The Enduring Appeal of the Rom-Com: How Netflix's To All the Boys Evolves the Genre

As the popular trilogy comes to an end this week, we talked to its director, original author, and even an online dating coach to figure out why the genre is still so popular.

by | February 10, 2021 | Comments

On February 12, Netflix will release To All the Boys: Always and Forever. It’s the last in a trilogy of films based on author Jenny Han’s young adult novels, which follow the starry-eyed Lara Jean Covey (Lana Condor) as she accidentally — and then on purpose — falls in love with her perfect suitor (or, at least as perfect as a high school relationship can be).

The films are extremely popular. The first two, which were released in 2018 and 2020, have respective Tomatometer scores of 96% and 75% and are both Certified Fresh. Fans became obsessed with Yakult, the so-called “Korean yogurt smoothie” that Lara Jean and her family drink in the films, and they especially became captivated with Noah Centineo, the actor who plays love interest Peter Kavinsky. In doing this, To All the Boys has followed in the tradition of other rom-coms – some of which it actually references, like Always and Forever’s re-creation of John Cusack’s boom box moment from 1989’s Say Anything … – in crossing the line from being a sweet flick to an endearing part of pop-culture canon.

To All the Boys: Always and Forever

(Photo by Katie Yu/Netflix)

“I think that people crave conflict, but not too much conflict.”

But why are some rom-coms so addictive?

“I think that people crave conflict, but not too much conflict,” Han says. “When the outside world is so tumultuous, people don’t necessarily want to be stressed out when they’re watching a movie, and they have a couple of hours just to relax… Because, ultimately, regardless of whether the two people get together in the end — which they usually do, but not always — you know that it’s still going to be like an optimistic ending.”

This is further confounding because these movies’ viewpoint is diametrically opposed to the way more people have reportedly begun to feel about monogamy. Marriage rates have been dropping for years for a number of reasons and a pre-coronavirus report from the Pew Research Center found that “fewer than one-in-five U.S. adults say being married is essential for a man or a woman to live a fulfilling life.”

To All the Boys: Always and Forever

(Photo by Katie Yu/Netflix)

“Rom-coms, like mainstream teen films, female friendship films, bromance films and others, are ‘feel-good films.'”

And yet, just because people are more woke to the complexities of modern-day relationships doesn’t mean that they haven’t traditionally been eager to watch something light and fun.

“The rom-com has a long history in Hollywood back to the screwball comedies of the 1930s, the sex comedies of the 1950s, the anxious rom-coms of the 1970s and the nostalgic rom-coms of the 1980s and ‘90s,” says Shelley Cobb, an associate professor of film at England’s University of Southampton and a feminist film and media studies scholar.

Cobb says that while “their popularity waxes and wanes over time” these films stick in the zeitgeist because of the promise of “the comfort of predictability, the satisfaction of a happy ending, and the comedy.”

“Rom-coms, like mainstream teen films, female friendship films, bromance films and others, are ‘feel-good films,’” Cobb says, adding that “even if the relationships on screen don’t look exactly like your own, we know what it’s like to love and hate people in our lives and to be sad and be happy because of those people.”

To All the Boys: Always and Forever

(Photo by Katie Yu/Netflix)

“People have this pressure that they have to find the one.”

But does the genre also bring with it a risk of false hope? Are some movie-goers who relate to To All the Boys’ Lara Jean raised to obsess over meet-cutes and promposals? (And then perhaps feel depressed if things don’t work out that way in real life?)

Julie Spira, a Los-Angeles based matchmaker and online dating coach who runs, says she still has clients who “expect me to have this digital magic wand that, you know, within three days or three weeks, they’re gonna find the one.”

“People have this pressure that they have to find the one,” Spira says, adding that, especially now that we’re in a pandemic, “I’m saying you just need to expand. You need to cast a wide net. You need to expand your social circle. You need to find a pen pal; you need to find a digital pen pal. And that person is going to be a friend. And, maybe, that friendship will turn into romance. Maybe it won’t. But your life can be enriched by having a great person in your life.”

