Critics Consensus

Sully Is Certified Fresh

Plus, The Wild Life is adrift on an island of mediocrity, and Atlanta and Better Things are also Certified Fresh.

by | September 8, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a heroic pilot (Sully, starring Tom Hanks and Laura Linney), a famed castaway (The Wild Life, with voice performances by David Howard and Yuri Lowenthal), a sinister surrogate (When the Bough Breaks, starring Morris Chestnut and Regina Hall), and a ghost-infested domicile (The Disappointments Room, starring Kate Beckinsale and Michael Landes). What do the critics have to say?


Sully (2016) 85%

Tom Hanks excels at playing decent fellows, and Clint Eastwood has more than proven his ability to make compelling cinema out of stories about simple guys rising to difficult situations. All of which is to say that on paper, this weekend’s Sully — about the heroic efforts of real-life US Airways pilot Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger to save a plane full of people by landing his crippled craft in the Hudson River — looks like a complete slam dunk. Critics say the end result more or less lives up to those lofty expectations, although not quite to the extent its pedigree might suggest; instead, reviews describe a straightforward drama that runs more toward the “solidly entertaining” end of the spectrum than the ranks of surefire Oscar contenders. If Eastwood and Hanks have both made better movies, that certainly isn’t to say Sully doesn’t soar often enough in its own right — or that it isn’t well worth a trip to your local cineplex.


The Wild Life (2016) 17%

The story of Robinson Crusoe has been adapted for film plenty of times, and given unusual twists ranging from telling the tale with a female castaway (1954’s Miss Robin Crusoe) to transplanting the action to Mars (1964’s Robinson Crusoe on Mars). Now, that long list yet adds yet another entry with The Wild Life, a 3D animated effort offering the classic story from the perspective of the animals living on the island where Crusoe shipwrecks. It isn’t a terrible idea, but critics say this is one case where far too much has been lost in translation; overbearing and unfunny, the end result has little to offer any filmgoer who isn’t a very young child or a parent desperate for a 90-minute reprieve. If you find yourself outside either of those demographics this weekend, feel free to find other viewing options.


When the Bough Breaks (2016) 12%

Domestic interlopers have been used as the catalyst for cinematic thrills on numerous occasions, and this weekend’s When the Bough Breaks — starring Morris Chestnut and Regina Hall as a couple whose bliss is threatened by an unbalanced surrogate played by Jaz Sinclair — might deliver its share. Unfortunately, it wasn’t screened for critics, so we have no way of knowing yet… and you know what that means: it’s time for you to guess the Tomatometer!


The Disappointments Room (2016) 0%

Also arriving without the benefit of early reviews is The Disappointments Room, a thriller from Eagle Eye and Disturbia director D.J. Caruso. Starring Kate Beckinsale and Mel Raido as a couple whose new home comes with a secret (and potentially lethal) room, it could give us the first terrifying haunted house of the fall film season — or it could be a rickety dud. Which will it be? Guess that Tomatometer!


What’s Hot on TV

Atlanta: Season 1 (2016) 97%

Atlanta offers a unique vehicle for star and series creator Donald Glover‘s eccentric brand of humor — as well as a number of timely, trenchant observations.


Better Things: Season 1 (2016) 95%

Pamela Aldon‘s Better Things abstains from traditional sitcom sendups and forges a path all its own – in this bawdy, often hilarious and bittersweet ode to the daily highs and lows of being a single mother.


Queen Sugar: Season 1 (2016) 93%

With an authenticity of culture and place and strong performances throughout, Queen Sugar rises above melodrama in this alluring, unhurried and powerful portrait of a fractious black American family.


One Mississippi: Season 1 (2015) 93%

One Mississippi proves an honest vehicle for its moving dramatic narrative, observational comedy, and the genuine acting skills of its lead, Tig Notaro.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Cameraperson (2016) , a documentary honoring the career of cinematographer Kristen Johnson, is at 100 percent.
  • One More Time With Feeling (2016) , a behind-the-scenes look at the making of Nick Cave‘s tragedy-fueled new album, is at 100 percent.
  • As I Open My Eyes (À peine j'ouvre les yeux) (2016) , about the Arab Spring’s impact on one Tunisian family, is at 100 percent.
  • Demon (2016) , about a Polish wedding threatened by supernatural events, is at 90 percent.
  • Author: The JT LeRoy Story (2016) , a documentary about an infamous literary hoax, is at 89 percent.
  • Other People (2016) , starring Molly Shannon and Jesse Plemons in a seriocomic look at the illness-mandated reunion between a mother and son, is at 86 percent.
  • Kicks (2016) , about a teen’s quest to retrieve his stolen sneakers from a local delinquent, is at 79 percent.
  • London Road (2016) , offering a unique documentary/musical approach to the true story of a rash of U.K. murders, is at 74 percent.
  • First-time director Meg Ryan‘s Ithaca (2016) , which traces the aftermath of a young man’s decision to fight in World War II, is at nine percent.

