Critics Consensus

The Curse of La Llorona Is a Crying Shame

Plus, Breakthrough is bolstered by strong performances, and Disneynature's Penguins is another winner.

by | April 18, 2019 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got a crying woman (The Curse of La Llorona, starring Linda Cardellini and Raymond Cruz), the power of prayer (Breakthrough, starring Chrissy Metz and Josh Lucas), and, well, penguins (Disneynature: Penguins, narrated by Ed Helms). What are the critics saying?

The Curse of La Llorona (2019) 30%

If you’re looking for inspiration for a new horror film, turning to folklore isn’t a bad idea, considering parents have been keeping their children in check with scary stories for generations. Producer James Wan thought it was a good idea, anyway, and the end result is this week’s The Curse of La Llorona, based on a well-known Mexican legend about the vengeful spirit of a scorned woman whose cries of anguish are said to bring misfortune to anyone who hears them. The film stars Linda Cardellini as a widowed mother and social worker who, skeptical of La Llorona’s existence, eventually finds herself and her children terrorized by the spirit and must work with a local faith healer (Raymond Cruz) to free herself from the curse. Unfortunately, critics weren’t particularly thrilled — or chilled — by the latest would-be entry in the Conjuring universe, calling into question the unsophisticated storytelling and director Michael Chaves‘ frequent and excessive use of jump scares. The character’s folk-tale origins certainly carry a lot of potential, but very little of it is realized in The Curse of La Llorona.

Breakthrough (2019) 60%

Faith-based movies are being made and released more frequently than ever, but they rarely come with the kind of mainstream-friendly cast that Breakthrough boasts, and you can go a long way when you’ve got solid, experienced performers on board. Chrissy Metz (This Is Us) and Josh Lucas play Joyce and Brian Smith, adoptive parents to John (Marcel Ruiz), a 14-year-old from Guatemala. They’re also Evangelical Christians, so when John falls into a coma after suffering a near-death drowning accident, they set about praying for his recovery alongside their community, who has rallied around them. The film is based on a true story, and inspirational Christian movies never end sadly, so you can guess how everything turns out, but critics don’t entirely seem to mind. They say the story is appropriately uplifting and the cast, which includes Mike Colter (Luke Cage), Topher Grace, and Dennis Haysbert, all put in strong work. It’s all a little predictable, and it’s not especially nuanced, but the right performances from a capable cast can do a lot to make up for some narrative and thematic shortcomings.

Disneynature: Penguins (2019) 92%

Sure, Disney’s got all the Marvel blockbusters and the Star Wars movies and the Pixar movies (and, now, everything under Fox), but they’ve also quietly been making a name for themselves as one of the foremost purveyors of great nature documentaries on the big screen, too. The latest in that vein is Penguins from Disneynature, which is billed as a “coming-of-age” story that follows a single male Adélie penguin in Antarctica as he sets out to find a mate and start a family of his own. Critics say that the film, co-directed by Alastair Fothergill of the groundbreaking Planet Earth and related series, is playful and entertaining for younger viewers, and its beautiful cinematography is a testament to the herculean effort put forth by the production’s dedicated photographers. In fact, even if the story being told is somewhat familiar to some viewers, particularly those who have seen Planet Earth, the stunning imagery alone may be worth the price of admission.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Hagazussa: A Heathen's Curse (Hagazussa) (2019) , about a 15th century woman regarded as a witch who lives up to her title when she is wronged by a woman from the village that shuns her, is at 100%.
  • Little Woods (2019) , starring Tessa Thompson and Lily James in a drama about two wayward sisters in a run down town who face tough decisions when their mother dies, is at 98%.
  • Hail Satan? (2019) , a documentary profile of the Satanic Temple and its media-savvy efforts to fight for religious freedom, is at 95%.
  • Grass (2019) , South Korean director Hong Sang-soo‘s drama about a writer eavesdropping on patrons at a cafe, is at 93%.
  • Rafiki (2019) , a drama about two young women who fall in love in Kenya, where homosexuality is illegal, is at 90%.
  • Be Natural: The Untold Story of Alice Guy-Blaché (2019) , a documentary about the woman who became the first female director and later vanished, is at 90%.
  • Family (2019) , starring Taylor Schilling in a comedy about a socially awkward woman who must learn to adapt when the niece she’s babysitting runs off to join the Juggalos, is at 86%.
  • Fast Color (2019) , starring Gugu Mbatha-Raw in a sci-fi mystery about a woman with supernatural powers who returns to her estranged family when her abilities are discovered by the authorities, is at 76%.
  • Teen Spirit (2019) , starring Elle Fanning and Rebecca Hall in a drama about a teen who hopes to escape her small town by winning a singing competition, is at 69%.
  • Stuck (2019) , a musical about six strangers trapped on a stalled New York City subway train, is at 58%.
  • Under the Silver Lake (2019) , starring Andrew Garfield in a mystery about a man who embarks on a journey across Los Angeles to locate a missing woman, is at 53%.
  • Instant Dreams (2019) , a documentary about the enduring popularity of Polaroid cameras, is at 43%.
  • Red Joan (2019) , starring Judi Dench and Sophie Cookson in a thriller about a former British spy accused of treason, is at 28%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