It’s also helpful that the genre of romantic comedies is expanding. These films are increasingly more queer inclusive (see 2018’s Love, Simon or 2020’s Chemical Hearts and Happiest Season, for example) and To All The Boys is one of many recent examples that strove for racially diverse casts.

To All the Boys: Always and Forever

(Photo by Katie Yu/Netflix)

“Singles are saying that they’re looking for a meaningful relationship, a long-term relationship, more than ever.”

This series also makes a point of telling the story of a teen girl – not a couple.

Michael Fimognari, who directed the second and third To All the Boys movies and was the cinematographer on the first one, says that while the films’ plots have included a love triangle and will they/won’t they dynamics, the intent of the filmmakers was always to “show the full Lara Jean Covey story” and that “it was always about her dealing with being in a real relationship.”

Fimognari came to these films after a career that included a lot of horror titles – another genre that’s seen a shift in recent years – and says that “maybe, you know, 30 years ago, rom-coms could get made on the big studio level and get put out and you had [names associated with them like] John Hughes and you have these big theatrical releases with stars.” Now, he says, streaming services like Netflix have “thrived on being able to allow people to see the movie they want to see.”

But does this coalesce with what the viewing public expects for its own life?

Dating expert Spira says a focus on commitment-free courtships had a moment, but since COVID-19 locked people indoors, “singles are saying that they’re looking for a meaningful relationship, a long-term relationship, more than ever.”

“I’m very curious to see if that will continue as things open up,” she says. “I have a feeling it will, because peoples’ brains have been rewired into thinking that they want one meaningful person to spend your life with, or at least during a crisis.”

Or maybe they’ve just been stuck at home re-watching old rom-coms.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

