Terminator: Dark Fate First Reviews: Linda Hamilton Rules a Mixed Bag of Familiar Franchise Nostalgia

Critics say the latest chapter of the Terminator saga is a cut above previous sequels, but isn't quite as thrilling as many had hoped.

by | October 22, 2019 | Comments

Retconning more than half of its predecessors, Terminator: Dark Fate is the latest reboot-sequel to pull a do-over by directly following-up the early classic(s) of a franchise. For some, the effort is pulled off perfectly, while others see the new Terminator installment as a nostalgic rehash that panders to fans. The first reviews highlight the return of Linda Hamilton alongside regular Arnold Schwarzenegger, as well as the new cast, especially Mackenzie Davis, but they’re mixed on how well everything comes together this time around.

Here’s what critics are saying about Terminator: Dark Fate:

How does Dark Fate measure up to the other installments?

Dark Fate feels like a real Terminator movie at last.” – Helen O’Hara, Empire Magazine

Terminator: Dark Fate is the redo the franchise needed.” – Jason Guerrasio, Business Insider

“It’s easily the best sequel since 1991.” – Huw Fullerton, Radio Times

“It’s the saga’s best sequel since Terminator 2: Judgement Day, however you might interpret that.” – Clarisse Loughrey, Independent

“It’s a film that returns, in good and gratifying ways, to the smartly packaged low-down genre-thriller classicism that gave the original Terminator its kick.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“A clear step down from the franchise’s early heyday.” – Jordan Farley, Total Film

Dark Fate is just another bad Terminator movie in a string of bad Terminator movies (although better than Genisys).” – Lindsay Bahr, Associated Press

Does it try too hard to be like the first two movies?

“Coloring rigorously within the lines… it’s not a film of galvanizing imagination.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“[It] can sometimes feel like a remix of the series’ greatest hits.” – Jordan Farley, Total Film

“[It] mines nostalgia in all the thoroughly predictable ways, playing like a watered-down greatest hits of The Terminator and Terminator 2: Judgment Day.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

“Nostalgia alone doesn’t cut it. In fact, giving us happy memories of the first two films is what hurts this impostor the most.” – Johnny Oleksinski, New York Post

“There are references and callbacks galore – some welcome, some self-indulgent.” – Clarisse Loughrey, Independent

“Occasionally [it] leans too heavily on the homage but mostly, remarkably, feels like a worthy descendant rather than a cheap cash-in.” – Helen O’Hara, Empire Magazine

Paramount Pictures
(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

What’s it like to see Linda Hamilton back in action?

“What Terminator: Dark Fate makes clear is that… [Schwarzenegger] wasn’t the key ingredient that made these movies really work. It was Linda Hamilton.” – Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

“It’s Linda Hamilton who is the true star of the movie… She brings a ferocity to the screen that is fun and exciting to watch.” – Jason Guerrasio, Business Insider

“After 28 years away from the character, Hamilton brings the strength, vulnerability, and badassness you expect from Sarah and then some.” – Jill Pantozzi, io9

“Hamilton, playing this burnt-out husk of a savior, is triumphantly funny and alive… She’s like Susan Sontag as a badass.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“She’s not given material that does anything innovative with her legacy… [It’s] what the all-male creatives behind Sarah 3.0 think female empowerment looks like these days.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

And what about Arnie?

“Arnold Schwarzenegger adds a dash of life and much-needed comedy when he makes his… entrance.” – Lindsay Bahr, Associated Press

“The movie’s shiniest glimmers of genuine humanity come from Schwarzenegger, playing a slightly different version of this character than audiences may expect.” –  Jesse Hassenger, AV Club

“He’s invaluable in the action scenes, which are some of Dark Fate’s most crowd-pleasing moments.” – Huw Fullerton, Radio Times

“It almost felt like Arnold Schwarzenegger could have been left out of this film entirely. His initial appearance had me wishing they’d let him do less, not more.” – Jill Pantozzi, io9

Paramount Pictures
(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

Do any of the new cast members stand out?

“It’s [Mackenzie] Davis’s brusque and androgynous Grace who turns out to be Dark Fate’s most stonily compelling asset.” – Robbie Collin, Daily Telegraph

“Grace can kick ass, but she’s also pretty boring.” – Johnny Oleksinski, New York Post

“At least the film provides the franchise with a Latinx leading lady [with Natalia Reyes], who continually exercises her agency.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

“The casting of Natalia Reyes is a triumph for representation, but Dani is merely serviceable, a surrogate John Connor who’s largely devoid of a personality.” – Jordan Farley, Total Film

How do the female characters fare?