FXX Winners Paramount Black Mirror Awards Stephen King TCM 2016 discovery anthology Martial Arts Paramount Network Shondaland Holidays AMC Premiere Dates children's TV Freeform Trailer Food Network ABC APB biography Set visit Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Countdown Reality FOX Mary poppins teaser casting disaster TV Mudbound CW Seed crime drama Showtime cinemax E! cooking theme song Universal Creative Arts Emmys The Witch Christmas Drama revenge Red Carpet Comic Book Winter TV robots space sports crime zombies finale Heroines Star Trek politics A&E cars serial killer VICE Summer Sundance singing competition PBS 2017 DC streaming service Reality Competition SXSW SDCC E3 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Calendar Masterpiece blaxploitation ratings 007 cats First Look doctor who TCA 2017 Pet Sematary PaleyFest Esquire Quiz political drama anime Tarantino RT History strong female leads crossover unscripted binge Trivia hist spinoff GoT elevated horror Song of Ice and Fire Columbia Pictures richard e. Grant BBC The CW Box Office true crime MTV BET Crackle diversity movies Valentine's Day President Binge Guide award winner Music NYCC Nat Geo LGBTQ IFC 20th Century Fox Musical USA Network jamie lee curtis Britbox aliens Netflix Walt Disney Pictures series ITV Brie Larson LGBT cults Elton John Lifetime Hulu comic CMT harry potter vampires Emmys El Rey Character Guide Comedy YA Grammys supernatural TLC animated Star Wars Musicals adventure Lionsgate Year in Review crime thriller Spectrum Originals ghosts Bravo Apple Oscars DC Comics Film Festival Action golden globes Spring TV natural history The Arrangement Polls and Games RT21 Video Games Comedy Central BBC America Western zero dark thirty WGN sitcom 45 Mary Tyler Moore Epix Anna Paquin USA Extras TIFF Teen television social media San Diego Comic-Con transformers adaptation travel Chernobyl witnail cops Adult Swim DirecTV History Mindy Kaling Infographic police drama HBO Max psychological thriller Women's History Month Cannes Disney streaming service Nickelodeon boxoffice Mary Poppins Returns See It Skip It nature Ovation streaming Country TV Land composers toy story Dark Horse Comics GIFs Emmy Nominations medical drama what to watch Marvel YouTube Premium OWN Ghostbusters 2015 ESPN Superheroe Acorn TV Pirates science fiction Amazon Tumblr Rocketman Sneak Peek Opinion justice league Kids & Family Rocky psycho Sundance Now Marathons Disney Channel Film Fox News Thanksgiving Mystery Certified Fresh YouTube Red quibi Awards Tour mockumentary based on movie Superheroes CNN TCA ABC Family thriller Interview tv talk Starz facebook Fall TV Super Bowl war VH1 IFC Films Syfy mutant period drama FX Ellie Kemper 21st Century Fox American Society of Cinematographers dramedy Spike Writers Guild of America Cosplay TruTV GLAAD Rock Pixar NBC TNT comiccon dceu Sci-Fi New York Comic Con DGA MCU MSNBC zombie Biopics Amazon Prime Video Family green book festivals 2018 Trophy Talk kids Lucasfilm Fantasy Tomatazos Captain marvel HBO romance DC Universe 24 frames game show 2019 Logo spider-man Nominations Sony Pictures Disney Warner Bros. Animation WarnerMedia Cartoon Network sequel Shudder Vudu Schedule X-Men dc Rom-Com book spy thriller dragons Horror Amazon Prime Pride Month CBS Watching Series Election technology Photos docudrama Toys National Geographic Comics on TV CBS All Access historical drama miniseries talk show Podcast TBS Best and Worst Pop SundanceTV