boxoffice hidden camera DGA 21st Century Fox The Academy 2020 Red Carpet Marvel Television women Captain marvel rt labs critics edition cancelled TV shows E! cancelled popular Valentine's Day TLC Spike Reality Competition BBC cooking Turner Turner Classic Movies stand-up comedy psycho Ovation royal family blockbusters Comedy Film Festival dragons aliens wonder woman Classic Film video Nat Geo The Witch TCA 2017 Ellie Kemper know your critic scorecard CMT Hallmark Christmas movies Pet Sematary Trophy Talk canceled comedies Freeform disaster Cartoon Network black zero dark thirty Calendar docudrama thriller BBC America nature directors TCA The Walt Disney Company Super Bowl Discovery Channel Song of Ice and Fire Holiday Spring TV Cannes green book streaming movies suspense ESPN 2015 Fantasy 1990s DC Universe Film name the review police drama olympics 2021 mockumentary godzilla latino El Rey CBS natural history mcc CW Seed Summer international blockbuster new york parents SDCC true crime Heroines Lifetime Christmas movies new star wars movies theme song game show NBA Family WarnerMedia halloween streaming screen actors guild die hard FX Country breaking bad DC Comics series saw TIFF OWN rotten fresh American Society of Cinematographers transformers YouTube TCA Awards composers Elton John singing competition Rom-Com comic Pop TV Instagram Live Apple TV+ independent RT History ghosts Universal Pictures Tomatazos films comic books BAFTA spanish Drama Toys Trailer venice Holidays APB Teen Martial Arts IMDb TV TV renewals crime ABC Family Horror 45 93rd Oscars art house Stephen King ABC batman comic book movie sequels Star Wars 73rd Emmy Awards Neflix debate HBO spain Anna Paquin spider-man psychological thriller Best and Worst Year in Review Crunchyroll See It Skip It TNT DirecTV deadpool Animation golden globes SXSW posters Tokyo Olympics Walt Disney Pictures Bravo docuseries quibi Arrowverse 20th Century Fox CBS All Access halloween tv DC streaming service 24 frames First Reviews worst universal monsters Shondaland target sopranos 71st Emmy Awards Disney Channel 2019 new zealand RT21 best FX on Hulu science fiction spanish language President IFC Pirates free movies Starz ITV SundanceTV ID BET Awards FXX The Walking Dead Showtime Women's History Month Marathons what to watch anime San Diego Comic-Con dc Oscars social media MCU documentary superman 99% Rock Marvel adenture criterion Comic Book reboot Pacific Islander hist Disney+ Disney Plus stoner Musicals AMC Mystery Television Academy Mindy Kaling werewolf festivals Apple TV Plus cars justice league Sundance TV ViacomCBS crime drama based on movie TruTV jamie lee curtis medical drama Epix Countdown Tarantino foreign Set visit 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Peacock obituary spy thriller blaxploitation sag awards PlayStation Marvel Studios Endgame cops monster movies Sundance Now basketball cancelled television animated dogs Legendary miniseries heist movie festival unscripted indiana jones richard e. Grant reviews BET slashers Logo children's TV Grammys YA Adult Swim Ghostbusters television crossover live action Nominations scene in color Photos Image Comics mutant chucky 2018 Extras Paramount Amazon Prime Video Pop Vudu Broadway king arthur Musical AMC Plus critics nbcuniversal feel good VOD japan diversity Netflix 72 Emmy Awards USA Network LGBTQ movie king kong laika Mary Poppins Returns twilight HBO Go worst movies Columbia Pictures Pixar versus binge gangster news travel Christmas japanese National Geographic superhero live event ABC Signature asian-american black comedy 2016 legend Watching Series PaleyFest stop motion scary movies Kids & Family Universal Biopics toy story MTV hispanic heritage month facebook Warner Bros. anthology Sci-Fi classics Paramount Network doctor who Schedule 90s Brie Larson Premiere Dates zombie GIFs Trivia OneApp IFC Films Emmys Alien Funimation Lifetime Exclusive Video slasher teaser Infographic political drama pirates of the caribbean marvel cinematic universe elevated horror australia Acorn TV nfl kaiju A24 comic book movies New York Comic Con football Winners Amazon Prime Spectrum Originals Video Games Comic-Con@Home 2021 Hear Us Out aapi Character Guide movies Star Trek TBS Pride Month rt archives Nickelodeon The Purge sitcom adaptation Music Sony Pictures Black History Month Travel Channel VH1 Election satire Academy Awards E3 Thanksgiving adventure genre marvel comics YouTube Red space Fox Searchlight witnail sports Baby Yoda romance Paramount Plus Emmy Nominations Tubi dramedy 4/20 Awards Winter TV NYCC CNN talk show USA Rocky Superheroe telelvision war Interview Rocketman Mary Tyler Moore game of thrones Sundance award winner golden globe awards concert hispanic french politics Fox News Reality BBC One Quiz jurassic park MSNBC spinoff south america documentaries Box Office GoT rom-coms spider-verse screenings emmy awards dceu Amazon Studios remakes casting action-comedy 007 YouTube Premium period drama italian robots Superheroes a nightmare on elm street kong ratings high school cults mission: impossible Disney Plus vs. Comics on TV 2017 cinemax dreamworks Wes Anderson HBO Max Masterpiece Hallmark Hulu james bond Tumblr A&E Creative Arts Emmys Britbox TV finale Opinion GLAAD Chernobyl comics Food Network Action X-Men rotten movies we love franchise book adaptation toronto cartoon canceled TV shows VICE all-time Shudder First Look Syfy Comedy Central History Amazon prank Disney streaming service scary Western razzies supernatural dark zombies Polls and Games hollywood historical drama child's play Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Black Mirror NBC christmas movies cats Fall TV Podcast Awards Tour Television Critics Association mob indie biography sequel TCA Winter 2020 vampires The CW WGN technology Binge Guide harry potter TV Land serial killer Dark Horse Comics Lionsgate Certified Fresh young adult video on demand comiccon Disney romantic comedy TV movies Apple trailers Mudbound Crackle crime thriller discovery joker Esquire fast and furious Mary poppins dexter PBS Writers Guild of America tv talk Cosplay Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TV One Avengers biopic Sneak Peek FOX Lucasfilm The Arrangement TCM boxing strong female leads cancelled TV series kids Netflix Christmas movies renewed TV shows rt labs LGBT critic resources book lord of the rings archives revenge