Terminator: Dark Fate is an engaging story about three, tremendously powerful women. That’s it. That’s the review.” – Jill Pantozzi, io9

“It’s the film’s three female leads that come to the rescue. Given how depressingly rare it is to see women even talking to each other in an action movie, I suppose Terminator: Dark Fate should be commended for this.” – Clarisse Loughrey, Independent

“Dani is not much more than a plot device and Sarah is a reductive stereotype of an embittered woman. Even Grace, who thanks to Davis rises above the rotten script unscathed, has coded ‘female’ limitations.” – Lindsay Bahr, Associated Press

“The motives are transparent…imparting a disingenuous feeling. We’ll give you a cookie, filmmakers, when you add the depth and dimension these women so richly deserve.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

What about the new Terminator?

“The Rev-9 is a genuinely fearsome piece of creature design.” – Robbie Collin, Daily Telegraph

“[The] new Terminator can do more than ever; it can also look like a weightless little cartoon character in the process.” – Jesse Hassenger, AV Club

“He’s a first base riff on what Patrick and Schwarzenegger did better decades ago.” – Jordan Farley, Total Film

Paramount Pictures
(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

And the visual effects?

“[The] VFX are generally so impressive that you can forgive a few poor moments.” – Helen O’Hara, Empire Magazine

“The biggest issue in the film is that the CGI is a mixed bag… When you compare it to the effects from T2, which still stand up today, it just nags at the back of your brain a bit.” – Jill Pantozzi, io9

“The film too often slides into a CGI blur, with zero sense of who’s where and what’s going on.” – Clarisse Loughrey, Independent

“Tim Miller has gone overboard with special effects here, staging an impossible fight on an airplane, which leads to a cheap-looking underwater sequence.” – Johnny Oleksinski, New York Post

Does the action live up to franchise standards?

Dark Fate [has] dynamic action pieces and inventive fight sequences. They are all extremely high-octane and will leave you gripping your seat.” – Jill Pantozzi, io9

“The action scenes have a satisfying 20th-century crunch, thanks to a tactile intermingling of practical effects and CG.” – Robbie Collin, Daily Telegraph

“The action in Dark Fate is all over the map — an early highway chase is thrillingly clear, while a later airborne fight is visually incomprehensible.” – Karen Han, Polygon

“This one offers a series of action set pieces that go from big to huge to ludicrous.” – John DeFore, Hollywood Reporter

“[The] inevitable desire to keep upping the ante result in the movie going a couple of action sequences too far, straining plausibility and sheer gravity to their breaking points.” – Brian Lowry, CNN

Paramount Pictures
(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

How is the script?

Dark Fate is a movie of the now…the story will likely surprise with some ever-present current issues in our society.” – Jill Pantozzi, io9

“There were times when I was actually a little bummed out when another shootout would erupt because I was having so much fun watching Sarah Connor banter with the Terminator.” – Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

“The fun parts of Terminator: Dark Fate can’t mask the fact that the episodic script drags.” – Karen Han, Polygon

Should we look forward to more Terminator movies?

“It raises the question if the franchise has much life beyond this point. Dark Fate certainly sets up for another sequel, but this vein feels pretty tapped out.” – David Crow, Den of Geek

“After Dark Fate the question is no longer who can save Terminator, but who will be bold enough to just let it die?” – Lindsay Bahr, Associated Press

“Whatever happens, if they keep Hamilton on board it’ll be worth another visit.” – Huw Fullerton, Radio Times

Terminator: Dark Fate is in theaters November 1. 

Adjusted Score: 84.739%
Critics Consensus: Terminator: Dark Fate represents a significant upgrade over its immediate predecessors, even if it lacks the thrilling firepower of the franchise's best installments.
Synopsis: More than two decades have passed since Sarah Connor prevented Judgment Day, changed the future, and re-wrote the fate of... [More]
Directed By:

