia christmas movies documentaries 24 frames docuseries A&E Classic Film Sneak Peek Apple TV Plus venice El Rey golden globe awards USA canceled Marvel Studios ID Trophy Talk Black Mirror Family Biopics satire Comedy transformers Winter TV high school VICE Fox News Academy Awards new york Premiere Dates ITV video on demand Travel Channel technology slasher adaptation Film cars Ovation fast and furious Image Comics Britbox emmy awards BET Awards Rocketman Teen 2021 dragons MSNBC FX on Hulu 99% Super Bowl zombie sports Endgame Cosplay science fiction diversity OWN Hallmark stop motion spanish language trailers binge facebook Drama animated 93rd Oscars tv talk criterion lord of the rings basketball Musical Amazon Prime 72 Emmy Awards superhero crossover pirates of the caribbean HBO Go comic HBO Max hispanic blockbusters TruTV romance parents Tubi kids DGA Brie Larson Fox Searchlight psycho game show richard e. Grant Mindy Kaling Trivia Ghostbusters 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Black History Month cooking die hard superman discovery Apple TV+ First Look Creative Arts Emmys classics Kids & Family See It Skip It Disney name the review TLC Sundance First Reviews Peacock telelvision Song of Ice and Fire Pride Month Elton John medical drama Film Festival Awards Tour jurassic park directors composers harry potter comiccon legend Disney+ Disney Plus mission: impossible boxing supernatural National Geographic cartoon Shudder Awards Disney Plus The Academy screen actors guild Watching Series cancelled television documentary VH1 Tumblr Hear Us Out best crime thriller elevated horror comedies crime what to watch The Arrangement Comedy Central halloween tv period drama romantic comedy Pop CMT deadpool finale halloween spider-man BBC One Nickelodeon festival child's play LGBTQ fresh mockumentary SDCC American Society of Cinematographers The Walt Disney Company gangster hist movies thriller Exclusive Video football mutant rotten cults scary movies witnail all-time unscripted ESPN anthology The Witch Amazon Studios blockbuster Epix Legendary ratings Television Academy Star Wars Alien comic books Funimation biopic green book CNN Box Office award winner posters remakes films Comics on TV TCA Winter 2020 book spinoff MCU DirecTV Captain marvel TV Marathons Reality Competition E! Universal OneApp foreign BET DC streaming service prank Crackle Rock comics cops toy story Marvel Television debate hollywood scorecard Set visit scene in color canceled TV shows Holiday slashers franchise Martial Arts reviews