Tag Cloud

Western video streaming Showtime TNT SundanceTV GoT Rom-Com zero dark thirty Schedule NBC E! Superheroes Lionsgate mission: impossible quibi Mary poppins AMC Drama Starz Film Festival dogs Horror YA dc hist psychological thriller vampires OneApp science fiction TCA 2017 Heroines harry potter Disney Plus Walt Disney Pictures Pet Sematary San Diego Comic-Con CNN talk show sitcom Nat Geo 2018 series BBC crime Best and Worst Esquire travel Interview Marvel Studios APB Character Guide Comics on TV biography Dark Horse Comics medical drama Extras GLAAD GIFs BBC One Endgame Emmy Nominations TLC Marvel TV Land Baby Yoda Winter TV Television Academy rotten Grammys batman Certified Fresh FXX game show Rock TCA Winter 2020 chucky DGA MSNBC Turner Classic Movies Spring TV Hulu Infographic Election FX on Hulu spanish language Holiday MTV Chernobyl TCA 2015 christmas movies Acorn TV asian-american YouTube Premium Pop Captain marvel Logo anime canceled singing competition spider-man 007 2020 El Rey Shudder spy thriller Red Carpet romantic comedy psycho crime drama cancelled dramedy politics E3 First Look CBS Toys Comic Book Spike justice league National Geographic Vudu miniseries golden globes video on demand spinoff 2019 WGN Netflix Christmas movies Box Office Comedy Central jamie lee curtis PBS movie hispanic natural history reboot ABC Family comics Tomatazos HBO Go scary movies Tumblr Warner Bros. Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Black Mirror indie stoner YouTube Stephen King Apple TV+ Sundance festivals CBS All Access superhero VOD comic 2016 The CW Sony Pictures Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Avengers Fantasy Trivia social media Masterpiece Netflix CW Seed Discovery Channel parents children's TV Mary Poppins Returns supernatural Awards Tour 72 Emmy Awards foreign diversity Pride Month Watching Series Tarantino USA Network renewed TV shows 20th Century Fox NYCC Brie Larson television Calendar spain slashers obituary Country Epix unscripted Disney+ Disney Plus Holidays DC Universe Star Trek Set visit Women's History Month cancelled TV series screen actors guild Bravo Arrowverse Oscars Crunchyroll cults tv talk Marathons Disney streaming service Nominations Apple TV Plus ESPN HBO Max Emmys robots south america Reality Competition comiccon sports Columbia Pictures adaptation period drama disaster MCU LGBT dragons Academy Awards ITV Peacock Turner Year in Review a nightmare on elm street breaking bad worst blockbuster Universal technology Sci-Fi werewolf true crime Shondaland TBS cancelled television Classic Film war TCA Awards Comedy WarnerMedia Ovation History 2017 Paramount Network SDCC 21st Century Fox Kids & Family Tubi witnail Biopics Binge Guide PaleyFest Freeform Summer award winner Hallmark ratings canceled TV shows Britbox documentaries 24 frames theme song YouTube Red thriller President Cannes versus Polls and Games toy story emmy awards The Walking Dead DC streaming service Hear Us Out Podcast finale Black History Month critics Marvel Television Super Bowl Spectrum Originals halloween Fall TV Lifetime Christmas movies cats Premiere Dates Superheroe cooking Amazon Prime Video Nickelodeon dark independent best Cartoon Network reviews TCM richard e. Grant ABC Family USA cops A&E BET See It Skip It cars game of thrones Travel Channel casting HBO The Purge police drama composers free movies 71st Emmy Awards dceu Action binge fast and furious ghosts revenge indiana jones Adult Swim SXSW FOX classics aliens Animation child's play Trailer Valentine's Day Amazon Studios Creative Arts Emmys FX nature sequel Paramount blaxploitation Apple Cosplay TV renewals satire films name the review IFC Films crime thriller TV facebook rotten movies we love Writers Guild of America Sundance Now Pixar laika X-Men Winners Elton John A24 sag awards PlayStation Ghostbusters Mary Tyler Moore Musical Pirates what to watch Amazon Prime Anna Paquin Disney VH1 Awards adventure Mystery Syfy cartoon The Witch cancelled TV shows RT History Rocketman Martial Arts Fox News transformers Funimation romance mutant anthology TruTV Countdown OWN Trophy Talk Photos Disney Channel TIFF joker zombie Pop TV book Television Critics Association concert space Ellie Kemper crossover Rocky VICE historical drama stand-up comedy movies Teen BAFTA Star Wars Christmas based on movie Crackle zombies Sneak Peek docudrama kids Quiz First Reviews franchise news Film Reality American Society of Cinematographers Musicals elevated horror New York Comic Con nbcuniversal mockumentary DC Comics doctor who Food Network directors animated twilight die hard Song of Ice and Fire screenings Hallmark Christmas movies green book all-time IFC serial killer discovery 4/20 Amazon comedies RT21 Lifetime Music criterion The Arrangement strong female leads Thanksgiving LGBTQ political drama DirecTV boxoffice Mudbound latino Opinion Lucasfilm cinemax Mindy Kaling documentary teaser hollywood Video Games BBC America Sundance TV stop motion CMT BET Awards universal monsters 45