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Lucasfilm Musicals critics crime thriller dragons 21st Century Fox politics SundanceTV Teen Mystery Travel Channel Bravo CBS All Access talk show WarnerMedia Hear Us Out mutant Sony Pictures transformers reboot ABC Family Mary Poppins Returns Nominations 20th Century Fox The Walking Dead Disney A&E BBC Brie Larson USA Network docudrama Fantasy Elton John Music Television Critics Association Turner Classic Movies television Freeform Crunchyroll casting war Best and Worst Comedy HBO Hallmark zombie binge blaxploitation OWN NYCC movies batman Pirates National Geographic documentaries stop motion doctor who Country superhero Song of Ice and Fire The Witch Comics on TV christmas movies kids Grammys supernatural TCM cancelled TV series TV Black Mirror BBC One free movies cults zombies mission: impossible Interview Martial Arts crime mockumentary DirecTV sitcom robots award winner psycho hispanic halloween sports screenings spain Year in Review TIFF sag awards Crackle game show Marvel Television Captain marvel 2017 natural history adventure nature Holiday cancelled television Christmas PaleyFest laika Red Carpet Biopics A24 FXX BAFTA Masterpiece TLC Calendar Sundance Funimation Amazon IFC Films true crime witnail Classic Film twilight TruTV worst 2020 police drama die hard Animation spanish language BET Awards medical drama parents Logo Cosplay versus comic Women's History Month SDCC cancelled HBO Max CBS south america dogs Netflix Christmas movies TNT cartoon BET comiccon Mary Tyler Moore cars APB YouTube Premium FOX Rock Countdown discovery Peacock ABC Tumblr Ghostbusters aliens latino TCA 2017 justice league Certified Fresh joker rotten movies we love FX CMT Mudbound Apple TV Plus name the review Hallmark Christmas movies composers Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Musical BBC America Epix emmy awards E3 streaming serial killer SXSW American Society of Cinematographers travel indiana jones LGBT Fox News facebook renewed TV shows Reality Competition Marathons Baby Yoda WGN TCA Awards Marvel Studios Drama stoner hist Pride Month Sundance Now video on demand HBO Go The Arrangement adaptation rotten Valentine's Day Disney streaming service Creative Arts Emmys video Winter TV Avengers reviews directors dark cancelled TV shows 24 frames Stephen King Reality 2016 revenge Syfy Lifetime Universal Holidays DC Universe Spring TV social media Video Games unscripted anime ghosts festivals toy story based on movie Opinion The CW DC Comics cinemax Acorn TV Watching Series spy thriller PlayStation 72 Emmy Awards Cartoon Network asian-american Esquire Superheroes 007 Set visit Lionsgate spider-man 45 Writers Guild of America Trailer Rocky Endgame Emmys Action President slashers dceu Spike series romance romantic comedy elevated horror VH1 Amazon Studios what to watch IFC Western Academy Awards Disney Channel VICE canceled TV shows Pixar Trivia Hulu TCA Winter 2020 anthology TV Land 2015 Rom-Com Pop foreign Sci-Fi cooking dc sequels TV renewals Amazon Prime Video Anna Paquin 2018 Star Wars Awards Cannes Photos PBS vampires jamie lee curtis child's play 71st Emmy Awards werewolf theme song GIFs Apple TV+ breaking bad concert period drama political drama technology Binge Guide Thanksgiving El Rey Turner Disney+ Disney Plus Film TCA NBC YA strong female leads Disney Plus canceled finale Fall TV Spectrum Originals USA Mindy Kaling Warner Bros. Quiz sequel The Purge Ellie Kemper space Walt Disney Pictures historical drama RT21 CW Seed indie richard e. Grant Summer See It Skip It LGBTQ Food Network chucky Dark Horse Comics Shudder singing competition psychological thriller stand-up comedy ITV satire Marvel Winners Sneak Peek Comedy Central GoT Schedule Television Academy Ovation films MCU movie OneApp Britbox game of thrones Infographic Oscars spinoff Election disaster E! best Family Film Festival Kids & Family Horror Super Bowl Shondaland quibi Superheroe cops Nickelodeon dramedy biography Emmy Nominations Star Trek Paramount Network Sundance TV a nightmare on elm street comedies Netflix X-Men book Pet Sematary Tomatazos miniseries diversity boxoffice San Diego Comic-Con crime drama Chernobyl Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt green book Lifetime Christmas movies screen actors guild 4/20 comics Black History Month ratings Pop TV science fiction Starz franchise Nat Geo animated classics Apple all-time VOD harry potter DC streaming service YouTube Red hollywood Rocketman obituary thriller History ESPN nbcuniversal RT History Trophy Talk documentary Amazon Prime Toys teaser Tubi Paramount blockbuster fast and furious Columbia Pictures MTV universal monsters Heroines Adult Swim GLAAD Extras Vudu Showtime Discovery Channel Character Guide Comic Book zero dark thirty crossover golden globes First Look cats MSNBC CNN 2019 TBS First Reviews independent FX on Hulu Podcast Arrowverse scary movies Polls and Games Awards Tour Premiere Dates tv talk Tarantino AMC Mary poppins DGA New York Comic Con children's TV news YouTube Box Office criterion