Showdowns

Star Wars Prequels vs. Star Wars Sequels: Which Trilogy Is Better?

Fandoms, unite: We're finally settling the Prequels vs. Sequels debate with a deep dive into box office results, Tomatometer scores, and the characters and moments that make us love Star Wars so damn much.

by | February 26, 2020 | Comments

OK, commenters: Fire up your engines because we’re tackling a big one in our latest edition of Vs., pitting the Star Wars Prequels against the Star Wars Sequels and declaring definitively which galactic triptych is the superior set of films. We’re looking at box office data and Tomatometer scores for Episodes 1-3 and 7-9, as well as which trilogy delivered the best moments and gave us the most memorable characters. Are you a Darth Maul vs. Qui-Gon vs. Obi-Wan person? Or do you prefer your lightsaber battles more of the Throne Room variety? Does a Jar Jar Binks outweigh the awesomeness of Ewan McGregor’s young Obi-Wan? And how do they compare to Babu Frik? Watch above as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis lays out the case for both trilogies and – bravely – declares a winner.


Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is available digitally on March 17, 2020. 

#1
Adjusted Score: 73.335%
Critics Consensus: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker suffers from a frustrating lack of imagination, but concludes this beloved saga with fan-focused devotion.
Synopsis: The battle between the Jedi and the Sith comes to a thrilling conclusion in this final chapter of the Skywalker... [More]
Directed By: J.J. Abrams

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

TNT theme song Mudbound Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Winter TV teaser based on movie 2016 Certified Fresh what to watch critics Pride Month historical drama slashers Paramount Network witnail Musical cancelled TV series SXSW Schedule RT History transformers Animation MTV Nickelodeon Amazon The Purge nature indie composers WarnerMedia thriller Television Academy facebook Academy Awards A&E Star Wars vampires Box Office Travel Channel TLC ABC NBC Horror Disney Channel natural history cats Acorn TV discovery concert VICE Vudu 20th Century Fox CBS 71st Emmy Awards spy thriller video on demand AMC Warner Bros. blaxploitation canceled TV shows Quiz Photos universal monsters films Amazon Studios FXX Netflix Marvel Television E! child's play Comedy Rocky crime thriller green book TCM FOX mockumentary National Geographic Superheroes jamie lee curtis cartoon TruTV 2020 Tubi cancelled television blockbuster YA cancelled Fall TV directors Brie Larson Teen Universal free movies Reality talk show Pop TV Turner Classic Movies festivals Emmy Nominations chucky halloween 4/20 San Diego Comic-Con Syfy adventure Tarantino RT21 comiccon Writers Guild of America Year in Review space game show mission: impossible Nominations documentaries Sony Pictures CW Seed foreign Comic Book El Rey true crime 007 Fantasy Hallmark Christmas movies Amazon Prime LGBTQ Pixar dogs New York Comic Con Mary poppins NYCC children's TV series Hear Us Out Martial Arts anthology scary movies best Nat Geo indiana jones Sci-Fi FX on Hulu revenge war X-Men Country Columbia Pictures Captain marvel Superheroe ratings 2018 Christmas streaming franchise doctor who TBS 24 frames social media Mystery cancelled TV shows psycho zero dark thirty Winners book Cartoon Network adaptation Best and Worst Creative Arts Emmys unscripted USA PlayStation crossover anime YouTube Apple TV+ Starz hispanic A24 toy story Freeform Sundance Cosplay werewolf IFC Films Calendar Rock television Grammys The CW Toys period drama dceu dramedy Holidays DC Comics Film BBC political drama Lionsgate Arrowverse OneApp latino WGN Valentine's Day casting GIFs Fox News Reality Competition Ovation Epix Music CNN romance Women's History Month name the review Holiday comics Awards Tour Apple christmas movies TIFF Marvel Crackle Tumblr Rom-Com comic Anna Paquin docudrama Song of Ice and Fire ITV stoner YouTube Red Pirates Britbox Infographic Mindy Kaling asian-american movies Netflix Christmas movies hist Kids & Family elevated horror TCA Winter 2020 Heroines comedies MCU TV cops Mary Poppins Returns spinoff independent police drama Podcast Adult Swim dragons Bravo BAFTA canceled cinemax twilight CBS All Access Avengers LGBT Shudder Trivia TCA medical drama renewed TV shows south america Disney streaming service The Arrangement VH1 First Look animated Food Network diversity Discovery Channel joker die hard satire DC streaming service kids singing competition quibi crime Super Bowl movie Mary Tyler Moore Comedy Central Lifetime Christmas movies aliens Countdown Trophy Talk a nightmare on elm street PaleyFest Cannes Western Star Trek justice league TCA 2017 BET video Trailer APB ABC Family DirecTV FX E3 Drama documentary Tomatazos Pet Sematary Emmys boxoffice PBS Classic Film Marathons Marvel Studios DC Universe sag awards game of thrones award winner SDCC Logo Spring TV Stephen King Spike Red Carpet harry potter VOD GLAAD First Reviews Election HBO Go tv talk See It Skip It Chernobyl American Society of Cinematographers Awards rotten movies we love Masterpiece Polls and Games Sundance TV CMT Funimation Disney+ Disney Plus Pop biography Apple TV Plus batman SundanceTV spain mutant Hulu BBC America Video Games stand-up comedy Lucasfilm romantic comedy strong female leads USA Network Spectrum Originals richard e. Grant Walt Disney Pictures HBO Max breaking bad serial killer TV Land finale screen actors guild Ellie Kemper reviews Baby Yoda 2015 robots Hallmark zombie Ghostbusters Film Festival Watching Series Black Mirror golden globes Oscars psychological thriller IFC Peacock President The Walking Dead YouTube Premium Binge Guide DGA Disney technology Crunchyroll politics Character Guide Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt BBC One ghosts binge Shondaland Opinion Premiere Dates parents zombies MSNBC Turner Thanksgiving Family sequel Showtime supernatural science fiction Elton John Interview versus Rocketman Biopics cars sports sitcom Paramount travel spider-man Esquire miniseries reboot Dark Horse Comics Extras dc news Endgame Summer TV renewals dark Musicals History 45 screenings OWN HBO 21st Century Fox Set visit 2019 Sundance Now ESPN Comics on TV all-time 2017 GoT Black History Month cooking Action Disney Plus criterion Amazon Prime Video crime drama Sneak Peek disaster BET Awards spanish language Lifetime cults The Witch